10 Comics That Saved Hated Characters

Reminding you that Deadpool used to suck.

By Zoë Miskelly /

Perhaps the single strangest thing about comics is having to come to terms with the fact that some of the most interesting and loveable characters lacked their most compelling features when they were first introduced.

Advertisement

With Daredevil, Deadpool, and even the iconic Punisher having some less than stellar beginnings, it's honestly shocking that so many popular superheroes only developed their most iconic incarnations midway through their history on the page.

It's one thing to write a likeable character, but it's entirely another thing to write a previously hated character and change fans' minds on them. That said, often this is less a task of monumental proportions, and more one of introducing unexplored aspects of the character - such as the Iceman's life outside of him being in the X-Men, or The Question outside of him being used as a way to espouse his creator's political musings.

There are dozens of writers and artists who could stake a claim to have changed their characters for the better, and yet most tend to get overlooked.

While there is no one consistent way to judge a character's 'redemption' in the comic world, it's always worth appreciating the decisions that improved and fixed characters who were once found wanting.

10. Iceman - Uncanny X-Men #600

The case of Robert Drake is an unpredictable one. While Bobby was never the worst characterised of the X-men, his arcs were generally focused on the turmoil surrounding his ice powers, which could prove irritating when it seemed Iceman was trapped in continually rediscovering his own powers. As such, we never really got a full insight into Bobby himself - or rather, we didn't until Uncanny X-Men #600, wherein a young Bobby realises he is gay, and confronts his future self about it (it's complicated).

Advertisement

The delicate nature of the subject matter made for a particularly unpredictable moment, yet one that ended up being handled with ease. Instead of it being a case of the older Drake being in denial, he supports his younger self's conclusion immediately, explaining that a mixture of his obligations to the X-Men and awareness it was another unfair reason others would hate him left him reluctant to address the elephant in his own head.

The unique, emotional conversation that the two characters have really served to make Iceman twice as dynamic and rounded a character as he was prior, and for a surprisingly warm moment from the man of ice.

9. The Punisher - Born

As much as watching a stoic, endlessly violent badass with a tragic backstory is fun, it's not exactly difficult to find a character who fits this description within the medium.

Advertisement

As such, the move away from the Punisher being yet another character cut from this cloth turned out to be a massively refreshing one. While many previous comics paved the route for a more three-dimensional Frank, it is Born that marks a particularly unique development that the Punisher gets to move him away from the conventional embittered anti-hero.

The strikingly named series covers Frank Castle's life prior to him becoming the relentless vigilante, instead focusing on his time in Vietnam and how it affected him. What it does decidedly different to comics that came before it, however, is to suggest that Castle's thirst for blood is not a product of his anguish at his murdered family, but instead a dark urge for violence that had resided within him far before that event came to pass.

It's not the most favourable portrayal of Frank, sure - but then the best Punisher comics tend to revolve around his moral complexities.

8. Blue Beetle - Infinite Crisis

Infinite Crisis is admittedly less of a redemption of any previous Blue Beetle character, and more a redemption of the figure of Blue Beetle itself. In this case it comes in the form of Jamie Reyes, the third person to take up the mantle.

Advertisement

While Ted Kord is engaging in his time as Blue Beetle - and Daniel Garret's run was long enough that any flaws are forgivable - each provided their own problems in properly exploring the exciting aspects of the superhero alias. Although Kord isn't a hated character as such, it is frustrating that he could have existed as a different superhero in his own right, instead of closing off any potential of a superpowered Blue Beetle for years upon years.

With Jamie, however, both these issues are solved. Reyes is both able to harness the Scarab that is supposed to power the Blue Beetle, while also maintaining intrigue by being pretty much constantly at war with the alien technology and it's own occasionally brutal desires.

As such, his beginning as the hero marks the fulfilment of the ample potential the superhero alias has always had.

7. Scott Lang - Ant-Man 2016

For one of the MCU's film sweethearts, Scott Lang had a less than pleasant beginning character-wise.

Advertisement

Despite starting out as being arguably the most moral Ant-Man thus far - which admittedly didn't take much, given Eric O'Grady starred in the 'Iredeemable Ant-Man' series - it takes some considerable time before Scott can really be considered a superhero, and not just a deadbeat dad who wears a super-suit.

Initially, this distant relationship between father and daughter is played tragically realistically, with Lang dying upon trying to reunite with his teammate Jack of Hearts. In the reboot of the series, however, things are very different, as Scott puts real effort into reconciling his difficult relationship with Cassandra, even turning down a job offer from Tony Stark to live closer to her, and the two begin to build a legitimately healthy familial bond.

It was a bond that was many, many years in the making, but one that got there in the end nonetheless - and that majorly redeemed Lang along the way,

6. Daredevil - Daredevil #158

As weird as it feels to say, Daredevil was not particularly popular in his initial incarnation.

Advertisement

The Guardian Devil's rise would be a gradual one, brought about by several changes and developments in his story and character - all gently moving fans more and more from disregard and discontent, to adoration of what is now one of Marvel's most iconic characters.

Of these important developments, Frank Miller's time behind the wheel of the Man Without Fear is arguably responsible for the way we remember him to this day, which is quite impressive, when you remember that his first comic, Daredevil #158, was written in 1979.

While it's almost expected that Frank Miller would bring a sense of dynamism to the series, the impact to the Daredevil character and comic was unimaginably long-lasting, with Miller introducing the marital arts themes that would prove so important to the character, and also establishing a far darker, grittier tone for the masked hero.

Had it been later, Daredevil would perhaps have hit an audience inundated with gritty superheroes, but, as it was, he struck gold, launching Daredevil into a spotlight he is yet to depart.

5. Shazam - 2019 Series

With the Shazam 2019 series, the case was less one of him being hated, and more one of the way he had started to be handled being hated. For example, the fact that his previous run in 2013 was placed intermittently in the Justice League left a sour tase in many fans' mouths, as it disrupted the pacing of one of DC's major comics with material that already existed in another comic.

Advertisement

A mixture of this and a more salient storyline made for 2019 to be something of a redemption in regards to dealings surrounding Shazam. The 2019 series focuses far more on Billy Batson and his adjustment to the weird world of being a child superhero than merely focusing on his origins and conflict with Black Adam.

With the magical bizarreness of the Magic Lands linked to Shazam having not been explored for such a considerable amount of time, the reintroduction of this can also be seen as a significant move on the road to the character's full redemption.

4. The Question - The Question Quarterly

The Question is a completely unusual case, as the issue with The Question was more a case of his creator's politics than the figure himself.

Advertisement

While it's no crime for comics to get political - indeed, this often makes them all the more interesting - there's something to be said for characters being made into a mouthpiece for a writer's personal viewpoints. Doing this limits the actual protagonist, as they're unable to have aspects that would compromise the views they are intended to exemplify.

With this in mind, Steve Ditko's time writing The Question was not ideal for these exact reasons, as his considerable skill as a comics writer was restrained by his insistence on making a hero that totally reflected his own objectivist values.

As such, when Ditko stopped writing for him, The Question naturally changed in a great many ways. Dennis O'Neil and Denys Cowan's run with the character served to really develop the character into a more philosophical figure, and one uncertain about his own vigilante behaviour. It made for a much more three-dimensional figure - as well as one aware of his own motives and drive.

3. Damian - Batman Incorporated #9

It's safe to say that, upon introduction of Damian in Batman #656, the majority of fans considered him something of a pretentious, emotionally repressed brat.

Advertisement

Had no writer ever taken the time to focus on Damian's character development, this would still likely be the way most people regarded the youngest Robin. But with Damian's noble efforts in Batman Incorporated #9 - and subsequent death at the hands of his evil twin The Heretic - it was difficult not to grow a soft spot for the youngest Robin.

Not only does Damian ultimately sacrifice himself in order to protect others from his clone, but it is immediately apparent at the start of the fight that his intentions are non-violent - as he repeatedly asks The Heretic to step down and let him speak to his mother, who he hopes to talk things out with.

Seeing Damian literally give his all - even if he was eventually brought back - is almost scientifically crafted to make you kind of love the little terror, even with all his flaws.

2. Jason Todd - Batman: Under The Red Hood

With people being so adverse to Jason Todd that they actively voted to have him killed, it's safe to say that his return as the Red Hood really served to bring interest to a previously unliked character.

Advertisement

Although Death in the Family definitely generated sympathy for the murdered Robin, it didn't change the character of Todd himself. The first comic after his resurrection did however, taking Todd from being a slightly whiny disliked sidekick, to a rebellious badass with a reasonable justification for his angst.

It also served to diversify the Bat-kids from a pack of wholesome do-gooders into a series of people with wildly different motivations and moral codes.

One of the most interesting dynamics in the Batclan is that of how the various other characters deal with Jason as the black sheep of the family. Balancing watching all the respective cast deal with the guilt and emotions dredged up by seeing Jason alive again,and their concern and upset in regards to his murders appears can't be easy, but it is exactly this that makes Jason's emergence as the Red Hood such a smart move.

1. Deadpool - Deadpool #17

With how beloved a character Deadpool is nowadays, it's easy to forget that he had a phase of being one of the worst characters in Marvel comics.

Advertisement

Although his hijinks remained much the same, the way Deadpool treated those close to him was profoundly different - and profoundly worse. The best example of this is his roomate/prisoner, Blind Al, whom the 1998 comics revealed he trapped in a torture room whenever she displeased him - or just when he felt like it - as well as systematically torturing and murdering anyone who tried to help the blind old woman escape.

However, in Deadpool #17 this all changes. After the issues leading up to it suggest that Deadpool had begun to understand the impact of his actions and deeply regret them, the Merc' with a Mouth finally begins the process of redeeming himself to Al and those others close to him, the first step being him sealing up the room where he tortured her.

While it doesn't fix all of his past actions, this marks the start of Deadpool as the well-meaning anti-hero that we know - and love - today.

Advertisement