10 Awesome Characters Who Deserved Better Death Scenes

By Simon Gallagher /

A good death scene can mean the difference between an Oscar nomination and a massive snub, and it is often the more tragic and emotionally engaging scenes that ensure that films endure beyond their usual shelf life. Does anyone really think My Girl would have been as beautiful or as poignant if little Thomas J hadn't been stung to death before his time? Exactly. And while that reference is probably lost on some, the fact remains that Hollywood and TV writers will consistently play the Death of a Main Character card to sell extra seats or bring in more viewers at key points. That's why the soaps in Britain ritualistically sacrifice many of their most beloved characters at Christmas time under cars, trams and buses to win the busy festive ratings war. But then some beloved or popular characters aren't given that sort of appropriate send off: they are killed in a manner that simply doesn't fit their important to their films or shows, and we're expected to just move on with our lives despite these obvious crimes against story and character. But we won't forget, and we often won't forgive. So, behold - a list of 10 awesome characters who definitely didn't deserve to die so poorly. Needless to say there are SPOILERS during this article - so if you don't want to know which of your favourite characters might now be dead, you might want to look away now. Honourable Mention: Wilson (Castaway) That little ball messed with my heart in ways I've never been able to recapture since. His "death" was a profound and devastating moment from a great film full of tragedy and pathos, but it doesn't really count, since he was a volleyball and probably felt no pain. I hope.

1. Newt

Advertisement
Died In: Alien 3 She's basically the emotional heart of Aliens and her story is perhaps even more important than that of Ripley, as she gives Ripley something extra to live for, and also gives the increasingly androgynous heroine something of her femininity back. And then, at the start of Alien 3, poor little Newt is killed off in one of the most ridiculously unnecessary murders sprees of all time, which also sees fellow Aliens survivors Hicks and Bishop bite the big one in similar, unfair manner before the film has even got going. Alien 3 is a massive mess - the script feels both under and over-cooked, the story is all over the place and it's basically just the limping, idiot brother of the first two films, but that's still not reason enough to just brush three of the most important characters of the entire series under the carpet to get them out of the way.

2. Blake

Died In: MASH Back when MASH was a huge deal, TV deaths just weren't cricket, and the death of Lieutenant Colonel Henry Braymore Blake, M.D. caused some serious waves back in 1975, not least because he was pretty much just dumped as an after-thought after being given an honourable exit earlier in his final episode. When the actor playing Blake - McLean Stevenson - confessed that he wanted to leabe the show, at the height of its success, he was initially scripted to decided to be discharged and sent home, but the show's writers pulled an almighty switcheroo at the last minute, and wrote in a scene that reported that Blake€™s plane has been shot down over the Sea of Japan, leaving no survivors. The scene was all but kept a secret, with the pages being handed over by producers Larry Gelbart and Gene Reynolds just minutes before filming, to keep everyone (except Alan Alda) in the dark and thus inspire authentic reactions from the cast, who duly obliged. But regardless of the scene's impact, the off-screen death of a character as major as Blake was a betrayal of the character.

Advertisement

3. This Guy

Advertisement
Died In: Total Recall Okay, so maybe he's not quite an awesome character, but the random guy who was enjoying his day riding elevators in Total Recall's dystopian future right up until the moment he was brutally murdered at the hands of Quaid's foes deserves a mention not just for the matter of fact bluntness of his demise, but also for what happens after it. Not content with allowing him to die, Quaid then holds his body up as a human shield, in a really classy move, and allows his corpse to be further riddled with bullets. Real hero behaviour that... http://youtu.be/sdvelKhWLTc

4. Cyclops

Died In: X-Men: The Last Stand How do you ensure that the audience's affections aren't split between two potential leader-types in one film? Easy, you get rid of one of the characters to make way for the other taking all focus and becoming the new heart of the matter. But you should at least give the departing hero some kind of momentous death scene - like Willem Dafoe's in Platoon - to celebrate his importance to the story. But not in The Last Stand, which features the almost immediate and off-screen death of Cyclops, who apparently explodes at the hands and over-zealous lips of Jean Grey, having spent the last few months tormented by her death. We don't even get to see him die a tragic lover's death, and the X-Men are rather unceremoniously robbed of their leader after just half an hour of him moping about. Not cool.

Advertisement

5. Dobby

Advertisement
Died In: Harry Potter & The Deathly Hallows All three of Dumbledore, Sirius Black and Snape died for emotional impact in the Harry Potter series, and their deaths had genuine and important reasons in terms of the franchise's continuing narrative, and in particular their effects on Harry. Other characters, meanwhile died because, like, war is bad - Fred Weasley(it should have been Ron), Tonks and Lupin - and they serve their own purposes for that very reason. But there is absolutely no need to kill Dobby at all - and especially not in the manner it is done. Recently freed and made a hero by his successful attempts to free Harry and his fellow captives from the Malfoys' dungeon, Dobby cruelly dies thanks to the flying blade of Bellatrix Lestrange, taking his last breath in Harry's arms mere seconds from freedom. Killing the little house elf was just one step too far for the kill-happy author who had also needlessly killed Hedwig earlier in the same film. JK Rowling, you utter cow.

6. Maggie

Died In: Million Dollar Baby It isn't so much the fact that she dies - that would have been a fitting and dramatic end to the story, it's more the nature of her death, which feels like something out of a Shakespearean tragedy that poor Maggie definitely didn't deserve. This was supposed to be an empowering, feminist movie about equality and women being just as tough as men, but instead it ended up being some sort of skewed parable about the woman who didn't know her place and was forced to perish paralysed, with bed-sores and an amputated leg to boot. Christ! Had it been a film about a kid from a deprived community, or some similarly difficult social background, the film would have ended in triumph (or in the odd triumph that came with Rocky's end) - but not for Maggie, who ends up euthanised by her coach and manager in a pretty heart-breaking scene. By then she has earned her death, because of the awful things her life has dragged her through, but it doesn't mean she deserves it at all.

Advertisement
7. Captain James T Kirk

Advertisement
Died In: Star Trek Generations The greatest hero in Star Fleet history, killed in the line of duty helping a fellow captain to basically save the world. A fitting end to Kirk's story, some might say, but others would very vocally disagree, given the manner of Kirk's death. Originally, he was set to be shot in the back - somewhat fitting for Malcolm McDowell's villain - but that was scrapped in favour of something far more fitting for the captain. He would be given the auspicious hero's death of having a great big bridge dropped on him, after a brief, exhilarating slide down a mountain side. There has to have been a better way of sending the great captain off, especially since Generations was supposed to be a celebratory opportunity to say a final goodbye to Kirk's reign and herald in the TNG cast for their run of movies. But no, Kirk wasn't killed in hand to hand combat with God, or by the ravaging hand of venereal disease, as he should have been - he went out with a whimper and a slight smudge of ketchup on his chin... http://youtu.be/y8_oqgPwHfI

8. Chef

Died In: South Park Here's how the late great Isaac Hayes' acrimonious departure from South Park went down, in simplified form: South Park criticises Scientology, Hayes gets mad and quits, South Park respond by criticisng Scientology even more, turning Chef into a child molester and killing him. In a fairly obvious critical stab at Scientology, the season 10 premiere of South Park - called "The Return of Chef" - featured the rotund food dispenser joining a cult called the Super Adventure Club, which brainwashed him and turned him into a child molester, using their religion as a flimsy explanation for their criminal activities. Though the South Park boys attempt to rescue him, Chef eventually chooses to stay with the cult, but falls from a rope bridge that is struck by lightning, impales himself on a tree and is then torn apart by a bear and a mountain lion. Talk about overkill. But despite the terrible nature of his death, Matt Stone and Trey Parker eulogised their departed hero with another open and provocative criticism of his chosen religion. At Chef's funeral, Kyle reads a eulogy that contains the following line:
"We shouldn't be mad at Chef for leaving us, we should be mad at that fruity little club for scrambling his brains."

9. Charlie Sheen

Died In: Two And A Half Men Back in 2011, Charlie Sheen caused the heads of Two and A Half Men some serious problems by just generally having a massive melt-down in front of everyone in the world, criticising show head Chuck Lorre and failing to make his way successfully through rehab at least twice. Eventually he was sacked, amidst claims that he felt he was underpaid at more than $1.2million per episode and replaced by Ashton Kutcher, before having an even more public melt-down involving tiger blood and claims he was from Mars or something and then eventually apologising to everyone involved in his former show. So, how did Lorre and co deal with their absent former star? Naturally, by running him over with a train off-screen in Paris, and having him return briefly as a ghost consigned to Hell and damned to live forever as a woman (Kathy Bates) with a pair of testicles. Now, Sheen probably did deserve to be kicked off the show for his behaviour, but Charlie didn't deserve to be killed off screen in such a manner - he was an anchor of that programme, and though Kutcher has proved to be a shrewd replacement - it would have been nice for a door to have been left open for a possible Charlie return.

10. Joe Black Dude

Died In: Meet Joe Black Another broad application of the term "awesome characters," but the original spiritual host of Brad Pitt's body in creepy sort-of-necrophiliac romance story Meet Joe Black was unfeasibly good-looking, and that's what counts in Hollywood. He definitely didn't deserve to be tossed about by a couple of cars like a rag-doll simply for a little bit of disposable dramatic impact. His only crime was to fall immediately in love, and be stupid enough to walk backwards in the middle of a busy road wistfully imagining where his future might be taking him with his new potential love in tow. Such a bright future, and then kablammo - good night! I mean, come on now, does ANYONE deserve this sort of death? http://youtu.be/VDdN_b6TjYo What do you think? Did we miss any of the death scenes you think weren't suited to their victims? Share your thoughts below.