10 Terrible Mistakes That Almost Ruined Spider-Man For Everyone

Why would Spider-Man need a car if he can swing around the city? No, really?

By James Egan /

Shortly after Stan Lee started churning out his Marvel creations, his co-workers warned him that a spider-themed superhero would never sell. Luckily, the naysayers couldn't have been more wrong.

Advertisement

Since Spider-Man's inception, the wallcrawler has proven to be one of the most relatable, charismatic, and beloved characters in Marvel's pantheon. I mean, who hasn't dreamed of being your Friendly Neighbourhood Spider-Man web-slinging across the skies?

Of course, it hasn't always been clear sailing. No matter how popular a superhero is, readers will get bored, especially after a couple of decades. When this happens, the creative team need to do something drastic to spice things up. So, how do you make a massive shift in the story without it coming across as gimmicky or desperate?

Sometimes, these massive changes work. When Marvel decided to give Peter Parker a new look, Spider-Man donned a black costume. This decision was a massive success since it indirectly led to the creation of one of Spider-Man's greatest rivals, Venom, and eventually a whole other pillar of cosmic Marvel.

Sadly, these bold changes don't always work. Over the years, there have been terrible story arcs, pointless reboots, and changes so inept, they nearly ruined Spider-Man for everyone.

10. The Spider-Mobile - Amazing Spider-Man #130 (1974)

Many superheroes have their own distinctive mode of transport to assist them in their crimefighting. The Avengers pilot the Quinjet, Wonder Woman pilots the Invisible Jet, and Batman has the Batmobile.

Advertisement

Now, not all vigilantes have their own distinctive vehicle. Since Spider-Man can zip around the city of Manhattan with his web shooters, it would be non-sensical for the webhead to drive a superhero-styled car.

But in Amazing Spider-Man #130, Spidey got his very own Spider-Mobile. When the Human Torch of the Fantastic Four revealed the car, he told Spider-Man he could use it to catch criminals. Despite the fact the webslinger had never driven a car before, he took the Spider-Mobile and used it for several adventures.

The response from readers was mostly negative, mainly because it was clear the Spider-buggy was only incorporated into the comics to sell toys.

Why would Spider-Man need a car when he can thwip his way around the city at ten times the speed? It would be like if Superman fought crime while riding a bicycle!

9. Rebooting Spider-Man - Spider-Man: Chapter One #1-13 (1998-1999)

To draw in new readers and to contemporize Spider-Man's early stories , Marvel decided to reboot Spider-Man's backstory in the 1990s in a new series called Spider-Man: Chapter One.

Advertisement

It was neat idea in theory but it bombed in practise. Many key moments in the early comics were condensed, which made the stories feel rushed. For example, the explosion that turned Otto Octavius into Doctor Octopus also released a radioactive spider, which then bit Peter Parker. It felt like the series was zooming through the iconic moments rather than focusing on the characters or letting them develop at a steady pace.

It was also odd to reboot the series considering Untold Tales of Spider-Man, which centred around Spidey's early adventures, just concluded the year before. Although Chapter One was meant to be canonical, this idea was abandoned after the series received negative backlash.

Now, there's nothing wrong with rebooting a superhero's backstory. The series was rebooted again as Ultimate Spider-Man two years later, which was hailed as a masterpiece, but that also had the benefit of being situated in an entirely different universe.

The problem with Chapter One, really, was that it had none of Spider-Man's passion or heart, so it felt like it was made purely to make money rather than to contribute something that would enhance Spidey's history.

8. Changing His Powers To Match The Movies - Spectacular Spider-Man #16-20 (2004)

After Ana Soria was exposed to nuclear radiation, she turned into an insect-controlling being called the Spider-Queen. Desiring a mate, she kisses Spider-Man, infecting him with a toxin that gradually mutates him into a giant spider. Despite this transformation, MJ acts surprisingly cold towards Peter, even forcing him to go to a wedding even though he developed four eyeballs!

Advertisement

He eventually turns into a giant spider, finding himself completely under the thrall of the Spider-Queen. As Ana's masterplan reaches the final stages, Spider-Man drops dead and gives birth... to himself. This Spider-Man looks the same as the original, save for one major difference; he has organic web-shooters.

At this point, most readers realised this ENTIRE story was written solely to give Peter organic webs to tie-in with the movies. (And Marvel thought the best way to incorporate this element was to make a pregnant Spider-Man give birth to himself.)

What makes this story more ridiculous is how Ana keeps referencing how she can control Spidey because of his insect DNA. There's just one problem. Spiders aren't insects! They're arachnids! You'd think someone on the creative team would've noticed that.

7. Spider-Man's Robot Parents - Amazing Spider-Man #363-388 (1992-1994)

When Peter Parker comes home one day, Aunt May introduces him to his parents, Mary and Richard, who were supposedly dead for years. His parents explain they had been imprisoned for most of Peter's life and had escaped recently.

Two years after this revelation, Peter discovers his "parents" are robots built by Spider-Man's oldest foe, the Chameleon. When Chameleon confronts the wallcrawler, the shapeshifting spy points out he was also the mastermind behind Kraven burying Spidey alive during the Kraven's Last Hunt saga. What does this epiphany have to do with anything? Absolutely nothing.

Advertisement

Just when you though this story couldn't get more convoluted, it was revealed two years later (again) that this scheme was the brainchild of Norman Osborn. This twist was made all the more confusing since the reader assumed Osborn died 20 years ago.

Even though Osborn knew Peter's secret identity and could use that knowledge to expose him to the world, the deranged industrialist thought it was more sensible to have the Chameleon build two robots in his parents' likeness. Osborn has a reputation for unnecessarily complex schemes but this is one of the dumbest.

However, it's not the worst...

6. The Gathering Of Five - The Final Chapter Storyline (1998)

When Norman Osborn was revealed to be alive decades after he seemingly died in the aftermath of Gwen Stacy's murder, readers expected his next masterplan to be epic.

Advertisement

Sadly, his grand return was offset by a truly weird scheme to destroy Spider-Man, as it was filled with unnecessary twists and enough red herrings to fill a river. During the Gathering of Five story, Osborn took part in an ancient ritual, hoping it would grant him magical abilities. After seemingly obtaining this power, he unmasks and kills Spider-Man.

Except he doesn't. It turns out the "murdering of Spider-Man" was just in his head.

Readers then learn that Peter and MJ's daughter, thought to have died in childbirth, was stolen by Osborn, implying the child was still alive.

Nope. That plot thread went nowhere.

Finally, it is unveiled that Aunt May, who readers saw die in Amazing Spider-Man #400, was alive. It turns out this "May" was an actress who Osborn convinced to impersonate Peter's aunt. Even though this woman needed plastic surgery and a DNA transfusion to resemble May, she was totally up for the gig.

Why did Norman Osborn do all this? Simple. To mess with Spider-Man's head... that guy really needs a new hobby.

5. The Clone Saga - Spider-Man #52-75 (1994-1996)

Miles Warren was a genius bio-chemist who cracked the code in human DNA, allowing him to create perfect clones.

Instead of using his research to better mankind and make billions of dollars, Warren turned into the supervillain, The Jackal. (Because that's how you pay the bills.) Furthermore, he created a duplicate of Spider-Man called Ben Reilly and dedicated his life to toying with both superheroes.

As silly as this story sounds, we're only getting started. Peter Parker eventually deduces that he is the clone and Ben Reilly is the real Spider-Man. Although the Marvel creators thought this would be a mind-blowing twist, readers felt cheated that the superhero they had believed to the one true Spider-Man was a fake.

Advertisement

But it gets worse. When Peter learns his wife, Mary Jane Watson is having his child, he decides to settle down with her and passes the Spider-Man mantle onto Ben.

And if you're wondering, yes, this entire scheme was concocted ONCE AGAIN by Norman Osborn for... reasons. The Clone Saga story was so universally reviled, everything was reversed so Peter became the real Spider-Man after all.

4. Mary Janes Dies! (Except She Doesn't) - Amazing Spider-Man #13-29 (2000-2001)

Many Marvel editors didn't like the idea that Peter Parker was a married man since they felt like it aged the character. As a result, the company's higher-ups pulled one convoluted storyline after another to end Peter and Mary Jane's marriage.

Advertisement

And in Amazing Spider-Man #13, the creative team thought, "Hey, why don't we just kill off MJ?" In this issue, we see Mary Jane walk onto an airplane moments before it explodes. Since nobody onboard survived, it's safe to assume she's dead.

Although this moment is meant to be shocking, it comes across as gimmicky. Because of the status quo, we know Marvel aren't just going to kill off Peter's central love interest, especially in such an anticlimactic way. Nevertheless, the comics dragged this plot point out for well over a year.

We later discover (to the shock of maybe like eight people) that Mary Jane... is alive! It turns out a crazy mutant called Stalker boarded her plane and kidnapped MJ just before blowing it up.

And what happened after Spider-Man finally rescues his wife from the kidnapper? She dumped him. Way to go, Marvel.

3. Wolverine Hits On Mary Jane As Peter Parker - Ultimate Spider-Man #66-67 (2004)

In the now-defunct Ultimate Marvel universe Jean Grey grew so tired of Wolverine hitting on her, she pulled a Freaky Friday and swapped Logan's mind into Peter Parker's body and vice versa. As the two superheroes try to reverse their predicament, they do their best to adapt to their bodies, leading to all sorts of wacky and terrible hijinks.

Advertisement

This story may be pure filler but it's pretty funny. Seeing Peter depicted as a broody, tough guy while Wolverine acts neurotic and whiny is hilarious.

Now, this story isn't to be taken seriously. The issue is literally called Jump the Shark so you know the writer, Brian Michael Bendis, was just having a laugh.

Nevertheless, you can't ignore the disturbing implications of the ending. After Spider-Man and Wolverine are returned to their original bodies, Peter meets up with Mary Jane and apologises if he was acting weird earlier. MJ then points out that Peter tried to do something sexually inappropriate with her and asks him "not do that 'till we're older."

Just to remind readers, MJ is 15 years old at this point and Wolverine is 150! This throwaway line was completely unneeded and just cemented that the Ultimate Wolverine was a complete and total creep.

2. Aunt May Is Peter Parker's Mother?? - Trouble #1-5 (2003-2004)

The five-part mini-series, Trouble, centres around Peter Parker's Aunt May, Uncle Ben, and his parents, Mary and Richard, when they were teenagers. As a concept this is a great idea since we get to see what Peter's family members were like when they were his age.

Advertisement

Unfortunately, the comic was a disaster. The four main characters are depicted as horny teenagers and talk about sex every second page.

Being the devil's advocate, you could argue "but they're teenagers!", but that would also require forgetting just how weird a trope it is that adult writers continue to write adolescents this way. Plus, so was Peter, and he was never depicted as sex-crazed as this lot.

Richard complains how he can't "close the deal" with Mary while Ben whinges how he's spending all his wages on condoms. When you read dialogue like this, it's like the creative team were consciously trying to destroy these beloved characters' reputations.

The most baffling moment is when it is revealed that "Aunt" May is Peter Parker's mother and she gave her child to Richard and Mary to raise!

Now, you could argue that this story shouldn't be taken seriously since it takes place in an alternative universe. But even if that is the case Trouble still came off as incredibly gimmicky.

1. Marvel Nukes Decades Of Spidey's Continuity - One More Day

During the Civil War storyline the Registration Act made vigilantism illegal, forcing superheroes to register with the government or suffer imprisonment. Not only did Iron Man compel Peter Parker to embrace the new law, he encouraged Spider-Man to unmask on live television to encourage other heroes to follow his footsteps, giving up his secret identity forever.

Advertisement

When the Kingpin learned Peter and Spider-Man were one and the same, he tracked down where Peter was living and hired an assassin to eliminate his long-time rival. However, the hitman missed Peter and shot Aunt May, gravely wounding her.

When the world's best doctors informed Peter nothing could save her, he made a literal deal with the devil. Mephisto agreed to spare May's life under the condition that Peter gave up his marriage with Mary Jane Watson. Just to sweeten the deal, the arch-demon promised to make everyone on Earth forget Spider-Man's identity.

This story was hated by pretty much everyone, mainly because Spider-Man seems like the last superhero that would agree to any terms made by Marvel's version of Satan.

This story arc also undercut the impact of Spider-Man giving up his secret identity during the Civl War. His unmasking felt like one of the biggest moments in comic history but feels pointless in hindsight - not to mention the fact it set the character's development back by literal decades, and was only introduced because editorial thought Peter being married made him unrelatable to younger readers.

Advertisement