10 Actors Who Didn't Know They'd Been Cut

Sean Bean had no idea he got the chop from The Two Towers.

By Jack Pooley /

Filmmaking sure is hard, and the decisions that go into creating a final released movie are basically innumerable.

Advertisement

A director has to balance so many interests when finishing their edit, as often results in some actors' contributions being left on the cutting room floor.

Virtually every actor who has ever made it big in Hollywood has suffered through the indignity of being cut out of a movie at least once, especially earlier in their career.

The reasons are myriad - perhaps the part affected the pacing, the acting chemistry wasn't on-point, or the director simply changed their mind about the necessity of the role.

It can be tough for actors to hear that they won't ever get to see their work, but directors and producers can help smooth over any disappointment by letting the actor know beforehand - it's a basic courtesy in the business.

And so these 10 actors couldn't really be blamed for being baffled, flummoxed, upset, and even outraged that their role in these 10 huge movies was cut without their knowledge.

In extreme cases they even ended up attending the movie's premiere expecting to see themselves, only to see first-hand that most if not all of their work was relegated to the cinematic ether...

10. Adrien Brody - The Thin Red Line

In what's surely one of the most infamous instances of an actor having their role "revised" in post-production, Adrien Brody was hired to play protagonist Cpl. Geoffrey Fife in Terrence Malick's war epic The Thin Red Line.

Advertisement

Brody does indeed appear in the final film, though his part is better described as an extended cameo, amounting to little more than a few lines of dialogue.

This is despite Brody spending roughly six months filming a lead actor's role, which Malick ultimately decided to cut the overwhelming majority of during the film's laboured editing process.

But Malick's worst sin? He never told Brody, and so when the actor attended the film's premiere, he finally discovered the truth, that he was only a small fixture due to Malick shifting the focus to the larger ensemble. Brody said of the experience:

"I was so focused and professional, I gave everything to it, and then to not receive everything… in terms of witnessing my own work. It was extremely unpleasant because I'd already begun the press for a film that I wasn't really in. Terry obviously changed the entire concept of the film. I had never experienced anything like that... You know the expression 'Don't believe the hype?' Well, you shouldn't."

Brody clearly resents the experience, and who can blame him? He thought this would be his big Hollywood break, and he instead had to wait another four years until The Pianist made him the youngest Best Actor Oscar winner in history.

Malick has repeated this fast-and-loose treatment of his cast members ever since, but at least nowadays actors are well aware what they're signing up for on a Malick shoot - you might make the cut, you might not.

9. Terry Crews - Terminator Salvation

As forgettable as Terminator Salvation is, keen-eyed viewers might notice a blink-and-you'll-miss-it appearance from Terry Crews as a fallen soldier in John Connor's (Christian Bale) army near the start of the film.

Advertisement

As it turns out, Crews originally had an actual living, breathing role which was cut during the editing process. Crews played Jericho, a Resistance soldier who takes part in an opening Skynet raid at the cost of his life.

Crews has stated that the producers never informed him that his part was being cut, and so he had to discover the truth himself at the film's premiere.

Crews has expressed bitterness about this in the past, particularly that because a single shot of his corpse was left in the film, he was asked by many why he was in the movie at all.

More recently Crews seems to see the funny side of it, though, joking about being the "losingest badass in Hollywood."

8. Robert Pattinson - Vanity Fair

0

Mira Nair's 2004 historical drama Vanity Fair originally cast Robert Pattinson as the older version of Sir Rawdon "Rawdy" Crawley the Younger - the son of Reese Witherspoon's protagonist - but his role ended up being cut from the final film.

Advertisement

Given that this was Pattinson's first major movie gig and he wasn't yet a known quantity, seemingly nobody thought to inform him that his part got the chop, and so when he attended a screening of the film, he was mystified to find his role missing. Pattinson said:

"I'm sitting there going, 'Ummm... really?' No one had told me that I had been cut out."

Pattinson's scenes did later appear on the DVD, but ultimately being cut might've been the best thing to ever happen to him, as the casting director felt so bad about it that he invited Pattinson to audition for Harry Potter and the Goblet of Fire.

Pattinson ended up winning the role of Potter's Cedric Diggory, majorly raising his profile and setting him on a course to land the coveted, star-making part of Edward Cullen in the Twilight franchise a few years later. The rest, as they say, is history.

7. Peter Serafinowicz - Solo: A Star Wars Story

Voice roles may not be as time or effort-consuming as live-action ones for the most part, but that doesn't mean voice actors shouldn't still be treated with basic respect.

Advertisement

Peter Serafinowicz, who voiced Darth Maul in Star Wars: Episode I - The Phantom Menace, was asked to reprise the role for the most recent Solo: A Star Wars Story.

And though Serafinowicz agreed, it was decided in post-production that his voice didn't match up with the one used in the various Star Wars animated series.

As a result, Serafinowicz was replaced with Sam Witwer, who had voiced Maul across the animated series, and said of Serafinowicz's performance:

"I don't want to say that what Serafinowicz was doing was bad. It just didn't sound recognisable as the character from The Phantom Menace nor the character from Clone Wars. It was a totally different thing. They needed people to recognise the voice, so there it is."

The decision is fair enough, except that nobody bothered to tell Serafinowicz, who wasn't invited to the film's premiere and only found out a few days later when he received a production e-mail informing him of the decision. Yikes.

It's especially awful given that the actor was planning to bring his family to the premiere, only to get shut out entirely.

6. Viggo Mortensen - The Purple Rose Of Cairo

The prospect of cutting an actor of Viggo Mortensen's caliber out of any movie just seems silly these days, but back in 1985, the famously scissor-happy Woody Allen thought nothing of it.

Advertisement

Mortensen filmed a small role in Allen's Oscar-nominated The Purple Rose of Cairo, playing a man with a brief speaking role in the movie's Hollywood party scene.

Despite not being given a script, Mortensen got to set and improvised some dialogue during filming that got a laugh from Allen, leaving the actor confident that he'd done a good job.

But sadly Mortensen had a nasty surprise when he went to see the movie with his family:

"Of course the movie comes out the next fall or whatever, and I told my family, 'Friday.' And I'm not in it. I'm not in the credit, nothing."

Mortensen at least laughed about it, while adding that he's been cut from films "a couple times" over the course of his career. Those days are surely behind him now, though.

5. James Caan - The Godfather

If you're thinking that James Caan's role as Sonny Corleone wasn't cut from The Godfather, you'd of course be absolutely right, but Caan's role in the final edit of the movie was nevertheless a rude awakening for the actor.

Advertisement

At the premiere, Caan discovered that his part had been massively downsized during the editing process, estimating that around 45 minutes of Sonny's character work - including his reaction to his father Vito's (Marlon Brando) shooting - was cut out.

An incensed Caan decided to confront producer Robert Evans, reportedly shouting at him at the premiere, "Hey, you cut my whole f**kin' part out."

While Caan's frustration is understandable if the scenes were that good, the final runtime was already 177 minutes, so it may simply have been a utilitarian choice that some of Caan's material had to hit the cutting room floor.

It certainly didn't do the Best Picture Oscar-winning masterpiece any harm, nor Caan who received a well-deserved Best Supporting Actor nomination for his work.

4. Jack Whitehall - Frozen

Jack Whitehall is certainly enjoying a career-high right now, but back in 2013 he was still a rising British comedian with no clout at all in Hollywood.

Advertisement

And so he was thrilled to be cast as the voice of Gothi the Troll Priest in Disney's Frozen, only to attend the premiere and find that the bulk of his role had been cut and he didn't even receive a credit.

Though in Whitehall's stand-up he claims that his entire voiceover role was deleted, this was an exaggeration presumably for comedic effect.

In actual fact three of his lines made it into the final film, though it's reasonable to assume that he was expecting far more of his work to end up in the movie.

All the same, it left Whitehall red-faced when he went to the film's premiere and saw his role - what little of it remained, that is - on the big screen.

Whitehall has spoken about the experience numerous times over the years, even referring to watching the film, which he loves, as an "icy dagger to the heart" because of how his own part turned out.

Thankfully Disney treated him far more charitably on the recent hit film Jungle Cruise.

3. Sue Casey - American Beauty

Sue Casey was an actress best known for appearing as a prominent extra in more than 85 major films and TV shows between 1945 and 2002, including Rear Window, Breakfast at Tiffany's, Paint Your Wagon, and even two Best Picture Oscar winners - An American in Paris and American Beauty.

Advertisement

Well, only sort of in the latter case.

Casey was cast in Sam Mendes' iconic 1999 drama as a woman who ambitious estate agent Carolyn Burnham (Annette Bening) desperately tries to sell a dilapidated house to.

According to Casey she filmed a few scenes with Bening, only to discover to her horror at the premiere that, apart from a brief shot of her walking into the house, she was cut entirely from the movie:

"Nobody told me. I brought my son to the premiere and felt so foolish when I realised they excised our scene."

But the late Casey, a veteran of the industry, was at least pragmatic enough to appreciate the realities of the filmmaking process. "That's show business", she added.

2. Sean Bean - The Lord Of The Rings: The Two Towers

Despite his character Boromir dying at the end of the first Lord of the Rings film, The Fellowship of the Ring, Sean Bean was asked by director Peter Jackson to return to the New Zealand set to shoot a lengthy flashback sequence for the sequel, The Two Towers.

Advertisement

However, when Bean watched the film at the premiere, he discovered that his scenes had been cut out of the theatrical release, without Jackson or any producers telling him so beforehand.

Jackson reportedly felt "absolutely terrible" at cutting Bean's part after he'd gone to the effort of flying from England to New Zealand to film it, though at least restored it in its full glory for the Extended Edition on home video, which is far and away the definitive version of the film in every sense.

These weren't the only feathers Jackson ruffled with his brutal cuts, though - after Christopher Lee learned that his pivotal scenes as Saruman had been cut from the third film, The Return of the King, he decided to boycott the premiere.

1. Sam Benjamin - Justice League

Up and coming British actor Sam Benjamin snagged by far the most exciting and high-profile role of his career when he landed a part in Zack Snyder's original version of Justice League.

Advertisement

Though there have been many rumours over the years that Benjamin was hired to play Green Lantern, we know now that he spent a week shooting a part as a military officer who appears in STAR Labs and gets caught in the middle of the League's battle against a resurrected Superman (Henry Cavill).

However on the day of the film's release, more than a year after shooting wrapped, Benjamin learned from screening reports that his role had been cut amid the film's hectic post-production process, with nobody in the Warner Bros. camp informing him of this fact.

By Benjamin's estimation, he appeared as a background character in 20-30 minutes of the movie which Joss Whedon decided to remove when he took over the troubled project.

There was a happy ending of-sorts, though: Benjamin's role was restored for the recent "Snyder Cut," confirming beyond any doubt that no, he was never playing Green Lantern.

It was a total background part, but at least Benjamin finally got his role and, perhaps most importantly, his credit restored.

Advertisement