15 Most Inappropriate Comics Storylines Of All Time
Meet Aunt May. No, seriously...
Comic books have never been afraid to push boundaries. Captain America socked Hitler in the face years before the US had even engaged the Nazi menace, superheroes have been used to illustrate countless societal ills, and Superman made it okay for people to wear their pants over their trousers.
The form has been home to countless brave editors, writers and artists who are keen to make their mark and really say something with the comics they produce. Sometimes, though, those creative teams are misguided in their choice of topic, or in the way that they go about exploring it. Sometimes they've not really thought through the implications of introducing heavy themes like drug abuse, incest and rape into their superhero stories. Or at least, you'd hope they hadn't, because the alternative is that they thought it totally fine to trivialise horrible subjects, or purposefully made squeaky clean superheroes do bad things for shock value and publicity.
All publicity is good publicity, though. Sort of.
These controversial comic book storylines - featuring everyone from Batman to Tigra - have often been some of the publisher behind them's biggest sellers, sometimes even becoming classics of their genre. That doesn't stop them being massively inappropriate for a variety of reasons, not least of which being that they usually involve characters who are otherwise fun, colourful kids favourites.
Here are fifteen of those very, very inappropriate comic books story arcs.
15. Tony Stark The Lush
One of the things that has set Marvel apart from its competitors is in their humanising of their superhuman characters. Spider-Man is a goofy, bullied teen; The Fantastic Four are an average bickering family, with added cosmic powers; the X-Men are hated and feared. Iron Man, on the other hand, was principally created as a rich arms dealer because Stan Lee wanted to troll hippies during the Cold War.
So how to bring him down from that mean spirited, satirical height, and into a "real" human character? Make him an alcoholic, duh.
Demon In A Bottle is considered a classic in the comic book canon, and it certainly helped redefine Tony Stark, his alcoholism becoming a permanent aspect of his characterisation that has been referred back to ever since. At the same time...it's a story about a drunk superhero. And one that ends with him pretty much conquering his drinking problems after a few weeks, which is hardly the most realistic depiction of a drinking problem.
Admittedly, it's a depiction of alcoholism in a guy who has a flying robot suit, but if you're gonna bring real life into your comic book, you've got to play by its rules at least a little.
14. Batman Gets High, Wets Pants
It could have worse. The writers of Demon In A Bottle could have been under the influence of the very substance they were writing about, which has worked for any number of fiction writers - Thompson, Hemingway, Fitzgerald - but not so much for filmmaker and sometime comic scribe Kevin Smith. At least if Smith's as-yet-incomplete Batman miniseries The Widening Gyre is anything to go by, which he admits was principally written under the influence of marijuana.
It's a credit to Smith that in his previous comics writing, he's managed to avoid the more mature/immature topics he gravitates towards in his movies. And it's a massive discredit that he indulges each and every one of them in The Widening Gyre. There's a whole issue where Batman gets high, having been dosed with a specially grown "herb" by Poison Ivy; there are umpteen awful sex jokes, including Bruce Wayne's girlfriend revealing she calls the Caped Crusader "Deedee", because they "reached double digits" their first night together; and if that wasn't lowest common denominator for you, Smith retcons the dramatic scene from Frank Miller's Year One where the young Batman confronts Gotham's crime elite so that he wet himself from fear.
This is the stuff of fan fiction, not officially published comic book.
13. Scarlet Witch And Quicksilver's "Special Relationship"
In the regular Marvel Universe, the twins Scarlet Witch and Quicksilver have a strained relationship. They grew up not knowing their father, and discovering that he was the mutant menace Magneto - with whom they had been collaborating with for years - didn't much help things.
In the Ultimate Universe, though, it was very different. They were much closer. Too close, arguably. As in, they engage in incestuous love making on the regular, and everybody is very horrified by it. Especially Captain America, whose poor WWII brain can't get his head around it.
To be fair, neither can ours, and so far as we know we've never been frozen in a block of ice for centuries. As if that wasn't inappropriate enough, there's also the hints that the pair are actually Wolverine's kids - Logan having had an affair with Magneto's missus not long before she got pregnant - and the above scene is being narrated by the X-Man as he watches from the bushes as the brother and sister get it on.
The brother and sister who may just be his own children. Because that wasn't creepy enough on its own, and needed a whole other level of ew ew ew please make it stop.
12. Extreme Babewatch, Extremely Terrible
When Todd McFarlane, Rob Liefeld, Erik Larsen and Jim Lee broke away from the Big Two to begin their independent Image Comics studio in the nineties, it was seen as a big score for creators owning their original work. In actuality it was mainly an outlet for these all-star writers and artists to create their own terrible knock-offs of Marvel and DC characters they had previously worked on, except now they could get away with all the violence and rufty they were never allowed to before.
They also decided to mimic their competition's penchant for big crossover events, and the best they could come up with was one where all the male characters in their shared universe became female for a month. And this event was called Babewatch. That actually would be a progressive move for an industry dominated by men both on the page and drawing them, right? Especially when it started with a witch getting revenge on the male gender by turning every man Image hero Glory had ever met into a woman.
In practice, though, it was just an excuse to stick scantily clad women on every cover and in every comic for a month. So women could only get ahead in the Image Universe if they were actually men, and if they had little-to-no-clothes on. Yep.
11. The !*$% Batman, Orphan Hater
Frank Miller has written and drawn some of the most iconic comic books of all time, and specifically two groundbreaking Batman storylines: the dystopian future of the Dark Knight and the gritty origin tale, Year One. At some point, however, he seems to have been bashed on the head or been replaced by an insane robot doppelganger or something, because he totally went off the deep end.
He put together the insanely Islamophobic Holy Terror! graphic novel, but before that he wrote All-Star Batman And Robin, The Boy Wonder, one of the most bizarre comics DC has ever published. Usually Bruce Wayne is a compassionate man who is tough on crime, but in Miller's head he becomes a borderline psychopath who essentially kidnaps Robin immediately after his parents have died, then leaves him to hunt for food in the Batcave as "training". He makes out with Black Canary on a motorcycle. He refers to himself, most infamously, as "the !*$% Batman". Multiple times. And he made no bones about how the women characters should be depicted in the series, either, namely in their underwear focussing on either their chest or bums at all times.
This was all in an actual Batman comic people were expected to read.
10. Hank Pym, Model Husband
Hank Pym is one of the biggest jokes of the Marvel Universe. People mock his supposed intelligence, which pales in comparison to peers like Reed Richards and Tony Stark. People laugh at his constant attempts to reinvent himself, having taken the aliases Ant-Man, Giant-Man, Goliath, Yellowjacket and even Scientist Supreme over the course of his career. Then there is his terrible, terrible track record as a husband to fellow Avenger Janet van Dyne, better known as the Wasp, better known as the wife who Hank Pym beat.
Around the same time as Iron Man started boozing it up, Marvel tried to give a little more tragic gravitas to the perpetually unpopular Pym by having him suffer a mental breakdown on his dismissal from the Avengers, deciding to send a robot to attack them during his court martial, and then striking the Wasp when she tried to stop him.
Of course, his plan failed, and Janet divorced him, in a storyline that barely touched upon the reality of spousal abuse in favour of evil robots. A little ill-conceived, to say the least.
9. Tigra Is Pro-Choice
In a universe full of goofy characters, Tigra is one of the goofiest. Transformed into a cat-person by a mystic ritual that fused her soul with some sort of feline god, her main use in Marvel Comics was to wear a bikini for adolescent teen boys to stare at, and occasionally lick her fur so as to remind them that she was part cat. She was single-handedly responsible for furries, basically. Recently, Tigra got a dose of that patented Marvel Tragic Storyline when she got pregnant from a Skrull posing as Hank Pym (that jerk again!), and had to decide whether she was going to keep the baby or not.
This is probably the first time that abortion was directly dealt with in a superhero comic, and the results were...mixed, at best. Even before she realised the father was a Skrull she was considering it, given Pym's track record as a husband. She was put off going through the procedure when she battled Ragnarok, but began to think seriously about it when a mechanical facsimile of Thor's hammer clocked her in the belly.
Then Norman Osborn demanded she either abort it or give birth to it immediately, since he wanted to use the baby as a weapon. So. Yeah. Sensitive subject, covered in the least sensitive manner possible.
8. The Evil That Men Do; Kevin Smith Specifically
Just when you thought it was safe to go back to comic books, it turns out Kevin Smith turned his skills to a Marvel title as well. Spider-Man/Black Cat: The Evil That Men Do was a miniseries by Smith and artist Terry Dodson that mainly dealt with the latter character, the cat burglar known to her friends as Felicia Hardy, started off on dodgy footing. Spider-Man and Black Cat a fun pairing whose adventures have a flirty undercurrent, so the best thing to do with them in Smith's eyes was have them delve into the murky criminal underworld of heroin dealers. Yay!
Over the course of the pair's attempts to bring down drug baron Garrison Klum, it is implied that the Black Cat is sexually assaulted by the villain. Then the story ends with her meeting Garrison's younger brother Francis, who was molested by the villain as a kid. Which is when Black Cat reveals she is a multiple rape victim, and her initial attack inspired her to start training herself up as an anti-hero in the first place.
So that's a bunch of topics that should be tackled in a Spider-Man comic. Especially when the male victim of abuse becomes goofy villain Mysterio at the end.
7. Sexy Aunt May Is Sexy
Mark Millar has presided over some controversial comic books in his time, from the increasingly violent Kick-Ass to Marvel's Civil War event, but one that didn't cause nearly as much upset as it should was Trouble. The only title to come out of Marvel's failed attempt to resurrect the romance comics that had been big in the fifties, Trouble was the story of two couples in the seventies who just happened to share the names of the parents and aunt and uncle of Peter Parker, aka Spider-Man: Richard, Mary, May and Ben.
The series did get into a bit of trouble with its photographic covers of two teen girls in bikinis who looked suspiciously underage (they weren't, it turned out), but the real controversy for fans was when the character of May got knocked up, but her friend Mary agreed to say the baby was hers. And that baby was called Peter.
So, Trouble implied that Aunt May was secretly Peter Parker's mum, and if that wasn't enough for fans also included sex scenes between her and Richard Parker, which only a very small and disturbed niche had ever asked for.
Trouble has never been collected in trade paperback form, so perhaps Marvel realised just how inappropriate this all was.
6. Lois Lane Goes Black, Then Goes Back
The sixties were a landmark era in the struggle for Civil Rights, as the protests by racial minorities became part of the mainstream cultural conversation. DC Comics, who would later tackle the same issues with the left-leaning Green Lantern/Green Arrow series, decided to add its voice to the conversation with an issue of Superman's Girlfriend, Lois Lane where the titular reporter, erm, goes into a magic box in the Man of Steel's Fortress of Solitude and comes out as a black person.
Look, they probably had good intentions. Lois is given the assignment of writing about Metropolis's black community (who live in an area of town called, ahem, Little Africa), only to be ostracised when she goes there. By transforming herself into a black woman, though, she gains acceptance from them and begins to sympathise with their plight, even becoming the victim of racism herself.
In theory, the story would give the white readers a similar insight into how it was to be a person of colour in seventies America. In practice, it's a pretty bad taste fable where Lois gets to be white and privileged again at the end.
5. Every Swimsuit Special
Cheesecake is one of the most disheartening aspects of mainstream comic books. You can't go down an aisle in a comic shop without being faced with dozens of titles featuring female characters in various states of undress, or in impossible "seductive" poses, or with exaggerated busts that would give them serious back problems. If that wasn't inappropriate enough for a form that's still read by a lot of young, impressionable kids, well, there's the Swimsuit Specials.
Still going strong today, Swimsuit Specials drop any pretense of telling a story and simply show female and male characters alike (although mainly female) posing in double-page spreads that have more than a hint of the Playboy about them.
To DC's credit, they've mainly kept out of this sleazy practice, whilst Marvel had one every year between 1991 and 1995, the already-bikini-clad Lady Death has made a cottage industry out of it, and Image were the pioneers in the nineties. It's bad enough seeing the sorts of costumes characters put on in the pages of regular comics, without having to see them in their undercrackers, doing lad's mag poses on the beach. Bah.
4. Spider-Man's Toxic...Y'know
Spider-Man is a fun loving character who just happens to have terrible things happen to him. Those terrible things rarely manage to grind him down, though, because for every loved one who dies tragically he is reminded that his superhero work has saved the lives of countless others. That wasn't enough for Kaare Andrews, however, who decided to write and draw a Spidey spin on the Dark Knight Returns, where the wallcrawler was a depressed and broken retired hero living in a dystopian future New York. Who wouldn't want to see that?
The reason Peter Parker decided to hang up the Spider-Man mantle is probably one of the inappropriate plot twists we have ever come across. It was the death of his beloved Mary Jane that triggered it but, surprisingly, she did not lose her life to one of her husband's many superpowered arch enemies. It was from Peter himself, whose...well, let's just use the medical terms here.
Having been bitten by a radioactive spider, it turns out Peter's semen was irradiated, and Mary Jane's exposure to it had riddled her with an incurable cancer. Spider-Man's wife died because he had sex with her and it killed her. So...that's a thing.
3. League Of Extraordinary Buggery
Alan Moore loves sodomy. That's not a piece of scandalous gossip on the eccentric, bearded writer's bedroom habits - we can but speculate on what happens in deepest, darkest Northampton - but more a trend that comes up in a surprising amount of his most celebrated work, including the deconstructionist superhero classic Watchmen and most distressingly in the League of Extraordinary Gentlemen.
A historical take on a superteam formed in the Victorian era, with a membership comprised of fictional characters from the era that are in the public domain, Moore nonetheless managed to shoehorn some buggery into a story set in an infamously chaste time period. Actually there's a lot of inappropriate couplings within the pages of League of Extraordinary Gentleman, including the repeated graphic love scenes between elderly adventurer Allan Quatermain and eternally younger vampire woman Mina Murray. But it's the (pun not in any way intended) climactic scene of the second book that's his piece de resistance when it comes to sodomy.
It transpires that the Invisible Man has been conspiring against the team, colluding with their War of the Worlds-inspired Martian enemies, a scheme which is uncovered by colleague Dr Jekyll in Mr Hyde mode. Enraged by his supposed friend's betrayal, the Hulk-like Hyde beats the Invisible Man to a pulp and then rapes him for good measure. Which is either a bravura twist on a classic piece of literature or totally inappropriate, depending on your point of view.
2. Nightcrawler And The Devil Babies
You have to have some sympathy for Chuck Austen. The writer was brought onto the flagship X-Men title following the incredibly successful and influential reboot by Grant Morrison, Frank Quitely, et al. That's a tough act to follow. Then again, he decided to follow that act by turning the mutant team into a terrible sex comedy - so terrible, in fact, that Austen wrote only one more title after this before disappearing from the comic book world entirely.
It's not a coincidence that this title was a soft-porn manga knock-off. It's also not a coincidence that Austen, who began his career in comics writing straight-up erotica, would cause the X-Men to bomb so hard by turning them into hormone-ridden maniacs. There's always been sexual tension within the team - including the Cyclops/Jean/Emma love triangle of New X-Men - but Austen brought it to the forefront, and also made it super gross.
The Juggernaut bedded She-Hulk, Angel got it on with Husk in mid-air above her parents' house, and in a storyline that is widely regarded as one of the worst in comics history, he unveiled the true origins of teleporting blue fuzzy guy Nightcrawler. The Draco revealed that Kurt Wagner's father was Azazel, one of the Marvel Universe's many analogues for...Satan. And Satan had been impregnating women across Earth for centuries, conspiring to use all his devil babies to somehow take over the planet.
This is a comic book storyline about Satan banging his way to world supremacy. And let's never speak of it again.
1. The Rise (Mainly Fall) Of Arsenal
Roy Harper has had an inauspicious career in the DC Universe. Taking the alter ego Speedy and becoming Green Arrow's teen sidekick, he was nothing more than a Robin rip-off for the first few decades of his existence. Then, in an award winning 1971 story arc in the pages of Green Lantern/Green Arrow, he was revealed to have been a heroin addict for years.
With the help of other heroes and the federal government, Speedy overcame his addiction and fronted various initiatives to keep other kids off the horse. He grew up some, was an on-off member of the Teen Titans and later the Outsiders, and took the new mantle of Arsenal. Which is where things took another turn for the worse for Roy and his readers. In 2010 he got his own miniseries in the form of Justice League: The Rise of Arsenal, which should have been good news for the character!
As it happens, though, it simply launched him into one of the most grossly inappropriate and thoughtless comic book storylines ever committed to paper, which has since been roundly described as one of the worst comics to be produced in history. There's the iconic image of Arsenal, completely off his !*$%, brutally beating a bunch of people half to death because he thinks the rotting corpse of a cat is his daughter. That's after he's smoked a bunch of heroin because he was unable to "perform" during a romantic encounter.
Luckily Batman shows up to kick him in the face whilst claiming to be his friend. Drugs, sex, violence, and without a single logical connecting thread, Rise of Arsenal is a greatest hits compilation of inappropriate comic storylines all in one horrific package.