10 Actors Who Still Haven't Outdone Their Debut Performances

Quite the impression.

By Audrey Fox /

There's a reason we have that old expression, "beginner's luck." But ideally, it applies to more mundane things - like getting a bullseye the first time you throw a dart, or winning at blackjack the first time you've ever gambled. We like to think that acting success is something that comes to those who have paid their dues and worked steadily up to the point of starring in a film, which then becomes critically acclaimed. But the truth is, sometimes it's all about being in the right place at the right time, and having a little bit of raw talent. Typically unknowns don't get cast in major roles, but when they do they're just as likely to find success as the old veterans. But there can be a downside to getting that perfect role right out of the gate. What happens when you can't top it? When you spend the rest of your career trying to live up to that fantastic, once-in-a-lifetime performance? Well, some of the actors here have faded away, the one hit wonders of acting. Others are truly amazing actors who have been let down by their material, seemingly unable to find another project that showcased their abilities properly. But for whatever reason, they still haven't managed to outperform the movie that got them their SAG card...

10. Sharlto Copley - District 9

Neill Blomkamp burst onto the scene with 2009's surprise hit District 9, and he brought star Sharlto Copley along with him. For a virtually unknown actor, Copley gave us a powerhouse performance as the timid office worker infected with a substance that saw him transforming into the species of alien that faced tremendous prejudice in this universe. His work is incredibly layered, with a gradual, detailed transformation that flows effortlessly throughout the film. The end product of the character is almost unrecognizable from where he began, and the credit for that has to go to Copley. Since District 9, he's done a string of mediocre films, none of which really capitalized on the level of performance he's capable of as evidenced by his debut film. There's still hope, though. Elysium may have disappointed audiences and gone in a weird direction with Copley and fellow costar Jodie Foster, but both actor and director are getting another shot at capturing the magic of District 9 with Chappie, due to hit theaters next year. It stars Copley as a robot adopted into a dysfunctional family of criminals, and will hopefully be just as fantastic as it sounds.

9. Jamie Bell - Billy Elliot

Billy Elliot is just one of those roles that an actor will never be able to escape. Jamie Bell played the dancing Northerner when he was only fourteen years old, and even now, when he's a strapping young man in his late 20s and married to Evan Rachel Wood, you can't help but think of Billy. The film was a smash hit back in 1999, with audiences falling in love with the young lad. It spawned a musical that had both a successful run on Broadway and the West End (the London production is still going strong). But the biggest draw for the film, and what makes the role so remarkable, is the sheer amount of talent required to play Billy Elliot. They had to find a kid who not only had enough acting skill and screen presence to carry a film on this scale, but also had the dance training to believably portray a child prodigy. Jamie Bell did all of that and more. He's managed to have a pretty consistent career as he transitioned into adulthood (he's currently starring in the Revolutionary War drama Turn on AMC), but at this point none of his roles have had the impact of Billy Elliot.

8. Alan Rickman - Die Hard

It's crazy to think that Hans Gruber, one of the film's greatest ever bad guys, was Alan Rickman's first film role. And he probably wouldn't appreciate us saying this, but although he's had many stellar performances throughout his long and varied career, he's never topped his work in Die Hard. Hans Gruber was an iconic character that dominated every inch of the screen. He was debonair, dangerous, and cool as a cucumber. If it wasn't for the macho charisma that Bruce Willis brought to the film, we all probably would have been rooting for Gruber to win. Sure, Severus Snape is great, but in a weird way, by the time the Harry Potter franchise rolled around, the performance felt a little bit like the same old Alan Rickman that we'd been seeing for quite some time. When he did Die Hard, though, we hadn't seen it yet. It was a fresh, exciting new style of acting that was uniquely his. No matter how good his performances are, you're never going to be able to recreate the magic of the first time we ever saw him.

7. Michael Rooker - Henry: Portrait Of A Serial Killer

You might recognize Michael Rooker as Merle from The Walking Dead, Daryl's older and significantly more racist brother. Indeed, the actor has experienced a bit of a career resurgence thanks to the popular zombie show, with an appearance in the much-awaited Guardians of the Galaxy film due out this summer. But back in the 80s, he was one of those rare creatures who was lucky enough to star in their film debut. Up until 1986, his only screen acting experience had been a bit part in the pilot of the forgotten procedural Crime Story. Then he got to play the eponymous Henry in Henry: The Portrait of a Serial Killer. His chilling portrayal of the real life serial killer Henry Lee Lucas helped catapult the film into cult classic territory, but unfortunately, it didn't do the same for his career. He's continued working steadily, but for some reason film studios have been reluctant to give him the opportunity to show off his considerable acting abilities.

6. Orson Welles - Citizen Kane

It's astounding to think that Citizen Kane, considered by many to be the greatest film ever made, was Orson Welles' directorial and acting debut. After a tremendously well-received production of Julius Caesar on Broadway, Welles caught the attention of Hollywood. The young prodigy of Mercury Theatre, Welles had almost unlimited control over the production during an era when many directors were under the thumb of the studio to which they owed allegiance. His film-making techniques were detailed and groundbreaking, his performance as Charles Foster Kane a towering portrayal of a media magnate from the optimism of youth to the embittered loneliness of old age. Although the film was technologically innovative, it wasn't a box office hit, and Welles was kept on a much tighter leash for all the rest of his films. His creative genius stifled, his later films show flashes of brilliance but suffered from an editing style that went against Welles' vision. It is unfortunately the legacy of Orson Welles that his first film was doomed to be his best, and all that untapped potential would go to waste.

5. Tatum O'Neal - Paper Moon

When you are the youngest ever winner of a competitive Oscar at the age of ten, there's really not a whole lot of things you can do to top that. Cure cancer? Be the youngest person to win two competitive Oscars? Sadly, none of that was in the cards for Tatum O'Neal. After a ground-breaking performance as the newly discovered daughter of a con man (played by her real life father, Ryan O'Neal), nothing would ever really measure up. She was mature beyond her years, with an intuitive acting ability that allowed her to give an emotionally honest performance while most child actors her age are still struggling to spit out their lines. She followed Paper Moon with The Bad News Bears two years later, where she played a talented young pitcher on the verge of puberty who is tempted to reject baseball in favor of more feminine pursuits. While The Bad News Bears is a classic and she does a great job with it, she's in a much smaller role and as such has less to do in terms of acting. Paper Moon, to this day, remains her finest achievement.

4. Tim Curry - Rocky Horror Picture Show

Although Tim Curry had been in a slew of television shows prior to The Rocky Horror Picture Show, Dr Frank-N-Furter was his very first film role. And what a debut. Always known for his quirky performances, Tim Curry as Frank-N-Furter was the ultimate in counterculture decadence. He's a cross-dressing alien from the planet Transsexual in the star system Transylvania, who fancies himself a scientist and is trying to build himself the perfect man. Now, when you say it like that, it sounds ridiculous, but when you actually watch it€well, it's still ridiculous, but in a good way. Tim Curry owns the screen and everyone else is just orbiting around him. It's a role he was born to play, and nothing he's done since then has matched it. You could make an argument that his delightfully mischievous butler in Clue is also worthy of note, and you would have a point. But at the end of the day, his work as Mr Boddy is very good, but his performance as Frank-N-Furter in Rocky Horror Picture Show is iconic.

3. Patrick Fugit - Almost Famous

Patrick Fugit was only a teenager when he was asked to star in Cameron Crowe's most autobiographical project, Almost Famous. This was huge. After all, Crowe hadn't disappointed us with Elizabethtown and We Bought a Zoo yet, and the idea of him recounting his own teenage experiences as a traveling reporter for Rolling Stones was intriguing. But the real trick in this kind of project is finding a young actor who can be surrounding by a troupe of larger than life characters and not fade too much into the background. Fugit nails it. With a combination of curiosity, trepidation, and frustration, he manages to avoid being a spectator, even though his job in the film is to be a spectator. He quietly observes the circus, with all the rock stars and the groupies (sorry, Band Aids), but we can't take our eyes off him. That is a major achievement for a 17-year-old kid in his first real film role, especially considering that he's appearing alongside the likes of Philip Seymour Hoffman, Billy Crudup, and Frances McDormand, who can act circles around other actors even on their worst days.

2. Andrew Garfield - Boy A

The Spider-Man actor has had some great performances and some high profile gigs, but none have matched the raw emotional power of his very first role. Back in 2007, he starred as Jack Burridge in Boy A, the story of a young man introduced to the world after spending a large hunk of his teen years in juvenile detention for the murder of a schoolmate. We are given glimpses of his past throughout the film, although the specific details of the murder are kept purposefully ambiguous. But what becomes immediately clear to us is the innocence and desire to be good that Jack possesses. Garfield plays the role wide-eyed and painfully shy -- it's obvious that he does not believe himself worthy of love or affection. The film forces the audience to struggle with one of life's biggest questions: do people ever really change? And do they deserve a second chance? As it becomes clear to the audience that a clean slate and a quiet life are not in the cards for Jack Burridge, Garfield gives an intimate and vulnerable performance that leaves even the most emotionally hardened viewers shaken up.

1. Brad Dourif - One Flew Over The Cuckoo's Nest

When your very first role is Billy Bibbit in One Flew Over the Cuckoo's Nest, it's almost inevitable that it's going to be the peak of your career. The film was a critical darling, winning the five main Oscar categories (Best Picture, Best Actor, Best Actress, Best Director, and Best Writing) and earning Dourif a nomination for his work. Billy Bibbit was a cripplingly shy patient with a stutter and severe bouts of anxiety and depression. He'd attempted to kill himself more than once, and lived in abject fear of his overbearing mother, a fear which Nurse Ratched uses against him. Dourif plays the character as a man with an incredibly delicate emotional state, but one that wants desperately to be normal. He is the one who is most drawn to Nicholson's McMurphy, who attempts to draw him out of his shell. He even helps Billy secure a fleeting romantic encounter with a girl, although it heads south the next morning when Nurse Ratched finds out. Dourif's portrayal of Billy's newfound confidence, and its swift disappearance upon the mere mention of his mother, is heartbreaking to watch and without a doubt an Oscar-worthy performance. Like this article? Agree or disagree? Let us know in the comments section below.