X-Men: 5 Best And 5 Worst Writers

By Percival Constantine /

Created in 1963 by Stan Lee and Jack Kirby, the X-Men form the third point on the Marvel Universe€™s holy trinity of superhero teams. But the X-Men were different. Unlike the Avengers and the Fantastic Four, the X-Men were teenagers at first and despite saving the world countless times over, the fact that they were mutants made them outcasts, hated and feared by the very people they were sworn to protect. These days, it€™s hard to imagine that the X-Men were ever unpopular, but in the beginning, the title was plagued by poor sales and was constantly under threat of cancellation. Eventually though, fortune turned and the X-Men skyrocketed from one of Marvel€™s lowest-selling books to one of the most popular comics ever. And that success has translated to other mainstream success, with cartoons, video games, and, of course, the popular series of live-action films. It€™s not hard to see the popularity of the X-Men. Outcasts from society, they provide a form of escapism that many people can relate to, particularly unpopular nerdy kids, like yours truly was once upon a time. The X-Men may not have been the first comic I ever read, but it was the first that really spoke to me on a personal level, and I€™ve been a fan ever since, through the good and the bad. And there has been a lot of good and bad. Over the years, the X-Men have been handed over to some extremely talented comic book writers and others who€weren€™t as talented. For now, let€™s take a look at the best of the X-Men writers and also the worst that left fans wondering just what Marvel was thinking. We€™ll start off with the good.

The Best

5. Fabian Nicieza

Advertisement
The 90s are generally regarded as a low point for the X-Men, and it€™s hard to argue with that. During a time when the X-Men animated series was widely successful, the comics themselves were a bit less so, plagued by annual crossovers and some really confusing ideas. But despite all of that, Fabian Nicieza€™s run on the comics, spanning from X-Men #12-45, is something of a diamond in the rough. For instance, if you€™re a fan of Gambit, you probably have Nicieza to thank. While he was created by Chris Claremont and Jim Lee, the character didn€™t really get much development until Nicieza came around. And it was something he would expand when Gambit received his own ongoing series, written by Nicieza for issues #1-24. And if you like the matching of Gambit and Rogue, again that€™s Nicieza to thank. Seeds for it were sown before he came onboard, but Nicieza really developed the bulk of their relationship and wrote some of the best stories between them. Outside of the X-Men, Nicieza was also the scripter for Rob Liefeld€™s X-Force run, and when Liefeld departed Marvel, Nicieza took the reins of the book, bringing it closer to the New Mutants title that preceded it. A lot of the initial character work on Cable and Deadpool also came from Nicieza, and later he got a chance to write them together in the highly entertaining Cable & Deadpool series.

4. Mike Carey

Advertisement
The less said about House of M and Decimation, a contrived story that reduced the mutant population to 198, the better. But fortunately something good came out of it€”namely Mike Carey€™s run on X-Men beginning in issue #188. Carey formed a truly unique team, a strike force hand-picked by Rogue, and whom she chose was a very interesting mix. You had veteran characters like Iceman, Cannonball and Cable. And in addition to that, there were some very offbeat picks, like Omega Sentinel, a former police officer whose body was altered with Sentinel technology and villains Sabretooth, Mystique, and Lady Mastermind. Such an offbeat team shouldn€™t have worked, but it worked very well for this book. Carey brought some much-needed development to woefully underdeveloped characters like Lady Mastermind and Omega Sentinel, and he introduced fascinating new villains like Pandemic and the Children of the Vault. In addition, he managed to use other concepts from X-Men history, such as the Mummudrai from Grant Morrison€™s run and new twists on familiar characters like Mr. Sinister and the Marauders and Exodus leading a new group of Acolytes. Following the excellent Messiah CompleX crossover (really the best one the X-Men had been involved in for a very long time), Carey€™s title was retitled X-Men: Legacy as of issue #208. In Messiah CompleX, Professor Xavier was shot in the head by Bishop and X-Men: Legacy saw him revived from a coma by Exodus and go on a quest to fill in the gaps in his memory. Issue #226 changed the focus to Rogue. Carey addressed numerous dangling plotlines in X-Men continuity, while providing some of the best characterization of characters like Professor X, Rogue, and Gambit.

3. Jason Aaron

Jason Aaron broke into comics after he won a Marvel talent search contest with an eight-page Wolverine story. He went on to write an acclaimed Wolverine story, €œGet Mystique,€ in Wolverine #62-65, and then followed this with a new Wolverine spin-off book, Wolverine: Weapon X and then became the writer of the relaunched Wolverine series. But X-Men: Schism is when he started directing his talents towards the team as a whole. Up until Schism, the remaining mutant population had been living on the remains of Asteroid M, called Utopia, in order to avoid the persecution of the government and Norman Osborn, who had become the Director of SHIELD and renamed it HAMMER (don€™t ask€seriously). Then a rift between Cyclops and Wolverine over what the X-Men€™s role should be led to a split. While Cyclops and his so-called Extinction Team remained on Utopia, Wolverine and a number of X-Men and students returned to New York and reopened the X-Mansion, this time called the Jean Grey School for Higher Learning. Aaron showcases this team currently in the pages of Wolverine and the X-Men, and at twenty-seven issues, it may seem a bit premature to label him one of the best. But his work so far has been characterized by being fresh, yet still honoring the classics. Aaron already proved how well he understood Wolverine, but he€™s also managed to write intriguing versions of the Beast, Kitty Pryde, Storm, and his takes on the student body, represented by characters like Quentin Quire (a rebellious telepath), Broo (a nerdy version of the vicious Brood alien species), Genesis (a teenage clone of Apocalypse), and Kid Gladiator (hot tempered son of the Shi€™ar character Gladiator). And if recent issues are any indication, Aaron has some interesting things in mind, such as possibly redeeming a terrible villain in the form of Azazel. One only hopes this will also lead to the resurrection of Nightcrawler€

2. Grant Morrison

Following the success of the X-Men movie, Marvel€™s new editor in chief, Joe Quesada, turned his eye to revamping the X-Men. To this end, he hired Grant Morrison, a critically acclaimed writer known for revamping DC€™s Justice League with JLA and also Vertigo titles like The Invisibles. Morrison€™s run began with the renaming of the X-Men title as New X-Men in issue #114 and concluded with issue #154. Morrison€™s run showed that mutants had become more and more common, and mankind was on the path to extinction. It was Morrison who expanded the concept of the school, increasing the student body from just a few students as it had always been in the past to dozens, if not hundreds. The main cast was pared down from recent years to a team of Professor X, Cyclops, Wolverine, Jean Grey, Beast, and Emma Frost. Cyclops, who had just returned to the team after being possessed by Apocalypse (don€™t ask), received the bulk of the character development, something quite unusual at that time. Eschewing the typical villains, Morrison conceived of all-new threats for the X-Men. These included Cassandra Nova, Professor Xavier€™s evil twin, the U-Men, a group of humans who wanted to be mutants so badly that they grafted mutant organs onto their bodies, and Sublime, a sentient bacteria that manipulated events from behind the scenes. One of the best spots of Morrison€™s run was the creation of a new X-Man, a Chinese mutant named Xorn who possessed a star for a brain. In a controversial story, Morrison revealed that Xorn was actually Magneto all along, hiding among the X-Men and biding his time before he struck. The move was so controversial that following Morrison€™s departure, Marvel immediately retconned the story, revealing that Magneto and Xorn were two separate characters (more on that shortly). Almost ten years later, Morrison€™s run still generates headed discussion among X-fans. There are many fans, both new and old, who feel that his run marked a return to greatness for the X-Men, while others felt that he didn€™t understand the characters at all. Throughout the X-Men€™s entire fifty-year history, there is arguably no other writer regarded with as much divided and intense opinion as Morrison.

The Best

1. Chris Claremont

I don€™t think there is a single X-fan who will be surprised by this choice. In the introduction, I said that the X-Men went from a low-selling title to one of Marvel€™s biggest franchises, and that can all be traced to the efforts of one man: Chris Claremont. In 1975, Claremont, who at that time had been a young writer fresh out of college, was quite enthusiastic about the €œAll-New, All-Different€ X-Men team formed by Len Wein and Dave Cockrum in Giant-Size X-Men #1 (marking the introduction of now-classic characters Storm, Wolverine, Nightcrawler, and Colossus). Noting his enthusiasm, Wein gave Claremont the sagging title, because there would be no objections from other writers due to the book€™s poor standing. Claremont€™s approach to the X-Men was nothing short of groundbreaking, not only for that book, but for superhero comics as a whole. His complex plot structures and vivid characterization became a staple of the X-Men and the approach has been mimicked by virtually every comic writer since. While the concept of mutants acting as stand-ins for various minorities was introduced by Stan Lee, it was Claremont who really developed the concept. Religious oppression of minorities took form in the seminal story, God Loves Man Kills (and the basis for the movie X2). He created the African nation of Genosha to act as an allegory for both slavery and apartheid. Claremont even looked to popular films at the time as a basis for many stories, such as Star Wars serving as inspiration for the Phoenix Saga and Alien inspiring the creation of the alien race called the Brood. Although Claremont didn€™t create all the X-Men, he developed them into their recognized forms. He also created scores of new characters. Famous X-Men characters Kitty Pryde, Rogue, Gambit, Emma Frost, Psylocke, Jubilee, Mystique, Sabretooth, and many, many more all sprung from Claremont€™s mind. Over the course of his seventeen-year run, Claremont took the X-Men through numerous incarnations and different takes, with an ever-changing roster of colorful characters. Many cite Claremont€™s seminal run with artist and co-plotter John Byrne as being the definitive period for the X-Men, a collaboration that brought two of the greatest X-Men stories ever, €œThe Dark Phoenix Saga€ and €œDays of Future Past€ (soon to be adapted as a movie). But that run only lasted for around four years, whereas Claremont remained as writer for close to two decades. He helped turn the X-Men into a franchise, writing initial spin-off books like The New Mutants, Wolverine, and Excalibur. Now that we€™ve looked at the best, it€™s time to have a look at the worst€

The Worst

5. Scott Lobdell

In the early 90s, Jim Lee and Whilce Portacio were providing the stories for Uncanny X-Men and veteran X-Men creator John Byrne contributed scripting. Byrne famously called it one of the worst working situations and he was soon replaced by a new writer named Scott Lobdell. Beginning with issue #289, Lobdell became the sole writer on the book. When people talk about the 90s being a dark time for the X-Men, they€™re mostly referring to Lobdell€™s run that went until issue #349. Following Nicieza€™s departure from X-Men, Lobdell also wrote or plotted many of the issues spanning from #46-69. When X-Men, the second core book, was launched, the concept was that both would feature a different squad: X-Men would be the Blue Team led by Cyclops and Uncanny X-Men featured Storm€™s Gold Team. But during the period when Lobdell was writing both books, the two teams bled together and there were something like fifteen different characters being used in both books. This was the era when Cyclops really developed the stigma of being either Jean€™s husband or Xavier€™s lapdog, and that€™s thanks to Lobdell€™s writing. Gambit and Rogue€™s romance, intriguing under Nicieza, became positively irritating under Lobdell (largely thanks to his terrible use of accents). Another story saw Psylocke gutted by Sabretooth, and Wolverine and Archangel retrieved a magical liquid called the Ebon Vein from the Crimson Dawn dimension to save her life. This marked her with a red tattoo over one eye and she gained the ability to teleport through shadows. Because evidently, Psylocke€™s backstory wasn€™t confusing enough. Cannonball, who€™d been shown as a capable leader and hero in X-Force, €œgraduated€ to the X-Men and Lobdell quickly turned him into an €œaw shucks€ rookie character. And the new characters were some of the worst. We had Maggott, an Australian who spoke with an overblown accent, whose powers were two large slug-like creatures that consisted of his digestive system. Marrow, a former villain and Wolverine wannabe. And Joseph, who appeared to be Magneto, but de-aged and amnesiac and walking around with long hair (he was later revealed to be a clone after Lobdell left the books). Lobdell had some good moments. His €œtaking a break€ issues that featured character-oriented stories were generally pretty good, as was his run on the X-Men spin-off title, Generation X. But his plotting was quite bad, enough to earn him a spot on this list.

4. Stan Lee

Advertisement
I can already hear the gasps. Yes, Stan Lee, the man who created the X-Men, was also one of the X-Men€™s worst writers. As I mentioned before, Lee may have created the idea of mutants as an allegory for minorities, but he didn€™t do very much with this. His run only lasted for the first nineteen issues of the book€™s history, and although he created Magneto, the character was extremely underdeveloped by him. In the early issues of the X-Men, Magneto was not the tragic character he€™s come to be regarded as, but rather a stereotypical comic book supervillain. Even his history of being a Holocaust survivor and an old friend of Professor X came from Claremont. The entire period was extremely unremarkable. Despite the introduction of Magneto, the Brotherhood of Evil Mutants, the Sentinels and the Juggernaut, most of the X-Men€™s foes were easily forgettable mutant criminals and alien invaders. Even among X-fans, this era isn€™t regarded with any particular fondness. Towards the end of Lee€™s Silver Age Renaissance, some of his later concepts didn€™t really get the same attention he devoted to the Fantastic Four and Spider-Man. And some of those, like the X-Men and Daredevil, suffered as a result. Although Lee did create some famous characters, they were fairly one-dimensional under his pen. The work of developing these characters mostly fell to future writers, particularly Claremont.

3. Matt Fraction

Advertisement
After Ed Brubaker€™s brief run on Uncanny X-Men, he was succeeded by Matt Fraction, his co-writer on The Immortal Iron Fist. At first glance, this might seem like a good idea. Fraction€™s creator-owned work prior to Marvel included an excellent little series called Rex Mantooth: Kung Fu Gorilla and at Marvel, his work on Iron Fist as well as The Invincible Iron Man and The Order showed he had a knack for writing entertaining stories. Unfortunately, that didn€™t translate so well to the X-Men. Fraction had an affinity for cringe-worthy captions introducing the characters and their powers in each issue, and trying hard to come off as hip or amusing. Here are a few examples: €œXi€™an Coy Mahn - Karma. Psychic possession. Wasn€™t crazy for the wrap-up of Battlestar.€ €œDr. Henry McCoy - The Beast. Beastly. Intellectual.€ €œDr. Kavita Rao. Human. Mutant geneticist. Superb dancer of tangos.€ €œWarren Worthing III - Angel. Wings; wealth. Turn ons: Betsy Braddock. Turn offs: science.€ €œBobby Drake - Iceman. Man of ice. Brutal three-point shooter.€ €œDr. Nemesis. PhD in nemesising.€ €œFantomex. Watched Danger: Diabolik one too many times. Currently flying his symbiotic ship.€ €œAlison Blaire - Dazzler. One who dazzles. Pop star!€ €œMegan Gwynn - Pixie. Teleportation, flight, stabby, Welsh.€ And this isn€™t including the running gag about Cyclops and his damn jetpack. Fraction ballooned the cast to include just about every X-Man ever. The dialogue was painfully hip and sardonic, sacrificing characterization in favor of supposed wit. The only real characterization was of Cyclops, and it was basically regressing the character, throwing out all the great development he underwent in recent years and just turning him into a total dick. While Brian Michael Bendis has been doing a great job with the whole Dark Cyclops thing, it had some extremely poor development by Fraction.

2. Chris Claremont

Advertisement
Whoa, what? The guy listed as the best X-Men writer is also one of the worst? No, I didn€™t accidentally include his name twice. And no, I€™m not crazy. Chris Claremont was the greatest X-Men writer ever. But in 1991, after he and artist Jim Lee launched a new X-Men book just titled X-Men, Claremont only managed to write three issues before leaving. At that time at Marvel, there was much more focus on the artists, and Claremont frequently clashed with the editors and Jim Lee. Then in 2000, Claremont was invited to take over the two core X-books, Uncanny X-Men and X-Men. There was a lot of fanfare behind this and many fans, including me, were quite excited. Initial interviews and news about the books seemed very positive. Throughout the 90s, the X-Men were almost in a state of perpetual sameness. Two separate teams of X-Men, one led by Rogue and the other led by Gambit, and an assortment of new villains. It seemed like the return of Claremont would mark a return to greatness. Instead it was more like a return to mediocrity. Claremont€™s second run on the X-Men was one of the worst periods for Marvel€™s mutants. He seemingly paid only the barest attention to continuity that happened after he left the book, and it showed in his writing. The villains seemed interesting on paper, but were mostly forgettable. Reportedly, Claremont had a lot of difficulty dealing with then-editor in chief Bob Harras, so when Harras was replaced by Joe Quesada, it was a positive sign for X-fans, and it did indeed give us Grant Morrison€™s X-Men run. Quesada also gave Claremont his own X-title, called X-Treme X-Men featuring Storm, Rogue, Thunderbird, Psylocke, Sage, and Bishop, with Gambit and Cannonball later joining. And the book was every bit as bad as the title. Cornball dialogue littered the pages, and there was an overuse of mind control as a plot device. This then continued when, following Morrison€™s departure, X-Treme X-Men was cancelled and Claremont returned to Uncanny X-Men. Claremont did get a chance to redeem himself later when he started writing X-Men Forever, a series free of continuity and picking up exactly where he left off with X-Men #3 all those years ago. This series was far more entertaining, but it wasn€™t enough to make up for the period of time when he was tarnishing the very franchise he helped build. How bad was it? Well, the only reason Claremont is not ranked #1 on both the best and worst lists is because there was someone else who did a far worse job€

1. Chuck Austen

While Morrison was working over on New X-Men, Marvel hired another writer to take over Uncanny X-Men after the departure of Joe Casey. That was Chuck Austen. At first, Austen€™s run was met with a positive response by fans. He focused on a small team of Archangel, Iceman, Nightcrawler, Wolverine and new character Stacy X. He reformed the Juggernaut, bringing Professor X€™s step-brother and frequent X-Men enemy onto the team. And Alpha Flight€™s Northstar, who is gay, also joined. Did I mention he€™s gay? Because that€™s apparently his most important character trait. But despite a decent opening arc, things quickly went downhill. The initial cast grew a lot larger when Austen brought back Havok, who€™d bee in an alternate dimension and was in a coma for a while, and being watched over a creepy nurse named Annie (who despite her bizarre Florence Nightingale thing, was invited to join the school€™s staff). He also brought in Polaris, Havok€™s psychotic ex-girlfriend who had never been psychotic before. And Husk from Generation X, who went from being a strong, intelligent character to an X-Men groupie who begins a relationship with the much-older Archangel. They even have mid-air sex. In front of her mother. I wish that were a joke. And Jubilee joins the team, but she never does anything more than stand in the background and marvel at the size of Nightcrawler€™s penis. Again, I wish that were a joke. Characters were written terribly. In Chuck Austen€™s world, women are all sex-crazed nymphomaniacs. They jump into the sack for the smallest of reasons. Everyone€™s always sniping at each other for absolutely no good reason. Iceman went from being the team comedian to consummate whiner. And the stories€oh benevolent spirit of Dave Cockrum, patron saint of X-fans, give me strength€ First we€™ve got the Church of Humanity and their plan to destroy the Catholic church with Nightcrawler as the pope and exploding communion wafers. We also got Nightcrawler€™s origin. Apparently, he€™s the son of Azazel, who also happens to be Satan€or something. Azazel is trapped in another dimension and he needs his children (who can all teleport) to open a portal to free him from the dimension he€™s trapped in. The very same dimension he leaves to father these children. Does your head hurt yet? Because it€™s going to get worse. After Morrison€™s departure, the retcon I mentioned about Xorn and Magneto was handled by Austen. He revealed that Magneto was not Xorn, but rather Xorn was Xorn, and somehow could make himself look like Magneto. You see, Xorn posed as Magneto, posing as Xorn, because€evil? And the X-Men found out about this thanks to a convenient explanation from Xorn€™s twin brother. Who also has the same powers. And Xorn II knew about this because€twins? I don€™t even freaking know any more. There are no words to describe how horrible Chuck Austen€™s run on the X-Men was. I€™d say this is what you€™d expect from a brain-damaged ten-year-old fanfic writer, but that would be an insult to brain-damaged ten-year-old fanfic writers. It€™s just€wow. You sit there reading this, and you wonder just what sort of blackmail material Austen had on his editors. Oh, and by the way, Northstar is gay. Just in case you forgot.