WWE 2K18: 10 Most Over-Rated Main Roster Members

According to 2K, Finn Bálor's Demon is more powerful than The Undertaker...

WWE 2K18 Shane McMahon
2K Games

It's hardly a surprise to see that Roman Reigns (95) and John Cena (93) rank amongst the top main roster members in WWE 2K18. Similarly, it's difficult to argue with AJ Styles getting a 90 rating overall after the 18 months he's had in WWE. No, the problems start cropping up when you delve deeper into the list.

A character doesn't necessarily need a high score to be considered over-rated. All they require is a rating that doesn't quite fit with their stock in real-life WWE, or one that only highlights how others have been poorly treated by 2K during development.

Prepare to be scratching your head a lot, because who knows how 2K came up with some of these numbers.

In 2K's world, the demonic character played by Finn Bálor is worth more than The Undertaker, Shinsuke Nakamura is more powerful than Braun Strowman, and Nikki Bella is as good an in-ring performer as Charlotte Flair. What were they thinking?


Freelance journalist, podcasting loony, lifelong wrestling fan and musician (drums are people too), who has a vague resemblance to a loudmouth announcer in Defiant Wrestling. Also a huge, HUGE fan of Halloween and Lucky Charms. Huge.