10 Things DC Comics Wants You To Forget About Bane

What's the deal with this masked Mexican wrestler dude?

By Tom Baker /

People were a little surprised at the choice of villain for the final entry in Christopher Nolan's Dark Knight trilogy. The previous installment in the latest series of Batman films had made a (sadly posthumous) star of Heath Ledger, who delivered a barnstorming performance as psychotic supervillain The Joker, whose chaotic cunning and lack of limits placed Christian Bale's Bruce Wayne on the back foot from the off. Rumour had it that, with Ledger passing away between films, the third movie would see a similarly cerebral, psychological bad guy take his place. When Joseph Gordon-Levitt was cast, the scuttlebutt is he would be playing The Riddler, who has some similarities with the Clown Prince Of Crime. Nobody was expecting the announcement that followed JGL's addition to the ensemble: that fellow Inception star Tom Hardy was on board, and would take the part of lead antagonist Bane. Those unfamiliar with the comics replied, simply, "Who?", whilst fanboys were...actually, they were just as confused. Why is this buff Mexican wrestler, addicted to the DC Universe equivalent of steroids, going to be the star of Nolan's next "realistic" Batman flick? Well, by changing a lot of stuff, that's what. Since the Nolan reboot DC have done their best to dispel previous depictions of Bane, bar his debut in the Knightfall storyline which The Dark Knight Rises ultimately took a lot of inspiration from. If you were one of those confused fans or non-fans who wondered what was up with this metahuman luchador suplexing Patrick Bateman, allow us to recap some of the more...out there parts of the character that have been retconned due to his movie incarnation. These are ten things DC wants you to forget about Bane.

10. Batman & Robin's Bane

Tom Hardy's essaying in the role of Bane was a further surprise to audiences, who were expecting this more "physical threat" to the Dark Knight to be nothing more than a lumbering hulk. Instead he was a lumbering hulk who occasionally gave eloquent speeches about pits of flames in a plummy British accent. You could be forgiven for thinking otherwise, since 1. Hardy proper bulked up for the role (seriously, he's terrifying in Bronson, and he's about half the size in that) and 2. The last time Bane appeared on screen he was dumber than a bag full of bat guano. Which is to say: pretty dumb. For Joel Schumacher's Batman & Robin from 1997 - not counted amongst the best Caped Crusader films, and part of the reason that it took so long for Nolan to get on board and reboot the franchise - the part was played not by a noted, up-and-coming actor, but by a former professional wrestler. We can't lay the blame for the film's portrayal of Bane entirely with Robert Swenson (especially because he died not long after it was released), but clearly they were going in a different direction by casting him. Batman & Robin's Bane is a total moron, barely able to string a sentence together and used only as muscle for the movie's main villains, Mr Freeze and Poison Ivy. He just sort of repeats his name a bunch and hits things. Like a Pokemon. A Pokemon dressed like a Mexican wrestler. Anyway, that's nothing like any version of Bane we've seen before, and thankfully we haven't since. It did sort of affect the way people viewed the character, mind.

9. That He's Super Smart

Which is a shame, because as we say, it's got nothing in common with any other incarnation of the character. In fact Tom Hardy's Bane is much closer to how he originally appears in the comic books, where his huge, buff bod is almost secondary to his huge, buff brain. Antonio Diego may have had to learn how to defend himself whilst growing up in the vicious Peña Dura prison, but just as important was figuring out how to manipulate his fellow inmates and eventually engineer his escape from the maximum security facility and chase down the tricksy bat who had been haunting his dreams (yes, that is why Bane ends up in Gotham and yes, that is pretty silly in itself). In fact, creator Chuck Dixon compares Bane to Bruce Lee. He's not a big, lumbering hunk of muscles that just obliterates everything in his way. He's an intellectual, a master strategist you can put highly complex plans into action and actually pull them off - like breaking Batman's spine and conquering his city - which he does by entering a deep form of meditation. It's even implied that all this hippie guff gives Bane an extra edge during battle, that his mindfulness makes "time and space playthings to him". Anyway, all the cod-spirituality aside, he's also a leading expert in a number of scientific fields, is fluent in eight languages (two of them being dead ones), and figured out Batman's secret identity in just a year. Others have been it at it for decades and never even come close. Nowadays though, it's still the "physical threat" angle of Bane that gets used, as he continues to act more as a heavy for the A-list supervillains in big crossover events like Forever Evil. Look at him, brain the size of a planet and they ask him to push over buildings...

8. His First Appearance Was Kinda Bad

For some, Bane's debut in the DC Universe - the Batman epic Knightfall - makes up some of the best comic books in the Dark Knight's history. For us...it was a Tuesday. Hang on, sorry, we were channelling Raul Julia for a second there. Yes, Knightfall does often get mentioned in the same breath as classic Bat-Titles like The Dark Knight Returns and The Long Halloween and it does, in fact, deliver on its promise of greatness. To start off with, anyway. The introduction of Bane's character is genuinely intriguing, offering an enemy unlike any other we've seen Batman face before, who seems to have gone through as many trials, tribulations and traumas as our hero. He also seems to be the first sane genius that's tried to take down the Caped Crusader. That's worrying. All that tension comes to a head as Bane launches his assault on Gotham City, releasing the inmates from Arkham Asylum, taking control of the entire town and then effortlessly snapping Bruce Wayne's spine over his knee. Even now it makes us wince to look at the above panel, especially with the knowledge of the sickening snapping sound effect Christopher Nolan's foley artist elected to use in the same scene for The Dark Knight Rises. For all intents and purposes, this is the first time we've really seen Batman defeated. Which is pretty interesting. What happens after that is a lot less so. The mantle of Batman for some reason gets passed onto Jean-Paul Valley, a crummy novelty character who'd been introduced not long before, who fought crime under the name Azrael and was super into Jesus and stuff. He upgraded the Dark Knight's costume to be shiny and spiky, with big gold shoulderpads and pouches aplenty. It was horribly nineties and embarrassing, as was the rest of the story.

7. And He Got Taken Out Like A Chump

Including Valley's ultimate, inevitable confrontation with the man who had crippled his mentor. After Bane has installed himself as the new ruler of Gotham's criminal underworld, and finds nobody willing to stand up to him, he's pretty much got the run of the city. That is, until Valley has had his totally sweet makeover (we imagine a montage where he keeps coming out of the Bat Cave changing room with different outfits, Bruce and Dick Grayson shaking their heads until we got that...monstrosity). Jean-Paul takes a very different tack with his spin on Batman, refusing to acknowledge Robin as his partner and choosing to be a lot more violent and heavy-handed with his apprehension of bad guys. Which all comes to a head when he does, finally, stand up to Bane. That's despite Bruce Wayne's warnings not to, but then Bruce probably also told Valley not to kill people who be such a jerk to his younger brother, but the new Batman just yelled "YOU'RE NOT MY REAL DAD" and went ahead and did it anyway. Breaking into Bane's penthouse apartment, Batman 2.0 shoots a load of pointy things at the villain which see him lose a lot of blood. No matter, the baddie thinks. I'll just up my dose of the DC analogue of steroids, Venom. That will keep me big and strong. Which it did, and he punched Valley until he ran home crying. Except he never got those cuts looked at, and then Teen Girl Squad Batman returned to finish him off. Bane crawls around like a little baby while the new Dark Knight tears him a new one, cutting off his Venom supply and then straight up torturing him in front of the Gotham Police Department. Sort of an inauspicious defeat for such a hyped villain. Let's just not mention it again. Or Jean-Paul Valley. Or his costume. Ta.

6. His Role In The Secret Six

Since he totally got his butt handed to him by some whiny Bible-basher, creative teams have been loathe to actually use Bane in any further comics. He's definitely cropped up from time to time, but never has he approached the level of interest and respect that he earned during the first half of Knightfall. Perhaps one of the most...interesting uses of the character in recent years was during Gail Simone's run on Secret Six, which took the established-villains-as-anti-heroes-plus-jokes set up of Suicide Squad and, well, gave it a different name. And took away Amanda Waller. Which is a huge mistake, if you ask us. Serving alongside Catman, Deadshot, Scandal, and Rag Doll, Bane's position on the team was as again as more of a lethal enforcer than a master strategist. Occasionally his kooky, foreign ways of thinking came at odds with the more traditionally villainous members of the team, but for the most part he just smashed things. He was also the team's comic relief a lot of the time, especially when it came to the fatherly relationship he had with colleague Scandal Savage. He does get a shot at leading the Six for a time, but it's clear that Bane has eyes on a very different prize: he doesn't want to eliminate Batman any more, he wants to be Batman. Somehow a grudging respect for his former adversary becomes a glowing admiration, as he tells civilians he rescues to tell people the Dark Knight was responsible, before eventually giving Dick Grayson his blessing as stand-in Batman whilst Bruce Wayne was back in time (long story). Unsurprisingly, Bane The Batman Fanboy is not a portrayal we've seen much of before or since.

5. He's From The Caribbean

Remember we mentioned the plummy accent Tom Hardy adopted when he played Bane in The Dark Knight Rises? It was hard to make out anything he was saying behind that terrifying contraption he had strapped to his gob, but one thing we knew for sure is that he wasn't from the Caribbean. We're not entirely sure where he was supposed to be from - his accent sounds like the weird English-via-South African-via Australian dialect Shia LaBeouf adopted for Nymphomaniac - but we were fairly certain that the pale and pasty bod of Hardy has never seen the sunshine of the Caribbean. Which, well, Bane also didn't for the first couple of decades of his life. Because he grew up in a prison. And they are infamously rigid with their sunbathing policies. Another part of the character which made him so interesting and distinct from the rest of Batman's enemies, however, was his origin story. He wasn't some citizen of Gotham driven mad, another novelty white guy with a gimmick. Bane was born in the fictional Caribbean Republic of Santa Prisca, son of revolutionary Edmund Dorrance, whose sentence he lived out in prison after his dad hot footed it out of there. A lot of that background informed Bane's later character, as he adopted some of his absentee father's guerilla warfare tactics in bringing down the Dark Knight and Gotham City (both in the comics and the film, come to think of it). Santa Prisca got mentioned a lot during the eighties and early nineties, as writer Denny O'Neil used it in both the Knightfall storyline and his Question series. The tourism industry seems to have dried up, however, since Bane's rarely been back and his country of origin never mentioned.

4. That He Owns A Beloved Teddy Bear

During Bane's time in the hellish prison called Peña Dura, he had only one friend. Well, two friends. First of all there was the kindly, elderly Jesuit priest who gave him the classical education that enabled him to become a master strategist and one of Batman's few intellectual rivals, a man that the great Ra's al Ghul says "has a mind equal to the greatest he has known". So that makes him pretty smart. He was a nice old dude, and played a big part in making Bane into the man he is today, but the villain ended up killing him regardless. Which left him with just one friend - no, not a fellow behemoth or super genius. A teddy bear. Osito - Spanish for "little bear" - was Bane's constant companion for his time in jail, probably helped by the fact that he was an inanimate object and therefore couldn't be murdered in cold blood. Osito was considered his only true friend, to the degree that the bear has come as an accessory with Bane action figures and actually had a cameo appearance in the Batman & Robin film. Oh also he has a removable head which reveals the knife concealed inside, which Bane totally uses to shank fools during his time under lock and key. Which is a pretty goofy little accessory to give to a big, scary villain like Bane. Even when you account for the fact that he hid a friggin' shiv inside it in order to defend himself, the image of one of Batman's most formidable foes carting around a plush toy is pretty amusing. Which is probably why Osito is now relegated to being a hidden item in the Arkham Asylum game rather than getting a starring role alongside his erstwhile pal. We're angling for a Bane & Osito team up book - styled after C-Bear and Jamal - at some point, though.

3. When He Learned How To Love

One of the big character changes we saw Bane gone through during Sinister Six was the melting of his heart in the presence of young supervillain Scandal Savage. Whilst his friendship with Osito the teddy bear was spoilt a little by the plush toy concealing a knife, the paternal love Bane exhibited for Savage was completely without pretense, and made the masked supervillain seem a lot less like an intelligent, uncaring, unfeeling force for destruction and more like an embarrassing dad. Not that he danced like Bernard Sumner or poorly adapted the lyrics of popular songs. Instead Bane was the sort of embarrassing dad who thinks all your friends are bad influences and decides not to let you go to fun stuff like hang out at the mall or go on life-threatening adventures to steal magical items from under the noses of other supervillains and heroes. Which is exactly what he did when he took brief control of the Secret Six team, booting Savage from the roster for her own safety. The lighter side of Bane was not one fans were interested in seeing. We actually kinda dug it, although it did at times have a similar vibe to classic Bond villain Jaws' about-face in Moonraker where he sacrifices himself to save the bad guy because he's fallen in love. The cliche of the big lumbering monster being transformed by the love of a good woman has been around for yonks, and it did kinda work for Bane - just not enough for it to define the character in any book besides Secret Six.

2. He And Batman Share A Wife

Bane's love for Scandal Savage was very, very different from the first woman he fell in love with. That dubious honour went to Talia al Ghul, the daughter of Batman's eternal (and immortal) nemesis Ra's al Ghul. Following his shameful defeat at the end of Knightfall Bane was shipped off to Blackgate prison, where he recovers from his addiction to Venom and consequently escapes. After unexpectedly teaming up with the Caped Crusader to take down a drug smuggling ring he leaves the country to search for his father, crossing paths with the League of Assassins on the way. In battle Bane impresses Ra's so much that the villain decides to offer him his daughter's hand in marriage. Once the engagement is confirmed Ra's takes Bane along as his right-hand man for his next major attack on Gotham City, unleashing a plague in the Legacy storyline which culminated in Batman finally getting a rematch against the man who once crippled him. In one-on-one combat the Dark Knight easily bests Bane, which displeases Ra's so much that he deems the unlucky luchador as "unworthy" of marrying his daughter and eventually taking control of the League of Assassins, breaking off the engagement before they can seal the deal. Which is probably for the best, because that would put Bane and Batman in a weird sorta polyamorous relationship with Talia. The only "champion" previously deemed worthy of marrying Talia and giving her children had been Bruce Wayne, who Ra's begrudgingly accepted as being the most likely to replace him. Of course that didn't work out - because superheroes shacking up with their enemies rarely does - which is just as well. Bane as stepdad to Damian Wayne is something that deserves to remain a thing of fan fiction. Weird, weird fan fiction.

1. And Maybe...A Father?

Which isn't the only time that Bane and the Bat's paths have crossed in a more familial sense. Remember when we said Bane went off searching for his missing father? Good, your memories still in good shape then, since we mentioned that like five seconds ago. Anyway, after the Ra's al Ghul thing is a total wash Bane decide to renew his quest for a paternity test, returning to his home country and meeting up with that elderly Jesuit priest again (nice that he left him alive just long enough for the priest to be let out of prison, and then kill him). Before he knocks off the poor guy, though, the priest manages to get out possibility that Bane's biological father is an American doctor. Hey, you know who else's father is an American doctor? Bruce Wayne's. Prior to being gunned down in Gotham's infamous Crime Alley - and we dunno how a guy smart enough to get a doctorate didn't realise wandering down a road called Crime Alley at night wasn't a good idea - Thomas Wayne was one of the premiere surgeons in the world. It's where he made all that money his deadbeat son could using on making wonderful toys and stealing orphans. Bane did some digging and actually came up with more than just "hey my dad was a doctor too!", discovering that Dr Wayne became close to his mother whilst Bruce's dad was spending time in Santa Prisca. Over the course of the Tabula Rasa storyline Bane stays at Wayne Manor and actually fights crime alongside his one-time arch nemesis, during which team they send off for a paternity test to find out whether they really are long lost brothers. This all leads to a climax worthy of an episode of Maury as Thomas Wayne is revealed to not be the father, and Bane bids his almost-sibling goodbye to look for his actual parent in the snowy mountains of Nepal. Eventually it turns out Bane's papa is some jerk mercenary who calls himself King Snake, but for a minute there it looked like DC were gonna pull a fast one on us all and reveal that Knightfall had more in common with a couple of brothers joking around than a vicious assault on a superhero. Guess what? This has also never, ever been brought up since, and the pair have gone back to the classic hero/villain relationship that they will probably continue to have forevermore.