9 Times Batman Broke His One Rule And Killed

Batman doesn't kill? These examples say different!

By K.J. Stewart /

Warner Bros.

Batman has one rule: He doesn't kill people (he also doesn't use guns, but that's just an extension of the same rule). Except he actually does - and he has done so on numerous occasions.

Advertisement

The Dark Knight is notorious for his non-lethal methods - preferring to immobilise both petty criminals and supervillains so that the Gotham Police Department can deal with them, rather than getting rid of them for good by killing them. A big deal is made of that fact - Batman is seen as a noble and somewhat merciful vigilante, but the fact is that couldn't be further from the truth. The Caped Crusader is effectively a mass murderer!

Across pretty much all forms of media, he has killed a hell of a lot of people. Whether it's in one-on-one situations or whether he carries out a deed that despatches large groups, he's ended the lives of many - often in quite brutal ways. It really is about time he lost his tag of a non-killer, because he simply isn't one and in this article we're going to take a look at a number of the occasions in which he has offed people.

Advertisement

Here are nine times Batman broke his one rule and killed...

9. Crushes People In Junkyards (Various)

DC Comics

This particular entry could actually extend this list well in to double figures, because it's happened several times, but for the purposes of not repeating ourselves we're limiting it to one entry.

Advertisement

Batman seems to enjoying killing people in junkyards, by way of crushing them. Here are a couple of examples of that:

- In 1988's Batman No. 425, Batman fights an angry drug dealer who is seeking revenge on Robin after the Boy Wonder intentionally dropped his brother off a rooftop. The dealer chases Batman with a gun and Batman ends up toppling a large pile of cars on top of him (despite the fact he had lectured Robin about how killing the drug dealers brother was wrong).

Advertisement

- In 1990's Detective Comics No. 613, Batman investigates a turf war going on between rival disposal companies (yeah, really). When he gets there, one of the guys involved in the dispute tries to hit him with a chair, prompting the Dark Knight to kick him, which subsequently launches him in to another crook, leading them both to fall into a garbage grinder.

Pretty brutal - especially in the second instance when the situation was just a couple of guys arguing about who was top dog in the garbage disposal world.

Advertisement

8. Leaves Ra's Al Ghul To Die (Batman Begins)

Warner Bros. Pictures

2005's Batman Begins was a reboot of the origin story of Batman which served as the first of the three movies in Christopher Nolan's Dark Knight trilogy. In the movie, Bruce Wayne becomes Batman having been taught the skills required to do so by Henri Ducard - a man representing the mysterious group known as the League of Shadows.

Advertisement

Little did Bruce know that Henri Ducard was actually the alter-ego of Ra's al Ghul - a man wanting to make the world better, but in harsh, Draconian ways - and, as a result, the two end up fighting.

In the movie's final battle, Batman overpowers Ra's aboard Gotham City's monorail and leaves him hanging precariously from a height. He says that he will not kill him and Ra's is relieved, but he goes on to say that it does not mean he has to save him and leaves Ra's to die as the train collapses and explodes. While he didn't directly kill him, his inaction caused the villain to die.

Advertisement

7. Blows Up Axis Chemicals When It's Filled With Henchmen (Batman)

Warner Bros.

Axis Chemicals was a chemical plant in Gotham City, created by Tim Burton for his 1989 Batman movie. It was the place where Jack Napier was submerged into a vat of toxic chemicals, despite Batman's attempts to save him, and subsequently transformed into the villainous Joker in that particular continuity.

Advertisement

Later, it was the scene of Joker's master plan of lacing hygiene products with a deadly chemical known as "Smilex", which causes victims to laugh to death when combined with certain other ingredients, and Batman arrived to put a stop to it.

After realising that it was the only way to put an end to the scheme, the Dark Knight charged in to the plant in the Batmobile and destroyed it in a mass explosion, killing the large numbers of the Joker's henchmen who were present in there at the time.

Advertisement

6. Buried KGBeast Alive (Ten Nights Of The Beast)

DC Comics

The KGBeast was an assassin sent by the Soviet Union in a 1988 comic to kill, amongst other key figures, President Ronald Reagan. Batman stepped in to stop the villain but was outmatched by him in their first few encounters.

Advertisement

In issue #420, the Dark Knight destroyed KGBeast's signature arm gun and led him down in to the sewers. The pair came to a dead end and KGBeast challenged the hero to a final battle whilst wielding a lead pipe. Instead of stepping up to the challenge, Batman simply explain that he couldn't be bothered - especially when there was no need to risk his life.

He then walked out of the room they were in, shut the door and blocked it closed with a large pile of wooden planks, leaving the villain to die of starvation - essentially burying him alive in the sewers.

Advertisement

5. Hangs A Guy From His Batplane (Batman #1)

DC Comics

In the very first Batman solo comic (yes, the VERY first time Batman appeared in his own title), the Dark Knight was going after an evil scientist who had used a toxic serum to turn a group of innocent mental patients into muscular, out-of-control monsters.

Advertisement

A van containing some henchmen who were driving one of the monsters somewhere for him to wreak havoc crashed into a tree, when Batman attacked it. The monster got loose, Batman hung a noose from his Batplane around his neck, then lifted him up, hanging him to death.

This was an innocent mental patient who had simply been used in a cruel experiment. Incidentally, this was all after Batman had mowed down every other person who was on board the van with a newly mounted machine gun that he had on his Batplane. But he "doesn't kill", of course...

Advertisement

4. Kicked Some Guys Into A Fire... Then Has Sex (All-Star Batman & Robin, The Boy Wonder, Vol. 1)

DC Comics

In this issue, Batman jumps a group of thieves who are stealing a shipment of bleach (yeah, bleach). After scaring them witless, his opening gambit is to combine a bottle of the flammable stuff, combine it with some thermite from his utility belt and throw it at them, which instantly sets them all on fire.

Advertisement

While they're all on fire, Batman still feels the need to beat the crap out of them - while fellow Justice League member Black Canary watches on and gets aroused by the whole thing (seriously). The pair then do what any other normal pair would do - they have sex next to a pile of burning corpses. That's normal, right?

Is it becoming a bit more clear that Batman is actually a bit of a murderous b**tard yet?

Advertisement

3. Pushes A Guy Into A Sword (Detective Comics No. 37)

DC Comics

In this particular issue, the villain in question is a monocle-wearing Count. The upper-class cretin makes the mistake of throwing a sword at the Dark Knight, whose only inconvenience is that he was ticked off at the guy's audacity. He calls the fellow a "rat" and subsequently serves him an incredibly needless death.

Advertisement

Batman shuts the door, walks towards the man, gets on the other side of him and hits him with enough force to send him flying on to the very sword he had just thrown. He ends up with the weapon impaled through his neck and, of course, perishes. Batman did this when the man was unarmed, when he was no longer in any danger, and he had to orchestrate the situation by closing the door and positioning himself suitably for it to occur.

It's an outright murder in the true sense of the word.

Advertisement

2. Shot Darkseid (Final Crisis)

DC Comics

Final Crisis sees Darkseid's spirit falling to Earth, setting in to motion the sundering of reality itself, creating a singularity at the heart of creation, into which all of space and time are slowly being drawn, setting the stage for the evil god's final victory.

Advertisement

In Final Crisis #6, he is confronted by a number of heroes who are trying to save reality itself. After having killed his son with a bullet made of Radion - a substance that is toxic to the New Gods - Darkseid finds himself facing down the barrel of a gun wielded by Batman with that very same bullet in it. Batman fired the gun and intended to kill the villain, even stating explicitly that he'd break his one rule to do so, given the dire circumstances the universe was facing, and was killed by the Omega Beams that Darkseid fired off simultaneously.

The shot hit Darkseid in the shoulder and wounded him terribly, but it didn't kill him - although the fact that he would probably have died from the wound anyway, the fact that he was finished off by a group of other heroes soon after, and the fact that Batman was explicitly trying to kill him means it has to be included on this list.

Advertisement

1. Kicks Qayin Into Cables (Batman: Son Of The Demon)

DC Comics

Qayin AKA Quinlan Landor was the godchild of Ra's al Ghul and his wife Melisande. The pair would look after him as a youngster, when his parents went away on missions, working for Ra's.

Advertisement

They died whilst on a mission and Qayin blamed Ra's. He started behaving bizarrely and Ra's' daughter Talia wanted him to be expelled from the house. Ra's couldn't bring himself to do this, which resulted in the death of his wife, as Qayin caused her to fall into an early version of the Lazarus Pit, which killed her. He fled, re-emerging years later as a terrorist.

He set in to motion a plan to use a weather satellite as a weapon against Earth, whilst also seeking eternal life as he was dying - for which he sought Ra's al Ghul out. In attacking Ra's, he caused Talia to lose her unborn child - that of Batman's - which prompted Batman to join the fight against him. When Qayin tried to kill Ra's with sparking electrical cables, Batman pushed Qayin into them himself, electrocuting him.

Advertisement