10 DCEU Characters That Are Nothing Like The Comics

For better and for worse.

By Jack Pooley /

Warner Bros. & DC

If the Marvel Cinematic Universe has proven anything over the last decade, it's that you don't need to stick slavishly to the source material in order to make the big bucks and keep comic book fans satisfied. Hell, the MCU has become iconic enough to actually influence the comics themselves.

Advertisement

Sadly the DC Extended Universe hasn't had quite such a fruitful time, with the seven movies to date varying wildly in quality while failing to convey a consistent tone or aesthetic across the board.

And as such, fans have proven themselves a lot less amenable to some of the more daring changes Zack Snyder and co. have made to certain DC heroes and villains.

Advertisement

While the DCEU has borrowed liberally from The New 52 incarnations of numerous front-line characters - especially Wonder Woman - it's also safe to say that Snyder has bet the house on some pretty bold reinterpretations of comic book icons.

But to be clear, though each of these movie characters doesn't much resemble their most popular and iconic iteration from the page, they're not all bad, and one of them even miraculously fixed the iffy reputation of a most-troubled superhero.

Advertisement

Yet sadly not all changes were quite this persuasive, and the deviations from decades of comic book history haven't always been for the best...

10. The Joker

Warner Bros. & DC

The Joker is without question the most iconic villain in all of DC media, be they comics or movies, and time has certainly proven how many distinct and divergent iterations of the Clown Prince of Crime will be embraced by fans.

Advertisement

Yet fans almost immediately balked at the first glimpses of Jared Leto's Joker in Suicide Squad, deterred by the character's Edgy-with-a-capital-E design above all else.

The tatted-up, grill-wearing "Hot Topic Gangsta" couldn't be much further from his traditional comic book aesthetic, lacking the iconic purple coat and better resembling a contemporary mobster with a few distinctive Joker-y flourishes.

Advertisement

But honestly, fans probably would've dealt with this fine enough if the characterisation felt even remotely consistent with what was expected.

Leto certainly tried to convey the character's frayed sanity with the scarce screen time he had, but strip away the eccentric design and his character is mostly just a money-hungry gangster like you'd see in any garden variety crime thriller.

Advertisement

Furthermore, his oddly earnest affection for Harley Quinn (Margot Robbie) rings mostly false given the knowingly toxic nature of their relationship in prior animated and comic book iterations.

It's fair to say that Leto's Joker does borrow superficial elements from various comic books - the tattoos being very Frank Miller, for instance - but in trying to reinvent the character in a post-Dark Knight world, Leto and writer-director David Ayer may have strayed too far from his roots.

Advertisement

9. Superman

Warner Bros. & DC

Batman (Ben Affleck) may be a shameless killer in the DCEU, but he still feels like he captures enough of the Caped Crusader's mood and philosophy to be workable, albeit through an extremely radical lens.

Advertisement

The same sadly hasn't proven true of Superman (Henry Cavill) so far, who despite a solid effort from Henry Cavill in the role, has been the DCEU's most high-profile misfire.

In the comics and also in basically every popular movie and TV adaptation, Superman has been an optimistic, chisel-jawed beacon of hope for Metropolis and the world. This is supposed to make him a perfect mirror to the darker-inclined Batman.

Advertisement

And while Superman's DCEU debut, Man of Steel, saw Zack Snyder promising a gritty, Dark Knight-esque take on the character, he ultimately made the fatal mistake of transforming both Clark Kent and Supes into joyless dullards.

Cavill's Superman suit actually looks pretty terrific, and he certainly nails the physical requirements of the role, but many fans took umbrage with Supes allowing so much collateral damage to take place in the film's third act, rather than, as in the comics, finding a way to keep public harm to a minimum.

Advertisement

Snyder at least seemed to take the criticism to heart and indicated that Batman v Superman would address the issue of Superman being party to Metropolis' destruction, yet he ultimately ended up doubling down on the misery.

In this movie, Clark and Supes are both painfully boring mopes who spend their entire screen time either listlessly contemplating their place in the world or punching things.

Advertisement

Where is the charm? Where is the heroism? Batman v Superman could've course-corrected Man of Steel's dodgy characterisation by focusing on Superman saving normal people and, you know, smiling every now and then.

Instead, Clark is clearly still haunted by the more morally dubious lessons imparted to him by his father Jonathan (Kevin Costner), and it's just a bore to watch.

Advertisement

Justice League finally seemed to be steering the character in the right direction by leaning into his more classically heroic attributes...in the final 15 minutes of the movie. Plus, the whole digital jaw debacle made it tough to take Supes seriously.

As disappointing as it is to hear rumours about Henry Cavill being done with Superman, on the flip side hitting the reset button on one of comic lore's most iconic heroes isn't such a bad idea.

Advertisement

8. Lex Luthor

Warner Bros. & DC

As wildly divisive as the DCEU's versions of The Joker and Superman have been, none have received quite the near-universal scorn from fans as Jessie Eisenberg's Lex Luthor.

Advertisement

In the comics, Luthor is most recognisably a mega-rich, ultra-intelligent megalomaniac with a God complex, who upon seeing Superman as an obstacle to his global dominion, plots to take the Man of Steel out.

Though some basic aspects of the popular comic book Luthor do remain - he's rich, smart, crazy and hates Superman - Zack Snyder and co. otherwise revised the character to reflect more contemporary visions of "villainy."

Advertisement

It goes without saying that Eisenberg's casting is no coincidence, and was an attempt by Snyder to lean into the smooth-talking, young hotshot tech billionaires who own the halls of Silicon Valley these days - a reprise of Eisenberg's rendition of Mark Zuckerberg in The Social Network, to a point.

Batman v Superman introduced Lex as all of these things but also physically diminutive, not particularly handsome and touting a ghastly head of greasy hair.

Advertisement

These ideas weren't inherently bad by any means, but what truly turned many fans off was Eisenberg's twitchy, high-pitched, rodent-like performance as the character.

A Luthor who went full dweeb just wasn't what people wanted to see, and it was a far cry from even the more out-there comic book renditions of the supervillain.

Advertisement

7. Jimmy Olsen

Warner Bros. & DC

You'd be forgiven for not even realising that Jimmy Olsen has appeared in the DCEU to date, but back in the early Africa sequence of Batman v Superman, the character indeed showed up for a brief beat, as played by Michael Cassidy.

Advertisement

Of course, Olsen is fondly remembered by fans for being a Daily Planet photographer and close friend of both Clark Kent and Lois Lane (Amy Adams). He quite typically has a bookish demeanour in the comics, which has been carried over to most live-action versions of the character.

Zack Snyder yet again decided to throw out the rule book, however, by having Olsen appear as an undercover CIA agent posing as a Daily Planet photographer working with Lois.

Advertisement

He ends up killed after terrorists discover a tracking device in his camera, yet only in the film's Ultimate Edition is his name explicitly mentioned.

Though the "what if?" comic Superman: Red Son did technically depict Olsen as a CIA agent, otherwise there's been a sure consistency to his role in the comics as a Daily Planet stalwart.

Advertisement

As for Jimmy dying, Snyder said that they knew they didn't have room for the character, but wanted to provide audiences with an in-universe explanation for his absence. Naturally, fans were pissed.

6. Alfred Pennyworth

Warner Bros. & DC

Alfred Pennyworth (Jeremy Irons) has always been Bruce Wayne's trusty confidante and one constant tether to the outside world. Generally speaking, the comics haven't ever veered too far from depicting him as the sharply-dressed, well-spoken, endlessly suffering butler fans largely know him as.

Advertisement

Jeremy Irons' performance as the DCEU's Alfred is really quite different from what fans may have been expecting, then, with him proving far more stern and assertive during his conversations with Bruce.

Michael Caine's Alfred from the Dark Knight saga was no slouch, but it was also tough to avoid the feeling that he was still, at the end of the day, an employee as much as he was a family member.

Advertisement

The DCEU Alfred feels on a more even keel with Bruce, fully unafraid to admonish him with a severe tone, and largely lacking the cheeky humour that defined Caine's beloved take - or his typical conception in the comics.

Irons' Alfred is certainly a solid riff on the character, if quite a divergence from most of the iconography and stereotypes fans associate with Batman's trusty aide.

Advertisement

It's a shame Irons never really had sufficient time to flesh the character out - assuming he isn't returning for The Batman, of course - because he's one of the few Snyder revisions who worked out pretty damn well.

5. Aquaman

Warner Bros. & DC

It's fair to say that Aquaman (Jason Momoa) was one of the most challenging DC heroes to adapt to the big screen, if only because the general public couldn't really help but view him as, well, a bit of a goof.

Advertisement

Thanks to decades of pop culture summarily dumping on Arthur Curry as both ineffective and daft, the DCEU faced one hell of a struggle making audiences actually give a damn about the hero who can talk to fish.

But they struck gold with Jason Momoa, whose dark skin, flowing brunette locks, epic beard, tattoos and laid-back demeanour couldn't seem further from the blonde-haired, pale, chiselled, ridiculously-attired Arthur Curry who dominated the comics for decades. And thank God.

Advertisement

The character's attitude is also virtually unrecognisable from his traditional conception - if the comic Arthur is typically quite earnest and straight-laced, the DCEU's Arthur is far more playful, sarcastic, and just plain fun to be around.

This clashes quite entertainingly with the whole King of Atlantis shtick, lending Wan's film much of its, uh, fish out of water flavour (sorry).

Advertisement

The newer Aquaman comics have absolutely made a clear effort to shake off Arthur's unfortunate rep for being a squeaky-clean wet fish, yet for the most part there's a giant gulf in both looks and personality between the DCEU Aquaman and most major comic book versions.

4. Anatoli Knyazev (KGBeast)

Warner Bros. & DC

Anatoli Knyazev (Callan Mulvey) has a small role in Batman v Superman as a Russian arms dealer working for Lex Luthor, who helps frame Superman for the carnage in Africa and later kidnaps Martha Kent (before being blown to shreds by Batman).

Advertisement

Though you'd reasonably assume that Knyazev was a generic goon created specifically for Snyder's movie, he in fact made his comic book debut way back in 1988 as the supervillain with the ludicrous moniker KGBeast.

In the comics, he worked for the KGB (obviously) as a master martial artist kitted out with cybernetic enhancements, while rocking attire that can best be described as a "tactical gimp suit" - though more recent comics, such as Rebirth, have thankfully given him more imposing clothing.

Advertisement

Without his famous supervillain name nor any identifying signatures of his comic book namesake, Snyder's take may as well have been any random Russian thug, sadly.

3. Enchantress

Warner Bros. & DC

Enchantress aka June Moone (Cara Delevingne) serves as the primary antagonist of Suicide Squad, and no matter what you make of Delevingne's divisive performance in the role, she's quite the far cry from her comic book counterpart.

Advertisement

For starters, they look extremely different - DCEU's Enchantress is messy, dirty, and wears darker shades of clothing, while the comic book version famously wears green everything.

Both versions show off a fair amount of flesh, though with the heaving bustiers from the comics nowhere to be found, the DCEU iteration is thankfully a tad more modest.

Advertisement

Character-wise they're both unfortunate humans who stumble into powers - in a cave and at a party respectively - yet while the comics have often depicted Enchantress as an anti-hero, she quickly becomes an unrepentant villain in Suicide Squad.

The film's focus on a romance between June and Rick Flag (Joel Kinnaman) also might seem extensive enough as to be inspired by comic lore, but this is another divergence from the source material, and in recent comics Enchantress has actually been getting cosy with Killer Croc of all people.

Advertisement

Aesthetically and in terms of their character arcs, these two versions of Enchantress are quite diverse, and let's be honest - in the comics she's never tried to summon an apocalypse with a weird hula dance.

2. Dr. Thaddeus Sivana

Warner Bros. & DC

Shazam!'s antagonist is Dr. Thaddeus Sivana (Mark Strong), a physicist who grew up estranged from his family following a tragic car accident which crippled his father (John Glover), and which Thaddeus himself was blamed for.

Advertisement

Right from the jump, this is quite a distinct origin story from in most of the comics, where a young Sivana was mocked for his optimistic and ambitious scientific inventions. This caused him to grow into a prototypical mad scientist who sought various over-the-top means to kill Shazam (or as he was originally called, Captain Marvel).

If often depicted as a goofball in the comics, the Sivana of the movie is actually relatively serious and even sympathetic, at least to begin with.

Advertisement

This is closer to the tone of his depiction in The New 52, and the movie Sivana certainly resembles this version physically, though the comic run's influence on the film is ultimately superficial at best.

While a movie as light-footed as Shazam! probably could've pulled off the silliness of the classic Sivana, it was most certainly for the best to give him a more fleshed-out contemporary update.

Advertisement

1. Incubus

Warner Bros. & DC

Despite Enchantress seeming to be plenty villain for one movie, David Ayer decided to throw an extra baddie into Suicide Squad by way of her big, bad brother Incubus, who is released into a human host as they plot to take over the world.

Advertisement

And as with Enchantress, Incubus is rather unlike his depiction in the comics, where he was a fairly minor villain who possessed the body of a man named Larry Eden, causing Eden to die and allowing Incubus full dominion of his body. Furthermore, Eden was in fact the brother of iconic DC superhero Nightshade.

Nightshade is of course completely absent from Ayer's movie, with Incubus instead possessing a random schmuck on the subway in order to hatch his plan.

Advertisement

Moreover, despite the complex dynamics of Incubus in the comics - where it turns out that Enchantress is actually hosting his sister spirit, Succubus - he's ultimately little more than a generic CGI monster in the movie, serving as a second-rate mini-boss before the Squad battles Enchantress. Shame.

And let's be honest, how many people who saw Suicide Squad can even remember this digital goon's name?

Advertisement