While the character of Batman represents iconography and dark justice in a twisted environment – without his unrivalled cast of villains, the hero is nothing more than a two-dimensional charcoal sketch. The Joker, Two-Face, Catwoman, The Scarecrow, The Mad Hatter, The Penguin, The Riddler, Killer Croc – in describing this endless cascade of dangerous dames and demons, the term ‘rogues gallery’ is perhaps more appropriate than ever, as each colourful adversary is as aesthetically fascinating as The Dark Knight himself – they are artistic spectacles in their own way.
They could easily be the occupants of a 1930′s circus and are essentially a sideshow of enemies that represent childhood phobias haunting The Caped Crusader; further drawing on the metaphor of our hero as a boy, who’s lost his parents amongst a vast circus, filled with freaks, clowns and acrobats – distorted by the eyes of a child frightened of the dark. The cast amongst this ‘circus of fear’ is what makes The Dark Detective’s world thrilling and so memorable; actors find themselves employing a great deal of their own creativity in portraying these iconic, larger-than-life characters – in terms of performance, each role is a potential goldmine, which makes them so incredibly sought-after by the most recognised Hollywood stars.
The greatest performances in Batman movies are not always those that adhere to the source material the closest – but rather, those that merge these surreal characters with an essence of eerie plausibility; conveying the disturbing concept that these sinister distortions could exist in the real-world and are often mere victims – infected by the vampiric disease of crime.
Here are 10 of the best casting choices in The Dark Knight’s live-action cinema outings…
You Might Also Like...
- 8 Classic Trilogies That Almost Turned Out Completely Different
- 8 Movie Plot Holes That Could Have Been Solved With One Line Of Dialogue
- 5 Directors That Know How To Deliver A Blockbuster
8 Actresses Who Tricked You Into Thinking You Saw Them Nude
11 Irresistible Movie Moments That Wore Out Your Pause Button
100 Things Wrong With The Dark Knight Rises [Video]
10 Scenes You Won't Believe You Missed in 2012
10 Most Infuriating Movie Cliffhangers
10 Major Plot Holes You Probably Missed
10 Happy Movie Endings That Probably Had Horrific Consequences
12 Ruthless Movie Villains Who Were Defeated By Complete Fools
Want to write about the stuff you're passionate about and have your work read by an audience of over 10 million a month? Click here to become a contributor.







14 Comments
Great read, sir, though personally while Keaton is a great Batman I can never really buy him as Bruce Wayne.
No Aaron Eckhart?, the guy was the biggest surprise in the Dark Knight after the Jocker, and (in my opinion) a perfect portrayal of the Harvey Dent/Two-face characters.
I agree with the rest of the list, although personally, I’d consider a draw between Bale and Keaton, both of them are great in their respective Bat-universes.
Keaton at #1? Oh okay…..
Seriously?!?!? Where’s Aaron Eckhart on this list? He was Brilliant as Harvey Dent/Two-Face.
Lol, is this list for real? No Bale at all? Michael Gough ahead of Michael Caine? No Liam Neeson? And you’re also one of those idiots who continues to spell Christopher Reeve’s name with an “s” on the end. It’s “Reeve”. I’m surprised you didn’t have Bob the goon on this retarded list.
Bollocks! I can’t believe I forgot about Bob! How could one not help but shed a tear when the loyal henchman was executed by a boss that he held nothing but respect for?
While Eckhart was most certainly a step up from the dreadful Tommy Lee Jones, I still found Two-Face’s role in The Dark Knight unconvincing – the origin just didn’t delve deep enough into the psychological aspects of the character, as seen in the comics or animated series. Can you even remember Harvey Dent’s reaction to his facial scarring in ‘The Dark Knight’? No? One minute he’s an incorruptible force of good, with one small scene, vaguely exploring his short-temper – next, he’s a scarred, vengeful, mass-murderer – in my opinion, the mental transition just wasn’t believable. Plus, this is an enemy who’s been a central antagonist in Batman comics since 1942, and is instantly killed by Christian Bale’s Dark Knight during their first (and only) confrontation in the film… it just was incredibly disappointing for me, because I’m such a huge fan of the character. Again, this is all PERSONAL OPINION; I’m not asking you to agree with me, guys.
Regardless, thanks for the comments… any reaction is a welcome one – as long as I’ve left people debating the topic, then I’ve done my job.
Cheers,
T
Good article. One thing I can’t stand though is ridiculous grammar. You wrote “when Bruce and Vicki are sat at the dinner table with Alfred” this makes no sense it should read “when Bruce and Vicki are SITTING at the dinner table with Alfred”. Your English it’s your language use it properly.
Oh the irony.
I didn’t care for Michael Keaton’s Bruce Wayne/Batman at all in the first two Batman movies, but then again that could be because to me they didn’t feel like Batman movies. Too much of the movie was spent on the villains, and not enough on the title character himself. I think Christian Bale pulls off the role much better, and way more believable and more, well, human I guess. Maybe that was also due to the time spent getting to know Bruce in the origin story in Batman Begins though.
Apart from Aaron Eckhart not being in the list (though I understand why you didn’t after reading one of the comments above)and Michael Keaton instead of Christian Bale, I completely agree with the list. Good article.
Amazing article, i love Keaton and in my mind the best Batman.
For the record Bale doesn’t HAVE to be in there because he is in the current trilogy.
The only thing I’m not sure about is Alfred being that high up (Not caine)
It could blamed on the the filmmakers, but I couldn’t be satisfied with Keaton’s Bruce/Bats. Batman is more than a character, he’s a process. In Batman-89, all aspects of Batman hinge on exposition while Bale’s put in so much more depth by investing more in the transformation of Batman. The single-most compelling aspect of Batman, as I find him is that he’s product of his own hard work, and all psychological elements are strongest when they are tacked on that.
What a bunch of trolls. If you dont find Keaton to be the best Batman, then your too young to know better. And who cares about grammer. Get a life people and read the article and let other people have an opinion. LOSERS!!
“If you dont find Keaton to be the best Batman, then your too young to know better.”
“let other people have an opinion.”
Do you always contradict yourself that way?
Michael Keaton #1? This must be a real joke… Christian Bale is the best Batman ever, and the best Bruce Wayne ever ! There is no doubt about it. And Michael Cain is the perfect Alfred Pennyworth. Jeath Ledger should be # 1 on the list, and it should defenetly include Aaron Eckhart!