10 Disappointing Films That Let Us Down The Most in 2012

By Dan Schindel /

Ideally, we would all be able to approach movies with complete and utter objectivity. Expectations often cloud our better judgment, and prevent us from evaluating movies on their own terms. But we all allow our preconceptions to color how we view movies (and anyone who claims otherwise is a dirty, filthy liar). Sometimes, if we go in with low hopes, we can be pleasantly surprised by how good a movie can turn out. But more often, we set our expectations too high, to the point where nothing can hope to live up to what we've put in our head. But sometimes, it's perfectly reasonable to get excited for a film. If it's cast and/or crew has a great pedigree, or it's the latest installment in a beloved series, or what have you, then why not hope, or even expect, that it will be good? Sometimes, these pre-judgements are rewarded. Other times, they are dashed horribly. Here are the ten most bitter disappointments of the year. NOTE 1: Keep in mind that "disappointing" does not necessarily mean "bad." In fact, few of the movies on this list are bad by any measure. But they were all not nearly as good as they should have been, given who they came from. NOTE 2: The movies are listed in order of release date, not on some ranking of "disappointingness."

10. John Carter

The Hype: After the wild success of Finding Nemo and WALL-E, Andrew Stanton had accrued enough clout to do anything he wanted, and he wrote A Princess of Mars on Disney's blank check. Edgar Rice Burroughs's novels set a template from which much of the science fiction of the past century has drawn. And with Mission: Impossible - Ghost Protocol, Brad Bird showed that a Pixar alum could make the transition from animation to live action with aplomb. There were worrisome signs, like the uninspired marketing campaign, but that was no reason not to be optimistic, right? The Reality: There is some great stuff in John Carter, some moments of wonder and moments of fun. It has a great performance by Lynn Collins as Dejah Thoris, who transcends the role of mere love interest. It has Woola the superfast Martian dog-alien-thing, the most delightful cinematic animal sidekick in years. But movie is also awkwardly paced, sometimes even plodding, and overstuffed with unneeded elements. It also had weak villains and a mixed lead performance from Taylor Kitsch. It all evens out to a very nice, okay movie.

9. God Bless America

The Hype: Bobcat Goldthwait has built a reputation for pulling off a remarkable filmic act: he can make movies that are simultaneously extraordinarily dark and yet quite compassionate. In Sleeping Dogs Lie and World's Greatest Dad, he made topics like bestiality and teen suicide hilarious, but never at the expense of his characters. With God Bless America, he was poised to take on some utterly ripe subject matter: the USA's obsession with negativity in its media, from terrible reality television to vicious cable news pundits. It seemed the perfect recipe for success. The Reality: There are a lot of problems with God Bless America, all revolving around a core flaw: this is a cruel movie pleading for kindness. Goldthwait is obviously distressed by the lack of civility in society, and that shows in his characters, but the response to this meanness is murder. And this isn't done satirically - the film revels in the vicious killing of fictional analogues to Bill O'Reilly and Super Sweet Sixteen brats, among others. What purpose does this serve? It only undermines Goldthwait's point.

8. Prometheus

The Hype: Ridley Scott, making his grand return to science fiction! A totally stacked cast, featuring Noomi Rapace, Michael Fassbender, Idris Elba, and Charlize Theron! Gorgeous special effects! That amazing trailer! How could this go wrong? The Reality: Well, by stringing it all together with a terrible script. Very few of the actions taken by any of the characters in this story make any sense, and it's all wrapped in philosophical claptrap that would embarrass a high school sophomore. Such a monumental waste of talent and possibility.

7. Brave

The Hype: It's Pixar. I could almost leave it at that with a "Nuff said." Even the troubling behind-the-scenes stuff, with original director Brenda Chapman getting replaced, couldn't dampen enthusiasm. The Reality: Brave is still the best movie on this list. It's lovely to look at, has great voice performances, and some spectacularly-put-together sequences. It's also stunningly lazy on the story front, especially considering that it's Pixar. It goes through the motions of character arcs and story beats, but there's not really anything going on in Brave's head. There's no investment in the characters, no urgency to the plot, nothing to anchor and audience to it. It's a bizarrely hollow film.

6. To Rome with Love The Hype: Now, at this stage of his career, Woody Allen hasn't warranted much interest for anyone outside of a select circle of snooty-pants in LA, New York, and, well... Europe. But after the revitalization that was Midnight in Paris, I was excited to see what he would do next. An anthology set in Rome, with a great crop of actors? Why not? The Reality: Nope, seems it's back to aiming to make old people laugh. The worst and best that can be said about To Rome with Love is that it's bland and inoffensive. It feels like a whole bunch of spare ideas that Allen couldn't stretch into feature length tossed into one movie. What a letdown.

Advertisement

5. Savages

The Hype: Now, this was a rather specific object of hype for me. But anyone who's read Don Winslow's Savages will understand getting worked up for the film. The book is one of the best works of crime fiction of recent years, brutal and kinetic and funny and beautifully written. And even if Oliver Stone hadn't directed a good movie in over a decade, surely that cast would balance him out, right? The Reality: Nope. Basically nothing that made the book great is here. The California cool of the characters has turned into awful douchebagginess. The whole thing reeks of an old man trying to play cool, but failing miserably.

4. The Dark Knight Rises The Hype: Um, hello? It's the conclusion of Christopher Nolan's Bat-trilogy. Literally everyone loves Batman. Everyone loves Christopher Nolan. Everyone who made The Dark Knight so beloved was back. Anticipation was at a fever pitch in the days leading up to this film's release. Any critic who dare suggest it was anything but a masterpiece was subject to heaps of online vitriol. The Reality: Much like Brave, this film goes through the motions of making sense and being populated with human beings without actually going to the trouble of having those things. It's incredibly silly, which I actually wouldn't hold against it if it weren't so dour so much of the time. There's a reason Anne Hathaway's Catwoman (Oops, no wait, she's not actually called Catwoman. That would be silly) is the best part about it. It's just a mess.

Advertisement

3. Killing Them Softly The Hype: Back in 2007, Andrew Dominik directed this little movie called The Assassination of Jesse James by the Coward Robert Ford. It was kind of amazing. So when the sublime trailer for Killing Them Softly rolled in, I was considerably enthusiastic for it, to say the least. The Reality: There's some of the same visual and conceptual genius here that was on full display in Jesse James. But it only comes in spurts. In between, there are agonizingly long stretches of dullness. People talk. And talk. And listen to more talk on the radio. Which hammers in the film's themes again. And again. And again. Just in case you missed it. No one missed it. But few cared.

Advertisement

2. The Hobbit: An Unexpected Journey

The Hype: Remember those Lord of the Rings movies? How'sabout a prequel? Would you like that? Of course you would. The Reality: Urrrghhhh, why did this have to be a trilogy? Why? It's one little book. It's good as it is. It doesn't have to be a trilogy. Peter Jackson has fallen in love with bloat, so in love with this world that he overindulges, devouring all runtime until he explodes all over the audience. Every single scene in this movie goes on for too long. Whole swaths could be cut out without hurting anything. What makes it hurt even more is that there's still wonder and whimsy and fun and excitement in this world. It's all just smothered underneath the fat.

1. This is 40

The Hype: Judd Apatow has built a reputation for great characters and well-observed comedic writing and acting. Some people were let down by Funny People. I was not one of them. So I was looking forward to this one. The Reality: Oof. Oddly enough, Jackson is Apatow's kin on one front: their love of looooong running times. Which was never a problem for me with Apatow's films before, but this one is just formless meandering. It makes the movie feel way, way longer than it is. But if it were at all pleasant, I wouldn't mind. Except that the movie's an exercise is off-putting redundancy, with endless scenes of unlikable characters fighting one another, and few laughs in between. So what disappointed you in the theater this year? Sound off in the comments.