Batman's 9 Greatest Failures

Batman may be the world's greatest hero, but he is still just a man, and all men are fallible.

By Kevin McHugh /

For many years Batman has been presented as infallible. Both other characters and readers see him as the man who has all the angles covered. As his greatest enemy, the Joker, once quipped, "Every single time I try to think outside his toybox, he builds a new box around me.". This attitude makes the time's Batman does fail all the more shocking and, usually, devastating.

Advertisement

Sometimes it's through the machinations of one of his enemies, but the greatest threat to the Dark Knight has always been Batman himself. Bruce Wayne is a broken and haunted man who cannot always outrun his demons. Writers often present Batman as a man with an iron will who completely controls his emotions. Still, the truth is he suppresses them most of the time—treating them as a common criminal and bending them to his will through intimidation and overwhelming intellect.

Perhaps the greatest of all Batman's opponents is his hubris, the one thing that has seen him bested time and again.

9. Batman's Hubris Causes A Crime War

Stephanie Brown has one of the most storied histories of any DC character. From her humble roots as Spoiler - the daughter of two-bit loser, the Clue Master - all the way up to taking on the mantle of Batgirl. She has been "dead", pregnant and a Bird of Prey, but perhaps her most memorable moment came when she was, briefly, Robin.

Advertisement

When Tim Drake's father finds out about his son being Robin, he forces Tim to choose between him and Batman. Tim sides with his father and Bruce does not take the news well, and he swings into full "spoiled little rich boy" mode. Batman turns around and offers the mantle of Robin to Tim’s on-again/off-again girlfriend Stephanie Brown; someone who Batman had refused to sanction up until then.

The whole thing goes badly and, almost as quickly as Stephanie becomes Robin, Bruce fires her. A hurt and confused Spoiler then steals Batman’s plan to destabilize organized crime in Gotham and attempts to execute it. Stephanie’s ignorance of Bruce's alter-ego Matches Malone, a key component to the scheme success, results in an all-out gang war that tears Gotham apart.

8. Taken Down By Prometheus

There is a case to be made for Batman being his own greatest enemy. In Grant Morrison's seminal run on the Justice League book, he would test that theory quite literally with the introduction of Prometheus; a villain that is an evil version of Batman, only relying on a "quick fix" method of achieving human perfection rather than a lifetime of sacrifice and commitment.

Advertisement

Prometheus has a helmet that allows him to upload the combat abilities of the world’s greatest fighters directly into his mind. When he attacks the League's headquarters on the moon, he finds himself going one-on-one with Batman. The villain shakes the Dark Knight's confidence when he announces he has uploaded the skills of thirty of the world’s greatest martial arts masters and that the list includes Batman himself.

Although much of the fight takes place off-panel, the effect of seeing Green Lantern having a beaten Batman casually discarded at his feet by a sneering Prometheus is no less shocking.

7. Harold's Betrayal

Batman has had so many allies, agents and sidekicks over the years that it's easy for readers to forget them if they don't appear in one of the Bat-Family titles for a few months.

Advertisement

For Batman to forget about one of them is understandable from a creative perspective; ignoring them is more straightforward than killing them off if a writer doesn't want to use them. The problem being, can Batman afford to lose track of someone who knows all his secrets, including his true identity?

Jeph Loeb answered that question during the Hush story arc with Harold, Batman's one-time mechanic and gadget engineer. Written initially as a child-like savant who physically resembled Quasimodo, Batman rescued him from a manipulative relationship with the Penguin. Bruce would bring him into the cave and his life, setting him to work on the Batmobile. Despite appearing sporadically over the next few years, readers and characters would soon forget about him.

When Hush and his silent partner, the Riddler, began their campaign of terror, its success was mainly due to the inside information the two gained from Harold in exchange for helping cure his physical deformity. Harold's betrayal would ultimately result in his death.

6. David Cain's Manipulations And Batman's Own Grief

Bruce Wayne may be able to deal with almost anything the DC universe has to throw at him. He is as confident taking bank robbers as he is alien gods. Where Batman usually crumbles is matters of the heart. He may understand grief on an abstract level, but when it comes to emotionally processing it, Batman either buries it deep or uses it as fuel for his great crusade.

Advertisement

When his on-again/off-again love interest, Vesper Fairchild, is murdered by David Cain, and Bruce Wayne framed, the Bat-Family rally to clear his name. Only the loss of Vesper, along with the recent shooting and retirement of long-time friend Jim Gordon has left Batman struggling to come to terms with the pain and heartache he is suffering. Instead of dealing with it, he stops being Bruce Wayne, believing that he can leave the trauma behind with the mansion and his millions; choosing to spend his entire time as Batman.

His allies, especially his recently adopted son Nightwing, are left stunned and heartbroken. Cain's devious twist of making it appear to those in the know that Bruce has killed Vesper to protect his secret does not help matters. To the world at large, Bruce Wayne is a wanted fugitive, and worst of all, the actual murderer of Vesper Fairchild would remain at large for months.

5. Almost Killing The Joker

It's a question that gets asked of Batman repeatedly: why do you not just kill the Joker?

Advertisement

Nearly everyone who has written about the Batman and Joker dynamic has presented their answer to this question; most sticking to the moral line of Batman never taking a life or the fact that he doesn't kill him is what separates him from the Joker.

No matter what atrocities Joker commits, the Caped Crusader always chooses to save his own soul instead of permanently putting down the Clown Prince of Crime. Only by telling a story about the twilight years of Bruce Wayne could writer/artist Frank Miller address the question, how much of a toll on a man's sanity could a lifetime of Jokers cruelties take?

The answer is almost enough to push Batman to do the unthinkable. After causing another massacre, the World's Greatest Detective tracks down Joker and gives in to his anger, beating his enemy within an inch of his life and leaving him paralysed. The Joker would snap his own neck as a result and the world at large would believe it was Batman who had killed him.

4. Failing To Stop No Man's Land

The list of villains who have caused devastation to Batman and his world is long and bloody. The names that feature at the top end are some of comics' most notorious ne'er-do-wells, such as the Joker, Bane and Ra's al Ghul. Nicholas Scratch, satanic rock star and cult leader, is a name in those upper echelons that might not be as familiar to people.

Advertisement

In the aftermath of a devastating earthquake, Gotham City faces an uncertain fate. Batman, his allies and its populace wait to see the reaction of the United States government. Knowing that fists alone will not solve this problem, Bruce Wayne heads to Washington to plead with congress to pledge its support to the city he loves in its darkest hour.

What he finds is a corrupt senator under the sway of Nicholas Scratch and his cult. The rock star uses his media status to drum up the anti-Gotham sentiment with the public, his cultists to threaten and bribe those in power, and his influence to make Bruce Wayne look self-serving and corrupt.

Scratch succeeds in having Gotham declared a no man's land and cut off entirely from the United States.

3. Ra's destroys the Justice League

As Batman's status in the larger DC universe grew, so did his paranoia. Bruce Wayne has plans for every eventuality and is consistently one step ahead of his enemies; be they bank robbers or shapeshifting, superpowered, telepathic Martians.

Advertisement

When a group of Demi-Gods set up shop on the surface of the moon and become the arbiters of what is "just" in the world, Bruce has no choice but to plan for the chance that they will become a threat to Earth - even if he counts himself among their number and that these people are supposedly his friends.

When immortal criminal mastermind Ra's al Ghul comes up with a plan to dwindle the Earth's population, it requires keeping the Justice League at bay. Stealing Batman's secret files and strategies on how to take down each member of the League is only viable if you have the money and resources to put the plans into motion.

Fortunately, Ra's has that money and resources to hand, and within a matter of hours he had taken down the most powerful beings on Earth - all thanks to Batman and his ability to plan for every contingency.

2. The Death Of Jason Todd

It was the darkest moment in a life already awash with innocent blood, and was one of the most brutal chapters of the battle between bitter enemies. Dick Grayson grew up and assumed the identity of Nightwing, leaving the position of Robin vacant. DC would introduce readers to Jason Todd; a young orphan Batman first meets stealing the wheels from the Batmobile.

Advertisement

Bruce Wayne thought he could raise and instruct Jason just as he had done for Dick years before. The problem was, Jason wasn't Dick Grayson, and readers knew it. As Bruce failed to mentor the bitter and headstrong new Robin, fans voted in their thousands to have the boy killed off in a phone poll.

Both events culminated in Jason finding out that his biological mother was still alive and strong-arming Bruce into helping him track her down. After a couple of red herrings, Jason would see his mother under the thrall of the Joker. While Bruce was busy, the boy charged off wrongly, believing that he had enough training to take on the homicidal clown and save his mother by himself - a move that resulted in him being bloodily beaten with a crowbar.

1. Being Broken By Bane

It was the KRAKT heard around the comics world and one of the '90s defining moments. In the wake of the commercial success of The Death of Superman, DC Comics replaced most of its top heroes with varying degrees of success.

Advertisement

Hal Jordan would fall from grace, die and be replaced by Kyle Rayner. Wonder Woman, killed by Neron, ascended to become the Goddess of Truth, and Artemis briefly took her place in mans world. There was almost no character who made it through the Grunge Era unscathed.

Bane's ingenious strategy of freeing and arming every inmate in Arkham, exhausting Batman mentally and physically, was not the reason for the Dark Knight's defeat. It was once again Bruce's hubris that was his undoing; by refusing to allow others to help him lest they risk suffering the same fate as Jason Todd, Batman signed his death warrant.

Rushing headlong into battles with all his greatest enemies one after the other, keeping Robin at arm's length and Dick Grayson in the dark, it was inevitable Bane would break him.

Advertisement