The Joker is immortal. At least thats his claim in Endgame, the current storyline in Scott Snyder and Greg Capullos Batman comic series. Forget Jared Letos haircut this is the biggest Joker event going. For the first time, he seems to be explaining his history of countless returns from the grave. Resurrection is a huge part of superhero comics, certainly. Most characters have died a dramatic and hyped-up death, only to return a year later with a half-hearted excuse. But Jokers ability to cheat death goes beyond even the most flexible comic book mortality rules. Through his seventy-five years in comics, movies, animation, and video games, hes been shot, stabbed, dropped down smokestacks, and fed to sharks. Sometimes he seems truly gone for good. More often, it feels inevitable that hell return, leaner and meaner than ever. Because Joker just keeps on truckin'. Join me, won't you, on a tour of Joker's greatest downfalls...
10. Batman #1
The Joker was created as a one-off and died in the same comic that marks his first appearance. His debut in 1940 painted him as a grimly tricky serial killer that frowned as frequently as he smiled. When the Batman confronts him, he lunges with a knife, staggers, and accidentally drives the blade into his own chest. With trademark hysteria he shrieks with laughter as he dies. But! Editor Whitney Ellsworth sensed potential in the Joker. He requested that a panel be added showing his revival in an ambulance, and for that we are grateful.
9. Death Of The Family
Also by the Snyder/Capullo team, Death of the Family is one of the more conceptual Joker stories. He straps his rotting sliced-off face to his head, which is a lifestyle, and takes down the Robins, Nightwing, and Batgirl to ensure that Batman will be his and his alone forever. At the climax Joker trips off a cliff, as he does. Batman grabs his hand, pulls him up, and whispers that he knows Jokers real name and history, that hes just a normal man. Deeply insulted, Joker zaps Batman with a joy-buzzer and lets go. His face flutters off and reveals the grinning tissue beneath as he plummets into the abyss. All he wanted was an eternal frenemy, and he just couldnt take the rejection. No one could survive that fall. Could this be the end? (Nah.)
8. The Killing Joke
Leave it to Grant Morrison, the shaman of hidden comic book meaning, to unearth new significance in this landmark graphic novel. Alan Moores The Killing Joke is for many the be-all-end-all Joker tale due to its definitive origin story. But Morrison believes its masterpiece status doesnt come from the Jokers beginning, but from his end. Read the comic again and look closely as Batman and Joker share a laugh see Batmans hands come up to Jokers neck, notice the laughter stop as the sirens blare on, feel the silence as the lights go out. Are we reading too much into this? Possibly. I'm just not one to argue with the shrewd and possibly magical Grant Morrison.
7. Batman: Animated
The many undoings of the Mogul of Mountebanks in Batman: The Animated Series and its spinoff films are appropriately vague, given the intended youth audience. Examples: Joker triggers exploding marbles in his plane and crashes (laughing) into the sea. Joker vanishes (laughing) in smoke as an amusement park flames up around him. Joker jumps (deploying an inner tube, laughing) off an aquarium rooftop into shark-filled waters below. How could he not be dead? We never see anything really happen. The only certainty is that before long hell turn up in another episode.
6. Ace Chemical
In a way, one of the greatest deaths of the Joker is also his true starting point. Its the sequence re-imagined and immortalized in comics, in cartoons, and in film when the man fell into the Ace Chemical acid vat and ceased to exist. Its the snuffing out of the mere man, be it the failed comedian, the crimson-hooded crime boss, or the cruel mob enforcer. What bubbles to the surface with its clenched white hands, green hair, and bared teeth is reborn. The Clown Prince of Crime is here, and the deadly cycle has begun.
5. Kingdom Come
In this Elseworlds (non-canon) storyline, the Joker pays dearly for one of his worst crimes brutally killing Lois Lane. The story takes place a few decades in the future, and Joker has aged along with the rest of the DC Universe. His smile lines look deeper, his hairline receded, his physique heavier. Alex Rosss hyper-realistic illustrations prove the only thing creepier than the Joker is the elderly Joker. While Superman is away, Joker singlehandedly wipes out the entire Daily Planet staff. When he arrives at trial, super-powered upstart Magog (I know, Magog who?) does what Batman and Superman never would and kills him quickly with an energy blast. As smoke pours out of his body, the Jokers final expression seems to say that actually, hes pretty flabbergasted.
4. Batman Beyond: Return Of The Joker
The unedited version of this Batman Beyond feature doesnt pull punches when it comes to killing the Joker. This aint your dads animated Batman. This is Neo-Gotham. When a certain infamous clown crops up, Batman Terry McGinnis confronts the nastiest secret of Bruce Waynes Bat-Past in a rattling flashback. Once upon a time, the Joker and his girlfriend Harley Quinn decided they wanted a son. They kidnapped young Robin. They strapped him to a table and zapped his mind away and dressed him in a little purple tuxedo. Joker gave him a gun and told him to kill Batman. Robin laughed through his tears and pulled the trigger. BANG! The sharp end of the trick guns BANG flag pierced Jokers heart. The End.
3. The Dark Knight Returns
Youve got a 55-year-old Batman and youve got a flirtatious white-suited Joker fighting to the death in the Tunnel of Love. The stuff of dreams. This is a Joker who shook his years-long catatonia when his darling Batman came out of retirement, a Joker who clearly harbors feelings for his opposite number. Both hero and villain are left battered and bleeding from this vintage Frank Miller grudge match. As sirens close in, Joker showcases the suicidal recklessness that so often proves his undoing, but with a whole new level of commitment. He spits out his final cackles as he twists and wrenches his neck. Out of sheer spite, he breaks his own spine. Sheesh!
2. Batman (1989)
After Christopher Nolans Dark Knight trilogy, Tim Burtons Batman seems mostly dismissed as a cartoon by comparison. However, re-watch the movies weirdly emotional climax and realize, hey, theres a lot going on there. Jack Nicholsons Joker perches on a church tower ledge as Batman and Vicki Vale cling below him. He does a jig and stomps at their hands. Even while the stones crumble beneath him, hes still behaving like the jolly homicidal artist whos been partying (and wearing berets) all movie long. His henchmen fly in and throw down a ladder for a helicopter exit. Joker floats up and Batman throws a rope around his ankle, binding him to a gargoyle. Only now does everything catch up to the clown. Nicholsons expression as he slips down the rungs seems so suddenly human and fragile. He stares into space and grits his teeth. When he falls, he screams not with laughter but with a rational persons fear. This is a rare moment of vulnerability in an otherwise completely comedic character.
1. Arkham City
Jokers fate in Batman: Arkham City easily lays claim to being his most impactful death scene. The character as portrayed by Mark Hamill in the Arkham series is, for the gamer generation, a continuation of the definitive Joker that Hamill voiced years ago in the animated show. We all grew up watching the 90s cartoon, and to play the future of the animated world in these more mature games has been an emotional experience for many. Call me sick, but when Joker succumbed to the Titan poisoning and chuckled his last, I shed a tear. The scene of Batman carrying Jokers body in the street, bearing the corpse the same way he held the lifeless Robin Jason Todd, is devastating. Every passing second holds the weight of so much character history JOKER THE IMMORTAL on the theater marquee, the stilling of Jokers thugs and the sobs of Harley Quinn, the disturbed and questioning reaction of Commissioner Gordon. Batman lays the body on the hood of Gordons car and leaves without a word. The Joker is dead. Long live the Joker.