Back when An Unexpected Journey came out to mixed reviews, its defenders were keen to point out that it was merely the first in a three-part story and you couldn't condemn The Hobbit until it was over. After all, people didn't judge the whole The Lord Of The Rings trilogy on The Fellowship Of The Ring, did they? Well, yes they did - the first film was nominated for thirteen Oscars, including Best Picture - but humouring them people patiently waited to see how things transpired. Now, with the whole thing complete, it's totally acceptable to pass judgement. And boy were people right the first time around - The Hobbit is a bloated mess. Sure, there's the kernel of a good idea in there, but through a string of terrible production decisions it's lost in a greed that makes dragon sickness look like the flu. With his Star Wars prequels George Lucas failed to recapture the magic of the originals, but Peter Jackson went one worse with The Hobbit; he actively tried to copy his own previous work and failed embarrassingly. That's right - The Hobbit is worse than The Phantom Menace. And here are the ten biggest reasons why.
Honourable Mention - The Extra Material
When someone lists problems with The Hobbit, you can bet the amount of embellishment what is essentially a children's book has received will be there. On top of teasing out every possible event from the novel itself, the films have had copious subplots from The Return Of The King appendices and Peter Jackson's fevered brain thrown in for good measure. But don't forget that The Lord Of The Rings changed things up a fair bit in its transition to screen, cutting major parts (the Scouring of the Shire) and greatly expanding others (Aragorn and Arwen's relationship), and it worked perfectly well. The cases where it doesn't in The Hobbit (the entire character of Tauriel winds up being completely pointless) are less a issue with the notion of new material, and more to do with it being the product of greater problems, hence why it doesn't make the list proper.
10. Splitting It In Three
Let's get the most obvious point out of the way first. The Hobbit is a single narrative and, while it is incredibly episodic, it doesn't merit an annual pause to take in the basic plot. Ignoring the effects of it becoming a mammoth trilogy, simply having it be three movies is a fundamental flaw; there's a solid three hour movie hidden in there just begging for a fan-edit. No individual Hobbit movie has its own enclosed story, making the whole thing feels painfully disjointed - a TV miniseries released in a bizarre manner. An Unexpected Journey is a film with countless beginnings, The Desolation Of Smaug is a never-ending middle and The Battle Of The Five Armies is a protracted end. This could work when presented in one go, but over three years it's ponderous. Compare this to the original trilogy, where each movie left you with a sense of satisfaction. The original plan since early in pre-production was to have two films, with one telling most of the story (probably up to Smaug) and the second tying the events into The Lord Of The Rings (Dol Guldur, the Battle of the Five Armies and beyond), and while it started the journey from the sheer logic of The Hobbit being one film, it's not really a terrible idea. Things changed through the movies' development, but up until the decision to make a trilogy, the multi-movie concept was still pretty solid. During shooting, the intended bridge point was going to be just after the barrel sequence, with the introduction of Bard. Now that kinda makes sense - you have one movie where the dwarves amble through the inconsequential adventures, then a second that draws the whole thing into the broader scope and traditional epic action of Middle-Earth; narrative cohesion in both individual entries and the broader scope.
9. Unnecessary CGI
There's a lot of CGI in The Hobbit, plain and simple. That isn't in and of itself a big issue - don't forget that a lot of The Lord Of The Rings, particularly the latter two movies, had copious moments of (now obvious) computer enhancement. The problem with Weta's effects in the prequel trilogy is that they're used to the nth degree when it's all rather unnecessary. Minas Tirith, Helms Deep et al were achieved by a mix of gargantuan miniatures (affectionately nicknamed bigatures by their creators), life-size sets and visual enhancement, but for The Hobbit the likes of Goblin Town and Thranduil's castle were all just built in a computer. Sure, some sets were built (see Laketown), but there was so much CG augmentation it was almost a fools errand. Add to it that the effects aren't as photo-realistic as Jackson appears to think and you've got something that doesn't look too dissimilar from a Shadow Of Mordor cutscene. Most egregious is that in several cases practical effects were actually done over with computer effects, probably because they now stood out against the flawed realism of the CGI. Bolg, the main goblin antagonist in the book, here reduced to snarling henchman to father Azog, was originally going to feature one of the series most inventive orc designs (above left), but come the finished film this was tempered to a poorly executed computer version (sigh, above right). For a series made famous for its incredible location shots and faithful realism, this world-building is more on the visual level of Minecraft.
8. The Action Is Over The Top And Threatless
Some of the most lambasted moments of The Lord Of The Rings are Legolas' shows of spirit-like agility; riding a shield in Helm's Deep and bringing down a massive oliphant with a couple of arrows on Pelennor Fields. So why the decision was made for this, rather than the immeasurable moments of believable, gritty action, to be used as the template for The Hobbit's fight scenes is down-right ridiculous. The elves appear to be in an endless conflict of one-upmanship, their fighting style so flawlessly agile it's a wonder any of them ever die in combat, while the dwarves get through deadly scrapes with laughably contrived luck. Not only does it feel distinctly unreal, making the sequences feel like glorified Let's Play videos, over three films it manages to suck out any sense of awe it may have had. Legolas felling a giant Mumakil was incredible, but when every single fight has him performing increasingly unbelievable feats of "skill" there's nothing to get excited about. The series had already pushed the limits of indestructible heroes, with death fake-outs an oddly common occurrence in the originals, but in The Hobbit death is never even threatened (until it becomes narratively necessary) - it's impossible to get invested in the threat when the heroes appear to be protected from deadly falls by some invisible force field.
7. The Desolation Of Smaug's Cliffhanger
In making a single story into three movies, one of the biggest hurdles is finding a suitable point to end each installment. Both The Hunger Games and Harry Potter chose to embellish minor plot points (Peeta's brain-washing and Dobby's death) for their two-part final entries, but The Hobbit doesn't go for anything so creative; the story just stops. An Unexpected Journey ended only in the technical sense - there's nary an attempt as resolution - but with The Desolation Of Smaug Jackson made a creative decision that hurts the entire trilogy, particularly now the grand picture can be seen. The second film ends with Smaug confronting the dwarf company, after which, realising they were aided by the men of Laketown, he sets off to bring down fiery revenge upon them. It's a stark cliffhanger that certainly makes you want to come back for the resolution, but having seen the pay-off it's clear the ending was woefully misplaced. Smaug's decimation of Laketown is little more than the prologue for The Battle Of The Five Armies, revealing Desolation's cut to black as little more than a cheap, TV-style, marketing trick. Chucking out some of the fan-fiction love story or the not-in-the-book forge set piece and instead having Bard fell the beast at the end of the second movie would have lent the final two films their own sense of narrative cohesion and removed that distinct sense of disappointment.
6. Indistinguishable Dwarves
Near the end of The Battle Of The Five Armies, a departing Bilbo tells Balin (the old dwarf) to pass his regards on to the rest of the company, only for the white-haired dwarf (that's his one distinguishing character trait) to reveal the gang you've got to know and love over the past three years are all here. Bilbo turns around, and... it's a sea of unrecognisable faces. It's hard not to laugh as you realise the only vaguely memorable dwarves (the leader, the one who doesn't look like a dwarf so he can fall in love, the one who doesn't look like a dwarf's brother) have been killed off, leaving a menagerie of characters who, after spending nine hours with, you know nothing about. To be fair to the films, in Tolkien's novel the dwarves aren't exactly given much in the way of personality, with only Thorin gifted any sort of arc. The problem is that there's clearly been some effort put in to make them a bit more interesting for the screen. If they'd just been treated as indistinguishable chaps, that'd have been fine, but with each given semi-distinct looks and multiple roll-call scenes, it strikes of a failed attempt to mimic the Fellowship. That Jackson so competently made not only the nine brooch-wearers, but also the wide supporting cast of the original trilogy, uniquely memorable makes this particularly disappointing - he should be able to make you care for thirteen dwarves in his sleep.
5. The Length Of Each Movie
Someone needs to get Peter Jackson a new editor, because Jabez Olssen, his current collaborator, doesn't appear to have even a vague understanding of acceptable film length. Since The Lord Of The Rings, every one of Jackson's films has been noticeably too long - King Kong was almost double the length of the original and The Lovely Bones bloated a hundred-minute thriller with numerous hollow effects shots - but things went way too far with The Hobbit. On top of not having little in the way of stand-alone narrative, the individual movies are bladder-bustingly long. The Hobbit is a children's book shorter than any one of the three volumes of The Lord Of The Rings, and yet has been made into a film series that runs only an hour and a half shorter. Isn't that the most ridiculous base statistic that highlights just how far from the original idea The Hobbit movies got? Had they each ran ninety minutes there'd have been the question of why not just make one film, but at least all of the stuff included would have been justified and the overall experience would have been much less ponderous. Do you need a dwarf washing up song? Do you you need to have a mythology-breaking dwarf/elf love story? Do you need the big climax to spend half its time on Legolas playing Mario? Of course you bloody don't. The Lord Of The Rings movies each circled the three-hour mark, but there the material was so dense it was the only way to do it justice.
4. They Were Made With The Extended Editions In Mind
Talk to a Tolkien fan and odds are they won't even accept the theatrical versions of The Lord Of The Rings; the Extended Editions are so comprehensively awesome die-hards view them as the definitive version of the films. Made following the movies' theatrical successes, these longer cuts were of incredibly high quality (they were even rescored) and brought a lot of extra material to light. Naturally it was only really to be expected that The Hobbit would get the same treatment. In fact, it was so expected that Peter Jackson made his theatrical versions with the explicit intention of making a director's cut a year later. Whereas The Lord Of The Rings' longer cuts were made of footage too heavy in lore or plot-inessential to be included first time round, with The Hobbit Jackson purposely left out scenes just to please the fans come the Extended Edition. Which sounds fair enough, but when what's cut is more interesting than what's left in, it's pretty damaging, leading to films that are only offering some of their riches. The Extended Editions for both An Unexpected Journey and The Desolation Of Smaug are, despite their added length, better versions of the films and much more invested in achieving the director's vision. The dwarves are given more screen-time, each feeling a little more unique, and the second film offers up some major plot details - Smaug is already in league with the Necromancer. We'll take that over cartoony Laketown politics any day of the week.
3. Turning Quiet Moments Into Epic Action Set Pieces
In Tolkien's The Hobbit, the dwarves escape the elf prison by hiding in barrels that discreetly wash them down the river to Laketown. In Jackson's The Hobbit: The Desolation Of Smaug, they loudly leave, alerting the elven guards just as a gang of orcs also on their trail try and cut them off. What follows is a raging rapids action sequence of ever escalating action beats. Just as subtlety is a secondary concern for the whole cinematic Hobbit enterprise, so is not fighting for the characters. Whenever there's an opportunity for a big action set piece in the films, you can bet Jackson will throw it in. Obviously, as discussed earlier, these scenes lack any discernible tension, but as they're entirely fabricated for the screen, there's also no narrative drive to them either - once one starts you an basically switch off and miss nothing. Heck, The Battle of the Five Armies all happens off screen in the book - Bilbo's knocked out at the very start. By far the worst example of this is the foundry fight at the end of The Desolation Of Smaug. In the book the dwarves never come face to face with the fire-breathing lodger. Instead, the entire sequence is just a lengthy conversation between Bilbo and Smaug, with the latter finally getting riled up to the point he fancies visiting Laketown. Clearly included only to give the artificially constructed second movie an action finale, the sloppiness of the editing - the fight merely punctuates Bilbo and Smaug's confrontation, with all the motivation towards dragon's decision to actually attack the humans coming from their interplay - makes the sequence's superfluousness painfully obvious.
2. Heavy Handed The Lord Of The Rings References
Did you know The Hobbit is a prequel to The Lord Of The Rings? Well don't worry if you didn't - it's going to go out of its way to remind you. Oh look, it's Frodo in the opening. And he's going to go to go meet Gandalf - geddit, it's the start of The Fellowship Of The Ring? And here's Saruman acting all grumpy and evil despite not being evil yet. Oh, and here's Gollum being bi-poplar. And look, a cameo from Legolas that for some reason goes on for two movies - was everyone too awkward to tell Orlando Bloom he could go home? It's any wonder there's any time for Bilbo Baggins' adventures with all the shoe-horned nudging Jackson's forced into the movies. The Battle Of The Five Armies looked like it was going to avoid most of this, but come the final minutes it goes for broke. Thranduil basically looks at the camera and winks when telling Legolas to go find a ranger named Strider (duh, wonder who that could be), while ending the whole trilogy on a call-back to first film highlights just how much The Hobbit exists in The Lord Of The Rings' shadow. Putting the continuity breaking issues aside (why does Gandalf have to run off to research Sauron after seeing the One Ring in Fellowship when he's come face-to-face with him earlier?), it's just all so heavy handed - what should be geektastic moments become insufferable, eye-rolling scenes. References to the modern classics is fine, particularly given the attempts to greater tie what is traditionally a stand-alone novel into a wider plot, but done in such obvious ways reveals there's little on offer in the new trilogy beyond nostalgia.
1. Letting Guillermo Del Toro Go
See that. That weird, unique design that looks like a mesh of The Lord Of The Rings and Pan's Labyrinth? That's the original design for Smaug. Yeah, seriously. Originally Guillermo del Toro was set to be the director of The Hobbit duology, set to deliver a take on the book that, while set in the same world as Jackson's The Lord Of The Rings, would be stylistically distinct. What concept art has been revealed looks incredible, while his story divide (the aforementioned two-parter, with the first telling the bulk of the story and second filling in the gaps between books) would have been much more narratively satisfying. Sadly, as the whole process stretched out longer and longer (without a studio giving a green-light), he jumped ship to work on his own projects, leaving his take to the realms of "what if's". Del Toro's departure not only robbed fans of a worthy Hobbit, but it also set in motion the events that made many of the issues talked about earlier. You see, Peter Jackson didn't have much of an interest in bringing The Hobbit to life, but a lengthy pre-production period meant he had no choice in the matter. He had to make them or risk losing a lot of money, leading to a bunch of decisions (splitting it in three, cliffhanger endings, holding content back for double-dip home video releases) that have had a major impact on the films' ultimate quality. Anyone for a reboot? What were your thoughts on The Hobbit Trilogy as whole? Did The Battle Of The Five Armies expertly round it off, or merely reaffirm how messy the enterprise was? Have your say down in the comments.