The Joker's 7 Most Compelling Potential Origins

"Do you wanna know how I got these scars?"

By Bryant Lucas /

The Joker has always had a notoriously ambiguous origin. As one of the greatest comic book characters of all time, the Joker has had hundreds of different writers, each with their own unique take on the Clown Prince of Crime. After various reboots, rewrites and retcons, DC eventually gave up on trying to create a definitive origin for the Joker and embraced the chaos inherent within the character. In Alan Moore€™s Batman: The Killing Joke, the Joker even admits: €œSometimes I remember it one way, sometimes another€ If I€™m going to have a past, I prefer it to be multiple choice!€ This only proves that DC wants this character€™s origin to remain a mystery. Yet despite this mystery, there are some frequent (though not always consistent) elements within the Joker€™s back-story, which usually involve someone falling into a vat of chemicals, having their skin bleached and hair turned green, and suffering a severe mental breakdown. And while these are the most common elements of the Joker€™s narrative, the circumstances and identity of this individual remain inconsistent and mysterious. Recently, DC has changed its approach to continuity. Since the end of Convergence re-established an infinite multiverse, everything counts. Every version of every character through out the entire history of the DCU now exists in one form or fashion within the multiverse. This only complicates the matter even more, as every version of the Joker€™s origin is now potentially valid. Therefore, here is a quasi-chronological compilation of the seven most compelling, most likely origins of everyone€™s favorite Bat-Villain: The Joker. WARNING: There are Batman: Endgame spoilers ahead.

7. Detective Comics #168 €“ The Silver Age Joker (1951)

In order to understand the earliest origin of the Joker, you first need to know a little bit about the DC multiverse. The multiverse was a retcon introduced in the €˜60s to explain how Batman was around fighting Nazis in the €˜40s, yet still relatively young and active in the €˜60s. In 1961 DC established that the older Golden Age version of Batman existed on Earth Two, while the younger Batman of the €˜60s, the Silver Age Batman, existed on Earth One. While this was an elegant solution to DC€™s continuity problem, Detective Comics and Batman were never renumbered; therefore, it was never truly established which of the early Batman stories were set on Earth One or Earth Two.
Turning to the Joker of both Earth One and Earth Two, we see that the two characters originally shared the same back-story, as the lines between which Joker is which were not established when DC published his original origin. The Joker makes his first appearance in Batman #1(1940); however, this issue did not give an origin for the Clown Prince of Crime. This came over a decade later in Detective Comics #168 (1952), which was titled The Man Behind The Red Hood. It was revealed in this issue that the Joker was originally the masked professional criminal leader known as the Red Hood. One night, when the Red Hood and his men were attempting a heist, Batman and Robin chased the Red Hood into a chemical plant and cornered him on a catwalk. Out of desperation, the Red Hood jumped off the catwalk into a vat of chemicals that changed his appearance and drove him mad. It was later added that this vat of chemicals contained the ink used to make playing cards thus the origin of the Joker€™s clown motif. With regards to the Golden/Silver Age split, this origin falls about 10 after the Joker was revealed and 10 years before DC established it multiverse; therefore, it was unclear as to whether this was the origin for the Golden or Silver Age Joker until recently.

6. Detective Comics #27 €“ The Retconned Golden Age Joker (1939; 2014)

Batman€™s first adventure was published in Detective Comics #27 (1939). Here we are given the tale called The Case Of The Chemical Syndicate, which focused on a group of businessmen who owned the Apex Chemical Corporation. One of the men, Stryker, made a deal to pay each of the partners a sum of money yearly until he owned the company. He eventually grew impatient with waiting and hatched a scheme to kill his partners and take control of their shares of the business. When Batman shows up to stop Stryker, he hits him so hard that Skryker breaks through a railing and falls into a tank of acid. Although this story has much in common with the aforementioned The Man Behind The Red Hood, this was never the official origin for the Joker€ until 2014.
During 2011 DC rebooted and renumbered their line, and when the renumbered issue of Detective Comics #27 (2014) was released, they used it as an opportunity to celebrate the 75th anniversary of Batman. This super-sized issue was a compilation of Batman stories, which also included a retelling of Golden Age Batman€™s first adventure by written by Brad Meltzer with art by Brian Hitch. At the end of this retold story, Meltzer potentially offers a new origin for the Joker, as we see Stryker€™s marred hand reach up out of the acid bath. Meltzer€™s retcon has possibly fixed a continuity problem dating back to the €˜60s by making Stryker the Golden Age Joker of Earth Two and thereby establishing that the 1951 Red Hood origin was indeed the Silver Age Joker of Earth One.

5. Batman: The Killing Joke (1988)

The Killing Joke is one of the most controversial Batman stories of all time, as it depicts the brutal marring and potential rape of Barbara Gordon, the Silver Age Batgirl. However, if you are able to look past the sexism in this story, it€™s actually a brilliant character study of the Joker and his origin. Written by comic book legend Alan Moore in 1988, after the Crisis On Infinite Earths reboot, The Killing Joke served as the first pos-Crisis Joker origin. And to this day, it's considered to be one of the most influential Batman stories of all time. This story depicts the Joker as an engineer at a chemical plant named Jack* whose life-long dream was to become a stand-up comedian. So he quits his job and tries his luck at comedy only to fail miserably. Unable to support his pregnant wife, Jeannie, Jack agrees to help two criminals who are planning to rob the chemical factory where he used to work. However, during the planning of the crime, he is informed by the police that his wife died in an accident. Grief-ridden, he tries to back out of the heist, but his partners threaten and force him to continue with the plan. Because Jack is the inside man for the job, he is forced to take on the Red Hood persona. This leads to the appearance that he is the leader of the criminal outfit, thereby allowing the real leaders to escape if need be. As they enter the plant, the gang is caught by security guards, and the two ringleaders are killed in a shoot out. Batman then arrives on the scene and confronts Jack. While trying to escape, Jack jumps over the rail and into a vat of chemicals. He resurfaces in a Gotham reservoir, and upon doing so, he discovers that his skin is chalk white, his hear is bright green, and his lips are now ruby red. This causes him to have a mental break and go insane €“ thus the birth of the Joker. *NOTE: Although Moore never names the Joker, in Batman: Gotham Knights #50-55 it€™s revealed that his version of the Joker is named Jack.

4. Batman: Black & White Vol. 2 (2002)

Written my Paul Dini (one of the creative talents behind Batman: The Animated Series) with art by Alex Ross, Batman: Black & White Vol. 2 (2002) provides a very concise noir style origin for the Joker with a unique twist. After the Joker is once again recaptured and returned to Arkham Asylum, one of his doctors expresses his frustration with the Joker€™s lack of progress, as he is unable to cure the Joker€™s psychosis. Another doctor tells of an anonymous un-filed report that was written years ago that he discovered, which proposes that the reason the Joker cannot be cured is because he is, in fact, not truly insane. This report recounts interviews of other mobsters who interacted with the Joker before he became the Clown Prince of Crime. Apparently, the Joker was a smart and cunning mobster, who worked for various different crews under various different names. After the Joker deposed Gotham€™s most powerful crime boss, he became Gotham€™s kingpin of crime, forcing others to do his dirty work for him. The police were never able to bring charges against him. https://youtu.be/k67SxiNzmis Eventually, he grew to miss the thrill of his early days and decided to get back in the game, creating the Red Hood disguise to mask his identity. One night when pulling a heist on a chemical factory, he€™s confronted by Batman. Knowing that there was no other way out, the Joker dives into vat of chemicals, swims through the waste, and escapes down into the river, thereby changing his appearance. The report hypothesizes that upon marring his face, the Joker became more rational. Given a new mission born out of trauma similar to the Batman€™s origin, the Joker also adopted a fearsome persona allowing him to carry out a very calculated campaign of revenge against Gotham and Batman. Essentially, the Joker wears the mask of madness like Batman wears the cape and cowl. While initially convinced by the report, the doctors suddenly discover that Dr Harleen Quinzel wrote it before she became Harley Quinn. It was then discarded, as it would never stand up in a court of law. This particular story is different than many of the other countless Joker origins, as it posits that the Joker is not really crazy. Plus Paul Dini's masterful story is accompanied by some amazing artwork by Alex Ross. Batman: Black & White was a compilation of Batman stories that eventually was turned into a motion comic. Check the video above for Ross and Dini's story.

3. Batman: Lovers & Madmen (2007)

Originally published in Batman Confidential #7-12, Batman: Lovers and Madmen (2007) provided an modernized Joker origin Written by Michael Green with art by Denys Cowan. Although there has been some debate about whether or not Batman Confidential was considered canon, the argument has become moot considering DC's current approach to continuity where everything counts. Plus the Joker's origin has always been an evolving tale; therefore, some divergence is to be expected. The story begins with a guy by the name of Jack sitting in a bar, regaling the local bar wench, Leena, with his sorrows. Jack is supposedly depressed because his job is unexciting and unfulfilling. He tells Leena that he works as a securities broker when really he€™s a bank robber. Turns out that Jack is board with life because he€™s just too good at pulling bank heists. Later that night, while Jack and his crew are robbing a bank, he meets the Batman for the first time and suddenly feels alive again. The Joker then plans another heist with the intention of attracting the attention of Batman. This time Jack decides to raid a costume charity ball, and Batman confronts him. During their scuffle, Jack wounds Batman€™s then girlfriend, Lorna Shore, and Batman throws a batarang, scarring Jack's face.
Jack escapes and is then captured by a rival gang and is brought to a pharmaceutical plant to be tortured. After bringing his girlfriend to the hospital, Batman discovers that Jack is at the pharmaceutical plant and runs to find him there. Meanwhile, Jack escapes his restraints and begins to fight his captors. Batman arrives in time to see a giant vat of antidepressant chemicals fall all over Jack, sweeping him down a drainpipe and out of the plant. When he comes through, Jack€™s skin is white and hair is green. The following day, Jack blows up a blimp over Gotham that is filled with Joker Gas, poisoning the population. Batman confronts and captures him. As an interesting twist, in this particular origin the Joker does not name himself. Rather, at the end of the book, Gordon mentions that the press has given Jack the name the Joker. What makes this particular story unique is that it was written with Christoper Nolan's The Dark Knight in mind. The Joker in this tale is supposed to be similar to the version Heath Ledger plays in the film. It also is the first origin to highlight the scarring around the Joker's mouth, making it even more closely linked to The Dark Knight film.

2. The New 52: Zero Year (2014)

When DC rebooted their universe in 2011, they reset Batman€™s continuity altogether, allowing writer Scott Synder to retell Batman€™s earliest day in a story called Zero Year. And although Zero Year focused on the Riddler as the main Bat villain, the first arc in this three part tale retold the story of the Red Hood Gang. This incarnation of the Red Hood Gang is comprised of blackmailed Gotham citizens under the leadership of Red Hood One. Though it was never confirmed, it was heavily implied that Red Hood One is the individual who would become the Joker €“ especially since he was the individual who fell into a vat of chemicals after a fistfight with Batman. It's kinda become the Joker's MO. Elsewhere in Synder€™s run, specifically his Death Of The Family arc, Batman mentions a possible origin for the man behind the Red Hood €“ that he was raised by a murderous, abusive woman named Aunt Eunice.
This origin is later explored in Batman #23.1 €“ the Joker€™s villain month issue. Written by Andy Kubert with Andy Clarke on pencils, this issue tells the story of the Joker raising his pet monkey, Jackanapes. Here scenes from the Joker€™s unhappy childhood are interspersed throughout the issue as flashbacks. When the Joker was a small child, his Aunt Eunice would starve and beat him. One day, when the child Joker was hiding behind a wall, his Aunt Eunice came at him with a hammer. She knocked the wall down, dragged him the sink, and scrubbed his skin white with bleach. While this issue contradicts the aforementioned Red Hood origin, Batman does note that the Joker is prone to changing his origin. Therefore, the Joker is known for being an unreliable narrator, hence casting doubtful shadows on the Aunt Eunice origin. These conflicting stories also set the stage for Synder's next big Joker story: Endgame.

1. Batman: Endgame (2015)

Following up on Batman: Zero Year, Scott Synder€™s Batman: Endgame story deals directly with the issue of the Joker€™s origin, as it plays with the idea that the Joker's back-story is a compilation of ever-evolving narratives. Having miraculously returned from the grave with this face in tact (read Death Of The Family for more details), the Joker reveals to Batman that he knows his secret identity and he plans on ending their long-term relationship. The Joker then releases a new version of the Joker toxin, an "incurable" air-born pathogen that spreads across Gotham turning everyone into crazy Joker zombies. Later, Jim Gordon discovers pictures of the Joker dating back to decades before the Joker€™s first appearance. The Joker shows up and attacks Gordon, who in turn shoots the Joker in the head. Although the bullet should have killed him, the Joker remains unharmed, revealing that the character now somehow has regenerative capabilities. Throughout the story, the Joker€™s origin is called into question, as each issue has a backup story that provides a different account of how the Joker came to be. Essentially, the Joker is now claiming that he is immortal and has been around forever.
Eventually, Batman deduces that the Joker is using a serum called Dionesum for his regenerative properties. And with the help of Julia Pennyworth, Batman discovers that the new Joker toxin is the inverse of that serum; however, in order to cure the city, he must obtain a sample of Dionesum. The story ends with Batman and the Joker fighting in the caves underneath Gotham, where the Joker found the original source of the Dionesum. As the cave collapses on the two of them, Batman clings to the Joker and reveals that his plan has failed, as Julia has created an anecdote to the new toxin. The cave crumbles, burying both Batman and the Joker. Needless to say, Endgame was a controversial addition to the Joker mythos. Synder has written a unique story that only adds to the mystery of the Joker's origin, leaving the question of the Joker's immortality unresolved. With various competing narratives, this postmodern take on the Joker calls into question everything that has been established about the Clown Prince of Crime.