The Nolanverse has ended. Despite rumors of Christian Bale's return in a World's Finest film, despite the rumors for a Nightwing or Catwoman film in the Nolanverse, it's over. As fans, we need to accept that Nolan's vision has reached its conclusion, and, regardless of whether you liked it or not, that chapter has ended. Rumor has it that Batman's future will involve him in a larger universe, a DC Cinematic Universe, along with Man of Steel and the inevitable Justice League film. The future Batman films will need to find a balance between the fantastic DC world and the more gritty, down-to-earth Batman universe. Whatever director comes Bats' way will need to pick and choose which elements of the Batman lore will work in their cinematic universe. They need to be distinct from Nolan's films, but not distinct just for the sake of being distinct. Nolan's time has come and gone. Who will stand in his place?
10. Neil Blomkamp
This one is a bit of an oddball choice. Personally, I feel Neil Blomkamp would be an amazing director for Wonder Woman or Green Lantern, but I am curious to see what he'd do for Batman. Right now, Blomkamp has only one major film to his name: District 9. This film is quite possibly one of the greatest films made in the last several years. It manages to perfectly integrate heavy political satire, crazy sci-fi, body horror, and a simple yet strong story in a way that's unique and visionary. Now, this begs the question: what can he bring to Batman? Blomkamp is skilled at integrating farfetched ideas and realism. Nolan's films all tried to be as realistic and plausible as possible, and in doing so kept out elements like the Joker's bleached face, Ra's al Ghul's immortality, Mr. Freeze, Poison Ivy, etc. Blomkamp can make these elements feel realistic. He made you believe bug aliens were really in South Africa. He can make you feel that a guy walking around in a cold suit is not only plausible, but a frightening possibility.
9. Robert Rodriguez
Have you seen Sin City? In that movie, Robert Rodriguez managed to perfectly capture Frank Miller's hyper-stylized graphic novel series onscreen. People thought it was impossible, but he did it. Was it realistic? No, but what is freaking cool? Hell yeah. Before writing Sin City, however, Frank Miller's main claim to fame was Batman: Year One and The Dark Knight Returns, two of the greatest graphic novels ever written. Of course, this was before Frank Miller lost his mind and wrote some of the worst graphic novels ever, but we'll forget Dark Knight Strikes Again and All Star Batman and Robin ever existed. Rodriguez's skills lie in putting crazy visuals on screen, and making it all work somehow. Is it realistic? No, but it is awesome. It would be a nice mix between Burton's fantastic Gotham and Nolan's gritty city. After all, that's what Rodriguez did with Miller's Sin City, and that went over wonderfully.
8. Matthew Vaughn
Vaughn has, to date, directed two major superhero movies, and while people argue whether or not Kick-Ass is a stroke of genius or an offensive mess, most people seem to agree that X-Men: First Class was an excellent superhero movie, particularly since it revitalised the dying X-Men franchise. After all, before First Class you had Origins Wolverine and, in my opinion far worse, X3. He brought something new yet familiar to the table that renewed interest in this new vision. Vaughn can do wonders in a very similar way for Batman. People are familiar with Nolan's bat, so something too different will not sit well with us. However, we need a fresh start. We need to divorce the public's perspective on Batman from Nolan's movies if we hope to move the Dark Knight into a larger DC cinematic universe. This is where Vaughn comes in. Not only is he talented enough to bring about a new Dark Knight film, but he can do it in a way that will appeal to everyone. He doesn't need to copy Nolan. His own style, as seen with Kick-Ass and First Class, balances out fantastic with real, while keeping it grounded in the best sort of way. In other words, he's perfect.
7. Sam Mendes
Sam Mendes has experience with comic book movies thanks to the Road for Perdition, but let's be fair: you know him as the guy who did Skyfall. Skilled with, again, bringing something new to an already familiar franchise, Mendes clearly has the skill and story telling genius to paint a new approach to the Dark Knight. Mendes's films are not particularly dark or gritty, but they do have a sense of adventure and largeness to them that has not been brought to Batman quite often enough. Batman Begins and The Dark Knight Rises both attempted to make the films bigger (with the League of Shadows posing as international threats directing their attention toward a single city), but even in Rises, when Gotham fell, it never felt close to the sheer size or magnitude of, say, No Man's Land. Mendes can change that. He can make a huge, gigantic Batman film, mixing and matching elements from the largest scale Batman stories (No Man's Land, Knightfall, etc). The Nolan films failed to really express the scale of Batman's universe, often times focusing on the personal struggles of Bruce Wayne. The Burton/Schumacher films didn't seem to even realize there was a world beyond Gotham. In all cases, new is good.
6. Rian Johnson
Fairly new director Rian Johnson has received praise recently for his time travel flick Looper. If you haven't seen it yet, I highly urge you to go out and watch it the first chance you get. It's awesome. However, Johnson is now one of WB's favorite rising directors, so it wouldn't surprise me if he actually DID get the role. Johnson's ability to mash sci-fi with a standard crime/action formula is what makes him perfect, since Batman technically qualifies as a sci-fi story. Sure, it's low sci-fi -- and the technology seems just out of reach -- but it's sci-fi. Johnson can bring villains like Mr. Freeze to life, giving him the respect he deserves, and weaponry that, rather than cartoonish, looks badass. Plus, from a directorial standard, he can really get good performances out of his actors. I bought Joseph Gordon-Levitt's character in Looper far more than I did in either Inception or TDKR. He can get the best out of his actors, and Batman, at its core, is about the characters and their psyches.
5. Ben Affleck
Ben Affleck is another favorite after The Town and Argo. Both films are very grounded and realistic, so you may question whether or not he can pull off a good Batman. The trick, however, is that Affleck likes comic books. Why else do you think he chose to be in Daredevil? (btw, that film gets a bad rap. Watch the Director's Cut version. That version is good). Affleck's films, again, are very grounded and realistic. This is more similar to Nolan's style -- maybe even moreso. However, the plus side to all this is that, as a fan of the character, Affleck would probably try to incorporate as much of the original material as possible, while still remaining fairly grounded. For example, his Joker probably would look like he does in the comics, complete with bleached skin...but he'd figure out an explanation as to why. His Batman would be an incredible crime fighter, complete with crazy gadgets, but he would also be fairly grounded, and, most likely, the world's greatest detective. Yeah, eight Batman films, and the only one where he is a real detective is the Adam West film (though '89 and The Dark Knight shows he does some detective work). While it may be weird to admit that Affleck would make a good Batman director. There were rumors, at one point, that he should play Batman...but no. Stick to directing, good sir.
4. Darren Aronofsky
Another man previously attached to the Batman franchise, Aronofsky is a wild card. His previous proposal for a Batman film is one of the single strangest things you will read. Loosely based on Batman Year One, it is...weird. Like, Bruce Wayne is homeless weird, and babies get their eyes gorged out weird. Weird. Still, if he were to propose a more straight forward Batman film that didn't laugh at the comic book origins, then we could potentially see some of the most tormented, tragic superhero characters on screen ever. As mentioned before, the core of Batman's universe is his cast of characters. Some are heroic, others not so much. All of them are tortured, with twisted, distorted psyches and obsessions. Imagine Aronofsky's Two-Face. And, best of all, unlike more grounded directors, Aronofsky isn't afraid to get fantastic. Watch Black Swan or The Fountain. Or even Pi, his first film. All of them incorporate fantasy into their otherwise realistic plots, and yet make it work all the same. Sure, in Black Swan it's all in her head, but the Fountain? Not so much. Imagine, again, how he could do Mr. Freeze...
3. Clint Eastwood
Another iconic director known for intense films, Eastwood's Batman would be -- intriguing. Eastwood might take Batman toward his detective routes, or make him a bad-ass who fights criminals. I have no idea exactly which way he'd go. I do know, however, that it would be awesome. Eastwood's Unforgiven featured a tortured man haunted by his past sins, unwilling to take a life until pushed to his limits. Gran Torino featured a new slant on vigilante justice. All great credentials for a strong Batman film, but the most important element is that Eastwood has no limitations. He's not afraid to take a story in a strange, even disturbing route if it means bettering the narrative. The only weird thing is if Eastwood cast himself as Alfred. Imagine that? I'm kind of laughing a bit to myself now, but admit it: that would be interesting.
2. Alfonso Cuaron
Cuaron is not a name you want associated with an adaptation, but, for this, I'll make an exception. Cuaron made the third Harry Potter without actually reading the book--he's done this with other adaptations. While some like the third film the most, as a fan of the third book, I was turned off by his film version. However, I have seen Children of Men. That film is amazing. Undeniably amazing. If Cuaron directed the next Batman film like that, incorporating soft sci-fi with an incredibly grim, intense plot, it would be awesome. Cuaron's films, no matter how "realistic," always feel larger than life and fantastic, which is just what Batman needs if he wants to exist in a world where a man can fly and green rings summon tanks. Cuaron doesn't need to really read every Batman story to get a good adaptation. He just needs to know the core essentials, and craft his world from there...but please respect the source material.
1. David Fincher
This is the guy I wanted to see make a Batman film since day one. Even when Nolan was announced, I was bummed the guy who directed Se7en was not behind the helm. Fincher's films are almost all modern classics, and the ones that aren't either were ruined by executive meddling (Alien 3) or just too big for their own good (Benjamin Button). The point is that Fincher can do anything. Sci-fi? Crime? Biopic? Fantasy drama? Fight Club? He's done it all. And, every time, he does it marvelously. The true mark of quality for a director is whether they can do a lot of different things well. Richard Donner, for example, did Superman, Lethal Weapon, and The Omen. Three entirely different films, all marvelous. Fincher is one of the rare great directors who can do anything, and make it awesome. That said, what can he bring to Batman that no one else can? Everything. He is the only man capable who isn't an unknown or Guillermo del Toro who can bring every element from the comics onto the big screen. He's written teenagers brilliantly (Social Network), so I'm sure he could pull off the Bat Family superbly. He's done crime and mysteries, so he'd pull off Batman's detective side without fail (Se7en and Zodiac). He's done revolutionary films (Fight Club), so you cannot convince me that he can take a revolutionary like Ra's al Ghul, and make him an incredibly charismatic villain, moreso than Liam Neeson and Nolan. Nolan's era has reached its peak. Give someone else the reigns. Someone better. What do you think? Post your criticism below, along with any directors you think I missed.