Marvel has been making headlines this week - the plural is important - owing to a massive shake up of their character roster. Established superheroes like Captain America and Thor are having their status quos severely altered, with the former switching from whitebread man-out-of-time Steve Rogers to former Falcon Sam Wilson, and the latter being replaced by a woman who's deemed more "worthy" of wielding magical hammer mjolnir than the blonde-haired Norse hunk we're used to. They're some pretty radical changes, so you can see why the announcements have caused a lot of...intense conversation. Yeah, that's the best way of putting it. What a lot of the people kicking off about the inherited monikers are forgetting, however, is that this happens in comic books literally all the time. Look, we even have a phrase for it: legacy characters. They're much more of a DC thing, as Golden Age heroes passed down their alter egos and costumes to younger generations, but there's a precedent for them in Marvel comics as well. And you know what? Sometimes it works out pretty well. In fact there's plenty of examples of times that superheroes were "replaced" by other characters, and it worked out for the better. If you're a glass half full type, or one of those people who can handle Thor as a frog but not a woman and need convincing otherwise, allow us to indulge you with ten successful superhero replacements. They're a bit like supply teachers, except they manage to remember your name. And can fly.
10. Kamala Khan As Ms Marvel
One of Marvel's other recent, bold choices was to revamp the Ms Marvel title with a brand new character. Previously the name held by Carol Danvers, once she finally got upgraded to full Captain Marvel status (more on that in a little while) it left an opening for somebody else to put on that lightning-bolt emblazoned swimsuit. In the interests of diversifying - and thus reaching a new audience who might never have picked up a comic book before - the company elected to make the new Ms Marvel a Muslim teenager from New Jersey called Kamala Khan. And she wouldn't be wearing the swimsuit. As that would be a mite creepy. The new Ms Marvel series has been a delight so far, with Kamala not so much trying to fill the spot left by Carol as carving out her own identity whilst adopting the name of one of her heroes, as a sort of homage. The young girl's powers don't have much in common with the previous Ms Marvel, mainly being of the shapeshifting variety that manifested themselves due to some latent Inhumanity, as opposed to cosmic light stuff derived from Kree alien DNA. Still weird, just a different kind of weird. The distance from the previous character - along with the fact that Kamala is a total fangirl, who originally chose to transform herself into swimsuit-clad Carol, her idol - has allowed the new Ms Marvel to flourish without any negative comparisons to her predecessor.
9. Cassandra Cain As Batgirl
We very much respect any genealogist who dares try to untangle the mess of the extended Bat-Family tree at this point. Not content with simply the Caped Crusader and his trusty sidekick Robin, over the years Gotham City has become home to dozens of derivative masked vigilantes in similar rodent-shaped cowls, ignoring due process of the law in favour of tying people up with grappling hooks and chucking boomerangs in their faces. One of the earliest additions to Batman's ever-growing inner circle was Batgirl who, when she wasn't dressed up in purple tights, was better known as Barbara Gordon, daughter of the Gotham Police Commissioner. At least she was right up until The Joker shot her through the spine and paralysed her for life, as seen in the classic (and brutal) Alan Moore and Brian Bolland graphic novel The Killing Joke. Although she couldn't do all the physical crime fighting stuff any more, Barbara remained part of the superhero community as Oracle, sat in a secret location and keeping tabs on Gotham's bad 'uns. Which left the Batgirl name up for grabs, and grabbed it was - by mute Asian assassin Cassandra Cain. Poor old Cassandra has been wiped out of continuity thanks to DC's New 52 reboot, but for a while she was a worthy successor to Barbara. The daughter of assassins David Cain and Lady Shiva, she was a little more violent than the Dark Knight preferred, and so Batman got her to tone it down a bit, whilst also teaching her basic social skills and literacy her bonkers parents had never bothered to. It was a sweet story, and she brought a fresh spin on a Batman sidekick, so it was a shame to see her go.
8. Dick Grayson As Batman
Cassandra Cain wasn't the only person to replace a member of the Bat-Family, of course. In fact the Caped Crusader himself has had stand-ins on numerous occasions, most notably following his crippling by the hulking villain Bane, where the Bat-Mantle was offered to Christian-themed assassin (don't ask) Jean-Paul Valley. Which was a little odd, because Valley - previously known by his codename Azrael - hadn't been part of the Gotham crime fighting crew for all that long when he was tapped as Bruce Wayne's replacement. We could all but hear Dick Grayson, Bruce's long-time ward and sidekick, sobbing like a runner up in a TV talent contest at the news. Thankfully the original Robin, and now former Nightwing, got his chance to try on the cowl in Grant Morrison's epic run on the Batman title over the past few years. During the bonkers Final Crisis crossover Bruce Wayne was seemingly killed by cosmic bad guy Darkseid, and the responsibility to carry on his work fell to Dick Grayson at last. It's the role Dick had been training for his whole life, although he did have to contend with people wondering why Batman had suddenly got taller and more slender, and the "precociousness" of new Robin Damian, Batman's long-lost son. In Morrison and Frank Quitely's Batman and Robin series, the new Dark Knight and his trusty sidekick flipped the usual dynamic of the brooding, violent Caped Crusader and the lighter, more sympathetic sidekick, as Dick tried his best to be a good example for the insane child who'd been raised by murderers and now wanted to play superhero. It wasn't long until Bruce returned to the role - turns out he wasn't dead, just sent back in time - but young master Grayson certainly made a mark during his time as Batman.
7. Kate Bishop As Hawkeye
For a little while there, Hawkeye was dead. Gone. Kaputt. Brian Michael Bendis's Avengers: Disassembled storyline saw many members of Earth's Mightiest Heroes killed off or otherwise dispatched, with the demise of Clint Barton being particularly memorable. A fan favourite for many years, the sudden and senseless killing of Hawkeye had a lot of fans up in arms. But it did provide the opportunity for bored, spoiled teenager Kate Bishop to do something with her life besides attending glitzy charity dinners with her insanely rich father. It just so happened she was a dab hand with a bow and arrow, too. Joining the adolescent superhero team the Young Avengers during one of their earliest missions, Kate raided the abandoned and half-destroyed Avengers Mansion and put together a costume that was half-Hawkeye, half-Mockingbird - in fact she even toyed with the codename "Hawkingbird" for a while, which everyone agreed was pretty stupid. With Clint Barton out of the picture she chose to honour his memory by taking on the Hawkeye name, and nabbing off with his quiver full of trick arrows whilst she was at it. As it happens Clint Barton wasn't actually dead. We er, don't actually recall the circumstances of his resurrection, but after sneaking around in the guise of Ronin for a while he decided to become Hawkeye once more. And Kate Bishop stayed as Hawkeye, too. So they're both called Hawkeye, which has become something of a running joke in Matt Fraction, David Aja and Annie Wu's series. Kate is great because she's everything Clint Barton isn't: young, female, together, prim, proper, and with slightly better luck. And both have pretty sweet archery skills. She's great as his equal and opposite, and we hope she keeps the name going for a good long while.
6. Renee Montoya As The Question
The Question is a character with a long, strange history. Originally thought up by Steve Ditko - the man responsible for co-creating Spider-Man, and most of his most famous enemies, alongside Stan Lee - this faceless private detective was supposed to represent the artist's own objectivist worldview. Invented by didactic novelist and crackpot Ayn Rand, objectivism is a weird form of morality that puts "justice "above all else. Therefore The Question was one of the earliest comic book anti-heroes, a vigilante who tracked down the bad guys and, more often than not, sent them off to an early grave. The character was a big influence of Rorschach, the similarly masked and unstable character from Watchmen. After Ditko wandered off from the character Vic Sage went from being an objectivist to a Zen-like master of calm, who still found the time to beat criminals to a fine paste with his bare hands. He also unfortunately took up smoking, which eventually lead to his own death from lung cancer. Not before he passed on the Question mantle, however, figuratively and literally. In the run up to his death, Sage trained up former Gotham police detective Renee Montoya - recognised as one of the first openly queer characters in DC Comics - as his replacement. Which she was, for a pretty long time, making key appearances in big crossover story arcs like 52 and Final Crisis. It was a natural evolution for Montoya, a character with inarguably strong detective skills but less aptitude when it came to following the strict guidelines of the GCPD. Renee carried on The Question's good work, providing a foil to fellow gay superhero Batwoman...at least up until the New 52 when, again, she was wiped out of existence. Which was objectively terrible. Ha, ha.
5. James Rhodes As Iron Man
The original Iron Man film was a gamble for Marvel Studios, since the character had always had a dedicated following in the comic books, but wasn't as well known to the general audience as, say, Spider-Man or even the Fantastic Four. Regardless, Tony Stark's big screen outings were a phenomenal success, and we've gotta assume that's at least partly down to the strong supporting cast. The ensemble that surrounds the shell head in the comics and the films is a diverse and interesting bunch, from love interest Pepper Potts to bodyguard Happy Hogan to - everybody's favourite - Colonel James Rhodes. In the films Rhodey got his own form of Iron Man armour, and suited up first as War Machine and then Iron Patriot. Which is much the same as happened to him in the comic books, but there was a time when he got to try on the original get-up, during a period where Tony was out of action. When Monsieur Stark succumbed once again to his recurring drinking problem - not the best state to be piloting a high-tech, weaponized suit of armour - it was Rhodes that took his place until he could get himself together. He did a good job, too - good enough that he managed to fight off the villainous Obadiah Stane and keep Stark Industries from being taken over. Rhodey was also rewarded with his own modified version of the Iron Man armour, the gun-toting War Machine, once Tony was finally fit to come back to work. When he fell off the map again (this time presumed dead) the role fell to James Rhodes once again, and for a second time he ably demonstrated that he's a different sort of Iron Man, but possibly a better one? Certainly a more sober one.
4. Wally West As The Flash
Ah yes, those legacy characters we mentioned back there. They don't get as much press these days, thanks to the oft-maligned New 52 reboot reinstating many of the original heroes that they were descended from. For a while, though, they were one of DC's crowning achievements, a much-needed nod to realism and the passage of time in their comic book universe. When Barry Allen, the first Flash of the modern age (although he actually got the name from Golden Age speedster Jay Garrick) met his untimely end during the universe-breaking Crisis On Infinite Earths event, Central City found itself in need of a new protector. Step forward, Wally West. After spending years at Barry's side as his imaginatively named companion Kid Flash, Wally was the natural successor to the Flash title. And he certainly made it his own, keeping the classic full-body red costume, and dealing with issues that Barry had never faced before: he couldn't run quite as fast (just getting past the speed of sound, rather than the speed of light) and had unique problems like having to gorge himself on food in order to satiate his accelerated metabolism. Besides the nitty gritty, Wally featured in a lot of his own classic storylines, including those involving new enemy Reverse Flash, and great runs on the book by Mark Waid and Geoff Johns. All good things must come to an end, however. Eventually Wally managed to escape Barry's shadow, realising that his powers were being limited by his own mental block at not wanting to dishonour the memory of his fallen friend and mentor. After all that, Wally West may actually have become a better Flash than Barry Allen ever managed - nonetheless, in the New 52 he was deleted from existence, and Barry remains the one, true speedster.
3. Carol Danvers As Captain Marvel
If anybody deserves a break, it's Carol Danvers. One of the most put-upon characters in the Marvel Universe - a universe that includes the unlucky likes of Spider-Man, Jean Grey and Daredevil, might we remind you - she's had to deal with any number of crummy life events over the course of her history. She briefly lost her powers to X-Man Rogue, when she was still in her evil early days; she was kidnapped and brainwashed into having a baby with an insane space god; and in the process of that, she had to deal with her Avengers teammates and so-called friends allowing her to be hypnotised and spirited away by Immortus, her lover/son (yeah, it's confusing) again, a stinging betrayal that she still feels to this day. She's also had to suffer the indignity, for the majority of her appearances in comics, of being saddled with the title of Ms Marvel. Like Captain Marvel, she's blessed with a vaguely defined set of powers that derive from the space-bound Kree empire. She can fly, shoot energy bolts, has super strength, all that good stuff. She's also worn costumes that look mighty similar to that of Mar-Vell, but her name has always pigeonholed her as a derivative of the original, a pale imitator of the proper Captain Marvel. Which is total nonsense, and also pretty silly, considering Captain Marvel's spent half of the last thirty years dead or otherwise indisposed. So it was a relief to readers and character alike when, with Kelly Sue Deconnick taking over writing duties on the title, Carol Danvers' series was relaunched as Captain Marvel, and she got a brand spanking new (and much more appropriate) costume to replace the aforementioned black swimsuit thing. She's also proven that she can easily live up to the legend of Mar-Vell, as a key member of the Avengers and as one of the few Earth-born superheroes who consistently and successfully deals with interplanetary threats. Her huge IRL fan following, dubbed the Carol Corps, is just further testament to how well she's done at making the Captain Marvel name her own. Major Danvers, we salute you.
2. Every Other Green Lantern
Everybody knows there's only one Green Lantern: Alan Scott, defender of Coast City. We're kidding. Alan Scott was the Golden Age Green Lantern, but his name was inherited by Hal Jordan in the Silver Age, whose title introduced the idea of the interstellar Green Lantern Corps - a sort of space police force, each of whose officers wield a powerful ring that lets them create anything they can imagine, and which they use to protect their own designated corners of the galaxy. After discovering the former protector of Earth Abin Ssur, Hal was endowed with the title of Green Lantern of Earth, and for many became the one character synonymous with said title. For many, but not for everyone. Besides the poor guy he inherited the role from, Hal Jordan isn't the only Green Lantern to patrol the stars over our little planet. In fact there's been something like a half dozen human Lanterns over the years, all of whom brought something new to the table. The cocky Guy Gardner was actually first in line to replace Abin Sur - it just so happened that Hal was closer. He was a back up Lantern for years, just in case anything happened to Hal, but tragedy befell Gardner himself as he was put in a coma for a year and came out...a little unstable. And douchey. When Guy was still comatose John Stewart was selected as Hal's new deputy, the first black Lantern and one who did things very different to his superior. His methods paid off, though, as he ended up becoming the first mortal Guardian Of The Universe (the Lantern's bosses, effectively). The first time Hal got replaced more permanently, however, was after he went nutso and tried to destroy half the galaxy. People don't tend to take kindly to that. A new Lantern was to be tapped, and that tapee was young Kyle Rayner. Initially criticised as DC attempting to jump on the early nineties bandwagon of rebellious, "radical" teens, the young and inexperienced Rayner was in fact an interesting choice of replacement for Hal Jordan, one who was much more fallible and relatable to readers. Which of course meant that he got replaced ASAP with the more traditionally heroic Hal when he got cured of his space madness and everybody conveniently forgot about it.
1. Miles Morales As Spider-Man
The recent developments with Ms Marvel, Thor and Captain America are nothing new, as we've seen. More specifically, however, they're nothing new for Marvel, who have been dipping their toes in recasting their flagship heroes with more diverse alter egos for the past couple of years. The first big change they made was killing off the original Spider-Man, Peter Parker, and replacing him with the half-black, half-Latino teen Miles Morales. Well, they did it in the alternate Ultimate universe, anyway, but that didn't stop people from getting their panties in a bunch over the radical change. Andrew Garfield, who currently plays the titular role in the Amazing Spider-Man movies, has spoken out before about how he'd've liked to make the big screen incarnation of Peter Parker gay, or bisexual. His reasoning is that Peter is supposed to be a sort of downtrodden, oppressed kid - the sort who channels all his frustrations and righteousness into fighting crime. It's a key part of the character's backstory, that he's bullied at school and a total dork. It's part of the reason so many people identify with him. Thing is, white dudes really aren't an oppressed minority in this day and age, are they? For it to be believable that Spider-Man would get such a hard time in his day-to-day life, he'd have to be someone who does incite the prejudices of others. He has to be an actual outsider, the way he is even when he puts on the costume. In which case, Miles Morales makes perfect sense. He's a mixed race kid from a broken home, living in New York, trying to do his best. He appeals to a far wider audience than Peter Parker could in the modern day, plus his struggles smack less of First World Problems. Putting aside all the political stuff, however, there's one reason while Miles has been so successful as a replacement Spider-Man: because he's a different character. He's not a different take on Peter, he's somebody totally different - he even has different powers. He's not trying to replace Spider-Man but, like Kamala Khan or Carol Danvers or Dick Grayson, trying to carry on his legacy and good work whilst being his own distinct person. That's what it takes to be a really successful replacement superhero. Let's see if Lady Thor and Sam Wilson are up to the challenge...