Comics are a tough racket to break into. Writers and artists slave away day and night, trying to perfect their craft by working on free, underviewed webcomics or self-publishing books that they might make a tenner profit off if they're lucky when they're not trying to convince editors and publishers that they've got the goods required to create for them. So it must be more than a little frustrating when a writer who's worked in a completely different field - say, movies or television - strolls along and decides that they'd like to have a crack at making a funnybook or two, too. And just because they've had a couple of quirky indie movies made or happened to create a cult TV show or two, the publishers get starts in their eyes and give them the keys to the kingdom in the hopes that putting the big celebrity's name in bold on the cover of their books will bring in the big bucks, regardless of how good their work actually is. Of course, it helps that most of the time the comics actually end up being pretty damn good, being that the writers in question must have had at least a modicum of talent in order to succeed in their original field. With the recent news that Tiny Furniture writer/director and Girls creator Lena Dunham will be penning a four-issue story arc for Archie comics in 2015, we thought it might be a good time to take a look at other screenwriters who's decided to dip their toes into comics - and whether they were any good or should have maybe thought about sticking to their day job.
13. Kevin Smith
You probably already knew this one if you've ever been a follower of the prolific Smith - on twitter, his blog, his books or just on the street - he tends to scream about whatever he's doing from the rooftops, especially if he gets to write Batman for any length of time. Kevin Smith got into the comics biz relatively early into his filmmaking career, driven by his eternal love of sequential art and given the opportunity to turn his creations Jay and Silent Bob into bona fide superheroes Bluntman & Chronic with artist Mike Allred (Marvel's FF and Silver Surfer). He soon got involved in (current Marvel Chief Creative Officer) Joe Quesada's Marvel Knights line of street-level heroes, writing the first arc of a new volume of Daredevil and a Spider-Man/Black Cat miniseries before working on DC books like Green Arrow and Batman, which he's returned to several times. He also adapted his unused screenplay for the Green Hornet movie into comics for Dynamite. The writer/director of Clerks has had a relatively hit-and-miss career when it comes to his movies, and though he's regarded as an extremely capable wordsmith, Smith's films are rarely praised for their striking visual style. Comics, then, are a much better fit for the unstoppable orator, as his occasionally over-wordy panels can be tempered by an artist with a keener understanding of action and tension. While there's some well-reasoned criticism of Smith's work for having rather dodgy attitudes towards women (his Black Cat miniseries sees Felicia Hardy revealed as a victim of date rape and his Poison Ivy is oversexualised to the point of being cartoonish), he's generally a writer capable of an enjoyable take on a familiar hero with some witty banter to go, and that's more than a lot of books get.
12. Alejandro Jodorowsky
He might not be big to everyone, but if you were a fan of midnight movies in 1970s New York, Alejandro Jodorowsky is probably your personal god, having directed the acid western El Topo and surrealist masterpiece The Holy Mountain. The octogenarian filmmaker and theatre director has had a wide-ranging and somewhat inconsistent career (he made no films for 23 years from 1990-2013), but has been a more or less regular comic creator since his first published work, Anibal 5, in 1966. Since then, Jodorowsky has produced many strange and wonderful sci-fi and fantasy books, possibly the most famous being Incal, illustrated by the legendary artist Jean Giraud aka Moebius. Widely praised as one of the greatest comics ever produced, the story spawned a trilogy of books and created the "Jodoverse", the fictitious universe in which many of the writer's stories take place. Jodorowsky's comics have also had an unintentional effect on other people's films, too: he once tried to sue The Fifth Element's director Luc Besson, claiming that he stole parts of the story and visuals from The Incal. He didn't have much of a leg to stand on, though, as Jodorowsky's collaborator Moebius did work as a contributing artist on the film...
11. Clive Barker
The author of Weaveworld, The Thief of Always and the creator of the Hellraiser, Clive Barker is probably most famous for his novels, but he's been making movies almost as long as he's been writing stories, having written the screenplays for two horror films in the mid-1980s before taking control of how his material was produced by writing and directing the first Hellraiser film (which he's just about to remake). He's had an off-and-on movie career since then, alternately writing, producing and directing either adaptations of his own work or original material, even founding his own production company Midnight Picture Show. But Barker's also had a finger in the comic book game for a long time now, first lending his name and plots to Marvel's Razorline imprint before allowing Marvel to make various adaptations from his other work - mostly Hellraiser books and spinoffs, which the author himself wrote for. In recent years Barker has been writing original comics for IDW and Boom! Studios, including 3D horror comic Seduth (co-written by Chris Monfette and illustrated by Gabriel Rodriguez) and the upcoming epic Next Testament (co-written by Mark Miller), in addition to lending his name to IDW's ongoing Hellraiser comic that follows directly on from the events of the Clive Barker-produced Hellbound: Hellraiser II.
9 & 10. The Wachowskis
I probably don't have to tell you that the creators of the Matrix trilogy and screenwriters/producers of V For Vendetta are pretty big comics fans, do I? The sibling filmmakers have long been fans of anime and sequential art, citing them as big influences on their work, as can be seen in their Animatrix shorts and the Matrix comics they wrote between 1999-2004. But you may not have known that the Wachowskis actually started out writing comics before they ever even had a script produced in La-La-Land. Lana (then Larry) actually wrote Ectokid for (#11 on this list) Clive Barker's Razorline comics along with various comic adaptations of his books in the early '90s, with Andy supposedly making some uncredited contributions to certain issues. Then Hollywood came calling, and after a brief few years in the limelight the Wachowskis returned to the form with the aforementioned Matrix comics and two original series created by Geof Darrow and published through their Burlyman productions, Doc Frankenstein and Shaolin Cowboy, which both ended up writing in some capacity or other.
8. J. Michael Straczynski
At this point in time we might as well switch the title of this article around, since Straczynski may well be better known as a comic book writer than a screenwriter these days. Well, except to people who've seen more than one episode of Babylon 5, anyway. J. Michael Straczynski started out writing anything and everything from plays, newspaper articles, a book on scriptwriting, radio plays and spec scripts for He-Man And The Masters Of The Universe, which he ended up on the staff of. He quickly graduated to live-action television and feature films in the late '80s and early '90, around which time he also started writing comics for various publishers which included Twilight Zone and Star Trek adaptations. He'd later write comics adapted from his own beloved sci-fi series Babylon 5 and started his own - relatively short-lived - line of comics with Top Cow, somewhat narcissistically named Joe's Comics, which was recently revived by Image with the books Ten Grand (with artist Ben Templesmith) and Sidekick (with artist Tom Mandrake). Straczynski has been in demand as a writer of superhero comics in recent years, working for DC on such small titles as The Brave and the Bold, Superman and not one but two Watchmen prequels, Dr. Manhattan and Nite Owl; and for Marvel on a host of A-list characters like Spider-Man, The Fantastic Four and is possibly most justly revered for his 2007 revival of Thor. Though he left all of his Marvel books abruptly due to creative differences (and, conveniently, the end of his exclusive contract) and is outspoken about his issues with the industry, he certainly managed to get a lot of his stories told in his time there.
7. Darren Aronofsky
Darren Aronofsky doesn't generally make things easy for himself. Whether it's making independent films like Pi and Requiem For A Dream outside the studio system and refusing to accept cuts or working within the system to create dangerously ambitious projects like The Fountain and the upcoming Noah, it seems that Aronofsky isn't interested in making something if there isn't a chance things could go badly. In the case of The Fountain, things went catastrophically, at least at first; the initial plan for the centuries-spanning sci-fi romance was to film it with Cate Blanchett and Brad Pitt in the leads for a higher budget than the version that was actually produced, but when it first fell through and the writer/director thought his film would never see the light of day, he decided to produce a comic-book version of his script with artist Kent Williams, whose stirring imagery served as a guideline for The Fountain's eventual resurrection with Hugh Jackman, Rachel Weisz and a smaller budget. That comic isn't a blip, though: Aronofsky's set to release a Noah comic (co-written by Ari Handel and illustrated by Niko Henrichon, known for the phenomenal Pride of Baghdad) alongside his big-budget feature film on the day it's released. It's not the same story translated to the page, however, as the comic is based on Aronofsky and Handel's original first-draft screenplay set in a more fantastical world, and looks to be much braver and more ambitious than the Russell Crowe picture is likely to be.
6. Jane Espenson
Espenson might not be the most instantly recognisable name on this list, but if you're a fan of genre television then I can almost guarantee that you've enjoyed something she's written: Buffy the Vampire Slayer, Battlestar Galactica, Angel, Torchwood, Warehouse 13, Firefly, Dollhouse, Deep Space Nine...hell, even The O.C. and Gilmore Girls. You name it, she's probably had a witty and delightful hand in it at some point. The talented screenwriter had maintained a relatively low profile due to her tendency to get staffed on shows but never create them (with the exception of Warehouse 13, which she co-created) until 2011, when her webseries Husbands (co-written and created with star Brad Bell) exploded all over the internet. The hilarious story of two gay men who accidentally get married while drunk and decide to stay that way was pretty much universally loved and has gone on to produce 3 seasons of free online content so far and given Espenson much more recognition than ever before. Espenson's foray into comics writing has been relatively recent, having written a few issues of Buffy the Vampire Slayer anthology comics in the early noughties and contributing to Seasons 8 & 9 of Dark Horse's canonical continuation of the TV show. She and co-creator Brad Bell also co-wrote a Husbands comic, released last year, and her breezy dialogue and well-crafted stories translate just as well to the page as they do the screen.
5. Guillermo Del Toro
Now don't yell at me, but this one's a little bit of a stretch. I don't need to tell you what Guillermo del Toro's done, do I? The Pan's Labyrinth, Hellboy and Pacific Rim director should be famous enough by now that the mere utterance of his name is enough to make all good nerds stop and take notice. When he's not making Spanish dark fantasy movies, del Toro can usually be found creating big-budget comic book worlds that are often actually taken from the pages of funnybooks themselves, like Blade II and the Hellboy movies, which del Toro co-writes with the red devil's creator himself, Mike Mignola. He's also responsible for some comics himself in the form of The Strain, an adaptation of the novel written by Guillermo del Toro and author Chuck Hogan. The series is written by David Lapham and illustrated by Mike Huddleston, but that's not the adaptation most people are getting excited about as a first season of a The Strain TV show is about to air on FX in July. Funnily enough, the story was originally pitched as a series but rejected and then turned into a novel...which was then turned into a television series directed by del Toro. Well, that's one way of going about it.
4. Hayao Miyazaki
The reigning king of Eastern animation and head of Studio Ghibli, Hayao Miyazaki is responsible for some of the greatest and best-loved animated films of the past 30 years: My Neighbour Totoro, Porco Rosso, Howl's Moving Castle and Princess Mononoke among many others were all directed by Japan's equivalent of Walt Disney. Predictably, Miyazaki wasn't always a revered animator: he worked as an artist for Toei animation and on his manga stories for many years before he got the chance to direct his first feature, The Castle of Cagliostro. Among his comic works were an adaptation of Puss in Boots and an original series, People of the Desert, which was a precursor to NausicaƤ of the Valley of the Wind, the first Ghibli feature anime and also Miyazaki's major manga work, having been produced both before and after the film's release and greatly expanding the characters, themes and world of the story. Miyazaki has continued to produce manga while simultaneously maintaining Studio Ghibli as a titan of the animation world and most recently adapted his 2009 manga The Wind Rises into what he claims will be his last film as director. But, y'know, he's claimed that with other films, so I'll take that with a pinch of salt.
3. George A. Romero
The godfather of the zombie movie may not be making as many films (at least as many decent ones) as he used to, but with a CV like his, George A. Romero can afford to get away with a duff movie or two. Not unlike Robert De Niro, though Romero at least has had the good sense to reduce his output somewhat while his muse is away. Part of the trouble with Romero's last few films is that they've exclusively been part of his Dead series, each with less atmosphere and more simple, obvious political allegory than the last. At least in the '70s and '80s he would refresh himself by making the odd vampire movie (Martin) or anthology film (Creepshow, written by Stephen King) between his zombie pictures, but he hasn't made a movie that doesn't involve flesh-eaters since 2000's Bruiser, and his comic-writing output doesn't do much to change that. Romero was a big fan of the EC Comics of the '50s, citing their horror and boldness as a great influence, so it's surprising that he never wrote a single comic until he contributed to a zombie series (what else?) called Toe Tags for DC in 2004. He didn't write a full series until he began Marvel's Empire of the Dead, a continuation of the world he created in Night of the Living Dead, with artist Alex Maleev last year. Although he's sticking to old guns, reviews have been fairly positive so far, so hopefully the new medium will bring new life to Romero's creative endeavors.
2. Dan Harmon
Who'd have guessed that Dan Harmon would ever have an affinity for anything that could be considered nerdy? Compared with Dungeons & Dragons, sci-fi stories about alternate dimensions and David Fincher parodies, comics are basically the Ray-Bans and leather jacket of the modern age. It's plain to see from most episodes of Community that Harmon adores comics (hell, he even performs his weekly podcast at a comic book store), but to most people's knowledge he's never actually contributed to any kind of novel, graphic or otherwise. Well, you might be surprised that the co-writer of Monster House and creator of Community was writing comics way before anyone started paying him to crack jokes onscreen. Harmon wrote several issues of his good friend and frequent collaborator Rob Schrab's independent absurd science fiction comic series Scud: The Disposable Assassin in the mid-'90s and the spin-off La Cosa Nostroid, both set in a world where people can buy robot assassins from vending machines which self-destruct after having killed their target. This, of course, wasn't Harmon and Schrab's only collaboration: they've since worked together in developing The Sarah Silverman Program, creating the cult Jack Black/Owen Wilson pilot Heat Vision and Jack and Schrab has directed several episodes of Community, most notably "Basic Lupine Urology", the show's Law & Order parody concerning the 'murder' of a sweet potato.
1. Joss Whedon
Well, I couldn't have made a list without the newly-crowned King of the Nerds, could I? Along with creating zeitgeist-defining shows like Buffy the Vampire Slayer and cult classics like Firefly, Joss Whedon is a huge comics aficionado and has been writing for the medium on and off since Buffy made the leap from small screen to smaller page. Whedon has written several books for Marvel, most famously his 24-issue run on Astonishing X-Men with artist John Cassaday which focused on Colossus and Kitty Pryde, a character who had a huge influence on the creation of Buffy. He's also the second writer to take on Runaways after Brian K. Vaughan and has created his own books: notably Fray, a Buffy spin-off centered on a slayer living 200 years in the future; and Sugarshock, an energetic, music-centric comic about a band who hate Vikings. Canonical continuations of both Buffy and Angel are currently being published by Dark Horse and are occasionally written by Whedon. It goes without saying that Joss Whedon's partly responsible for the current landscape of comic book movies, but his influence stretches even further back as he was initially hired to write the first X-Men movie (one of his only lines to survive was Storm's infamous "what happens to a toad when it's struck by lightning?" line) and the premise of his first Astonishing X-Men storyline, "Gifted", was partially adapted for X-Men: The Last Stand. And, of course, his team of movie Avengers is the current standard for Marvel's assembly of books - though I suspect that's less to do with Whedon and more to to with the powers that be...