10 Best Carl Reiner Films
In celebration of the Nicest Man In Hollywood.
One doesn't have to go far to celebrate the work and life of Carl Reiner. Not only does so much of it live on and maintain the kind of timeless quality the best of 1960s mainstream culture, he also served as comedy's straight man. And as a the straight man, his job wasn't to deliver the joke so much as set it up. It's what made him an indelible part of the 2000-Year-Old-Man routine and also a perfect comedian's director. Carl helped solidify the comedic talents of friend Mel Brooks, Steve Martin and Lily Tomlin.
Only a handful of celebrities carry the moniker the nicest man in Hollywood, and fewer still live up to it, but research has yielded not a single negative thing about him.
And Reiner worked until the end, last appearing briefly in the closest you can get to a "himself" role in Toy Story 4, further cementing his mark on yet another generation of fans.
Surprisingly, for such a mult-faceted talent, Reiner only worked behind the camera on 15 films. True to his nature, several of them were vehicles intended to showcase someone else's talent. Few, fortunately, didn't succeed. He simply knew how to tap into what made certain comics and celebrities funny, then get the best from them.
10. Summer Rental
You aren't going to see a lot of comedies today that celebrate the joys of being overweight without some serious blowback or messages about body positivity, but the 1980s were a different time. And John Candy was a different property, known for transcending his appearance, acting lighter than air.
John Hughes found his quintessential suburban everyman in Candy, a Canadian who had risen to fame thanks to Second City and its television show. And Reiner similarly used Candy in Summer Rental.
It began as an idea from SNL producer Bernie Brillstein: "I have five children and I weigh 240 pounds. Being heavy in California is not a terrific thing." Summer Rental doesn't stray too far from its fat-guy-out-of-water premise, but it's no matter. The film hinges on Candy's likability more than its standard eighties summer teen comedy set up.
While Hughes may have tapped into a more emotional side of Candy, Reiner gladly plays with his more pratfall-prone side. One's enjoyment of the picture depends on how much mileage you get out of nostalgic eighties fare, but it's certainly a step up from Reiner's Mark Harmon-led Summer School. Both are equally aimless and vaguely lazy, a trend that unfortunately continued into Reiner's nineties films, but there's some charm left.
Candy and Reiner got along so well they planned to reteam, but it wasn't to be.
9. The Comic
Comedians should not write about comedy. That seems to be the maxim, as attempts have led to bloated, self-indulgent messes such as Judd Apatow's later work and the notoriously bad Tom Hanks/Sally Field vehicle Punchline.
It's an old cliche that stand up comics' lives are usually morose or at least dipped in tragedy, so delving into their darker side for anything but comedy is rarely a success.
Reiner, though, is a kind of an exception to the rule. The worst hardship, careerwise, was that CBS wanted Dick Van Dyke to star in his proposed pilot rather than himself.
After that show's success, Reiner and Van Dyke reteamed for this dramedy inspired by the life of Buster Keaton. The film also directly parallels the life of one of its co-stars: Mickey Rooney.
Van Dyke has always been a great physical comic, and he certainly puts it to use here, patterning his routine after Stan Laurel.
It's maudlin, to be sure, but Van Dyke is particularly good. Years later, Van Dyke learned that Laurel had seen his performance and made no legal attempt to prevent it, making the longtime Laurel and Hardy fan proud. Unfortunately, it's one of Reiner's films still hard to acquire.
8. The One And Only
Only in recent years have we seen the range of Henry Winkler, an actor best known as a one-off character on a dated sitcom. But Hollywood was trying to make The Fonz a thing for a little while and, frankly, we would have been better off if Winkler had taken what Travolta stole.
1978's The One and Only really just modernizes Winker's Fonzarelli persona, playing an equally conceited young man. The roguish Andy Schmidt is convinced he's talented and handsome, but unlike the Fonz, there's really nothing likeable about him. He's a character made for comeuppance, however given Reiner's lighthearted nature, it was destined to be good-natured.
The One and Only is not currently out on DVD, which is fitting considering that it's very much of its time. Reiner incorporates recent trends like professional wrestling and the popularity of Herve Villachez in ways that feel out of place now, but probably made sense then.
It's also one of Reiner's major Hollywood films that calls back to his early years trying to make it in Hollywood, something Reiner often used as a plot device or, in the case of The Dick Van Dyke Show, an entire series.
7. Oh God!
Sometimes, you have to work with what you got. But when what you have is George Burns, you're on safe ground, even when the script is written by Larry Gelbart.
Gelbart created the M*A*S*H sitcom after the film's success and, according to Alan Alda, John Belushi and Dan Aykroyd, is one of the painfully unfunniest writers in Hollywood. His behavior on M*A*S*H led to Alda lampooning his entire persona in Crimes and Misdemeanors.
But of the work Gelbart scripted, Oh, God! is at least harmless - never setting out to be a particularly religious or anti-religious film but instead just that time George Burns was our Lord and savior.
And who better for God to rely on to spread his word than country music star John Denver? Granted, I can think of a few better options, but I'm willing to hear God out.
What works in Oh, God! is essentially everything you'd expect to work: Burns' kindly yet cranky grandfather is an ideal movie God. Morgan Freeman was too busy on The Electric Company for the gig, so Reiner found his seventies contemporary. Burns' God is even less of a lesson-teacher than Freeman, happy just to demonstrate a few miracles or even a card trick.
6. Where's Poppa?
Reiner was never one for black comedy, but he did try his hand at it during the cynical seventies. Where's Poppa? is a somewhat successful bleak look at the relationship between a lawyer (George Segal) and his senile mother (Ruth Gordon).
It's as relentlessly mean and unpleasant as any other film of its kind, having the most in common with Alan Arkin's Little Murders. What makes these two particularly interesting is that, despite their nature, there's a propensity and energy to the proceedings that make them feel lighter than they are. The subject matter is cruel and there's really no happy ending for anyone involved.
This is the angriest you'll ever see Reiner, and he unloads on some fairly easy but appropriate targets like the military, New York crime rates and elder abuse. It's entirely uncharacteristic, but it's worth knowing what it's like to catch the nicest man in Hollywood on a bad day.
5. Enter Laughing
Carl Reiner's directorial debut was never released on VHS or DVD, however, it has appeared on TCM over the years, so its absence is only a matter of time.
Reiner only had a handful of TV credits under his name when he sought to finance an adaptation of his novel and stage play. Enter Laughing is a largely autobiographical story about a young New York Jewish man (Reni Santoni of Dirty Harry) looking to break into show business.
This would be a common theme in a lot of Reiner's work, and he often managed to keep it fresh. It's certainly an important film in that respect, setting in place a throughline that works for most of his career.
It's also clear Reiner used his TV and comedy connections, calling in every favour gladly obliged. The supporting cast includes Don Rickles, Elaine May and The Dick Van Dyke Show's Richard Deacon.
Reiner's passing may well inspire fans and friends to push for a release, and TCM's message boards are already requesting a rerun, so it may be wise to keep an eye out in the near future.
4. Dead Men Don't Wear Plaid
Following The Jerk, Martin was having lunch with Reiner and screenwriter George Gipe while discussing a scene in a script Martin had written. The suggestion to use footage from an old movie led to the three developing Dead Men Don't Wear Plaid, which is... well, half a film.
Collectively, Dead Men collects scenes from 19 different old film noirs, from classics like The Maltese Falcon to lesser-known works like The Glass Key and films new scenes with Martin around them, concocting its own ludicrous detective plot.
It's easy to see how this idea could have gone horribly wrong, but the talent behind the camera ensured it wouldn't. Reiner is good at aping the styles of directors like Howard Hawks and Billy Wilder, but he never forgets he's making a comedy, exaggerating or accentuating the fine points of the noir genre. He smartly enlisted those who worked on the very films they were playing with, including costume designer Edith Head.
But the showcase here, as it should be, is Martin, who is having a ball trying to mix and match mysteries from several different plots in a way that loosely hangs together. He never tries to do an impression of the leading men he appears next to, wisely creating an entirely new, albeit goofy, hardboiled fiction legend.
3. All Of Me
Reiner's final film with Martin fully put on display the actor's physical ability, to the point where it's not unreasonable to call his performance Oscar-worthy. Taken from an unpublished novel, All of Me is their first pairing not entirely set in a heightened reality, with unhappy lawyer Roger Cobb (Martin) having half of his body taken over by the soul of a wealthy eccentric (Lily Tomlin).
Both halves of Martin are thankfully comic legends, with Tomlin having proven herself with years of specials, SNL hosting gigs and film roles. And the film is at its best when they're literally on opposite sides of an issue, with his body trying to stop one thing and do another.
Reiner doesn't just bank on the performance, however. A great supporting turn from Richard Libertini as a shaman with severe culture shock highlights much of the film's latter half.
It's a nice note to end a four-film partnership, with Martin finally playing the straight man.
There was talk at Dreamworks in 2012 of a remake, and later plans to adapt the property into a series, but replicating the chemistry between the two leads and the filmmaker just isn't feasible.
2. The Man With Two Brains
The Jerk toyed with absurdist humour, but it grounded it within some sort of reality. In The Man With Two Brains, Martin and Reiner gladly abandon all that, firmly planting the movie in the world of fifties B-movie sci-fi. Even the colours from the later-era films are lifted from the labs of cinema's maddest scientists, with purple and blue-tinted bricks in hidden castles.
Both Reiner and Martin understood that the same bright-fluorescent aesthetic could be applied to heightened comedy just as effectively. The script, with the exception of a few stand out jokes, could be played mostly straight just a few decades earlier, as Martin's Dr. Hfuhruhurr falls in love with his deceased colleague's experiment.
The film even includes an extraneous subplot about a serial killer stalking the area, commonplace to many such films it's lovingly spoofing. The identity of the serial killer, however, is pure Martin. The supporting cast, with a great malicious turn from Kathleen Turner and a winking David Warner, only add to Two Brains' pedigree.
Too many spoofs, especially today, wear from recycling the same jokes or attempting to be hip to the current times. Reiner found a better formula.
1. The Jerk
The Jerk was Steve Martin's first lead role in a film after just a few years of a stand-up act that was zany even by 1970s standards.
Martin has his choice of director, and it's not really much of surprise he went with Reiner. Both had come up in the sixties world of comedy writing - Reiner on Your Show of Shows and The Dick Van Dyke Show and Martin on The Smothers Brothers comedy hour - and instantly had a rapport.
So the two worked out the plot over the phone and in meetings, feeding their notes to Jaws scribe Carl Gottlieb.
The wacky, anything-can-happen spirit of Martin's stand-up is entirely retained in a film that intentionally just kind of meanders. The Jerk plays similarly to Forrest Gump without all the forced CGI and the uncomfortable political issues. There's a reason Stanley Kubrick not only cited it as one of his favourites, but was also inspired to start work on Eyes Wide Shut with Martin in mind.
Unlike Gump, The Jerk recognizes and revels in its own absurdity, but Reiner still managed to inject even the tiniest hint of heart - a motif he would pass on (with mixed results) to his son.