10 Times Supervillains Fought The WRONG Hero

It feels so wrong for the Joker to fight anyone except the Dark Knight.

By James Egan /

Batman and the Joker have one of the most fascinating rivalries, not just in comics, but in all storytelling. Joker isn't just a baddie - he is Batman's opposite. The fact that their morals, ideologies, and philosophies are antithetical is what makes their conflict compelling. They work off each other so well, it would seem weird - even wrong - if the Joker fought someone else like Green Lantern of Hawkman.

But since Marvel and DC are overloaded with heroes, supervillains are bound to face someone besides their nemesis at some point. Sometimes, these sort of changes work. After all, it would be repetitive if the Green Goblin fought nobody but Spider-Man for 50 years straight, so it's nice to see him clash with other characters.

Most of the time, these changes are done as a gimmick but sometimes, they turn out better than the writers ever imagined. In fact, some of the most iconic moments in comic history occurred when a baddie fought a hero outside their wheelhouse.

Let's have a look at the hero/villain crossovers that worked, the ones that didn't, and the ones that were just... bizarre.

Advertisement

10. Sabretooth Vs Iron Fist - Iron Fist #14

For decades, Sabretooth has served as Wolverine's arch-nemesis. He has beaten Wolvie to the brink of death more times than one can count and has personally slashed his loved ones to ribbons time and time again. Because of their bitter antagonism, it's hard to envision Victor Creed going against anyone except the Ol' Canknucklehead.

Advertisement

Strangely, Sabretooth didn't start off as an X-Men villain. In fact, he didn't face Wolverine until nearly ten years after he debuted! The first superhero he ever encountered was Iron Fist the Living Weapon. The pair butted heads when Sabretooth was hired to kidnap Jerry Hogarth, the lawyer of Iron Fist's father.

Now, this confrontation didn't seem odd at the time since Sabreooth was just another random goon. But in hindsight, it's crazy that the cannibalistic mutant that caused so much anguish in Wolverine's life started off fighting a kung fu master.

It's clear that the writers hadn't figured out Sabretooth's backstory yet since he doesn't seem to have a healing factor in his first few appearances. Iron Fist managed to defeat him by simply punching him in the face. The Sabretooth that we know today would have taken a hundred times more punishment before admitting defeat.

9. Joker Vs Wonder Woman - Wonder Woman #164-167

For millennia, the Greek gods attempted to manipulate events on Earth but, because of their vow to Zeus, were forbidden to directly interfere with mankind. But during the Gods of Gotham series, Ares's three children realised they could circumvent their all-father's laws by possessing the bodies of mortals and acting through them.

Advertisement

Because Gotham wreaks of corruption, the deities ventured there and seized control over the three most despicable people they could find: the god of fear, Phobos, possessed Scarecrow; the god of discord, Eris, possessed Poison Ivy; and the god of terror, Deimos, possessed the Joker.

Batman tried to stop them but quickly realised he was out of his element. Since Wonder Woman has tangled with Ares more than anyone, she headed to Gotham to stop the Joker before he utilised his godlike power to lay waste to the world.

The Joker wouldn't be able to hold his own against an Amazon, so it's awesome to see the Jester of Genocide even the odds by summoning mythical creatures like chimeras and Gorgon snakes. The two have duelled a number of times, but this confrontation is one of the most entertaining since their powers were on equal footing for once.

8. Green Goblin Vs Punisher - Punisher Vol 8 #1

Soon after Tony Stark was put in charge of S.H.I.E.L.D., he learned the Skrulls had infiltrated Earth and were preparing to take over. After an all-out war, the Skrullqueen was defeated by, of all people, Norman Osborn. Due to Stark's failure to contain the Skrull threat, Osborn replaced him as the director of S.H.I.E.L.D.

Advertisement

When he began reshaping S.H.I.E.L.D. to fit his own evil agenda, the Avengers realised they couldn't touch him since the Superhero Registration Act had criminalised vigilantism. With Tony Stark on the run and Captain America dead, the former Green Goblin seemed untouchable.

But when Frank "The Punisher" Castle learned Ozzy was using SHIELD's resources to fund criminal organisations, he became the skull-motiffed vigilante's top priority. While giving a public speech, Castle shot at Osborn with a sniper rifle. Unfortunately, the bullet was caught by Osborn's bodyguard, The Sentry.

When Osborn got wind that Castle was going to expose his connections with the city's crime lords, he ordered Wolverine's son, Daken, to exterminate him. After he tracked down Castle, the pair had a vicious brawl that ended with Daken chopping off Castle's head, arms, and legs. (But because this is a comic book, the Punisher eventually got better... by being a zombie for a while.)

7. The Riddler Vs Green Arrow - Green Arrow #34-37

Albert Davis was a wealthy occultist from Star City who lost his mind when his family was killed by carjackers. To ensure no one would ever suffer a similar tragedy, Davis vowed to perform a magical spell that would cease all crimes in the city. He hired the Riddler to acquire key artefacts to conduct the ritual and paid the bowler-wearing supervillain for his services with an atomic bomb.

Advertisement

The Riddler then demanded the mayor of Star City to give him $100 million or he would use his nuke to blow the city sky-high. While Green Arrow and the other superheroes of Star City were distracted by the enigmatic madman's antics, Davis had ample time to prepare his crime-cancelling ritual.

Upon completing the spell, Star City was sealed in an impenetrable dome, which deactivated all technology (including the Riddler's bomb). Worst of all, the city was then swamped by fiery demons who punished criminals for the mildest felony with lethal force. When Green Arrow learned the dome would increase in size until it sealed the entire world, he created a rag-tag team to track down Davis to make him reverse the spell.

6. Juggernaut Vs Spider-Man - Amazing Spider-Man #229-230

Tired of being defeated by the X-Men, Black Tom Cassidy ordered Juggernaut to kidnap Madam Web so he could use her psychic powers to kill his enemies once and for all. As Juggers made his way to Madam Web, she sent a telepathic signal to Spider-Man, begging for his help.

Advertisement

Despite Juggernaut's immense size, Spidey assumed he could take him on due to his spider-proportioned strength. Unprepared for the crimson-clad criminal's inhuman power, Spider-Man realised very quickly that he couldn't beat Juggernaut conventionally.

Trying a different strategy, the web-slinger placed his hands over the eyeholes of Juggernaut's helmet so he couldn't see. While the titan was swinging blind, Spider-Man lead him to a foundation of wet concrete, causing Juggernaut to sink to the bottom. When the cement solidified, Juggernaut found himself entombed and unable to move.

Although it seems odd to pair your Friendly Neighbourhood Spider-Man against the X-Men's most unstoppable foe, it's one of Spidey's most entertaining stories. This simple two-part tale shows how the loveable superhero can defeat the most intimidating and strongest villains by relying on brains rather than brawn.

5. Venom Vs Iron Man - Iron Man #302

After Stark Industries was falsely implicated in a scandal, society was under the impression that its CEO, Tony Stark, was living off the labours of the poor. Since Venom sees himself as a guardian of the innocent, he tracked Tony Stark down... and bit his head off!

Advertisement

Thankfully, this "Tony Stark" was actually a Life-Model Decoy that the playboy billionaire was controlling remotely. Realising that Venom was making his way to his penthouse, Tony headed to the armoury as quickly as possible, knowing he couldn't possibly survive a direct encounter with the alien without his Iron Man suit. As Tony darted through his home, Venom made mincemeat of the building, pulling off walls and tearing open elevators, trying to rip Tony apart.

Luckily, Tony managed to get to armoury and don his costume. Instead of blasting Venom to a pulp, Shellhead reasoned with him, telling him Stark was innocent and he will prove it in time. Venom was dubious of this claim but agreed to back off. However, he vowed to return for Stark's blood if he learned that Iron Man was lying.

4. Doomsday Vs Batman - Superman/Batman #10

After Supergirl crash-landed on Earth, she had great difficulty adapting to her newfound powers. To ensure she didn't misuse her strength, Wonder Woman transported her to her home, Themyscira, for training. Because her cousin, Superman, disapproved and Batman didn't trust Supergirl, the two superheroes headed to Themyscira to monitor her.

Advertisement

Meanwhile, the Lord of Apokolips, Darkseid, learned from a vision that Supergirl was destined to become a harbinger of death. Desiring new ways to wreak havoc upon the cosmos, Darkseid opened a Boom Tube upon Themyscira and sent an army of Doomsday clones to lay waste to its inhabitants while his lackeys kidnapped Supergirl.

Despite the fact the island is populated by Amazons, Batman put himself in the frontline against the Doomsday, only armed with an axe. Not only that, Bats is the one who leads the charge!!

Now, everyone loves Bats but it is ludicrous to watch the Dark Knight effortlessly take down multiple incarnations of a monster stronger than Superman. Although these creatures are described as "animates" and so, wouldn't be as strong as the original Doomsday, this moment still comes across as pure fan-service.

3. Magneto Vs Defenders - Defenders #15-16

The Defenders are considered a C-list team since they were originally composed of "leftover" superheroes who battled generic foes like wizards, robots, and demons. However, one of their stand-out moments was when the X-Men's mentor, Professor X, asked The Defenders to help him stop Magneto. (If you're wondering why the professor didn't call the X-Men for aid, it was because their comic was cancelled at the time.)

Advertisement

Despite the Defenders' best efforts against Magneto and his Brotherhood of Evil Mutants, the superheroes failed to stop Mags from awakening a constantly evolving mutant called Alpha.

Weirdly, this is the most famous Defenders story because it fixed a major plothole. If Magneto was born in the 1930s, how can he still be running around, fighting superheroes in the modern era as an old man? How does a 90-year-old man fight Wolverine and Cyclops without breaking his hip every five seconds?

To get around this plothole, Marvel decided to "reset" the Master of Magnetism's age. You see, this Defenders story concluded with Alpha realising Magneto was manipulating him and so, turned him into a baby. The X-Men's nemesis became an adult in a later issue but his body was of a man in his 30s.

2. Spider-Man Vs Doctor Doom - Amazing Spider-Man #5

For years, Spider-Man was perceived as a menace due to The Daily Bugle's slant against him. Because of this, Doctor Doom believed Spidey was a supervillain and so, attempted to ally with him so he could finally thwart his enemies, the Fantastic Four.

Advertisement

The Latverian monarch contacted Spider-Man by tapping into the frequency of an arachnid with a microphone (don't ask), asking him to join forces. When the wallcrawler refused Doom's offer, he attacked Spidey, forcing him to flee. At the same time, high school bully, Flash Thompson, set up a prank to scare Peter Parker by jumping out at him while dressed as Spider-Man.

When Doctor Doom spotted Flash in his costume, he assumed it was the real Spider-Man and so, captured him. He then sent a message to the Fantastic Four, stating that they must face him in battle or he will kill Flash. For a moment, Peter actually considered allowing Doom to snuff out his high school tormentor (I mean, he is a jerk). Unsurprisingly, Peter came to senses, located and defeated the maniacal dictator, and rescued Flash.

1. Joker Vs Superman - Emperor Joker Saga

After the Joker stole the powers of the reality-warping Mister Mxyzptlk, he remade the universe in his own image. He turned Lex Luthor into his personal jester, ate China, and had Jimmy Olsen bludgeoned to death by rubber chickens.

Advertisement

Although readers were expecting Batman to swoop in at some point to save the day, he was nowhere to be seen. It turns out the Clown Prince of Crime used his omnipotent power to trap his arch-enemy in a loop of torture and death for months on end.

With Gotham's protector unable to best his greatest foe, this looked like a job for Superman. Despite the Man of Steel's might, he was nothing more than a plaything to the Joker.

To prove his absolute power over the Last Son of Krypton, the Joker said he was going to destroy the entire universe. Supes appealed to the demented clown's ego, pointing that he would never be able to torture Batman again if he wiped out all of reality.

Filled with self-doubt, the Joker was left momentarily vulnerable, allowing Superman to defeat him and return his power to Mr. Myxzptlk.

Advertisement