10 Easily Solved Movie Moral Dilemmas

By Shaun Munro /

A great moral dilemma can transform a good movie into a great, indelible one that lives on for years and is discussed fervently forever more. A movie with a water-tight moral dilemma will provoke fierce, intense, divisive emotional reactions in viewers, who will come down on one side or the other and irrefutably defend that viewpoint to the hilt. However, some films often push the binary nature of the dilemma a little too hard, and the result is one that's actually not that complex at all when you think about it. Usually because the sensible option is actually pretty obvious when you boil it down, these movies got a little big for their britches and thought they were being far more thought-provoking than they actually were. Though occasionally these films arrived at the right moral choice, most of the time they blew it, and we were left despairing at our televisions. Here are 10 moral dilemmas that could have easily been solved...

10. Let The Child Stay With Morgan Freeman - Gone Baby Gone

The Dilemma: A child goes missing. It turns out that the local police Chief (Morgan Freeman) kidnapped the girl, Amanda, to try and give her a "better life" living with him and his wife. The protagonist, Kenzie (Casey Affleck) has to decide - rat the Chief out and return Amanda to her incompetent mother (Amy Ryan), or let her live with the Chief forever more. The Solution: Kenzie decides, against advice from basically everyone, to turn the Chief in, causing the child to be returned to her mother, whereby it is implied at the end that the mother hasn't learned her lesson, and continues to be neglectful. Kenzie instead, out of a sense of obligation, decides to act as a sort of guardian angel, looking out for her. How It Should Have Been Solved: You have to think about what's in the best interests of the child. It's best to shrug, leave her with the Chief, and promptly forget about the whole thing.

9. Revel In Capitalism, Sell The Lie - The Joneses

The Dilemma: The Joneses are a fake family unit who are a gang of so-called "stealth marketers"; everything from the clothes they wear to the food they eat has carefully been prepared, with the idea being that if they are depicted as a desirable, perfect family, then their neighbours will want to buy all the very same products that they have. The dilemma occurs when a neighbour commits suicide, having become obsessed with the struggle to, as they say, "keep up with the Joneses" - should the family out themselves and give up, or keep ploughing away? The Solution: In the movie, the fake mother and father (Demi Moore and David Duchovny) eventually decide to embark on the beginnings of a relationship, with love triumphing over money, it seems. How It Should Have Been Solved: An ironic "capitalism trumps all" ending would have been more realistic and also more amusing, rather than the sappy, trite mulch we got. When top-of-the-line everything is being thrown your way, is it really even a choice?

8. Blow Up The Other Boat And Save Yourselves - The Dark Knight

The Dilemma: The Joker has rigged two boats with explosives - one has civilians on it, the other has criminals and prison staff. Each boat has one detonator that will explode the other boat - will either boat blow up the other to save themselves? The Solution: Neither boat blows up the other, and then the explosives don't work anyway when The Joker tries to... How It Should Have Been Solved: The first civilian in control of the trigger presses it without hesitating. When it comes down to you or somebody else, survival instinct kicks in; you're going to live. The Dark Knight's view of humanity is rather optimistic and flowery, which is, frankly, ridiculous. Short of expecting The Joker to trick you and have you blow yourself up, there's no reason not to push the trigger immediately.

7. Kill John Doe, He Doesn't Win. He's Dead - Se7en

The Dilemma: Detective Mills (Brad Pitt) has just discovered that John Doe (Kevin Spacey), the movie's serial killer, has just murdered his pregnant wife. Mills wants to murder Doe, but doing so will simply complete the cycle of 7 Deadly Sins that Doe has been perpetrating throughout the film. This will allow Doe to "win" in effect. The Solution: Mills shoots Doe through the head anyway, essentially "losing" by the film's logic. How It Should Have Been Solved: This film ends the right way, though makes a big deal about how Mills has failed, because taking Doe to prison would have been an easy way to prevent the sin cycle from completing itself. Taking a nihilistic view of things - appropriate given the nihilism of the film - Doe is dead, he's not a winner of anything. That's not to say Mills has won either - his pregnant wife is dead - but hey, burning a round through the douchebag's head must take the edge off a little. Jail just wasn't an option with a crime so heinous.

6. Get The Hell Out Of There. God Will Forgive You - Of Gods And Men

The Dilemma: A group of 9 Trappist monks live harmoniously in Algeria with the local Muslim population, yet with the mounting fear that terrorists are going to storm their abode and kidnap, likely kill them all, they must decide whether to stay, committed to their faith, or seek refuge. The Solution: Most of the monks stick around, well aware of their fate, which ends up with 7 of them being executed by the terrorists. How It Should Have Been Solved: While these men may not have feared death in the same way that an atheist might, is God going to punish them for protecting themselves? What good are they to preach the word of God if they're strewn with bullet holes?

5. Let Wade Go, Nobody's Going To Blame You - 3:10 to Yuma

The Dilemma: Dan Evans (Christian Bale), is a crippled, poor farmer down on his luck. Evans is paid to escort a criminal, Ben Wade (Russell Crowe), to board a train headed for Yuma, yet Wade offers Evans more money to simply cut him loose. Let him go and get a nice windfall, or stick to your moral fiber? The Solution: Dan successfully escorts Wade to the train, though ends up shot dead by Prince (Ben Foster), leaving his son without a father, while it is implied that Wade escapes on the ride to Yuma. How It Should Have Been Solved: If only Evans had taken the pay-off, he would have lived to see his son become a man, and would have probably been able to prop up his farm nicely with that cash. I mean, who's going to be shocked that the local cripple couldn't escort a violent felon to justice? Just take the money and run...

4. Nuke New York, Prevent World War III - Fail-Safe

The Dilemma: You are the President of the United States, and by accident (somehow!?), a nuclear strike has leveled Moscow. World War III is on the brink as a result, but you have one lifeline - if you nuke a major US city, the war can be prevented. The Solution: The President (Henry Fonda) goes through with the nuclear strike, reducing New York City to rubble in the film's final moments, killing millions. How It Should Have Been Solved: It's an absurd scenario from the outset, and though the POTUS does go through with it in the end, it's really not as difficult as it sounds - the film really blows the anguish out of proportion (the cold, heartless robot says). Sure, you're going to be executing millions of innocents, but it's about utilitarianism in action; a failure to obliterate a city will result in certain nuclear obliteration of the US, whereas the willful destruction of NYC might at least pacify the Russians enough to stop a far greater loss of life. Twisted, but true.

3. Shoot Your Hand Off And Nobody Needs To Die - Looper

The Dilemma: At the climax of Looper, Old Joe (Bruce Willis) is about to murder Sid, who he believes will eventually become the unstoppable crime lord The Rainmaker. Young Joe (Joseph Gordon-Levitt) can stop it by committing suicide and erasing himself (and Old Joe) from the timeline - should he? The Solution: Joe goes through with it, saving Sid and his mother (Emily Blunt) at the cost of his own life. How It Should Have Been Solved: How's about just shooting your hand off? That would instantaneously cause Old Joe's shooting hand to disappear, and so best case scenario he'd be scrambling around trying to fire a gun in his weaker hand, likely giving Sid and mother plenty of time to flee. Or better yet, why not just shoot Old Joe? It gives Young Joe a limited lifespan and an exact knowledge of how he is going to die - unless he makes an effort to fix it somehow - but hey, it's better than dying on the spot. Boy, I need to lie down.

2. Live Life Controlling The Girl Of Your Dreams - Ruby Sparks

The Dilemma: Having willed a gorgeous, quirky dream girl named Ruby Sparks (Zoe Kazan) into existence, author Calvin (Paul Dano) discovers that he can get her to do anything he wants by writing about her. Should he pursue this to its most perverse ends, or let Ruby go? The Solution: After the two argue intensely, Calvin eventually lets Ruby go, giving her free will. At this point, with no knowledge of him, they coincidentally meet again, and presumably start over their relationship, but with Ruby being able to make her own choices this time. How It Should Have Been Solved: Yes, it's arguably misogynistic and would have gone over horribly with audiences, but what guy would resist having a typewriter that allowed them to do this? The more realistic ending would have involved Calvin holding her in his dominion forever more, and what a great date movie that would have been...

1. Friend Zone Your Daughter - Oldboy

The Dilemma: Oh Dae-su is freed after having been kept in captivity for 15 years for an unspecified crime. While seeking out his former captors, he falls for a local chef much younger than himself, only to discover that, after embarking on a sexual relationship with her, that she is, in fact, his daughter. He has himself hypnotised at the end of the film to forget this horrible truth, though when he meets up with his daughter at the end, the ambiguous final shot suggests that the hypnotism did not work, and that on some level, he still knows. The dilemma - does he tell her the truth, or simply live on in anguish? The Solution: Unknown. The film leaves it up to us. How It Should Have Been Solved: Let's face it, once you've done that to your daughter, you're never going to have a normal relationship, so you may as well write her off, because telling her the truth is really not going to help things. Instead, slowly give her the cold shoulder, eventually placing her in the friend zone and then cutting contact completely. Simple. Got any other solutions to these moral dilemmas? Am I over-simplifying complex problems? Sound off in the comments section below!