12 Horror Movies That Deserved Sequels

Considering some of the junk that spawns franchises, didn't these deserve a shot too?

Dog Soldiers Liam Cunningham
Pathe

Horror movies and sequels go together like PB and J. Produce one relatively successful horror movie, garner even a modest audience, and it's more or less a given that further films will follow.

And we're not just talking the big cheeses like Halloween, Friday the 13th, Nightmare on Elm Street, Scream, Saw, Paranormal Activity, The Conjuring. Very often there are horror movies that the wider audience has never heard of that have still spawned follow-ups: The Dentist, Killjoy, Grave Encounters... we could go on.

Oftentimes, sequels are made for horror movies that wouldn't appear to lend themselves to a franchise formula at all, and we wind up with little more than hollow facsimiles of what came before. This naturally lends weight to the argument that, as Randy so metatextually declares in Scream 2, sequels are by definition alone inferior films.

Even so, there are instances when a movie would seem to have franchise written all over it, yet no sequel ever comes. Sure, we might count ourselves lucky under these circumstances, grateful that we haven't had to see another once-successful formula gradually watered down to nothing - but we also can't help but wonder what might have been.

Are we necessarily any poorer for not having follow-up films to these 12 horror movies? That's open to debate - but in each instance, it isn't hard to see how the filmmakers could have given us more.

12. Troll Hunter

Dog Soldiers Liam Cunningham
SF Norge

This 2010 feature from director André Øvredal proved two things which, at the time, were a bit of a surprise to international audiences: firstly, that there was still some life in the found footage format; secondly, that Norway could produce world-class genre films.

Starting out very down to earth and humdrum, Troll Hunter is the video diary of a trio of young media students in production on a documentary for class, following an enigmatic loner who they suspect may have something to do with a slew of dead bears found in the area.

However, the mystery man turns out to be something altogether different: a hunter of trolls, secretly employed by the Norwegian government to keep the unruly creatures under control.

Particularly considering the film's low budget, the CGI trolls are truly breathtaking, and the concept is so much fun it cries out for further exploration - yet there's been no follow-up, nor any indications that one might be in the works.

A shame - although it's perhaps more pleasing to note that plans for a US remake (in motion before the film even went on general release) also failed to gain momentum.

Contributor
Contributor

Ben Bussey hasn't written a bio just yet, but if they had... it would appear here.