10 Most Evil Things Judge Dredd Has Ever Done

Sylvester Stallone and Karl Urban's films may have slightly missed the point of Judge Dredd...

By Patrick Watters /

If you only know Judge Dredd from his goofy 1995 cinematic outing starring Sylvester Stallone then you’ll be very surprised to see how much of a monster his comic book counterpart actually is. Even the hyper-violent 2012 movie Dredd, in which the titular character leaves swathes of criminals in bullet riddled gory mess on the floor, pales in comparison to what he gets up to in the comics.

Advertisement

First appearing in the second issue (or “Prog” in their parlance) of 2000 AD in March 1977, Judge Joseph Dredd has since appeared in over 2200 weekly Progs, received his own spin-off “Judge Dredd Megazine”, had his own newspaper strip, two movies, and a handful of video games.

In the subsequent 40 years as well as your standard criminals he’s fought robot rebellions, interdimensional death obsessed monsters, corrupt foreign powers, corrupt domestic powers, and even Xenomorphs and the Predator. He’s been shot, stabbed, blown up, and had his eyes gouged out by futuristic vampires.

Despite all that however, Dredd himself is often the biggest a**hole in the story...

10. Executing Surrendered Criminals

Judge Dredd first appeared in Prog 2 of 2000ad however that wasn't supposed to be the case. He was actually supposed to appear in the very first Prog the week before.

Advertisement

A story was written and drawn by series creators John Wagner and Carlos Ezquerra all ready to go. It opened with a bang too, quickly establishing the cruel authoritarian world Dredd lived in. We're told that the Judges of this world have complete authority to sentence criminals how they like, they are judge, jury and executioner. This is brought into stark relief when, after foiling a robbery, Dredd commands the surrendered criminals to get down on their knees, whereupon he sentences them to death and shoots them in the back of the head.

The image of the protagonist coldly executing people in such a way was a hell of a way to open this new comic and really showed what a bastard Dredd was right from the get go. Unfortunately, 2000AD's target audience at the time was young children and this was considered inappropriate by the publisher. Dredd's debut was pushed back while a replacement story was created, and Dredd was mostly shown killing in self defence thereafter.

Fortunately that original story was later reprinted in Judge Dredd: The Complete Case Files 01 and it's well worth checking out.

9. Imprisoning and then killing his brother

The Judge System was created in 2031 by Eustace Fargo, who served as Chief Judge until his attempted suicide in 2051. Fearing the loss of their leader the Judges implemented a cloning program to preserve his, and other notable Judges, legacy.

Advertisement

Several clones of Fargo were created over the years, most notably our protagonist Joseph Dredd and his brother Rico Dredd. Joe was the perfect Judge; Rico wasn't. In Prog 30 we learn that Rico was corrupt, committing multiple crimes including blackmail and murder.

Upon learning of his brother's crimes Dredd has him sent to a penal colony for corrupt Judges on Saturn's moon Titan. On Titan the prisoners are mutilated to be fitted with breathing equipment rather than waste a space suit on them. Naturally Rico isn't too happy with all this and vows revenge on his brother.

Eventually returning to Mega City One Rico attacks Dredd whereupon Dredd shoots him dead.

Familial bond doesn't mean much to Mega City One's toughest lawman.

8. Stamping Down On Democracy

Mega City One is a fascist state. Judge Dredd is a fascist enforcer. That's not some broad interpretation made by someone with too much time on their hands. It's just what the comic is about.

Advertisement

The story "A Letter to Judge Dredd" from Prog 661 showed just how brutal this system is for the ordinary citizens. It tells the story of a man named Sholley. Sholley believes that Mega City One should be governed democratically and attends a peaceful protest to that effect. Now naturally the Judges couldn't be having that and violently cracked down on the protesters. Sholley himself suffered a brutal head injury and severe brain damage, spending the rest of his life suffering violent delusions and outbursts, culminating in him committing murder.

This story is related to Dredd in a letter from a boy, Wenders, who questions the Judge System and why a peaceful protest warranted such a response. Ultimately Wenders was the one murdered by Sholley.

These events would cause Dredd to have misgivings about the system he enforced and he briefly retired, leading to the excellent Necropolis story arc.

Even so, it's now 30 years later and and Dredd is still a fascist enforcer for a fascist government.

7. Bullying His Only Friend

Judge Dredd lives to work, only sleeping 10 minutes a day with the aid of sleep machines and spending the rest of his day pounding the streets of Mega City One, leaving him little time for a social life.

Advertisement

It wasn't always this way though. Before the introduction of sleep machines Dredd had an apartment he would spend his off time in with his landlady Maria and his friend Walter. Walter was a robot first introduced in the early story arc "Robot Wars" as a comedic foil for Dredd. As his mincing man servant with a "hilarious" speech impediment Walter the Wobot (no really) absolutely sucked. Even Dredd himself openly despised him, belittling him at every opportunity.

Still, it was unnecessarily cruel when Dredd kicked him out onto the streets. All he wanted to do was be Dredd's friend and he was a major fixture of the comic in its first year. An embittered Walter would later lead a short lived robot rebellion, even shooting Dredd himself.

To be honest he had it coming.

6. Killed America (The person)

Starting in the very first issue of the spin off "Judge Dredd Megazine" the classic story "America" is rightly considered one of, if not the, best Judge Dredd stories ever.

Advertisement

The story follows America Jara, a child of immigrants named after the hope inspired by a country that, in the Judge Dredd universe, doesn't really exist anymore. Raised on stories of the American dream, America hates the Judges and everything they stand for. Her commitment to American ideals and democracy, coupled with the Judges' crackdown on any democratic movements, ultimately leads America to joining "Total War". Total War is a terrorist organisation who aim to install democracy in Mega City One.

America's story ends in tragedy when she is shot and killed in a failed attempt to blow up the Statue of Liberty to send a message. Dredd himself didn't fire the shot that killed her but as America dies on the steps of Liberty Island he towers over her in a chilling image and says the following: "Justice has a price. The price is Freedom".

5. Killing America (The Country)

With all the aforementioned authoritarian overreach by Dredd and his fellow Judges you might be wondering why the American government has never tried to stop them. Well, they did.

Advertisement

Founded in 2031 to combat rising crime, the Judges initially served the United States government. That was until the 2070's with the rise of President Robert L Booth, the last president of the USA. Booth was an authoritarian isolationist who surprisingly wasn't based on anyone currently in power. His policies caused him to repeatedly butt heads with the Judges and other world governments, ultimately building to a Third World War.

Nuclear war devastated the world, leaving huge chunks of it uninhabitable and forcing the survivors to huddle in the new Mega Cities.

All this gave the Judges the excuse they needed. Citing the United States Declaration of Independence as justification, Dredd and his fellow Judges stormed the Whitehouse and deposed Booth. The USA was no more and the Judges' power was total.

4. Discriminating against mutants

After the nuclear wars of the 2070 most of North America is a radiated desert known as the Cursed Earth where few survive. Some do live outside the Mega Cities though: outcasts, criminals, and mutants.

Advertisement

The mutants are victims of the war, twisted and disfigured by radiation. How does Dredd and his colleagues treat these people?

Well besides the useful ones like the psychic Judge Anderson they're all treated as monsters and banished from the city, forced to eke out a survival in the barren wasteland. In fact for the first 30 years of the comic Dredd would often execute these poor souls whenever they tried to get into the city.

During the 2006 story arc "Origin" Dredd did start to soften his views on mutants, although only after finding out some of them were his relatives. Dredd would petition to allow mutants into the city and after much back and forth, they are now welcome. (Provided, of course, they submit to sterilisation.)

3. Nuking a city

The Apocalypse War was a major story arc running from Prog 245 to 270, although first being seeded in 236. It followed the invasion of Mega City One by the Soviet city East Meg One.

Advertisement

The people of Mega City One are decimated by nuclear attacks and early on the Judges are left ruined. By the end over 400 million Mega City citizens are left dead and swathes of the city is reduced to rubble. It's intense.

Naturally Dredd himself isn't too happy about all this. He spearheads a guerrilla resistance against the Soviets, eventually capturing one of their missile bunkers. Deciding to turn their own nukes against them, one of the Soviet Judges begs Dredd to stop. "There are half a billion people in my city - half a billion human beings! You can't just wipe them out with the push of a button!" he cries. Dredd's reply?

"Can't I?"

With that, Dredd wipes the city from the map, leaving millions dead in seconds.

2. Causing Chaos Day

The fallout from the Apocalypse War continues to resonate throughout Judge Dredd comics even close to 40 years later. (Murdering millions of people will do that.)

Advertisement

Over the years survivors of East Meg One and its sister city East Meg Two have tried to avenge themselves against Dredd and his city countless times. Easily the most successful attempt was the Chaos Bug.

Featured in the story "Day of Chaos" in Progs 1743 to 1789, the story sees a former East Meg One colonel Yevgeny Borisenko unleash a deadly plague, the Chaos Bug, on Mega City One. The Bug has a 98% fatality rate and millions die. The resulting chaos sees the serial killer PJ Maybe escape prison, the genocidal Dark Judges being unleashed on the city, the Judges' surveillance centre in the Statue of Judgement being destroyed, and by the end 87% of the population are dead.

All because of Dredd's actions decades earlier.

1. Becoming death itself

The most recent story on this list, "End of Days" began in Prog 2184 in June of 2020 it featured the four horsemen of the apocalypse showing up on Earth and deciding to do what they do best.

Advertisement

Dredd and his fellow Judges travelling the world to track down and stop the horsemen. Each horseman had possessed a human who best represented their aspect: Pestilence possessed a researcher working on deadly diseases; Famine a Brit Cit politician who, in a not so subtle jab at UK politics, implemented austerity measures in a housing block named after Dominic Cummings.

But who could possibly represent death? Well if you've read the previous entries do you even have to ask? The man who has killed millions over the years. Judge Dredd himself of course. The malignant entity took control of him and tried to crash the moon itself into Earth.

He was stopped by his fellow Judge Giant, but if trying to destroy the Earth itself isn't up there on the evil scale then what is?

Advertisement