The term "movie flop" tends to be synonymous with that of "absolutely terrible," because good movies don't flop at the box office, do they? Despite the fact that the majority of movies that fail to gross back their budgets when they're realised in theatres are truly awful, there are a few motion pictures out there that flopped regardless of their quality - simply because they were marketed wrong, or because everybody in the world happened to be busy on that particular weekend, or for reasons that are unexplainable, but not - as many believe - because they really sucked. So join us here as we take a look at 10 movies that all flopped at the box office and failed to recuperate their losses - some well-known, some you might never have even heard of. What's important is that all the movies here are genuinely worth your time, despite the fact that they were considered poison to the studios that decided to green-light them. The emphasise here falls on the idea that a movie can be ignored by the general public and branded a massive flop even if it's good - though "flop" generally denotes an inferior product, it isn't actually always the case...
10. Final Fantasy: The Spirits Within
The most common complaint regarding Final Fantasy: The Spirits Within seemed to be: "It has nothing to do with Final Fantasy," which is an understandable criticism, but one that doesn't really ring true. Final Fantasy games, after all, are mostly single entities - with every new game, there's a new world, new characters, and a new story; there are staples of the series that reoccur throughout, of course, but generally speaking, with every added Roman numeral, the playing field gets reset. Perhaps it's just that Final Fantasy: The Spirits Within was too darn weird? Or was it that the Final Fantasy fanbase just wasn't big enough? Either way, this insanely expensive $137 million dollar animated movie grossed just half its budget back at the box office. Whereas many wrote off its story as dull and generic, they complimented the breathing-taking visuals. But there's more to this movie that meets the eye; not only did it raise the bar for the "photorealistic CG movie," the action scenes are stunning and mesmerising, the spiritual themes both timely and moving. If it's bewildering, then it's also a picture in need of multiple viewings.
9. Hugo
Martin Scorsese's first foray into the realms of children's films cost an arm and a leg to produce, mainly thanks to the progressive, swooping 3D effects that dominated the picture from start to finish, and 'cause CGI is expensive! Though critical reviews for Hugo were strong - audience reaction seemed to be more or less split down the middle - it failed to make much of a killing at the box office, grossing a mere $185 million on a $170 million budget. What happened? Did parents see Martin Scorsese's name on the marketing and assume there would be bloodshed? More likely, word of mouth got around that Hugo was a fairly complicated picture - Scorsese mines the history of cinema to tell the story of a boy who lives in a Parisian railway station, after all, and there are peppered references to Georges Méliès and the Lumière brothers scattered throughout. Hugo isn't a film without flaws - it's too long, for one - but there's magic to be had here, perhaps more so for adults who have the same appreciation for cinematic history as Scorsese does. Even for 3D-haters the world over (and there are lots), it's a trip worth taking.
8. Lolita (1997)
Vladimir Nabakov's most famous novel has twice been adapted to film, the most famous version helmed by Stanley Kubrick. But whereas that '60s telling of the tale aged Lolita up and emphasised the more humorous aspects of the book, Adrian Lyne's 1997 adaptation - starring Jeremy Irons as charismatic pervert Humbert Humbert, no less - made no attempt to play down the sexuality. It's true that both versions excel in their different ways, but fail equally in their attempts to nail the tone of Nabakov's book because they stray to far one way or the other. Kubrick's version was a hit at the box office, of course, whereas Lyne's plummeted - with a budget of $62 million dollars, it made just $1 million. The problem likely stemmed from the fact that the highly "inappropriate" film - with its pedophile plottings - scared audiences away in its strive for realism; the movie had trouble finding a distributor, flopped, and has been relatively forgotten ever since. But there's no denying that there's a strange, bold power to this overtly "romanticised" version; the performance are wonderful (Dominique Swain is arguably the perfect Lolita), the cinematography dreamlike and hazy, and Ennio Morricone's soundtrack is haunting.
7. Speed Racer
With their notoriously panned and hated upon follow up to The Matrix Revolutions, Speed Racer, the Wachowski siblings set out to do one thing: craft a movie that looked and felt like an anime cartoon. Say what you will about its unrelenting hyperactivity, wacky characters, and questionable story, then, but that's exactly what they achieved. So, of course, Speed Racer flopped at the box office - the source material, after all, wasn't familiar enough to western audiences, the lead actor was Emile Hirsch, and - viewed in trailer form - the movie looked super incomprehensible. Critics panned Speed Racer for its "headache-inducing special effects," as if that wasn't the point: watching Speed Racer is like being shrunk down, forced inside a bubblegum machine, and drip-fed LCD. If anime were rendered real, after all, this is probably what it would look like. The most criminally neglected aspect of Speed Racer, however, is in its willingness to embrace innocence; it's an adrenaline-fueled ride that appeals to our inherent childlike sense of adventure and wonder. And coated beneath all those layers of sugar, there's actually a lot heart here, too.
6. Treasure Planet
The early 2000s wasn't a great period for Walt Disney Pictures - though there were underrated classics like Lilo & Stitch and The Emperor's New Groove, there were also underwhelming efforts like Atlantis: The Lost Empire and Dinosaur, which paled in comparison to recent '90s gems like Hercules, Mulan, and Tarzan. Treasure Planet was the only movie from Disney's dodgy early 2000s disaster period that failed to make its budget back, though: it grossed just $110 million against a cost of $140 million, marking it out as the House of Mouse's first big flop in a long time. Which, quite frankly, is a sad state of affairs, given just how creative and brilliant Treasure Planet really is. A sci-fi retelling of Robert Louis Stevenson's classic novel, Treasure Island, it's still a mystery as to what, exactly, turned audiences away from this relentless, visually stunning vision of the future (though the likelihood is that Pixar were dominating the scene with CGI-rendered films, whilst Disney clung to traditional animation - people wanted different). But Treasure Planet is funny, has great characters, and includes some of the best set-pieces Disney have ever drawn.
5. Beloved
Based on the novel by Toni Morrison and directed by Jonathan Demme (perhaps best known for helming the likes of Silence of the Lambs), Beloved is a sort of dramatic horror movie set just after the Civil War - one that has been largely forgotten. Starring Oprah Winfrey, it runs at 171 minutes: is there any wonder as to why this might've not been pulling audiences into theatres in their masses? Beloved cost a whopping $80 million to put together, grossed only $22 million, but was well-received by critics, despite the fact that not a lot of people went to see it. Or did they? "Beloved only played in theaters for four weeks," said Jonathan Demme on the matter. "It made $22 million dollar - I think that's a lot of money." According to Demme, Disney wanted the theatres for Adam Sandler's The Waterboy, and proposed to bring back Beloved at the end of the year, but didn't bother. The failure of the movie apparently sent Oprah into a depression, but she should rest assured that there's nothing wrong with the product itself: Beloved is packed with wonderful performances, is creepy, strange and cerebral, and is absolutely beautiful to look at.
4. The Adventures Of Baron Munchausen
Terry Gilliam's often nauseatingly quirkly filmic ventures aren't to everybody's taste, which is why The Adventures of Baron Munchausen - his follow-up to the most beloved (but also flopping) Brazil - failed to make any money at the box office: presumably the downright surreal premise - which concerned the exploits of an 18th century German nobleman - was enough to steer people away. Despite the fact that it grossed just $8 million on a $43 million dollar budget, though, The Adventures of Baron Munchausen is one of Gilliam's best and most accomplished films. Alas, for some reason the solid critical reviews failed to inspire people to leave their houses, but there was another comprising factor as to why The Adventures of Baron Munchausen did so little box office business: it was released on a very limited scale, having suffered through a change of CEOs at Columbia, who had distribution rights. The production process was notoriously catastrophic, of course, which seems to be common fare when Terry Gilliam is in charge. Regardless, this is a brilliantly inventive and absurdly creative film from start to finish.
3. The Assassination Of Jesse James By The Coward Robert Ford
You'd have thought that Brad Pitt could have have sold any movie, even a low-key western that opts to give its ending away in the title - and yet The Assassination of Jesse James By The Coward Robert Ford failed to recuperate anywhere near its $30 million budget, proving that the public's appetite for slow, mediative and endlessly melancholic westerns wasn't quite there... even if Brad Pitt was the star! Despite it status as a well-known flop, however, Jesse James is one of the finest westerns in recent years - lagging pace and forced romanticism aside. What's mostly great about The Assassination of Jesse James is its realism - the wild west myth is deconstructed, as it has been so many times, but there's a lingering emphasise on accuracy, be it in the gunfights (people shooting at each other constantly miss, due to the badly-designed nature of the guns), or the lacking sense of bravado one might associate with "fun" westerns starring John Wayne. But it makes sense that this flopped; it's a difficult film, one unlikely to generate word of mouth buzz like other modern westerns such as Django Unchained.
2. Grindhouse
For a lot of movie buffs, there is no concept more exciting than a "grindhouse-inspired double bill; two movies directed by Quentin Tarantino and Robert Rodriguez shown back to back, with fake trailers inserted inbetween." And yet, for some reason, this mouthwatering experiment - despite clinging to marketing campaigns that made sure to emphasise Tarantino's name - was ignored when it was released, pulling in a pathetic $25 million on a $53 million dollar budget. A shame, since the actual "experience" of watching Grindhouse in a theatre is yet to be matched. The idea is inherently appealing, of course, but the results were equally brilliant: Rodriguez's Planet Terror is manic, zombie fun, whilst Tarantino captures the Giallo movie style in his cash crash slasher, Death Proof. Was it the 191 minute running time that put people off? Was it the Easter weekend release date? Viewed separately, these movies lose their impact somewhat; they belong together. "It was disappointing, yeah. But the movie worked with the audience," said Tarantino. "People who saw it loved it and applauded. I'm proud of my flop." And so he should be.
1. Heaven's Gate
The nightmarish shoot for Michael Cimino's follow-up to the Oscar-winning behemoth that was The Deer Hunter is famous for the fact that it brought an entire movie studio - United Artists - down to its knees, forcing closure. So on Heaven's Gate, a slow, picturesque western concerning land barons and European immigrants at the turn of the 20th century, the production was littered with bad press, budget inflation (it swelled to four times its original cost), unrelenting conflict - most of which stemmed from Michael Cimino's strive for perfectionism and refusal to give in. At the time of its release, Heaven's Gate was destroyed by the critics - Roger Ebert famously branded it as "the most scandalous cinematic waste ever seen." At a cost of $44 million, it grossed a mere $3 million, and for many years was hailed as the greatest catastrophe to have occurred in Hollywood history. Somewhere in the mid to late '90s, however, Cimino's picture was subjected to an unexpected reassessment; beneath the lavish runtime people suddenly saw a movie of great beauty, intelligence and - would you believe it? - downright genius . Michael Cinimo's notorious box office bomb isn't the worst film ever made, nor does it come close. In fact, there's enough ground here to argue that Heaven's Gate - despite its flaws - is a more accomplished picture than The Deer Hunter: there are wonderful performances; scenes of exquisite beauty and sadness; the cinematography is haunting. And Cimino crafts his movie like a great painter - with careful brushstrokes, each one clearly studied and yet natural in composition. It's probably true, then, that that initial negative press influenced the original critical reviews to a fair degree - what we have here is a box office bomb that also happens to be a masterpiece. Like this article? Agree or disagree? Let us know in the comments section below.