The Oscars have come and gone once again, but there are still some long overdue awards to handout. This list will honor those whom, save for one case, the Academy has generally overlooked. Warner Bros. Pictures' Batman franchise has been the beneficiary of some brilliant performances over the past 25 years and it's about time the very best were highlighted. This list will honor those who left an everlasting mark on one of Hollywood's most iconic and most historic franchises. The stars have already walked the virtual red carpet and taken their seats. There's no longwinded monologue to get through. Let's begin the fun with our first honoree.
10. Michelle Pfeiffer - Batman Returns
Say what you will about Tim Burton's second Batman film and its unconventional portrayal of The Dark Knight's most famous female friend/foe, but there's little doubt regarding the quality of Michelle Pfeiffer's performance. It really doesn't matter whether or not Pfeiffer played the Catwoman every fan wanted. What counts most is the way she kept the audience with her step for step through the complex evolutionary arc of her Selina Kyle. As a meek secretary, Pfeiffer's Selina Kyle was not an immediately recognizable symbol of feminine strength. It was, however, an effective starting point for a character whose near (or actual?) death experience emboldened her with the power one would have expected from Catwoman at the outset. But biggest achievement in the performance is what follows. While Danny Devito was busy making perverse puns as the sex-starved Penguin, Pfeiffer stood out by showing a woman who was emotionally unraveling just as quickly as the stitches were bursting in her homemade cat suit. In the process, Pfeiffer established Catwoman as simultaneously sexy, charismatic, crazy, and sympathetic. Most importantly, she made her character the most memorable component of the 1992 film.
9. Liam Neeson As Ra's Al Ghul - Batman Begins
The greatest trick Ducard ever pulled was convincing the world he actually existed. Liam Neeson was no stranger to the role of mentor when he was cast to train a young Bruce Wayne still on his journey to becoming Batman. Neeson was obviously perfect for that role and excelled in it as expected, but it was the turn that assured Neeson's place in Batman movie lore. When Neeson made the switch from Ducard to Ra's al Ghul, his warm father figure became a cold, calculating villain. Sure, a script leak a couple weeks ahead of Batman Begins' release may have spoiled the surprise for some fans, but most did not see it coming. Arguably, Neeson's performance is even better as Ra's than the facade of Ducard, as it put him in less famililar territory that elevated the drama of the film. The cool condescension with which he addressed his former mentee was so captivating that many fans wish Neeson's Ra's was immortal, or that Batman would have at least felt compelled to save him.
8. Jack Nicholson As The Joker - Batman
I'm going to get in a bit of trouble here, aren't I? The issue here is not whether Nicholson belongs on this list, but why he isn't ranked higher. If this was a list about the most important actors in Batman movie history then Jack Nicholson would be near the very top. This is a best list, though, and Jack's Joker has steep competition. Nicholson's Joker was undoubtedly great in its time, leaving an indelible mark on the franchise. His portrayal was a very faithful representation of the character, so much so that his Joker could have come to Anton Furst's Gotham by way of a Dennis O'Neil and Neal Adams comic book. The prankster aspect of the character was present along with an affinity for homicide. It is for those reasons and more that Jack belongs on this list. He is not ranked higher, however, for a couple reasons. First and foremost, the rest of this list will feature tough competition from remarkable actors. Second, while Jack was definitely The Joker in Batman (1989), he was still very much the idea of himself that he'd implanted in the minds of audiences years before. Jack Nicholson can still be found underneath the makeup and perma-grin, as there was not a full disappearance into the role, nor was a completely new onscreen villain created. Sure, people at the time may have thought Jack left behind impossible shoes to fill, but we now know that wasn't the case.
7. Tom Hardy- The Dark Knight Rises
Imagine having to emote convincingly with half of your face covered for all but one second of your performance. That's what Tom Hardy had to do as Bane in The Dark Knight Rises. Using only his eyes and posture, Hardy was frequently imposing, charismatic when needed, and even heartbroken in a rare moment of weakness. Hardy made his mask an asset, not a hindrance to his performance. Bane was primarily known for one very popular comic book story arc in the 1990s (Knightfall) in which he broke Batman's back. The character had a few highlights in the years that followed, but nothing compared to his rookie year. This made him an odd choice for "the epic conclusion to The Dark Knight Legend" in the minds of fans. Tom Hardy erased all (or most) doubts by embodying the very best of the concept while fleshing out all new elements to create a complete cinematic character. Any part of Bane's comic book origin excluded from the film had no adverse impact. Hardy physically and vocally loaned Bane a sense of history. There was a wisdom born from burdened past that not only made Hardy's Bane intimidating, but also gave the character an ideological authenticity.
6. Michael Caine As Alfred - The Dark Knight Trilogy
Michael Caine was immediately received as a perfect choice for the role of Alfred Pennyworth when he was cast in Batman Begins. Over the course of three films, Caine exceeded the audience's lofty expectations. He was everything fans ever hoped Alfred would be- warm, witty, opinionated, fatherly, tough, and more. It certainly helped that Caine got to play scenes with Bruce Wayne at every stage of his life shown in The Dark Knight Trilogy from the boy who fell, to the man who picked himself up, to The Dark Knight who rose. By Caine, the audience was spoiled. His outstanding effort is best exemplified by a scene in each film. In Batman Begins, Alfred literally saves Bruce from a burning, collapsing Wayne Manor. He lifts Bruce up and puts him back on his newly found path to saving Gotham. In The Dark Knight, Alfred is the one who educates Bruce on the inevitability of casualties and provides the necessary emotional lift to get Batman back into the fight against The Joker. In The Dark Knight Rises, Caine successfully pulls off a rather tricky scene in which his character, for the first time, takes a hard stance against Bruce being Batman. It's not because Alfred has given up on Bruce. Caine shows us that from Alfred's perspective, it is Bruce who's given up on himself and Alfred's only choice was to refuse to be an enabler any longer. Emotionally, it is a gut-wrenching scene that is worth enduring when Alfred's dream for Bruce is finally realized in the closing moments of the trilogy.
5. Anne Hathaway As Catwoman - The Dark Knight Rises
One word: "Oops." Just like that, Anne Hathaway flipped the switch and became Selina Kyle. Okay, there was an effective shrug of a shoulder, too, but that merely added to the style and attitude fans of the character had been longing for. It was the first, but not last scene Hathaway stole in The Dark Knight Rises. As the film progressed, Hathaway continued to serve as its arguably most entertaining element. Her dive bar dealing made for a classic scene in which she turned male perception of feminine weakness and inferiority against gangsters and cops alike. She was the smartest, most cunning person in the room and she knew it. Hathaway's facial expressions gave depth to Selina Kyle and really sold the character's arc. She smiled at the view over Gotham from the backseat of The Bat when Batman wasn't looking. She wasn't as adaptable as she thought she would be when that "storm" finally came to Gotham. Her thrill of escape from the exiled Gotham was quickly washed away by a heroic sense of duty to save those she'd always claimed she was fighting for. Jonathan Nolan had to convince director Christopher Nolan to include Catwoman in the first place. Anne Hathaway wound up making both brothers look very smart for that inclusion.
4. Michael Keaton As Batman - Batman/Batman Returns
He started it, or at least, he's the one who made the phrase iconic. Michael Keaton is a man that could probably never be cast as Batman in today's social media society. Fans didn't even need the internet to voice their outrage over Keaton's casting. They wrote letters and editorials in newspapers. They talked to anyone who would listen. And they were all dead wrong. Michael Keaton was exactly the kind of Batman needed for the character's first serious cinematic adaptation. He may have spoken softly underneath that cowl, but his understated vocals added to the mystery of the costumed vigilante. He was the dark, weird figure described by Bill Finger in Batman's earliest comic book adventures. As Bruce Wayne, Michael Keaton played right into the less stable approach Tim Burton wanted for his Batman. Conventional wisdom holds that a man would have to be crazy to dress up like a bat and fight crime. While Keaton wasn't afraid to "get nuts," he was the kind of man who spent more time living inside his own head than anywhere else. He was the kind of man just far enough on the outside fringes of reality to take the road less traveled to achieve justice in Gotham and fight the evil that took away his parents.
3. Gary Oldman As Commissioner Gordon - The Dark Knight Trilogy
Prior to Batman Begins, Gary Oldman was known better for being the thorn in a hero's side rather than a helping hand, or a hero in his own right. He was an unconventional choice for Jim Gordon, but the successful defiance of conventional wisdom is a common theme in Batman movies. All that mattered is that Gordon looked like he walked right out of Frank Miller's Batman: Year One, but sounded better and possessed fewer character flaws. As Gordon, Oldman was the most relatable character in the trilogy. He was the everyman, doing the best he could with what he had, as he told Harvey Dent in The Dark Knight. He lacked the time and resources for idealism. Batman, nutty or not, was just what Gordon needed to cut through all the red tape that kept him as an isolated do-gooder in a corrupt city. He may not have always been comfortable working with a masked vigilante, but he wasn't comfortable with all his badge buddies either, so what did it matter? Batman got results and allowed Gordon to get some of his own. He may have accomplished extraordinary feats, but Oldman set Gordon apart from the bats, clowns, and megalomaniacs by being the person audience members hoped they could be if faced with the same situation. He did what he thought was right, lived through regret, and tried his best to protect his family and put them first. The tragedy is that it wasn't always good enough. Perhaps one of the biggest missed opportunities of The Dark Knight Rises is how it left Gordon behind. Sure, he got the literal signal that Batman was not really dead, but with all that Gordon had been through, he deserved more. Bruce Wayne got to live happily ever after and it would have been great to see Gordon end the film inside a Cleveland home reunited with the family he fought so hard to protect. Then again, my rooting for him is ultimately a testament to how Oldman helped the audience connect with the character and hope that things eventually workout for an everyman like the rest of us.
2. Christian Bale As Batman - The Dark Knight Trilogy
Fans can quibble all day long over which live-action Batman is their favorite. When it comes to performance, however, it's hard not to give Christian Bale the edge if for no other reason than he was given so much more to do with the role than Michael Keaton or Adam West. Christian Bale was afforded the opportunity to touch on every major aspect of the Bruce Wayne/Batman character over the course of three films and he undoubtedly made the most of it. Many have complained about the bat-voice, of which some blame should be shifted to decisions Christopher Nolan made in post-production, but it was still a bold choice by Bale and made sense for a guy dressing up like a bat with the intent to be terrifying. Take the voice out of the equation and it's the eyes with which Bale communicated to clearly. Just watch the interrogation scene in The Dark Knight as his rage heats up moment-by-moment until it finally boils over. It's masterful. In the end, Batman is Batman and not the hardest part of the role to play. It is Bale's Bruce Wayne that puts his performance on a higher level. In public, he was the aloof playboy who could never be a costumed vigilante despite being the most obvious suspect. Bruce Wayne is Batman? Pfft. No way. Within the walls of Wayne Manor, the Batcave, or the Bat-bunker, Bruce Wayne was the tortured soul whose method of dealing with emotional anguish was to literally fight against those who dished out similar pain to other innocents. He was a strong, but flawed man to whom we would love to have been able to relate, but knew we never could. The hope is that we can process our grief better than Bruce Wayne ever did, but the greater goal is that we can do half as good of a job of turning our moments of adversity into lasting positive change. Christopher Nolan was the architect of Bruce Wayne's complete cinematic journey as Batman, but it was Christian Bale who made that journey feel as real and emotionally satisfying as it ever could.
1. Heath Ledger As The Joker - The Dark Knight
Without question, it is the most decorated performance in the history of comic book movies. Heath Ledger was the first and only actor to be nominated and win an Oscar for his work in a superhero film. Of course, the Oscar was just one of several awards with which Ledger was posthumously honored for his instantly iconic turn as The Joker in The Dark Knight. There are so many wonderful adjectives that can be used to describe Heath's performance as The Joker, but few, if any, feel sufficient. As a character, The Joker is expected to be a scene stealer, but Heath was so uniquely magnetic, commanding all eyes and attention when his character was onscreen. It all started before we even saw his face. The very first shot of Heath is from behind as he waits for his ride to bank heist. The men picking him up have no idea this anonymous, clown-masked henchmen is their undercover ringleader (and executioner), but it's obvious to those watching from the outside that something is different about him. They may not know exactly what just yet, but it does not take long for them to learn. As Heath made his fully-costumed debut in front of a bunch of mob bosses, a simple magic trick was all that was needed to convince the audience to sit back and enjoy the rest of the ride. The Joker was back, like you'd never seen him before and, tragically, will never see him again. He was funny in a way that inspired guilt for laughing, charismatic in a way that drew you in, and so disturbing that you know you'd never want to be in an interrogation room with him. Credit is due to Jonathan Nolan and Christopher Nolan for writing great lines of dialogue, but Heath absolutely took over the film with his delivery. More than that, he gave a full-bodied performance that exceeded anything put down on the pages of the script. The walk, the lip-smacking, and the frequent tracing and retracing of his scars with his tongue were all Heath. He created a series of mannerisms that made The Joker a character someone the audience could not stop watching even when someone else was speaking. In truth, calling Heath's Joker the best performance in the history of the Batman franchise is easy. It is Ledger's place in the history of all cinematic villainy in every genre that calls for debate. Anyone participating in that discussion would be well served to avoid underestimating The Joker, as that mistake comes at a hefty price. Even Batman will tell you that. So there you have it, the 10 best performances in the history of Batman movies. Which inclusions did you agree with? Whom do you feel got snubbed? Let us know in the comments section below.