10. Yoshi Tatsu vs Sheamus
One of those fights which seems unlikely, the big Irishman versus the diminutive Japanese star - even more surprising when the story concludes with Sheamus being the one beaten up. The story first swirled around the WWE locker room in 2009. They say there is no smoke without fire, and eventually this story had so much smoke it made its way into the pages of Dave Meltzer's Wrestling Observer. According to sources within WWE, before breaking into the big league, Sheamus and Yoshi were room mates in Tampa Florida. Ted DiBiase was also living with the pair. The big Irishman fancied himself somewhat as "the boss" of the house, and frustrated DiBiase and Tatsu with his lax attitude. One day Tatsu and DiBiase confronted Sheamus about unwashed protein shakers. Sheamus reacted with arrogance, annoying Tatsu further. Tensions came to blows when Sheamus threw the protein shaker at Tatsu and goaded him to do something about it. The New Japan Dojo graduate, who has some experience in boxing training, then proceeded to kick Sheamus's a**. Chances are that the pair quickly patched things up, although some versions of this story have Sheamus "crying" and running away for cover.