10 Shocking Times Superheroes Just QUIT

Those jaw-dropping moments when our favorite heroes just threw in the towel.

By John Tibbetts /

Everyone loves a hero who never gives up in the face of adversity. Who never backs down, no matter what the world throws at them. Well, sometimes the world has other plans.

Advertisement

Whether because a different writer has a different idea for how the character should progress or generally work, or because certain events are just that shaking, some superheroes just feel it's best to throw in the towel. Sometimes they come back, sometimes they stay gone for good.

And these moments can be built up over years to the point where you're just counting down the days until they throw in the towel, or in this case, they come out of nowhere and leave you utterly floored. But, just because you didn't see them coming doesn't make them bad, if anything it makes the act of them quitting even more effecting.

As long as you do it well, a superhero giving up can be the most emotionally resonant scene in your entire series. These moments range in terms of quality, but they are definitely the most shocking moments when our favorite heroes just gave up.

10. Superman - Superman #296 - #299

Being the most powerful superhero in the DC universe, naturally the idea of Superman retiring and the world adjusting to that retirement is a fascinating idea to explore. Equally fascinating, in this case, is focusing on how Superman himself would adjust to his own retirement. This is, after all, a guy who doesn't have an unhelpful bone in his body.

Advertisement

However, at some point he decided to at least give being Clark Kent full time the old Kryptonian college try. In Superman #296, Clark starts noticing an anomaly: whenever he changes into his Clark Kent persona, he loses his powers completely (caused by a villain who was fluctuating his powers, long story). He decides to test the theory by straight up abandoning the Superman identity altogether and becoming Clark Kent permanently. Even managing to finally work out a serious relationship with Lois Lane that lasted long after this story.

Superman even goes so far as to ignore someone in trouble because the police are already on their way and have it handled. But of course, the big lovable boy scout can't stay away forever, gets the anomaly worked out, but at least gets to keep his relationship with Lois.

But still the decision to quit being superman for almost four issues was a bold experiment on DC's part.

9. Captain America - Captain America #175

What does Captain America do when he can no longer believe in America?

Advertisement

This is the conflict Steve faced in Captain America #175, when constant head butting with the American government finally came to a head upon learning that the leader of the criminal cabal known as the Secret Empire was none other than the President himself. His idealism shattered along with his belief in the system he had dedicated his life to defending, Cap made one of the ballsiest moves in the character's entire history (which is definitely saying something). He threw away his shield and quit being Captain America altogether.

He tried to retire with his girlfriend Sharon, but of course, found that he just couldn't stay away while others were in peril. But he still didn't want to adopt the Captain America mantle again, so he created a new title: Nomad, the man without a country.

This lasted a lot longer than you'd think it would, to the point where - while he's never expressly called Nomad in Infinity War - Chris Evans' new suit in that movie eerily resembles his original Nomad outfit. Just without the giant chest window. Which is a shame in itself, for a number of reasons.

8. The Spectre - Jim Corrigan

The Spectre is one of the most fascinating characters in the entire DC canon. Starting out as the ghost of a detective who solves murders in the golden age, The Spectre was revealed to in fact be the literal wrath of God sent to bring punishment to the guilty. As such, it doesn't really need Jim Corrigan, and can move to whatever host it wishes.

Advertisement

So it was in the John Ostrander Spectre series from 1992, that Jim Corrigan would be retired as the host of The Spectre. Throughout the series, facing many great challenges, including finally confronting the man who murdered him in the first place, Jim learns why he was chosen as the Spectre to begin with. Not simply to smite evil, but to understand it, and himself.

By the end, Jim comes to terms with his anger at evil in the world, and how it had its roots in his own abusive childhood. With the peace he's found in death, the Spectre releases him to the afterlife, but stays behind to find a new host.

It was surprising to say the least, seeing this 62 issue run conclude with the departure of one of the original DC heroes. And while The Spectre itself has remained behind, this is where the story of Jim Corrigan, detective and supernatural superhero, concludes. The Spectre isn't exactly a character surrounded by cheer and happiness, but at least detective Corrigan finally got the happy ending he deserved.

7. Veil - Avengers Academy

As seen with the last entry, not everyone who gives up being a superhero comes back. Sometimes when the creators pull out the shocking "oh my god this or that hero is giving up" card, they really do mean it. And sometimes, you can't help but be in total agreement with the one leaving. Which brings us nicely to Madeline Berry, AKA Veil.

Advertisement

Madeline technically got her start in the event comic Marvel Dark Reign, where she and several other teenagers were kidnapped and experimented on, with the intent of activating their powers through the pain and trauma these experiments caused.

After Dark Reign ended, Maddy and the other kids were brought to Avengers Academy for training, since the Avengers didn't feel confident about leaving a bunch of tortured, traumatized teenagers alone with their thoughts now that they had devastating super powers.

Maddy went along with it for a while, but eventually went to work for entrepreneur Jeremy Briggs, who promised to cure her powers, but was secretly using her as a prototype for his plan to de-power all supers. Veil's last adventure as a superhero was stopping that plan in its tracks, before returning for good to her civilian life.

6. Martian Manhunter - JLA #71

The Martian Manhunter has had a fascinating career over the years, ever since he first popped up in Detective Comics #225. But for the longest time, his comics always played coy with the reason why he came to Earth in the first place. We know why he stuck around - he quite likes us monkeys - but why did he leave at all?

Advertisement

That answer would come in Justice League of America #71, and the answer is not fun. This is where readers were first introduced to the White Martians, another race of martians that had overrun and enslaved their green brethren a long time ago.

Although Jonn and the League emerge victorious in the end, Mars is left uninhabitable as a result of the plan set in motion by Blanx, the White Martian leader. Jonn then shocked his friends by informing them that he would set out with the remains of his people to help them find a new home.

Although he would pop back up every now and then, it would be 15 years before Jonn returned to Earth full time. That's quite a long time to go without a central character. At least Barry had Wally to replace him for the time he spent gone.

5. Black Panther - Black Panther #50

If there is a single writer responsible for bringing the Black Panther into modern comic book reading attention, it would definitely have to be Christopher Priest and his acclaimed run on the character. It's some of T'Challa's best stories and moments, including the one where he actually quit being The Black Panther.

Advertisement

After some shenanigans involving a future version of T'Challa found in suspended animation (it's a long story, Priest's run is WEIRD) T'Challa, to the shock of everyone, quit being the Black Panther in a bout of lost hope. To the point where he gave away the suit to a New York detective named Kasper Cole.

What was even more shocking, though, was how he came back. Because it turned out he never really left, having quit in some uber elaborate scheme to bring down the 66 Bridges Crime Cartel. It makes a lot more sense in context, promise.

The fact that Kasper Cole was Black Panther for a decently long time before T'Challa took back the mantle was a ballsy move on the part of Priest, and really made readers wonder if T'Challa was really coming back or not.

4. Jack Knight - Starman

While the nineties is mostly remembered as a dark time for comic books, Marvel in particular, the mid to late-nineties was when DC REALLY got its act together. It's insane the amount and consistency of great stories that came out of this period, Grant Morrison's JLA, Neil Gaiman's Sandman, and of course, James Robinson's Starman.

Advertisement

The story centred around Jack Knight, estranged son of the original Starman, who wanted nothing to do with the mantle since beating up bad guys doesn't exactly do much for the environment or world hunger. But after fate leaves him with little choice in the matter, Jack takes up the mantle once more and is way better at it than he thought he'd be.

However, by the end, Jack is understandably pretty tired by the whole thing. And on top of that, he'd just had a baby with his girlfriend. After some well needed soul searching, Jack performs some final acts of heroism to tie up any loose ends and make sure he leaves Opal City safer than it was when he started. Even straight up giving away the Cosmic Staff to his protege Courtney Whitmore, who bears the mantle of Stargirl to this day.

More than 15 years have passed since the last Starman issue, and we haven't heard out of our old buddy Jack. But then, that's probably for the best. Our time with Jack was comparatively short, but if anyone deserved a happy ending, it was him.

3. Ms. Marvel - Avengers #200

So far, we've seen superheroes who quit for personal reasons that they make of their own free will and autonomy. Sure would be a shame if that streak were to break so close to the end, right?

Advertisement

Yeah, okay, let's talk about Avengers #200.

In the realm of superheroes quitting out of nowhere, this is one of the most infamous examples. Mostly - in fact primarily - because of its utterly icky subject matter. The gist of it is that Ms Marvel has mysteriously gotten pregnant. Once the pregnancy occurs though, it turns out to actually be Carol's inter-dimensional "husband" (if we could make the air quotes bigger, we would) who reincarnated himself into this dimension through impregnating Carol. Who - along with the Avengers - is inexplicably okay with this, and rides off into the sunset with him shortly thereafter.

Yes yes, we see your raised hands and blaring alarm bells, those of you who haven't heard this story before, this isn't where the story ends.

Much later, Carol came back, having escaped her so-called husband Marcus. As it turns out, she was being brainwashed into being Marcus' wife just so he could enact an overly elaborate evil scheme. But notably The Avengers were under no such effect.

Carol quits the Avengers, quits being Ms Marvel for a while before joining up with the X-Men. All in all, a gross story glorifying rape and unwanted pregnancy that only acknowledged its own grossness after the ONE writer at Marvel who wasn't okay with this miraculously got to write Ms. Marvel.

And this was how you marked The Avengers' 200th issue, Marvel? Classy.

2. Wonder Woman - Wonder Woman #179

Like all of these classic superheroes, there are plenty of moments throughout Wonder Woman's life where she gave up the superhero life. But for this one, we went for the most jarring and bizarre of them all. Yes, even worse than the time she started dressing up as a 90's S&M biker chick for some reason.

Advertisement

This happened in Wonder Woman #179, wherein longtime love interest Steve Trevor started his campaign against crime lord Dr. Cyber. Diana of course offered her help, but then a crisis emerged in the form of the amazons needing to leave Earth to recharge the magic they use to stay alive and hidden. Wonder Woman chooses to stand with Steve and combat the threat of Cyber, so she stayed behind and thus lost all of her magic. Leaving her as simple Diana Prince. And also she lost all her years of combat training for some staggeringly stupid reason.

So, when you're in the late sixties and in need of combat training, where do you go? Why a racist caricature of a old Chinese wise man, of course!

This new status quo wasn't exactly popular, but that didn't stop DC from keeping things this way for FIVE YEARS.

1. Spider-Man - Spider-Man #50

Well, it pretty much had to be this one at the top, didn't it?

Advertisement

In the Spider-Man canon, there are a few generally agreed upon issues and moments that stand out among the rest to be true blue classics. The final scene of "If This Be My Destiny", "The Night Gwen Stacy Died", the issue where Green Goblin finds out who Spider-Man really is, and of course, "Spider-Man No More".

Peter's superhero life has always interfered with his normal life, that's the entire crux of his character. But it was in issue #50 when it all really came to a head for the first time. Fighting bad guys not only costs him a date with Gwen Stacy, but it also starts seriously costing him his grades. And if that weren't bad enough, his Aunt May falls seriously ill, and because of a supervillain fight, he was unable to be there for her when she needed him the most.

Add all that up with the icing on the cake of the Daily Bugle doing to Spider-Man what the Bugle does best, and the straw finally broke the camel's back. Peter throws his suit in the trash and storms off, in one of the most shocking and iconic images in comic book history.

It didn't last, obviously, but it took quite a lot to convince him to throw back on the suit. And even with him walking back on his decision, that doesn't stop this from being the most shocking time a hero just gave up.

Advertisement