They call him the Dark Knight for a reason. You could safely say that Bruce Wayne and Co. have endured some hard times throughout the Batman Family's several decades of publication, but then "hard times" would probably be an understatement. The nightmarish statistics on murder, torture, drug addiction and other Gotham City unpleasantries are enough to put even the grimmest HBO series to shame. Despite this impressive surplus of dark and twisted moments, though, the general rules of memorable and worthy fiction still apply - namely, that huge amounts of gore and sudden spurts of violence don't automatically make for compelling stories. The calm-before-the-storm moments leading up to a tragic event and the implications that follow are as important as the event itself. Though dozens of shockingly grim developments present themselves in the pages of these comics, a handful cement themselves as truly evocative and legendary sequences. A list of dark, haunting moments in Batman comics could easily be filled using only Alan Moore and the Joker (for my money, the former has a more terrifying visage), and admittedly both found their way onto more than one entry. Continue on to see Batman in his most helpless, vulnerable moments - and hopefully, in turn, to gain some insight into why he keeps donning that cape and cowl. Sweet dreams!
10. Return Of The Joker
From: "Death Of The Family" by Scott Snyder & Greg Capullo While DC's New 52 initiative found footing in the first few runs, the smiling hellion was conspicuously absent. All we knew was that his face had been surgically removed (you know, just a typical day in Gotham) and he had been missing for a year, presumably not sport-fishing off Boca Raton with some friends. I'll be a bit more careful regarding spoilers in this entry as compared to the rest of the list, as this is a very recent storyline - but suffice it to say that the Joker is back. Writer Scott Snyder and artist Greg Capullo deserve all of the attention they're getting, in my opinion, and they really drive the return of the Joker home in this arc. There is an incredibly tantalizing scene in a dark police station, and while there's no shortage of such scenes that tease the full reveal, these pieces all drive a little more toward the moment where Batman and his archenemy come face to face (to face). Not convinced? Scroll back up a little bit and gaze into those round steel eyes as they pierce your soul through a mask of flesh. That's what I thought.
9. Venom Addiction
From: "Venom" by Dennis O'Neil & Jose Luis Garcia-Lopez The original 1989 Legends Of The Dark Knight series began with a collection of incredible storylines, each spanning no less than five issues - "Shaman", "Gothic", and "Prey" were the first three, and all are excellent, essential Batman stories, but the fourth arc, "Venom", ratcheted the stakes even higher. When Batman fails to save the life of a young girl, he begins taking a strength-enhancing designer drug called Venom in an attempt to ensure that it never happens again. A bad idea all round. The drug takes over, and as Batman becomes increasingly violent he locks himself in the Batcave and instructs Alfred not to open it no matter what. Now, the story as a whole is great, but this middle issue dealing with the nightmarish detoxification is the reason why "Venom" makes this list. Bat-withdrawal is a hell of a thing, and Bruce suffers extreme delusions during his self-imposed incarceration. Dennis O'Neil is one writer who brings up what will become a bit of a theme in this list, that of turning Batman into something darker as a way to highlight the heroism inherent in his character. Another layer of grimness is added near the end of the arc, when Batman seeks vengeance for the departed young girl in the opening issue: "Not the kid, damn you. The kid didn't deserve any of it!" It's hard not to read a young Bruce Wayne as "the kid" in this passionate exchange, given a certain childhood trauma of his own...
8. The Death Of The Waynes
From: Various The beginning of the end and the end of the beginning for young Bruce Wayne, suddenly orphaned after a botched mugging attempt. This one has topped more than a few of Batman's greatest hits lists as a - perhaps "the" - defining moment in the origin of the hero. And as with most famous moments in comic book history, the death of Thomas and Martha Wayne has been subject to numerous retellings, inversions, and retrospective portrayals over the years. Initially, the murderer was an unknown phantom, and Batman's quest to find the killer seemed almost hopeless. The mugger then got a name - "Joe Chill" - in Batman #47 (1948), and appeared in most subsequent retellings as the man indirectly responsible for Batman's existence, though of course one notable exception is Tim Burton's first Batman film, in which Jack Napier does the shooting before going on to become the Joker. The implications and impact of this moment are immeasurable for Bruce, and if it was his haunted dreams we're talking about here, this would easily take the #1 spot for darkest moment. For readers, the image is just as enduring and it is precisely because these reiterations haunting Bruce are brought up again and again. The best example of this is on the last page of Detective Comics #439, at the culmination of a story called "Night of the Stalker". What does Bruce do when he arrives home after a long, mostly-successful night of crimefighting? He bursts into tears. I'll quote the final lines here, because Steve Englehart perfectly captures the ever-haunting presence of the death of the Waynes.
"As he lifts the cowl from his drawn face, his eyes automatically riseand suddenly, sorrow explodes within him. Time heals all wounds, they say - and, in truth, Bruce Wayne long ago learned to live with the agonizing fact of his parents' demise. But when he thinks of the boy crime left sobbing on the street at dusk - and the other boy crime left sobbing before the Batman's vengeance hours later - he remembers a third boy crime left sobbing so many years ago, and in this gray-lit, lonely tower, for this single moment in infinity he is that boy again."
7. The Rise Of Ra's
From: Various, but first in "Tales of the Demon" by Dennis O'Neil & Neal Adams. Ra's al Ghul has grown in popularity recently, in large part due to his role in Christopher Nolan's Batman Begins and his felt presence throughout the sequels. The Dark Knight Trilogy of course was excellent, and Liam Neeson did a fine job as Ra's, but certain elements of the comic book character were understandably removed to allow this version to fit within the more grounded and realistic world. Chief among these lost elements is the character's reincarnation, made possible by his bathing in the youth-bestowing Lazarus Pits peppered across the globe (essentially bubbling pools of Nickelodeon slime). The Pits were certainly alluded to in The Dark Knight Rises - what with Bale's Wayne being cast into a pit from which few "rise" and are "reborn" - but the supernatural image of a crazed regenerated man dripping with hot green goo doesn't exactly scream "realism." But it does make for a lasting image in the comics. Ra's is a character composed, refined, and sophisticated in his dealings, referring respectfully to Batman as "Detective". When he comes out of the Lazarus Pit, though, he is anything but elegant, as he is rendered temporarily insane (in most incarnations), and the only thing more dangerous than Ra's al Ghul is a Reincarnated Goo-Dripping Maniacal Ra's al Ghul. That may sound a bit silly, but the best writers are able to use this as a reflection of the inner demons of Bruce Wayne himself - as seen in the entry from "Venom" and as will be seen again in the next two entries, the distance between these external villains and the one behind the cowl can be frighteningly short.
6. Batman Kills
From: "The Cult" by Jim Starlin and Bernie Wrightson As stated in the previous entry, Christopher Nolan's Dark Knight Trilogy is rich with comic references. But while major stories like "The Long Halloween" and "Knightfall" tend to come away with most of the credit, an alluring cult leader named Deacon Blackfire built an army in the Gotham sewers long before Tom Hardy's Bane ever did the same. This is the one where Batman breaks bad. After being kidnapped and brainwashed by the titular cult, our shining hero proceeds to gun down someone who may be the Joker, or maybe Commissioner Gordon, or maybe someone else entirely, or maybe he didn't even shoot them after all - this back and forth uncertainty is a function of Batman hallucinogenic state, and it is simultaneously frustrating and terrifying. The most haunting element is the intimation that Batman is so close to the edge of evil. "The Cult" has many, many problems as a narrative (Starlin can do better), but never has the sense of "thank goodness he's on our side" been conveyed so urgently. Despite his constantly-reiterated aversion to killing, Bruce Wayne can't deny the power provided by a gun in his hand - bringing to mind Robin's comment on the subject, "Feels good, doesn't it?", in the "Batman: Odyssey" series by Neal Adams. The real-world implications of this are, unfortunately, very relevant, with gun control laws in flux in the United Sates and the world over. This relevance takes "The Cult" into dark territory that isn't often explored in comic books.
5. Vampire Bat
From: "Red Rain" by Doug Moench and Kelley Jones I haven't read as many Elseworlds stories as I should have, and I haven't enjoyed all of the ones I have read, but "Batman vs. Dracula: Red Rain" is not only a great Elseworlds tale, it's also quite simply an awesome Batman story. In order to have any hope in defending Gotham against a vampire horde led by Dracula himself, Batman must sacrifice his humanity and become like his enemy. He convinces a rebellious vampire called Tanya to take his blood and turn him into one of them, and what follows is an incredibly dark, incredibly fun dive into the deepest part of Bruce Wayne's psyche. This entry is placed next to the entry from "The Cult" because they both deal with killing, crossing boundaries, and doing "evil" in order to do "good". I don't place "Red Rain" higher because it is a tighter, more subtle story (although it is), but because these temptations and inclinations toward the taking of life are a greater part of Batman now. The desire to kill is insatiable and overpowering, and yes, it's mainly because he's a vampire - but the desire was always there. The need to suppress it is nothing new in the world of Batman, but it is brought to the forefront in a fresh way here. And this book is haunting on a superficial level too - did I mention Batman is a vampire? Again, the writing is superb here, but the art is phenomenal as well. The only "human" part of Bruce Wayne we ever see while in the guise of Batman is his mouth, and now that mouth is a grotesquely fanged grin. Overall, this tale does functions exactly as an Elseworlds tale should - as a lens on the basic character - and the perversion is a welcome terror.
4. The Killing Joke
From: "The Killing Joke" by Alan Moore & Brian Bolland. How do you solve a problem like Alan Moore? The man writes something as good as "The Killing Joke" and then all but disowns the thing. Of course, this has slightly less impact when you consider that he's also disowned every film adaptation of his comic works, every film adaptation of any comic work, anyone over or under the age of 40 who enjoys such works regardless of the medium, and any work from any time period from any artist that dares pack less of a thematic punch than Shakespeare himself. I digress. There is an obvious event, for those of you who have read "The Killing Joke", that stands out as the climactic tragedy of the story (the list isn't over yet). But the falling motion after this brutal event is laudable as a dark moment in its own right. On the final page of the story Batman has confronted the Joker, offering him rehabilitation, and the latter tells a winding and symbolic joke about two insane men. He laughs at the punchline and Batman, in one of the few times we see his stoic exterior crack, slowly begins to laugh as well. They each appear to take an awkward step toward each other, and then, as they seem to embrace, as their laughter moves between the thin pylons of falling rain... the book ends. What happens? Is Batman hugging the Joker or is he killing him? Everyone has their own theories on the ending - there is an excellent one regarding a certain poison needle from earlier in the book - but the unsettling fact remains that none of these can ever be declared "correct". This kind of stuff bothers me, and I actually think that's the point. To paraphrase the King of Ambiguity Henry James, from a note on ambiguity in his works, such uncertainty leaves room for infinite possibilities, for things so dark and terrible they defy any attempt to explain them. The readers are forced to "think the evil", to make it for themselves, and thereby are only limited by their own minds. Perhaps this moment wouldn't make your cut, but personally the uncertainty presented at the end of this already soul-crushing tale is a perfect example of how truly twisted a comic book can get.
3. The Death Of Jason Todd
From: "A Death In The Family" by Jim Starlin, Jim Aparo & Mike DeCarlo Batman's greatest failure has also left a lasting impression on readers of all ages, although the general consensus is that Jason Todd was not a good Robin. The sad truth was that he was barely even a likable character. Over time, the writers and editors over at DC realized that they had to phase out Robin II due to his unpopularity, and you can really feel something big on the horizon in the arcs leading up to "A Death In The Family" - check out "The Diplomat's Son" (Batman #424-5), in which Jason coolly lets a politician's son fall to his death, causing the diplomat to take drastic measures which result in even more deaths. DC famously set up a 900 hotline halfway through "A Death In The Family" - one number if you wanted Robin to live, another if you wanted him to die. After the Joker brutally beats him with a crowbar, votes were cast and the Boy Wonder was done for. Some call this a publicity stunt, others say the voting was rigged and Robin was always going to die* - I say neither of these pointless arguments changes the fact that he did meet his end, and even though he wasn't likable as Robin he hardly deserved to be beaten and blown up by the Clown Prince of Crime. How could the elected death of a widely-disliked character, you may ask, rank so much higher than the death of Bruce's parents? Simply enough, there aren't really any scenarios where the Waynes don't die. It's a part of the mythos - and so is a young spandexed sidekick at Batman's side. Seeing him removed so forcibly and mercilessly from the world makes for an eerily unforgettable moment, even if you do see it coming. *If you're in this camp (why are you in this camp?) check out the Batman #428 variant where Jason lives, drawn in the event that readers chose to save him. The ecstatic look on Batman's face is pretty ridiculous by itself, but compared with the actual reaction (above) it is especially hilarious.
2. Amadeus Arkham Comes Home
From: "Arkham Asylum: A Serious House on Serious Earth" by Grant Morrison and Dave McKean One of darkest moments in Batman comics doesn't directly feature the Dark Knight at all. In Grant Morrison's 1989 book "Arkham Asylum: A Serious House on Serious Earth", the main tale is intercut with flashbacks to the birth of the Asylum itself. Spurred by the vision and ultimate insanity of Amadeus Arkham, the madhouse has a history intricately linked to its namesake - a history of slow, torturous craze and unimaginable family tragedy. Amadeus is portrayed as a young doctor for most of the flashback. His mother Elizabeth had gone insane and committed suicide long ago, and so he founds Arkham Hospital in her name. As the wings of the hospital are expanded and remodeled, Amadeus is notified that a former patient of his - Martin "Mad Dog" Hawkins - has escaped from prison. Sure enough, Amadeus arrives home to find his door wide open and his wife and young daughter brutally mutilated. There is an image of a certain dollhouse resident that I dare not describe. But the darkness doesn't stop there, as the death of his family triggers a repressed memory to resurface within Amadeus's mind - his mother's suicide had, in fact, been a murder, with a young Amadeus himself on the giving end of the killing stroke in a devastating attempt to protect his mother from her own insanity. Morrison intentionally wrote this book to combat the realism that was trending in the industry at the time (and to this day), purposefully crafting a kind of "right-brain" Batman tale based in dreamlike, emotional, and irrational imagery. I'm not a fan of everything Morrison has written, but his work on "Arkham Asylum" continues to haunt me to this day.
1. The Joker Breaks Gordon
From: "The Killing Joke" by Alan Moore & Brian Bolland It might seem self-serving to include two entries from the same book, but each deserves the attention individually. Commissioner Jim Gordon has been absent from this list until now, but this moment from "The Killing Joke" makes up for all of that. He's a mainstay of the Batman mythos, an everlasting part of the story alongside Alfred, Robin, the Batcave, and the rest of it. He was also the best part of Frank Miller's "Year One", probably because he consistently showed how badass he could really be. As with any established mythos, it's the shaking up of the parts that makes for the most compelling reading, the sudden changing of the status-quo such that it can't be repaired - and the Joker certainly does just that. My summary will be brief, because you really should read it for yourself: after kidnapping, stripping, and torturing the Commissioner, the Joker pays his daughter Barbara Gordon - the former Batgirl - a visit. Jim Gordon is forced to see his daughter shot and crippled for life and is unable to do anything about it besides scream with rage and despair. It's brutal and it's hard to read. For a while DC started pasting a little box on the bottom-left corner of their issue covers that said "DC COMICS AREN'T JUST FOR KIDS!", and in reading a comic book like this, one wonders if they wouldn't have gone ahead and eradicated the "JUST" part. "The Joker Breaks Gordon" may be a bit misleading, because although we see Gordon dragged to the bottom of the pit of despair, he remains a steadfast rock on which Batman can rely. This event is horrific for the implications and for the way it all plays out in unflinching, all-too-real detail. But Gordon is more than a mainstay of the Batman mythos - very often, he is a mirror for the reader, trusting Batman against all authoritative decree, fighting to see the good in a city so enveloped by shadow. To see that character tortured both physically and emotionally is heartbreaking. To see him ultimately rise above it is the reason I read these books. Which haunting moments have been forgotten? Submit them in the comments below.