10 Embarrassingly Poor Horror Movie Monsters
Is that an evil... snowman?
We all know that there’s more to a good horror movie than the appearance of the villain. Suspense. Atmosphere. Jump scares.
Good old-fashioned extreme bodily dismemberment. Horror movies are a craft, and good filmmakers don’t need to use special effects as a blunt instrument to tear screams out of audiences.
That said, a truly horrific movie monster, realised with great make-up effects or skilful CGI, can really make the difference between a good movie and a great movie. But it's the truly garbage monsters that can make the biggest difference.
We’ve all been there: a movie is scaring us silly, but the terrifying monster that has been so carefully foreshadowed is finally revealed as a lukewarm drip and all of that lovingly cultivated fear parps straight out of the room like a deflating balloon.
But disappointment isn’t the only way that a monster can ruin your movie night. Far from it. This list looks at the most pathetic, the most underwhelming, and the plain silliest monsters in horror.
And it's true what you’re thinking – it’s a crowded field! So for this list we’ve tried to zoom in on some of the more interesting embarrassments, and to avoid notoriously terrible monsters like the gremlins from Troll 2, or ones that are deliberately ‘so bad it’s good’ like Sharktopus, Rubber, or Zombeavers.
Let the roster of shame commence!
10. Freddy Krueger - A Nightmare On Elm Street (2010)
Everybody knows that there was no reason to remake A Nightmare on Elm Street. The franchise was thoroughly exhausted, having dribbled and wheezed to a stop after five increasingly redundant sequels and an ambitious but patchy reboot.
But if there's one thing franchises are good for, it's a cash-in, and in 2010 Freddy was duly dragged from the grave for yet another spree through the dreamscapes of yet more naughty teenagers.
It's not a total turkey. There are some good performances and some strong effects sequences, and Jackie Earle Haley’s interpretation of Freddy is commendable in many respects.
The decision to make Freddy’s burned face look more realistic, however, is one of the most important examples of the main problem with the remake: it just doesn't capture the sense of the fantastic and the weird that made Wes Craven's first Nightmare such a fascinatingly original and scary piece of work.
Freddy was always a burn victim, but Craven's decision not to be too literal with Freddy's facial disfigurement had important effects on the whole feel of the film. It allowed Robert Englund's devilishly charismatic performance to shine through.
It was expressive, and it was suggestive, in the way that great surrealism can be. And it made Freddy appear more ghoulish, less like a real person who had suffered vigilante justice and more like some dripping, grisly, otherworldly phantom.
When it's too anatomically correct, as it is in the remake, it loses its freakiness and feels - well, ordinary, and it should go without saying that a dream demon should never be ordinary. Even at his cheesy, quipping, shark-jumping worst, Freddy was never dull.
9. Satan HImself - Rosemary's Baby
Rosemary’s Baby was convicted child abuser Roman Polanski's breakthrough horror hit, which made him into a global player in cinema. It's a sophisticated portrayal of paranoia, dread, and psychological manipulation.
Happy newlyweds Rosemary and Guy move into a new Manhattan apartment, hoping to begin raising a family together. Well-situated and elegant, it's a lovely place to start their idealistic, hopeful married life.
Apart, that is, from the nosy neighbours, who turn out to be a coven of satanists intent on using Rosemary as a host for the child of the devil.
One of the main accomplishments of the film is to create a crazed atmosphere of uncertainty, foreboding, and suspicion. It relies almost entirely on strong character work, with insinuation and suggestion doing all of the heavy lifting and only a few well-judged shock moments.
The monster letdown comes in one of the only scenes that features any kind of effects work. There's a delirious sequence on "baby night", when Rosemary is drugged so that she can be inseminated by Satan. From Rosemary's perspective, we see something that is supposed to be some kind of shadowy, beastly figure, clearly raping her in her sleep.
It’s a bloke in a rubbish suit, though, and it drains all of the credibility and emotional intensity out of one of the most important scenes of the film. A poorly-timed bit of crap costume punctures what should be a skin-crawlingly horrible crescendo.
8. Newborn/Hybrid Xenomorph - Alien: Resurrection
Alien: Resurrection brought the Alien franchise screeching to a halt in 1997. A wisecracking bunch of space mercenaries? A cloned Ripley playing basketball? Aliens threatening to land on Earth? No, no, and hecking thrice no.
The worst bit by far, though, is the hybrid xenomorph that emerges at the end of the movie. The sinister military organisation that cloned Ripley did so, of course, in order to acquire a queen alien for their weapons program. Said queen has developed a humanoid womb that she can use to reproduce instead of laying facehugger eggs. Inevitably, a xenomorph is born which is part-human and part-alien.
Perhaps it’s supposed to come across as tragic and heartbreaking. A doomed creature, trapped in its own hybridity, neither human nor alien. At the same time as it is repellent, you feel uncomfortable compassion for this beast and its evident love for Ripley.
It doesn’t work, though. As well as being corny and poorly realised, it also cuts facehuggers - one of the most compelling elements of the entire Alien mythos - out of the xenomorph's reproductive process. Why would you do this?
Much like the hole in the spaceship’s hull that kills it, the hybrid newborn xenomorph really sucks.
7. Killer Klowns From Outer Space
A bit like regular clowns, the 1988 alien invasion movie Killer Klowns From Outer Space is supposed to be funny, but it’s actually just embarrassing.
It's a wilfully schlocky parody of small-town invasion movies like Invaders From Mars, It Came From Outer Space, and Critters, poking fun at a hokey subgenre and having a bit of harmless, punky fun. But its attempts at campy horror comedy just come off as forced, desperate, and a little bit sad. Again, a bit like regular clowns.
The Killer Klowns are unpleasant enough, but only in the way that an awkward joke during Christmas dinner is unpleasant: just uncomfortable and weird enough to make you wish you were doing something else.
At best, they're unpleasant in the way that an unconvincing puppet is just kind of not very nice. More often than not, it's just flatulent and boring.
This film is evidence, were any more needed, that 'it's supposed to be silly' is no defence at all. Cream pies, but they kill you! Haha. Klownzilla! I am rolling on the floor, laughing my ass off.
There's no risk of dying laughing while watching this burning litter tray of a movie. Turn it off.
6. Jack Frost
It would be unnecessarily humourless to completely write off 1997's Jack Frost just because it's a bit on the daft side. It's a scrappy low-budget effort with plenty of attitude and lots of silly laughs, and it has a great fun Christmas-themed rock and metal soundtrack.
Okay, those are the good bits. Throat cleared.
Killers who won't stay dead are an immortal (sorry) horror staple. But of all the ways that serial killers can torment their victims from beyond the grave, a murderer who fuses with snow at the genetic level and becomes a shapeshifting, psychopathic snowman might just be the rock bottom worst.
But even the silliest ideas can work if they're well executed. And there's something to be said for the DIY aesthetic of low-fi practical effects. But come on. In some scenes you can as good as see the trolley that piece of crap is being wheeled around on.
No, thank you.
5. The Creeper - Jeepers Creepers
The first half of Jeepers Creepers is an unusually competent teen horror, with some visceral scares and a strong, bold build-up. But as soon as the villain is revealed, you see why everyone told you not to bother watching it.
It's true that this is a pretty conventional view of Jeepers Creepers. Reviewers at the time pointed out repeatedly that the second half of the film is a victim of the success of the first half, and they were right.
But it bears repeating: the opening is a very tense affair, with great pacing and restraint, and it's uncharacteristically dark for mainstream horror of the time.
Maybe it's the way that the use of scenery draws on movies like The Texas Chainsaw Massacre to indicate that there is a seedily human explanation for the carnage.
Maybe it's the strong performances, and the growing sense of mystery that comes from the revelation that whatever is hunting the protagonists can smell their fear.
Whatever it is, it sets you up for something considerably more interesting than the Creeper, a thoroughly generic and uninspiring manhunter which looks like an unimaginative collage of lazy horror tropes: bat wings, leather coat, scarred face. Yawn.
And director Victor Salva is a convicted sex offender, so it might be a blessing in disguise if his films also happen to fall flat.
4. Buguhl - Sinister
The first hour of Sinister is incredibly suspenseful, intriguing, and frightening stuff. With solid character development, a patiently established setting, and harrowing, serious, snuff-themed imagery, it’s the kind of marrow-chilling creeper that makes you want to sleep with the lights on.
Buguhl, the villain, is teased very effectively in well-timed, spooky scares. The mythology is gradually and fascinatingly revealed, as a true crime writer played with compelling vulnerability by Ethan Hawke slowly but surely uncovers the supernatural threat at the heart of the mystery of a murdered family.
But when Buguhl is finally revealed, it seems that Ethan Hawke is terrified of one of the guitar players from Slipknot.
Mick Thompson, Slipknot's #7, wears a mask based on a hockey mask which has distinctive blackened eyes and a sealed mouth, and Buguhl looks very much like it.
Of course, #7 didn't invent the repurposed hockey mask. Vorhees made it what it is today, and masked murderers have been a recurring presence in horror since long before the advent of the slasher genre. And of course, you could object that Buguhl isn't wearing a mask - that's his face.
Whatever the thinking behind the design, it has the hallmarks of heavy metal theatricality. Which absolutely, indisputably rules on its own terms. But if you want to actually scare someone in a movie with such an oppressively dark tone and with so much hard-edged, mean potential, you need a bit more than some heavy Kohl.
3. The Fly (1958)
David Cronenberg’s The Fly is one of his most powerful and memorable gorefests. Showcasing an extraordinary range of bloodcurdling practical effects, the 1986 remake of The Fly is a nightmarish vision of a scientist’s revolting physical degeneration after an experiment goes badly wrong and he is accidentally genetically fused with an insect.
At first the fusion affects Seth Brundle (a career highlight performance by Jeff Goldblum) positively, as his strength and sex drive are vastly increased. But it's not long until his body and mind start to deteriorate in gruesome, lurid detail.
The movie that it reimagines, however, though it has the same basic idea, tells the story very differently. For most of the film, the doomed scientist hides from his family, building the anticipation of what his horrendous transformation might look like. Cronenberg's genius is to display, in extravagant detail, a sickening metamorphosis that the original film only hints at.
It's another movie that builds tension effectively only to have the monster come out goofy. The scene in which the fly is eventually revealed is so clumsily literal that it comes across as simply comical. It's... it's... it's a bloke wearing a helmet that’s supposed to be a fly’s head.
Worse, the film's final scene features the unfortunate fly that the scientist swapped heads with. Hopping about on the plants outside his laboratory, there's a bluebottle with a man's head, squeaking "help me!"
Great idea, terrible execution.
2. King Kong (1976)
Part of the fun of classic, pre-CGI monster movies comes from knowing that the creature is actually an actor in a suit frolicking around a sound stage.
And, as a recent WhatCulture list showed, the delightfully ridiculous history of Kaiju movies is stuffed full of wacky characters, including insect gods, giant grumpy lobsters, and robotic alien dinosaurs.
Believability is not exactly a priority for movies like this. After all, complaining that a Kaiju doesn't look 'real' is a little like complaining that there's too much shouting on your Extreme Noise Terror record. What did you expect?
But the Dino De Laurentiis remake of King Kong from 1976 proves that there is a line somewhere. A line where lighthearted fun becomes uncharismatic tedium; a line where a good time becomes a hard time.
This version of King Kong discovers this mysterious threshold in the act of crossing it. The line is a dot to Kong.
1. Technology - Maximum Overdrive
What’s that speeding towards us? Is it... a heavy-handed metaphor for the perils of technology? It’s worse than that: It’s Maximum Overdrive, a truly cringeworthy movie in which all man-made technology is mysteriously possessed by the urge to turn on its creators.
Stephen King's only directorial effort, which even he considers a 'moron movie' that he made while out of his mind on cocaine, Maximum Overdrive is universally considered an utter, irredeemable embarrassment.
Like a child's sketch of Stephen Spielberg's debut movie Duel, the film features extended chase scenes involving overbearing haulage vehicles. Unlike Duel, though, the lead villain in Maximum Overdrive is a truck wearing a Green Goblin mask. Really.
But it's not just trucks. The terrifying range of evil automatons that wage war on mankind includes rogue chainsaws, murderous arcade games, bloodthirsty hairdryers, and homicidal vending machines.
This movie was cheated out of two 1987 Golden Raspberry awards (Worst Director for King and Worst Actor for star Emilio Estevez) by Prince's flop musical Under the Cherry Moon. It's a shame - Maximum Overdrive deserves those Raspberries more.
Though many adaptations of Stephen King's novels are without a doubt among the best horror films in existence, we should not forget that he is also capable of producing ludicrous Marenghi-esque tripe like this.
Avoid.