10 Most Inappropriate Superman Storylines
Superman is immune to nearly everything except cringe-worthy and inappropriate storylines.
Superman has been around for 84 years and has gone through a lot of changes since his introduction in Action Comics #1 in 1938. He has gone from an obscure social crusader to a pop culture icon. A number of writers and artists have come together over the years to put their stamp on the modern myth of the Man of Steel.
Some of the Man of Tomorrow's storylines have ventured into the odd, the offensive, or the downright silly over the decades. These stories have either portrayed Superman and his cast of characters in a manner contrary to the way they normally act, placed them in unusual situations, or introduced characters that make the stories go off the rails.
Other stories are just “of that time”, meaning what was said or done may have been acceptable then but is offensive to our modern sensibilities. Another explanation could be summed up by the term the “Silver Age”, a period rife with all kinds of weird, wacky, and odd tales. There is also shock value, as some writers can only pen an interesting story by doing something to shock the reader.
10. Superman Spanked
World’s Finest #201 is one of those Silver Age stories that started out with a simple enough premise but somewhere along the line, it takes a hard turn into the strange. And the fact that it was written by the astonishingly talented Denny O’Neil proves that even legends can have an off day. The story starred Superman and Green Lantern, with a guest appearance by Doctor Fate.
Clark and Hal got into an argument on how to save a plane. One of the Guardians of the Universe appeared and suggested that the pair settle their argument on a more cosmic scale. Soliciting the help of Doctor Fate, the first to reach an enchanted purple dragon wins. However, the pair must face their greatest fear. For Kal-El, that is the disapproval of his father, Jor-El.
The psychological angst is a powerful story point but the sight of a grown Superman being spanked by his gigantic father, wailing and screaming “Punish me, Daddy! I deserve it!” is extremely unsettling. And then to turn on a dime and realize that it is all an illusion and that Fate is a disguised Felix Faust not only bends credibility but breaks a few of its bones.
9. Burn The Bat-Witch!
The casual use of time travel was a recurring story troupe in the Silver Age. Heroes in costume from the present travel back to major events in history, make large-scale changes and assumed that everything will work out. And often, their reason for the trip could have been answered by a trip to the library.
In World’s Finest #186 and #187, Bruce Wayne receives a bust of Revolutionary War General “Mad” Anthony Wayne. The bust looks nearly identical to Bruce and, when the bust is accidentally shattered, Batman asks Superman to repair it as it looked like the Caped Crusader. The heroes traveled to the Revolutionary War era to uncover the mystery. There, they save a woman named Sylvia Ward from being drowned as a witch, and then Clark begins to turn the townspeople against Bruce. He impersonates Batman and performs “acts of witchcraft” that get the World's Greatest Detective arrested and tied to a stake. Only a well-timed entrance of a kid named Robbyn and a convenient piece of kryptonite chased a demon out of Superman and saved the Dark Knight’s life.
Among the odd things in this story is the demon that is not mentioned again. It is also never explained why Robbyn has the kryptonite in his possession. The initial mystery is easily solved but there are so many more that sprang up in the telling.
8. Lois Lane, The Marrying Woman
Lois Lane. Intrepid and fearless reporter. Multiple Pulitzer Prize winner. Respected and feared investigator. And for a significant part of her history, a sneaky conniving woman who would do anything to trick Superman into marrying her. Including marrying his friend, his greatest enemy, and any number of aliens, criminals, and random guys all in the effort to make Superman jealous.
Many of these were imaginary stories, like the time when Lois fell in love with Bruce Wayne and he waited until the wedding night to reveal the truth about his identity. In Superman’s Girlfriend Lois Lane #34, Lois marries a forcibly reformed Lex Luthor in another story. In Action Comics #245, Zak-Kul, a criminal from Kandor impersonates Superman and marries Lois, but when she starts to ask too many questions, he tries to kill her.
Lois married an alien from the far future that convinced her that it was her destiny to marry him and a convict as a death row favor. All of the marriages that happened for real were annulled or forgotten. Lois married Clark for real in Superman: The Wedding Album in 1996, although Lane was never afraid to use marriage as a weapon.
7. Supergirl And Comet
Many little girls become obsessed with horses. It’s unusual when the horse becomes obsessed with the girl and, even more so when the horse becomes a man and starts to romance the girl when she grows older. This is just part of the strange story of Comet the Super Horse.
Comet started life as a centaur named Biron who saved the sorceress Circe from a rival wizard. He asked to be turned human as a reward but the spell was thwarted by the other wizard, and Circe, believing the mistake is hers, gave Biron superpowers and immortality. Enraged, the evil wizard trapped Biron on a distant asteroid until he is freed by Supergirl’s escape rocket on its way to Earth.
He followed her to Earth and waited a few years to get himself taken to the Supergirl Dude Ranch. There, he and Supergirl thwart an alien attack that he had telepathically warned her about. Kara named the horse Comet. Biron gained the ability to change into a human whenever a comet went through the system from an alien wizard, and thus he romanced the Maid of Might as master horse rider 'Bronco' Bill Star. He never told her the truth.
6. The Lack Of Diversity In The 31st Century
The Legion of Super-Heroes was open to teens of any species that had a unique singular power that would be useful on the team. They had the blue-skinned Shadow Lass, the orange-skinned Chameleon Boy, the green-skinned Brainiac-5, and any number of white-skinned members, but there seemed to be a lack of black-skinned Legionnaires.
Legion artist Mike Grell stated that he had tried many times to introduce a dignified black character to the team, but the powers-that-be kept pushing back. What was finally presented in 1976 became Tyroc, a hero from a land called Marzal. It was an island that was settled by escaped slaves from Africa that regularly shifted into another dimension. It had become highly technologically advanced but isolationist by the 31st Century. Grell was offended by this idea and gave Tyroc a “silly” costume to go along with his odd powers of a reality-altering scream.
In addition to essentially segregating the black people by story mandate, there wasn’t another black Legionnaire until the second Invisible Kid was forced to stop his sister from becoming Computo seven years later. After that, DC retconned Kid Quantum into the first team of Legionaries after one of the many rewrites of their history.
5. Superman Marries Supergirl
It is surprising how often the writers of Superman and Supergirl titles have tried to find a way for them to be in a romance or even get married. It’s not as frequent a troupe as Lois finding herself in some strange predicament because of her trying to make Superman fall in love with her, but the fact that it happened more than once is somewhat unsettling.
One of Superman's creators wrote a story in Action Comics #289 where Supergirl tries to set her cousin up with the most beautiful women in history. She finds a super-powered woman on another planet for Superman who is a slightly older but otherwise identical twin to her. Kal-El tells Kara that the only reason he won’t marry her is that it was illegal on Krypton.
More recently, Peter David had the current Linda Lee Supergirl travel back in time and take Kara Zor-El’s place on Earth-One so Kara won’t die in the Crisis. Superman realizes that she isn’t his cousin, they fall in love and have a daughter. However, despite her plans, Linda isn’t powerful enough and Kara has to face the Anti-Monitor. Having failed, she leaves Clark a letter and disappeared.
4. World Shaking Sex
Frank Miller and Lynn Varley head down a road often taken in issue # 2 of The Dark Knight Strikes Again. They pair Superman and Wonder Woman. In fact, they even give them a teenage daughter. What we don’t normally get to see is five pages of airborn sex.
Diana finds a depressed and down-trodden Clark who has given up on the idea of being a hero and saving the world. She punches him and asks him where the man who once took her with such resolve and passion was. He said “Here” and they took to the sky. Their sex began to cause a tsunami, tipping over a destroyer, causing the evacuation of the big island of Hawaii and an earthquake of 7.8 on the Richter Scale. Their climax was literally explosive as it caused a volcano to erupt.
This is really something that you’d expect to see in fan fiction rather than in a mainstream comic book. And while the act did get the Man of Steel back in action, if you follow the idea through logically, thousands or maybe millions died due to their amorous act. What is the message readers are supposed to get from this? That sex and violence are two sides of the same coin?
3. Lois Lane “Turns Black”
Superman's Girlfriend Lois Lane #106 comes dangerously close to being racially offensive by having Lois Lane be “turned” into an African American woman for 24 hours simply to get a potential Pulitzer Prize-winning story.
Lois was assigned to write a non-specified story in Little Africa, Metropolis’ black community. She went to the area and is shunned and ignored by all except a man at a meeting who called her “whitey” and blamed her for all their neighborhood’s problems. Unable to think of any other way to connect with these people, Lois asked Superman to use a Kryptonian device to make her a black person for 24 hours. Thus changed, she was accepted, helped people, and was hit on by the man who yelled at her. He was shot breaking up a drug deal and Lois gave him a transfusion, and the man happily accepted her help with a smile.
The idea that Lois could begin to understand the black experience in a day simply by looking like a black person is probably the most insulting idea of this issue. The creators also fell into the “angry black man” trope and the trope that what one black person experiences is the same for all black people. The creators tried so hard, but they fell so short.
2. Superman XXX
Writer and artist John Byrne had restructured Superman from the ground up and returned to Action Comics by teaming him with a variety of DC heroes. In issue , Byrne teamed Superman with Big Barda and Mr. Miracle. But the Metropolis Marvel and former Female Fury didn’t exactly trade punches.
Mister Miracle found his biological father Darkseid sitting in his living room on Earth holding a videotape. Scott was shocked to see his wife Barda in a compromising position, and Darkseid told Scott the tape was acquired in Metropolis’ Suicide Slum. A being named Sleez had taken control of Barda and brought a controlled Superman to the office of an adult film director. On the set, Clark tried to push back against Sleez’s mind control but failed until Mr. Miracle broke in through the skylight.
You almost have to give John Byrne some credit for alluding to but not quite saying that he was trying to portray a pornographic movie in a mainstream DC comic. The fact that Darkseid made a personal visit to Suburbia to deliver the news, and that it takes three of the most capable heroes in DC to deal with a creature under 4-foot tall, only adds to the oddity of this issue.
1. The Injustice Of Injustice
Injustice explores the far too often used trope of Superman going evil and how the rest of the heroes and the world at large would respond to that. Injustice pushes the Man of Steel far beyond his heroic origins into a despot that takes over the world.
Jimmy Olsen is killed and a newly pregnant Lois Lane is kidnapped by the Joker and Harley Quinn. Superman arrived at the submarine where Joker was hiding and where Supes believed that Doomsday was attacking him. Kal-El carried the monster into space, ignoring the screaming transmissions of Batman and the Justice League. The Joker had laced Scarecrow’s fear toxin with kryptonite and Clark had actually carried Lois into space, killing her and their child. The Harlequin of Hate had also attached a kill switch to Lois’ heart for a nuclear bomb that destroyed Metropolis. Kal put his hand through Joker’s chest, killing him, and then stated that all violence would end. This started a descent into madness where the Boy Scout killed friends, ignored governments, and took over nations.
The true problem with Injustice, is it completely misunderstands the concept of Superman. At his core, no matter what, there is hope. He absolutely does not kill his friends and he does not become a totalitarian despot. The Man of Tomorrow is supposed to be inspirational and aspirational, not a villain.