10 Fan Edits That Totally Transform Famous Films

The Phantom Menace with 100% less Jar-Jar? Yes please!

By Tom Baker /

Lucasfilm

One of our pet peeves is when creative types dismiss all criticism of their art by people who aren't artists themselves. You know the sort: the self-righteous musicians, writers or filmmakers who shrug off bad reviews with the zinger €œ"well how many books have you written/how many number ones have you had/how many successful movies have you made?" or simply "€œthink you can do better? Then why don't you?€"

Advertisement

It's silly. And not just because we take it personally; believing that the opinions of your audience don't matter is a sure-fire way to end up making crappy products. Which people often do, especially in films.

Funnily enough, when they do, there are fans who prove that they can do better. Beginning in the early days of the internet, before download speeds increased and editing software became cheap-as-free and it grew into its own cottage industry, fan edits are exactly what they sound like: film obsessives taking movies, and piecing together their own versions of them. That could be chopping out the crappy bits of failed films, putting together €œextended editions€ with deleted scenes and the like, bringing adaptations closer to their source material, or even mashing up multiple different movies into something completely different.

Advertisement

Fan edits have fixed box office bombs and critical pariahs, brought us the €œtrue€ visions that never made it to screen, and also gone off in directions we never could've imagined. Just wait until you see what they did with Star Wars (and not just The Phantom Edit).

These are ten fan edits which totally transform films...

Advertisement

10. Prometheus: Giftbearer

Fox

The general consensus over Ridley Scott's return to the Alien franchise with 2012's Prometheus was...not great. Most audiences would rather they not have bothered explaining where the xenomorphs came from when it entailed loosely defined alien goo, confusing motivations, and predictably evil robots. Rumour had it that the original screenplay, before Lost's Damon Lindelof got his hands on it for rewrites,“ was much better, sticking to its guns as an Alien prequel whilst crafting an exciting, scary space thriller.

Using deleted scenes and other supplementary material, enterprising fan Severian (possibly not their real name) noticed €œPrometheus could be a better movie with those scenes included€. So they put them in.

Advertisement

Prometheus: Giftbearer grounds things a little more in the human story, without getting into all that spiritual, religious mumbo jumbo about space gods and the like. Well, they still show up, but they're not the crux of the plot. It also trims out a lot of the fat, plot holes, fleshes out the characters a little with extended dialogue scenes which allow for more development that the theatrically released version, and makes the final confrontation much scarier, even drafting in some of the original Alien score to recall the tense climax between Ripley and the xenomorph in her escape pod.

Best of all, however, is that with some judicious editing Severian has made the bit where Charlize Theron fails to sidestep a big rolling monolith from crushing her. Thank the maker.

Advertisement

9. Lost: The Miniseries

abc

When it started, JJ Abrams and the rest of the mystery box crew behind ABC's blockbuster TV hit assured us that everything would get explained in the end. They had a plan. Eventually, they would spill the beans on why Oceanic Airlines Flight 815 crash landed on that island, and why that island had a polar bear on, amongst other things.

Advertisement

As it happens they were talking out of their collective bottoms, and pretty much making things up as they go along, before crashing and burning with a terribly unsatisfying ending where (SPOILERS) they were in purgatory all along. Which is one of the first theories people came up with. Also there was time travel involved somehow. We're still not quite sure on the specifics of that one.

Allegedly part of the issue was that Lost was a victim of its own success: they had a plan to wrap everything up in four seasons, but ABC pushed them to continue it further, wanting to keep their cash cow alive as long as possible. Which is why all that ridiculous stuff got made up on the fly. An avid Lost fan going by the name of DriggyDriggs decided to totally change the disappointing final season, cutting it down to a four-part miniseries where the consequences of the season five finale were very, very different.

Advertisement

There's no time travelling. There's none of this nonsense about the afterlife or purgatory or magic churches. It's just a look at the lives of the surviving islanders, and they act more in-character, and the final scene is totally changed, too.

It's pretty neat, and manages to take everything that was in the broadcast version of Lost's final season and takes it in a totally new direction. Which was kinda necessary.

Advertisement

8. Terminator 3: The Coming Storm

Paramount

Oh yeah, Terminator 3, that was a thing. Besides the twist on the usual arrival of the time-travelling killer robots and the fact that one of them was a woman, absolutely no part of Terminator 3 stuck in our memories. It's almost like it never happened.

Advertisement

One person remembered, however, and that person goes by the totally-not-uncool name of Uncanny Antman. The Coming Storm removes any and all cheesy and unnecessary elements, cleans up a lot of the continuity issues, alters the ending, and generally takes the third Terminator film from a somewhat embarrassing live-action cartoon and more in line with the tone of the rest of the trilogy.

Now if only he could give Salvation a quick once over, too...

Advertisement

7. Spider-Man 3: Redemption

Sony

Probably the most derided and critically reviled film in modern cinema history, Sam Raimi's third Spider-Man film took all the quirks and goofy comedic bits he'd managed to conceal amongst the exhilarating superhero theatrics in the first two, brought them to the forefront, and thought we'd be placated by a ridiculous number of supervillains on show. Instead we just got an incredibly uneven movie with bad attempts at comedy, weird performances, and very little room to breathe amongst the introduction of three new bad guys, a second romantic interest for Peter Parker, and the mercifully brief sequence of Tobey Maguire with an emo fringe dancing down a street, pretending to be a badass. Urgh.

Advertisement

Badscooter did us all a favour by taking the scissors to Spider-Man 3's bloated running time (it ran for over two hours in the cinema, TWO HOURS FFS) and producing a much tighter version so that Sandman doesn't appear at all - which highlights how unimportant the character was to the overall film - Harry doesn't get told the whole Green Goblin story by his butler, Peter's motivations when preyed upon by the alien symbiote make a lot more sense, and literally every single one of those stupid Three Stooges gags, emo Parker dancing and flirting, the goofy musical cues and any joke that isn't a traditional Spidey one-liner has been excised.

By the time Badscooter's done with it, Spider-Man 3: Redemption isn't just watchable; it's downright enjoyable. Not something we never though we'd say about this cinematic abomination.

Advertisement

6. Twin Peaks: Fire Walk With Me €“(Teresa Banks And The Last Days Of Laura Palmer)

tumblr

Despite an inauspicious end Twin Peaks - the gonzo, surreal soap opera-cum-murder-mystery David Lynch somehow got ABC to commission for a prime time slot in the early nineties €- has managed to maintain a sizeable and dedicated cult following, even twenty years after it went off the air.

Advertisement

Recently re-watching the whole series on Blu-Ray, the occasionally awful, always strange story of murdered school girl Laura Palmer, possibly insane FBI agent Dale Cooper and the twisted, bonkers people who populate the titular town, has never looked like this before. Even better, the Blu-ray paved the way for Twin Peaks: Fire Walk With Me €(Teresa Banks And The Last Days Of Laura Palmer), a 3.5 hour redo of the feature film prequel to the show (which caused a bunch of controversy on release), Fire Walk With Me.

Fire Walk With Me did a lot of weird things. It went back to before the series, despite the show ending on an unresolved cliffhanger; it introduced further plot threads, which were destined to never be tidied up; it made the supernatural subtext of the show indisputable text; it had teleporting David Bowie. It brought up more questions than it answered. It was confusing.

Advertisement

Slightly less confusing is this assemblage of the original film, alongside all the deleted scenes of the Blu-Ray release previously assumed lost on the cutting room floor. Almost an hour longer, Teresa Banks And The Last Days of Laura Palmer includes those scenes, a rearrangement of others, and some extended parts that clear up some of the complex mythology behind the film and series.

5. War Of The Stars: A New Hope Grindhoused

tumblr

The Man Behind The Mask was a man with a dream €“- a dream of turning Jaws into the schlocky, cheap-and-cheerful exploitation film it so richly deserved. The book it was based on was a pulpy mess which Steven Spielberg somehow managed to elevate into the first example of the modern Hollywood blockbuster, and we love it, but wouldn't it be fun to make it more like its influence? He succeeded in that dream, too, but then he realised that no grindhouse flick gets released on its own; they're all double features. But what other film could stand the same treatment, with added gore, silly music, scratches, missing reels, all that? Star Wars, duh.

Advertisement

So he set to work producing War of the Stars: A New Hope Grindhoused, a total re-do of the first film in the series which reveals its low-budget, low-expectation genre origins. Star Wars was inspired by the sort of slightly crummy film serials and genre fare shown at grindhouse cinemas, so the film makes a surprisingly good fit for the sort of style Robert Rodriguez and Quentin Tarantino were aiming for with their Grindhouse double bill of Planet Terror and Death Proof.

Using the original, non-special edition footage (which has the right faded, aged look) and inserting some equally tatty deleted scenes and alternate takes, A New Hope reveals itself to what it always should've been: a shonky production with a lot of bad acting, clunky dialogue, cheap special effects, and R2-D2's dialogue being subtitled in the manner of an angsty blaxploitation sidekick.

Advertisement

4. The Matrix DeZIONized

Warner Bros.

There are a great many things wrong with The Matrix sequels. So many, in fact, that we would need a whole other article to list them. One of the main scenes that came under scrutiny in the Matrix Reloaded, however, was the weird orgy-rave-thing that happened in the €œreal world€ of Zion, where humanity is a pocket of rebellious so-and-sos who have escaped the computer simulation and the killer robots that keep them there, starting a new underground society where they can all dress like they just came back from a gap year in Cambodia where they, like, helped make a school and really discovered themselves and they really know how to live out there, you know?

Advertisement

We think sometimes they have more things to teach us than the other way round. Any time we went to Zion, in fact, was a drag. We don't wanna watch a bunch of dirty hippies banging in a cave, we want Keanu Reeves stopping bullets with his brain and Agent Smith jumping on cars like the floor is lava! So thank the architect that is CBB for producing The Matrix DeZIONized, which takes both the sequels (Reloaded and Revolutions) and cuts them down into one film which is all killer, no filler. And there was a considerable amount of filler in there, which is probably how they got a pair of two-hour long movies down into one.

There's absolutely zero Zion action, the weird fake-out €œdeath€ of Trinity goes too (which means the Jesus parallels with Neo are, mercifully, kept to a minimum), a bunch of exposition-heavy speeches are in the bin, and instead we just get a sweet sequel to The Matrix that's heavy on the stylish action we loved, and light on the tedious philosophising and techno babble we hated. Everybody's happy! Well, we're happy. Which is basically the same thing.

Advertisement

3. Bateman Begins: An American Psycho

tumblr

Now, this is where stuff begins to get a little weirder. Certainly a lot more creative. As radical a change as everything in War of the Stars: A New Hope Grindhoused is, that's nothing compared to the crazy amount of work and imagination that went into creating Bateman Begins: An American Psycho. There's a fun internet meme about how similar two of Christian Bale's most famous on-screen roles are €“ namely, that American Psycho - Patrick Bateman and Batman's Bruce Wayne are basically variations on a theme, mentally disturbed rich people who like to enact violence on others. See? Fun.

Advertisement

But not quite enough for one Adabisi, who goes a step further by turning American Psycho and Batman Begins into one film. Oh and also footage from The Machinist, The Dark Knight and even a blast of that aforementioned infamous on-set meltdown Bale had whilst filming Terminator Salvation. Cos boy did he sound crazy.

Somehow combining all of that source material into one cohesive narrative actually works, as Bruce Wayne trains himself to take down the corruption in Gotham City (whilst under the guise of stockbroker "Patrick Bateman"), only to have a psychotic break and start murdering loads of people.

Advertisement

Not Batman, no murdered parents, no gadgets or supervillains, just a rich dude with good intentions going off the deep end and slaughtering a lot of people whilst listening to Huey Lewis. It's bonkers, and brilliant, and we have no idea what to make of it.

2. The Phantom Edit

Lucasfilm

The fan edit to end all fan edits, which also kickstarted the whole trend of fan edits in the first place. The Phantom Edit was the original attempt at taking a film nobody liked and trying to reshape it into something more palatable. Whether or not you think the first of the Star Wars prequels deserves a reputation quite as bad as it has, it's definitely far from perfect. There's Jar-Jar Binks, there's that incredibly boring opening crawl about taxes, the slightly racist alien races, the midchlorians, the confusing climactic sequence, the bad acting by usually dependable actors, and then there's Jake Lloyd...man, so much went wrong with that film. Proving that you can, in fact, polish a turd in this case is Mike J Nichols, who aimed to make a film which better followed the previous execution and philosophies of film storytelling and editing of George Lucas.

Advertisement

So he wanted to make it less terrible, and more like the original trilogy, basically. Jar-Jar Binks is almost entirely absent from the Phantom Edit, as are all the terrible explanations of the Force and how it manifests in people, the goofy dialogue between the battle droids, the annoying speech patterns of the young Anakin Skywalker, and a total of eighteen minutes cut from the original film.

All the political stuff gets kicked to the curb, there's a lot less exposition, the editing is changed to be more in line with the original films, and deleted scenes pave over the many, many plot holes. It's a marvellous piece of work which takes a total turkey to something you'd actually wanna watch, an opinion shared by the likes of legit filmmakers such as Kevin Smith.

Advertisement

The Phantom Edit became the talk of €“fans and professionals alike €“during the early noughties, with no less than Lucasfilm condoning it. Is there any higher praise?

1. Cosmogony

Fox Searchlight

We promised fan edits which radically transform films, and we hope we've delivered. We've had edits that change the genre of films, which turn failures into unqualified successes, which blend several different films into something completely new. Cosmogony is something completely different. Cosmogony takes a handful of recognisable source materials, and mashes them up into something totally different. It takes films as varied as 2001: A Space Odyssey, There Will Be Blood and Jurassic Park III, and turns them into a new movie that hasn't got anything in common with any of those.

Advertisement

Another project from the grindhouse-crazy The Man Behind The Mask, this one is a heck of a lot more ambitious. Boasting the enigmatic tagline "A fanedit about us", the official synopsis elucidates further: "Cosmogony is a fanedit using a lot of movies to tell the story of humanity and nature, from the creation of life to wherever we are going."

The Man himself goes into his intentions in piecing this new film together, saying "I thought it would be cool to use all the great movies about the various wars and iconic moments in human history." He's basically made The Tree Of Life, only instead of getting Brad Pitt in the same film with CGI dinosaurs, he's done it with existing footage. That's crazy! He's taken something like a dozen films, all made at totally different times and completely different genres, and somehow weaved them together into a whole, a transcendent (and more than a little pretentious) piece of cinema about the history of humanity, and where we might go next.

Advertisement

With Daniel Day Lewis talking about milkshakes whilst Lou Reed & Metallica plays in the background. That's...certainly something. And definitely a fan edit which radically transforms not just one, but a whole mess of films. Isn't technology amazing?

Advertisement