10 Best Motion Capture Performances

Remarkable and compelling work from celebrated thespians wearing facial dots and onesies...

By David Ng'ethe /

Motion/performance capture (mo-cap) is a filmmaking tool that has revolutionized VFX-heavy filmmaking in the 21st Century through its precise capture of an actor's movements, posture, and facial expressions to create an otherworldly character that simply cannot be brought to life through make-up and/or prosthetics due to budgetary or logistical constraints.

Advertisement

Well-utilized CGI blended with motion capture can be used to effectively realize beings that are too large, small or just flat-out weird/fantastical. However, all this would not be possible without the actors behind the mo-cap dots and cameras humanizing these digital avatars. Without said actors, they would be simple digital creations devoid of life and personality; nice to look at but hollow and cold.

This list covers 10 of the most accomplished motion capture performances given by actors in film since the tech's inception. These performances were able to overcome skepticism from the film community and become classic works of art that stand tall and proud next to more traditional forms of acting.

10. Toby Kebbell As Koba (Dawn Of The Planet Of The Apes)

Toby Kebbell brought life to Koba, the tortured and scarred bonobo adviser of ape leader Caesar in Matt Reeves' first go at 20th Century Fox's then-new Planet of the Apes trilogy. The character was initially portrayed by stuntman Christopher Gordon in the first film, Rise of the Planet of the Apes.

Advertisement

He did an admirable job bringing life to a younger and less vicious version of the simian antagonist. That said, Kebbell brought a whole new dimension to the role that defined Koba as a dangerous threat with a sympathetic motivation for his actions.

His distinctive facial scarring hints at an abusive past at the hands of human scientists and the audience immediately empathizes with his actions. He admires Caesar but cannot understand why he's so lenient on a group of human survivors and would rather the apes take pre-emptive action against the humans.

Kebbell perfectly captures Koba's rage, pain and frustration and expresses

9. Mark Ruffalo As The Incredible Hulk (Marvel Cinematic Universe)

Proving that the third time's a charm, Mark Ruffalo's rendition of the Jade Giant was a wonderful blend of playfulness and savagery. This version of the Hulk was the most realized version seen in theatres; easily beating out Eric Bana's Shrek doppelganger and Edward Norton's poorly rendered CG beast in both expressiveness and screen presence.

Advertisement

It certainly helped that this version of Hulk visually resembled Ruffalo's Bruce Banner, giving audiences a never before seen emotional tether to the man beneath the beast. Ruffalo one-upped his predecessors by voicing Hulk as well, alongside the OG version of the character, Lou Ferrigno.

Thor: Ragnarok, Avengers: Infinity War and Avengers: Endgame saw the Strongest Avenger (sorry, Thor fans) really come into his own as a fully fleshed out character. Ruffalo was given more free rein to express himself through the CG coating and take the character to new heights and urgency in terms of storytelling and character development.

This growth is owed to The 'Professor Hulk' persona; an inspired direction to take the character in.

8. Benedict Cumberbatch As Smaug (The Hobbit Trilogy)

The Hobbit Trilogy was an unworthy successor (or predecessor?) to the groundbreaking Lord of the Rings trilogy. It was bloated, uninspired and uncomfortable to look at due to the choice to film it in 48 frames per second; giving the film an ugly sheen that lacked the tangibility and realism of what came before.

Advertisement

That said, arguably one of the trilogy's redeeming features was the giant dragon Smaug, wonderfully played by Benedict Cumberbatch. Aside from Martin Freeman's Bilbo, Smaug seemed to be the one character given any kind of effort and thought to realize. The VFX used to bring Smaug to life was cutting-edge but Cumberbatch really brought his A-game to the film.

He imbued Smaug with a booming voice that was the right blend of regal and hammy, and his dynamic facial expressions were flawlessly translated to Smaug's own visage. What really elevated Smaug though, was his sense of pride and greed, traits that Cumberbatch perfectly encapsulated. The dragon saw himself above everything else and was fiercely protective of his belongings; qualities that are seen throughout the Middle Earth saga.

7. Rosa Salazar As Alita (Alita: Battle Angel)

Alita: Battle Angel was one of 2019's most pleasant surprises, exceeding (admittedly low) expectations and delivered the requisite blockbuster thrills, stunning visuals and a sense of fun rarely seen in movies of its kind these days.

Advertisement

The glue holding the film's seams together was the titular character, infused with charm, innocence, and strength by the capable Rosa Salazar. The anime-inspired eyes were first seen as a dangerous dip into the uncanny valley, but they seamlessly blend into the cyberpunk world created in the film.

Salazar gives Alita a wonderful sense of innocence, grace, and strength, not unlike the titular heroine in 2017's Wonder Woman. Her amnesia lets her act as the audience surrogate as we discover the wonders and threats of Iron City and Zalem alongside her.

Her portrayal convincingly sells the fact that Alita can adorably fawn over an orange and yet go toe-to-toe with highly advanced killer cyborg gladiator in the deadly Motorball tournaments and come out on top.

6. Andy Serkis As Kong (King Kong)

Peter Jackson's 2005 King Kong remake may not have lived up to its lofty expectations, but it was a passable action film anchored by a larger than life performance from the great Andy Serkis, proving that he was the go-to actor to give compelling motion-capture performances.

Advertisement

The film was notable for its ground-breaking achievement in hair and skin simulations on CG creations, and it resulted in Kong becoming a lot more tangible and grounded compared to some of his digital contemporaries. In addition to the revolutionary means of conveying texture on a VFX heavy character, this version of Kong was the first motion-capture performance that heavily benefitted from performance capture markers on the actor's face. These markers gave the VFX team plenty of expressions to work with.

Of course, the technical wizardry would not be complete without Serkis' wonderful acting. He captured Kong's savagery, imbued him with an almost regal nature befitting his moniker and an innocence whenever he interacted with Naomi Watts' vaudeville performer, Ann Darrow.

5. Bill Nighy As Davy Jones (Pirates Of The Caribbean)

By far and large Pirates of the Carribean franchise's greatest villain, Davy Jones was brought to life by sinister and spectacular fashion by the talented Bill Nighy as well as Oscar-winning visual effects work done by Industrial Lights and Magic (ILM). The VFX work was so well done that a handful of reviewers mistakenly assumed that the effects work was practical in nature.

Advertisement

His cephalopod and crustacean-inspired design was a suitable fit for the maritime theme of the franchise, but Nighy's formidable screen presence (as well as outstanding effects work) really gave the villain gravitas and tangibility, even when proceedings in the movies got decidedly more outlandish.

Nighy imbued Jones with memorable characteristics such as a thick Scottish accent (to account for his lack of a nasal cavity) and his eyes were used in the character's final design for effective expressiveness as well as giving the character the proper lighting in various scenes.

4. Zoe Saldana As Neytiri (Avatar)

James Cameron's Avatar may have been seen as lacking in imaginative storytelling and relatable character development, but its groundbreaking effects work, well-crafted visuals and immersive worldbuilding were more than enough to carry the film to box office success. Despite the seeming emphasis on the film's visuals and technical prowess, the film had a solid number of performances, chief among them Zoe Saldana's Neytiri.

Advertisement

The Na'vi princess is imbued with warmth, strength and grace courtesy of Saldana's considerable talent. She gave the film an added human touch that was lacking in the majority of the human cast, particularly Sam Worthington's bland Jake Sully.

Saldana's efforts were greatly assisted by the always reliable WETA Digital, ILM and Cameron's own innovation. The most notable innovation from the film was the development of skull caps with specially designed cameras that capture the actor's full range of facial expressions and emotions and then transfer them to the actor's digital double.

3. Josh Brolin As Thanos (Marvel Cinematic Universe)

Josh Brolin gave life to the MCU's long-awaited Big Bad in a performance that was an inspired blend of gravitas, menace and a dash of humanity that grounded the cosmic conqueror in the conclusion to Marvel's Infinity Saga. Brolin expertly sold the physical presence needed to justify Thanos as the biggest threat the MCU heroes have ever faced, from his imposing stature, near-unstoppable might (even without the power of the Infinity Gauntlet) and resonant vocals that were both equal parts soothing and sinister.

Advertisement

Backing Brolin's performance was state of the art effects and well-done writing by the Marvel creative team. The ever-reliable ILM and Weta Digital (as well as other companies) pushed the envelope in photo-realistic CG imagery for Infinity War and Endgame, giving Thanos a tangibility that most comic book villains brought to life with CGI simply lack.

In addition to the onscreen talents, Thanos was well developed and fully realized despite having less than two movies of screen-time (not counting cameos). He had an undeniably flawed plan but it was borne out of an understandable place and this gave him a strong arc that cemented his place as one of the all-time villain greats.

2. Andy Serkis As Gollum/Smeagol (Middle Earth Franchise)

The brilliance behind this dual performance saw motion-capture performances as legitimate film performances and works of art. Andy Serkis elevated the corrupted Hobbit through a performance that was a masterclass combination of being jittery, sympathetic, threatening and scared all at the time.

Advertisement

Motion capture technology was in its infancy at this time and as a result, key elements such as facial dots and in-studio acting were still a few years out. However, the limitations of the day did not stop Serkis, Peter Jackson and the capable team of WETA Digital from bringing Gollum to life. The VFX team pushed the envelope in creating a palpable character and Serkis gave him idiosyncratic movements and conversational tics that are fodder for many impressionists to this day.

Serkis was able to bring his A-game to the Hobbit trilogy and never missed a step in his performance, even when the rest of the films faltered in a variety of ways.

1. Andy Serkis As Caesar (Fox's Planet Of The Apes Trilogy)

Andy "Give him his Oscar already!!" Serkis' Caesar is arguably the most realized motion-capture performance in film history. Caesar had the benefit of cutting edge VFX to create a palpable and weighty character with considerable screen presence. That said, another reason behind the success is due to Andy Serkis' excellent performance and Matt Reeves and Ruper Wyatt's capable direction.

Advertisement

We are first introduced to Caesar in Rise of the Planet of the Apes and we see his growth from a precocious gene-enhanced infant who sees firsthand how cruel (and caring) humans can be and this informs his decision to become an ape resistance leader who leads his species to dominance in Dawn of the Planet of the Apes.

However, he is given a series of layers and complexity that enables him to understand the fight for dominance is a complicated struggle that has heroes and villains on both sides. He ultimately becomes a martyr and inspiration for a new generation of apes that may be free of the conflict that took so much away from them. Serkis really gives it his all in a performance that transcends its (perceived) digital limitations and gives Caesar a spot in the annals of great film protagonists.

Advertisement