10 Awesome Examples Of Overacting

By Shaun Munro /

Overacting is a typically pejorative term to describe an actor's performance that is loud and overblown, entirely at odds with the other performers in the scene. This creates one of two effects - the actor is ridiculed for failing to have a grasp on the tone of the scene and what is demanded of them, or it creates comic gold and actually manages to enhance what we're watching. Pulpier films tend to get away with this better than most; often there are delights to be found in talented actors taking it easy and just having fun with a role, while it's "worthier" films that tend to be mocked for an actor's misappropriated performance. At its best, it can elevate a film's entertainment factor, and at its worst, it can make it impossible to take a film seriously. Here are 10 awesome examples of overacting...

10. Gary Oldman - Leon

Gary Oldman is a supremely talented actor who finally got a long-overdue Oscar nomination last year for Tinker Tailor Soldier Spy. However, my favourite Oldman performance - perhaps even more so than his work as Jim Gordon in the Dark Knight trilogy - is as the psychotic corrupt cop Stansfield in Luc Besson's thrilling action flick Leon. This is Oldman at his most unrestrained, let off the chain by Besson and seemingly encouraged to do whatever he wants. He delivers his character's manic dialogue ("I like these calm little moments before the storm. It reminds me of Beethoven") with nutty aplomb, while demonstrating the extent of his character's psychosis and drug addiction by jutting his jaw out and cranking his neck backwards. The most famously over-acted scene occurs during the fantastic exchange with Benny above. It's one I frequently quote with friends in the pub (much to the annoyance of bar staff everywhere I go, no doubt).

9. Nicolas Cage - The Wicker Man

Neil LaBute's 2006 remake of the 70's horror classic The Wicker Man was unanimously panned by critics upon release, though most of them did foreground one curious element - Nicolas Cage's ridiculous performance. Taking on the Edward Woodward role, Cage saunters around an island looking for a missing girl, and going by his shouty, wildly over-the-top performance, there are basically two schools of thought - a) Nicolas Cage is a terrible actor or b) Nicolas Cage is one of the greatest over-actors in movie history. Cage has talked about the film at length and claims that he knew he was making a silly bit of fluff, and so decided to just have fun with it. Given that Cage spends half the film running around in a bear suit, hitting women, accosting children and so on, it's not that hard to believe. Just take the most famous scene of the film, in which Cage maniacally shouts "Not the bees! The bees! Arghghgh!" as hundreds of bees are funnelled into his mask. If we remember how good Cage can be when he wants to (Leaving Las Vegas, Adaptation), this has to be on purpose.

8. Al Pacino - Scarface

One of the undisputably best over-actors of all time, countless Al Pacino films could have appeared in this list (Heat, The Devil's Advocate, Scent of a Woman), but the quintessential example of the man completely untethered is his iconic performance as Cuban immigrant-turned-gangster-extraordinaire Tony Montana in Brian De Palma's brilliantly bonkers Scarface. First there's Pacino's ridiculously exaggerated Cuban accent which has become synonymous with the role ("cock-a-roach!"), and then there's his shouty delivery of just about every notable line in the film. Given how much energy Pacino pours into the performance, it wouldn't surprise me in the slightest if he had been method acting the role of the famed cocaine baron all along (if you catch my drift). His turn culminates in the unforgettable closing sequence, when Tony Montana yells, "You wanna play rough? OK! Say hello to my little friend!", before blasting his own door open with a grenade launcher, and then finally succumbs to a shotgun blast to the back. It's totally ridiculous and outlandish, but the film wouldn't be what it is if Pacino took the low-key approach. Instead, it's loud, excessive, violent pulp, and all the better for it.

7. Michael Sheen - The Twilight Saga

Michael Sheen is the single, solitary actor in the Twilight films who actually seems in on the joke; he knows that he's making a crap series of paycheque roles - mainly to please his daughter, by his own admission - and simply has fun with it. The result is the actor becoming the rare, hammy bright spot in these otherwise execrable films; playing Aro, the leader of the Volturi and Big Bad of the franchise, he gets to prance around, cackle and deliver lines in a deliciously exaggerated mode. Sheen provides the only light relief for boyfriends dragged along to watch this tosh, mocking the whole shebang in a faintly passive-aggressive way, in that he doesn't quite derail things, but reminds us (as if we could forget) that we're watching poorly-written mulch. Sheen gets to rip the piss out of it while getting paid and earning the admiration of unfortunate boyfriends the world over.

6. Kevin Spacey - Superman Returns

Kevin Spacey isn't really known for going overboard with his acting; he's best remembered for his subtle, down-to-Earth performances in classics like Glengarry Glen Ross and American Beauty, but in playing Lex Luthor in Bryan Singer's Superman Returns, he had the opportunity to just let loose and experiment with a louder, sillier acting style. Though many criticised the film for its unconventional approach to the Superman mythos, Spacey received plenty of acclaim for his bonkers performance as the supervillain, which perfectly suited the tone the film was shooting for. Spacey clearly relishes the chance to try something different, and easily his most memorable scene involves him talking to Lois Lane and her son, sarcastically asking her questions before shouting "WRONG!". So popular is the scene that it's even become an Internet meme. In a film criticised for its lack of liveliness, Spacey is a definite bright spot.

5. Jack Nicholson - The Shining

Jack Nicholson is one of the go-to actors for "playing crazy", and many like to joke that it's because Jack is actually totally nuts in real life. Nicholson's penchant for playing loony has meant that he often takes things into the realm of overacting, notably in the Stanley Kubrick classic The Shining, as cabin fever sets in and turns his Jack Torrance into a murderous psychopath, intent on butchering his own family. With his wide-eyes and shifty expressions, Jack finds the most brilliantly bombastic way to bring manic life to the "I'll huff, and I'll puff..." routine, while he begins wailing away at the bathroom door with an oversized axe. It's not inconceivable to believe that Shelley DuVall's terrified expression is a very real fear of Nicholson. It all culminates, of course, in the famous "Here's Johnny!" line, which has been a popular mainstay in the pop-culture lexicon ever since the film was released, a delightfully overblown piece of acting that nevertheless enhances the horror of the piece.

4. John Malkovich - Con Air

Simon West's fun action thriller carries with it a boatload of swiss cheese, but there's no denying the brilliance of John Malkovich's performance as the dangerous, psychopathic inmate Cyrus The Virus. While Nicolas Cage is busy playing the disappointingly straight, earnest good guy, Malkovich is given license to run away with the picture, delivering one dour one-liner after another, hewing away from his usual choice of straight roles. Malkovich uses the role as an excuse to just have a laugh and take it easy, reading Poe's daughter's letter to him aloud in a shrieking little girl's voice, before letting out a dead-pan delivery of "Make a move, and the bunny gets it". This is the sort of film where that type of work is totally appropriate; Con Air is a daft bit of silly, entertaining action pulp, and Malkovich's contribution is both well-judged and very, very welcome.

3. William Shatner - Star Trek 2: The Wrath of Khan

So prolific is William Shatner's overacting in Star Trek 2: The Wrath of Khan that it's become a popular Internet meme, and even those who haven't seen the film are well aware of its most famous, infuriated utterance made by Captain Kirk. Shatner is by all classical standards a pretty terrible actor - the guy doesn't know how to deliver dialogue naturally and his inflexions tend to come off all wrong - but he has an amusing presence, which is harnessed perfectly in this unintentionally uproarious - but brilliant - scene in particular. "KHAAAAAAAN!", Shatner shouts as his face contorts into various configurations I hadn't previously thought imaginable. It's a moment that's supposed to be dramatically involving, though Shatner in effect "ruins" it by making it laughable. However, within a contemporary context, the scene is beloved by most Trekkies who have seen the film enough to not have his hamminess end up destroying things completely.

2. Jack Nicholson - The Departed

We couldn't stand to just settle for one Jack Nicholson entry, so here's another. Martin Scorsese's Best Picture-winning modern classic The Departed is a masterclass of fantastic acting, though one performer stands notably apart from the rest; while Leonardo DiCaprio, Matt Damon, Ray Winstone and Vera Farmiga deliver genuinely rousing, believable performances, Nicholson, playing gangster kingpin Frank Costello, just completely flies off the handle. That said, Scorsese's deft direction and Thelma Schoonmaker's superb editing manage to mould Jack's ridiculous ad-libbing and facial tics into something that is mischeviously playful and indeed, hugely entertaining to watch. The above scene, in which Nicholson imitates a rat gnawing on cheese as he talks about a rat in his employ is both hilarious and disturbing all at once, cementing Costello's cocaine-fuelled intensity and giving us insight into his character. There's also a classic moment later on when Jack is talking to DiCaprio's character, and as was a total ad-lib, decides to set a piece of paper on fire mid-conversation. Scorsese liked it so much that he kept it in the final cut.

1. Michelle Pfeiffer - Batman Returns

This is one performance best described as...purrrrfect (sorry). Though Anne Hathaway has received a wealth of acclaim for her performance as Selina Kyle in Christopher Nolan's The Dark Knight Rises, it's impossible to forget Michelle Pfeiffer's more...out there...performance as Catwoman in Tim Burton's Batman Returns. Here's an instance of a director making an outlandish, loud, silly film and finding like-minded actors who could deliver the goods; alongside Danny DeVito's unforgettable performance as The Penguin, Pfeiffer delivered a gleefully over-the-top performance that allowed this sequel to far outdo the original. If seeing Pfeiffer kitted out in tight PVC wasn't enough to get your attention, then her delicious delivery, sporting a sexy voice and elongation of syllables, was sure to. She took an already daft character and imbued her with an unforgettable, psychotic spirit that made her the most entertaining aspect of an already highly enjoyable film. Which instance of overacting is your favourite? Let us know in the comments below.