10 ‘Bad’ Horror Movies Everyone Gets Wrong
Don't believe the critics, these horror films are well worth your attention.
Forever a genre that has been savaged by critics, horror has always had a tough time being taken seriously. Considered by some to be irredeemably low-brow, or lacking in any real merit, the genre is more often than not subject to intense scrutiny just for simply existing.
And in some instances, it's easy to understand why.
Some films go out of their way to push the boundaries of taste a little too far, whilst many others are merely sequels that are devoid of any real creativity - and neither of those qualities is going to win over both critics and audiences. That said though, devotees of the genre will always champion their favourite fright flicks and make a case for their artistic quality, even in spite of their sometimes gaping flaws.
Which coincidentally, is exactly what we're here to do today.
The films listed here are ones that have either been panned by critics or utterly loathed by fans. So much so that they're often near-universally considered bad films and tales of their actual quality tend to consist mostly of hyperbole or a misunderstanding of the filmmaker's intentions.
They might not all be the most shining examples of cinema as an art-form, but they're certainly nowhere near as bad as everyone would have you believe.
10. Valentine
Much like how Halloween brought the genre to life before it, Scream successfully reanimated the bloated corpse of the slasher genre, and seemingly overnight, moviegoers were bombarded with all manner of stalk-and-slice films that were keen to get in on the box office cash cow.
Most of which were somewhat warmly received by fans and critics alike, with films like Cherry Falls and I Know What You Did Last Summer still being praised to this day.
But sadly Valentine has never been so lucky.
Panned by critics on release due to it bearing too many similarities to older slasher films, and lacking the wit and reflexive humour of Scream, the film sits at a woeful 12% on Rotten Tomatoes. Which if you've seen the movie, you'll know that's a grotesque over-exaggeration of its supposed badness.
Sure, it's not exactly going to win over those at the Academy, but taken for what it is, Valentine is a competently made slasher that's full of nasty little surprises along the way. Taking us back to a time when slasher films weren't so reliant on meta humour and snarky dialogue to capture an audience's imagination.
And to our minds, it's the best eighties slasher film, that wasn't made in the eighties.
9. A Nightmare on Elm Street 2: Freddy's Revenge
Of all the films on this list, Freddy's Revenge is easily the most well-known example of a supposedly poor film undergoing a reappraisal decades after its release. With its homoerotic undercurrents and subversion of the 'final girl' trope often being singled out as its strongest elements.
Aside from those two aspects though, Freddy's Revenge still has a whole lot to offer for fans of the genre. With numerous gruesome special-effects sequences, mean-spirited kills and one of Robert Englund's most menacing performances as Freddy Kruger, this film really is nowhere near as inept as its reputation would have you believe.
Several critics of the time were highly dismissive of the film, with some even going so far as to refer to the film as tedious and humourless. The latter of which being an interesting assertion when the first film isn't exactly a laugh-a-minute joke fest.
It may not be able to fully hold its own when compared to the likes of Craven's original, or the vastly superior Dream Warriors, but Freddy's Revenge is a solid entry into the eighties slasher canon that has far more going on under the hood when compared to its contemporaries.
8. Texas Chainsaw Massacre: The Next Generation
Given just how far The Texas Chainsaw Massacre series has fallen from grace, it's remarkable that its fourth entry is still often considered its worst.
And don't get me wrong here, it's not exactly a great film, but when compared to the likes of Leatherface and Texas Chainsaw 3D, it's a borderline masterpiece.
Grotesque hyperbole aside though, The Next Generation is a startling wild and intriguing film when you scratch beneath the surface. The film opens on a nudge-wink text-screen that jokingly alludes to the previous movies, before essentially launching head-first into a highly cynical and darkly funny re-telling of the first film's events.
Penned by the same writer as the original film, The Next Generation lampoons many of that film's ideas, as well as taking aim at the declining state of the genre at the time - i.e. through Leatherface's ineffectiveness and the bizarre ending which implies that the film's events have been orchestrated by mysterious businessmen.
In retrospect, it's surprisingly satirical, but sadly it's so bogged down in retreading the original that many of its more zany ideas are either lost in translation or simply outweighed by the sheer insanity of what's happening on the screen.
7. Halloween II (2009)
Rob Zombie's first stab at a Halloween movie did yield mixed results, but for the most part, it succeeded in what it set out to do - reinvent the Halloween franchise and take it in a completely different direction.
When the time came for a sequel, Zombie himself had no intention of returning but eventually relented when offered creative freedom.
And boy howdy does his disdain shine through. Halloween II is a much darker, meaner, and genuinely antagonistic film that revels in nihilism and misery. Unlike other slasher sequels where the characters are able to move on, the survivors of Michael's previous rampage are shown to be highly damaged as a result.
The script does tend to buckle under itself at numerous points, but as an exploration of trauma, survivor's guilt, and the way in which violence perverts everything around it, it's pretty damn effective.
Audiences were likely expecting something more akin to previous Halloween entries but were presented with perhaps the most oppressive and misanthropic slasher film ever made. It's certainly got its flaws, but it's hard to label it as a truly bad movie when it's capable of crafting such a palpable sense of hopelessness through its sharp cinematography and insanely violent kills.
6. Seed of Chucky
Upon release, Seed of Chucky was lambasted for its overly silly tone and lack of horror - which is somewhat surprising when you consider that the Child's Play series has always pitched its tent in that parts of the woods.
There is certainly a kernel of truth to these accusations, however, as Seed is more reliant on gross-out gags and meta-humour than any semblance of actual scares or suspense. What it lacks in genuine horror though, it more than makes up for in its sheer unabashed weirdness and dedication to its characters.
Moving the action to the bright lights of Hollywood, Chucky and Tiffany find themselves resurrected by their unnatural spawn Glen, a rather ghoulish-looking doll struggling with gender dysphoria.
Having parenthood forced upon the pair allows for us to peel back the layers of their psyche, and understand them both better as characters. With Tiffany's maternal nature becoming more apparent, whilst Chucky's hard-wired lust for killing is an affront to his new responsibilities.
It is every bit as ludicrous as it sounds, but that's not necessarily a bad thing. Taken on its own, Seed of Chucky is a gloriously goofy good time, and remains largely misunderstood by many.
5. Tusk
Considering that the origins of Tusk trace back to a joke premise that Kevin Smith pitched on his much-loved podcast, it does make sense that many people would also write this film off as a joke.
And yes, whilst the film is intended to be darkly funny, it does also succeed at being a very disturbing horror film.
This is mostly down to the numerous gore-gags and nauseating scenes in which the protagonist Wallace Bryant is mutilated and re-purposed into a human-walrus hybrid for the pleasure of his captor, Mr Howard Howe. All of which is further punctuated by Howe's harrowing backstory, which we're carefully drip-fed alongside all the brutality.
It's rare that a film can bolster such a unique and bizarre premise, and deliver on it tenfold by balancing the ludicrous nature of its narrative with several scenes that will make the audience wince.
It's most certainly not a film for everybody, but for those who can get aboard its unashamedly weird wavelength, there's plenty of gruesome delights to be found. Marvellously over-the-top and genuinely very repulsive in places, Tusk is a wholly unique viewing experience that dares you to keep watching it.
4. Black Christmas (2006)
The fact that Black Christmas has been remade twice now is a shocking example of just how far the horror genre is willing to sink. The 2019 version was an ill-conceived trainwreck that sought to be topical as opposed to terrifying, but the often-overlooked 2006 film is something of a lost treasure from the post-Scream era of slasher films.
Where the original film relied on atmosphere and persistent dread to unnerve its audience, this 2006 iteration instead goes for the jugular and offers up an orgy of brutal violence and appalling bad taste. This may not butter everyone's crumpet - nor did it do so upon release - but if you're in the mood for a nasty festive slasher film, you can't really go wrong with this one.
The plot is fairly loose and the characters definitely lack the depth of the original film's, but every else on display is so deliriously deranged and entertaining that it's easy to simply shut your brain off and enjoy the slay-ride.
It doesn't try to be the original film, and it's safe to say that if this film wasn't associated with Bob Clark's festive classic, it would have amassed a much bigger following by now.
3. Jason X
It's a well-worn horror trope that when a franchise is floundering with sequel fatigue that the only logical next step is to launch its main villain into space; and Jason X is quite often ridiculed for being the living embodiment of this laughably lazy concept.
But also, that's kinda the point.
The Friday the 13th franchise may have begun its life as a set of somewhat serious and gruesome suspense thrillers, but as time went on, the series leaned into its own ridiculous nature, and that is arguably why it has endured as long as it has.
And Jason X is the pinnacle of the franchise poking fun at itself, be it through cheeky nods to previous entries, or its gleaming self-awareness that lets the audience in on the joke. This film does not take itself seriously in the slightest, and once you give yourself over to its schlocky charms, you're going to have a good time with it.
The late-era Friday the 13th films are definitely a mixed bag, so it's understandable as to why many fans weren't appreciative of this film's overt campiness, but it's hard to call Jason X a truly bad movie when it's just so darned entertaining.
2. A Cure For Wellness
Easily one of modern horror's most unsung treasures, A Cure for Wellness has had 'cult classic' written all over it since the day it was first unleashed in cinemas.
This spiralling, gothic oddity has enthralled and befuddled audiences in equal measure with its gargantuan length, dizzying tonal shifts, and truly horrifying imagery, but the common consensus seems to be that the film isn't particularly good.
And whilst it's certainly a matter of opinion, the film does have many saving graces.
It's likely that many folks were drawn in by the trailer's promise of medical malpractice and body horror, but were instead greeted with something more old-fashioned. Something that took heavy inspiration from the European horror films of decades gone by - even down to those films penchant for truly nauseating gore shots.
Given where modern horror has been going for the last few years, it's easy to understand why A Cure for Wellness was so easily binned when people wanted cerebral terror over old-fashioned gothic atmosphere. And whilst the plot isn't exactly going to win any awards, it does have a compelling central mystery that will keep you guessing right up until the end.
1. Twin Peaks: Fire Walk With Me
Few shows can claim to be as important, or as groundbreaking as Twin Peaks was for its time. Its unequivocal strangeness captured the minds and hearts of millions - even if they didn't quite understand what was going on.
But despite the adoration that so many have for the series, its subsequent film adaptation has never fared so well. With many even going so far as to say it's the worst part of the Twin Peaks canon, which is strange when you consider the latter half of season two...
Analysis of the show aside though, Fire Walk With Me is a largely misunderstood film. On the surface, it's merely a prequel but it really should be viewed as its own separate entity.
Not only because it's in a completely different medium, but tonally and stylistically, it's a far cry from the show's 'soap-opera gone wrong' approach. It's also a callously cruel and deeply disturbing film, one that's anchored by a show-stopping performance by Sheryl Lee that really deserves to be seen and appreciated for the masterful work that it is.
Submerge yourself in its darkness and you'll definitely see what all the fuss is about.