10 Hated Comic Book Characters Who Became Fan Favourites
Damian Wayne was despised 14 years ago. Look where he is now!
While many newly introduced comic book characters have been lucky enough to be immediately welcomed by fans, this hasn't been the case for every character. Indeed, there have been many other characters who've had the very opposite reaction from fans.
As to why, however, varies from case to case. One character might be seen as the laughing stock of their comic book. Another might be poorly received due to backlash against newly incorporated continuity changes that include this new character. Or, it might've simply been that the character was just altogether unappealing.
Regardless of their initial undesirability, though, some of these characters have been able to manage a comeback later on in life.
An accomplishment that is in no small part due to the efforts of creatives, who sometimes revive and revitalize these characters so well, that they end up on-screen. Where, of which, they find themselves beloved by a spectrum of different kinds of fans.
With that being said, though, let's now take a look now at the winding journeys these characters have embarked on in their quest towards newfound popularity.
10. Guy Gardner
Guy may be everybody's favorite wise-cracking Green Lantern now, but before all of that, he wasn't nearly as popular as, say, Hal Jordan.
When Guy first appeared in 1968, he wasn't even introduced as an active character. He was instead presented in terms of an alternate reality, where he was chosen to be Earth's Green Lantern instead of Hal Jordan.
Hal himself had witnessed the potential of this alternate Green Lantern and decided to establish Guy as a possible replacement.
Following 1971, though, Guy would remain in standby, after it's decided that John Stewart should be the new Green Lantern of Earth. Not that this was hurting Guy much since he wasn't very noticeable until the 1980s when Steve Englehart began to solidify his personality.
Following Englehart, DC would continue the trend further by balancing out Guy's hot-headedness with a wiseguy demeanor, which began during his time in the 1987 Justice League International title.
This would kickstart Guy's fame as the Lantern that everyone hates but secretly loves, because of his appeal as a loudmouth, rebel lantern.
Going forward, Guy’s popularity would continue to rise and lead to him becoming one of the most well-known Green Lanterns from the DC Universe.
9. Ben Reilly (Scarlet Spider)
Before there ever was a Spider-Verse, the only Spider-Man that ever existed was Peter Parker, who had gained an incredible following since his initial debut in 1962.
Even still, though, Spider-Man wasn't unaffected by the constant trend of comic book reboots and retcons, either. Indeed, one of the first major changes that the wall-crawler faced happened in 1994 when Ben Reilly replaced Peter Parker as the friendly neighborhood hero.
What was most shocking to readers, though, wasn't Ben replacing Peter, rather it was the additional revelation that Peter was really the Spider-Man clone all along - not Ben Reilly.
This had then implied that the Spidey everyone knew and loved was actually a fake. A sentiment which didn't sit well with fans at all. It perhaps didn't help either that Peter was subsequently replaced by Ben either, in 1995. Not that he'd hold that title for long, though, as come a year later when he's supposedly killed off for good.
Fortunately, though, Ben would get a revival in 2016 which saw him undergo a compelling journey of self-discovery that fans would come to appreciate.
8. The Riddler
Seeing as Riddler is one of the oldest Batman villains around, it would only seem appropriate that he encounter changes to his character. The kind of changes that have led to a constant fluctuation in his popularity throughout his years in publication.
Most notably, though, it's been Riddler's on-screen representation that has had the most damning to his reputation. Causing, in turn, a near-permanent impression of him not as a criminal mastermind, but as a tights-wearing fool.
For this reason alone, many have previously dismissed Riddler as one of the more inferior villains of Batman's rogues gallery. The comics themselves have often proved otherwise, though, with stories like the War of Jokes and Riddles, where Riddler is conveyed as a calculating and sometimes cold-hearted villain.
No longer is it then that fans know Riddler in the context of film and television, as he's come to take on a new and improved image in the comics as the Moriarty to Batman's Sherlock Holmes.
7. Squirrel Girl
Today she may be a beloved Marvel character with admirable traits, but back in 1991, when she was first created, Squirrel Girl was hardly a fan-favorite.
Doreen Green (otherwise known as Squirrel Girl) was perceived by those both inside and out of the Marvel universe, as a joke. She was treated as a starry-eyed kid by her peers, and it didn't help either that her alias was also played for laughs.
From the beginning, though, Doreen has had the potential to be a formidable hero, which was even apparent in her very first issue. She'd initially ask Iron Man to be his side-kick, but he'd quickly turn her down. Tony inevitably gets egg on his face for this though, as Doreen rescues him from Doctor Doom shortly after.
The years following this would then see Doreen helping other heroes, like the Hulk, where she'd continue to maintain a supporting role from the nineties onwards. Her supporting role would even be downgraded further when Doreen is later reduced to being a nanny.
Fortunately for Doreen, she's resumed her role as the superhero Squirrel Girl where her representation has improved extensively with her 2015 solo series. This, in turn, has begotten her a rapidly growing readership that has come to appreciate her for the powerful hero that she always was.
6. Aquaman
Despite starting out in comics alongside the likes of Wonder Woman, Aquaman has fared much worse popularity-wise than his Justice League counterparts.
Namely, it’s been the perception of him over the years as a joke which led many fans to turn their noses at him. Ironic, really, given that he's not just a powerful metahuman, but the very King of Atlantis.
The start of this trend occurred back in the 1960s and '70s, with on-screen appearances on Saturday morning cartoons like Super Friends. Often it was in this portrayal of him that Aquaman was understood as a seahorse riding buffoon, who was chopped liver compared to his surface-world heroes.
Cinematic and televised portrayals of Aquaman really damaged the character, as joke after joke at his expense sank him further and further into the depths of unpopularity.
Fortunately, though, the tide does begin to shift in his favor come the New 52, where the challenges he faces as a man between two worlds are explored. Perhaps the most apparent sign that Aquaman's popularity was bound to reach new heights, though, was Jason Momoa's stellar performance as the Atlantean king.
5. Damian Wayne
Upon meeting Damian for the first time in Batman and Son, it's pretty difficult not to dislike him.
In the comic, Damian explains to Batman that he ought to be the only Robin due to his training with the League of Assassins, along with the fact that the Dark Knight is his biological father. Batman, though, isn't the least bit convinced (not that this stops Damian from taking the Robin mantle by force).
After severely injuring Tim Drake, the current Robin, Damian then steals his uniform, dons it, and finally proceeds to galavant around Gotham killing villains.
Clearly, this self-entitled brat of a Boy Wonder was going to rub people the wrong way. Thankfully, this was just the beginning of Damian's arch, as he would see real development following Final Crisis as the Robin to Dick Grayson's Batman, with Bruce Wayne having passed away.
During this period of time, Damian's tough exterior was slowly chipped away to reveal the human interior that lied underneath. Fans have loved him ever since.
4. Booster Gold
Given his reputation in the DC Universe for being a self-aggrandizing, money forward hero, it’s hardly surprising that readers didn't warm to Booster Gold.
Strange as it is though, Booster’s reputation was completely intentional when he was first created by Dan Jergens in1986. Inspired by the 1980s “Greed is Good” cultural vibe, Jergens had sought to introduce a hero that was motivated not by altruism, but by riches and fame.
In this sense, Booster not only stood out as one of the first new DC characters to be introduced since Crisis on Infinite Earths, but as a new interpretation of the ideal superhero. Unfortunately, the small following that Booster maintained with his 1980s solo series wasn’t enough to prevent its eventual cancellation in 1987.
For quite some time afterwards, Booster would then remain on as a regular Justice League member. This portrayal saw Booster relegated to comedy, where his entrepreneurial mentality outshined his heroic development.
Booster Gold didn’t improve much popularity-wise until entering his “the hero you never heard of” period. This is where Booster begins to resonate as a multi-layered character that’s misunderstood in his community, yet beloved by fans that know him to be a hero, despite his public image.
3. Kiteman
Like some of the other rogues in Batman’s gallery, Kiteman was undeniably created with humor in mind. His very name, Chuck Brown, is even a Charlie Brown pun (a character who's notoriously known for his inability to fly a kite).
With that said, Kiteman has nevertheless experienced a bit of a revival in the past couple of years, after writer Tom King put a new spin on him. Many years prior to that, Kiteman remained squarely in Condiment King or Crazy Quilt territory, following his second appearance in a 1986 Hawkman issue.
For the longest time afterwards, he'd then be reduced to acting as either a background character or a constant punching bag for villains and heroes alike.
Come 2016, and Kiteman would be rebooted as a character with substance and even a catch-phrase that read “Kiteman, hell yeah.” This was when War of Jokes and Riddles gave him not only a compelling backstory but a chance at duping both Riddler and the Joker.
Since then, the character’s popularity has only grown further, with audiences warming to his character in the animated Harley Quinn series. Not bad for a guy that was originally a D-list villain.
2. Jason Todd
Many might assume at first glance that Jason Todd was always destined to return as the Red Hood.
Back in 1983, though, this wasn't at all the case, since Jason was supposed to remain permanently dead following the 1988 A Death in the Family story arch. Originally, those in charge of the Batman comics at DC had wanted Dick Grayson to return as Batman's partner, but that wasn't going to happen.
So, instead, creatives had Dick Grayson assume a new identity (i.e. Nightwing) and have his mantle passed on to the newly introduced character Jason Todd.
This wasn't appreciated by fans, however, who saw Jason as a terrible replacement, while others, like writer Jim Starlin, simply hated the idea of a young sidekick all together.
The culmination of this was A Death in the Family - a story (written, of course, by Jim Starlin) that either concluded with Jason’s death or his survival, depending on the results of a call-in voting system. Obviously, Jason didn't survive.
Nevertheless, Jason would be figuratively and literally reanimated in 2005, where a persistent Judd Winick would fight for his return. A return that would see Jason finally become a fan-favourite member of the Bat-Family.
1. Deadpool
Considering the Marvel film franchise's current obsession with Deadpool, it's kind of ironic that he didn't start out nearly as popular as he is now.
Deadpool's ascension into pop-culture fame is much more recent compared to other characters, like Spider-Man.
He was originally introduced in 1991, a time when stoic-machismo was all the rage, while wiseguy humor was less so. Hence why Deadpool initially played second fiddle to Cable (the very king stoicism himself).
Nineties culture preferences aside, Deadpool's developing popularity was nevertheless stunted by several affecting circumstances. Like the fact that "Deadpool" comic creatives were often impeded by Marvel higher-ups that didn't see the point in pushing a character that didn't sell. Especially since Marvel was facing bankruptcy back then.
Nevertheless, others like Joe Kelly saw this as a chance to develop Deadpool more, and lead the charge of fleshing out the "Merc with a Mouth" persona. By the time Daniel Way comes along, Deadpool's personality and character most know of today would be firmly established.
It was by this point that Deadpool's popularity had sky-rocketed tremendously in a post-modern world that was becoming increasingly internet forward. Going forward, then, Deadpool's popularity would only grow further with his transition into film, where he's given one of the best endings to his comeback story.