10 Films You Probably Hated As A Kid But Love Now

To think, once upon a time you probably preferred "Hook" to all of these movies.

By J.D. Westfall /

Our individual opinions on movies are defined by a lot of things, such as our upbringing, our life stories, the movies our parents liked, and what our friends say. One notion that is undeniable, however, is that those tastes and opinions will change over time. It's a simple fact that movies we loved as a kid probably aren't as enjoyable to us as adults, after all. And in a similar way, we often find ourselves revisiting movies we hated as a kid, only to realize that... holy cow, this movie is amazing! To provide some examples of instances where this might be true, I built a time machine and went back to the year 1999, and asked little eight-year old me to write a review of some of my most hated movies from that period, after which I devised a review written by a present day, twenty-two year old me. On board? Let's begin, then, but do be warned: eight-year-old me is awful when it comes to giving away any spoilers...

10. Casablanca

8 Year Old Me: This movie sounded so cool. Set in Morocco during World War II, around a bar owned by an American, and it gets visited by Allies and Nazis alike. Doesn't that set-up sound awesome? Tense, suspenseful, and all? Well it's not. Just talking and boredom. And somehow, romance? How did they get that in there? Seriously, they really missed the mark on this movie. 22 Year Old Me: Wow, it's simply incredible how I could have completely missed the point of this film. The movie isn't about the battle between the two factions in the bar, or even necessarily the war. Sure, war is a central theme, but you could set this film during any war and it would still work. That's because the movie is about the struggle one man has with his neutrality, especially once his former love gets involved with it. And while there's walls of dialogue in here, there's no boredom to be found. Many scenes are powerful, and even moving. A particularly powerful scene is when the German army begins singing a patriotic song, and then one Frenchman begins defiantly singing the French national anthem. The scene slowly builds as the entire bar divides into two sides singing one song or another, until finally the French singing overpowers the Nazis. Due to that and many more incredible scenes, this movie is typically regarded as being one of the best films of all time, and with good reason.

9. The Elephant Man

8 Year Old Me: What is this? What. Is. This? I couldn't even finish this thing. The beginning scene with the creepy elephants and the lady screaming and.... ugh, it was just too weird. I thought this David Lynch guy had a doomed career, but then I saw Dune. Now that was an awesome movie. 22 Year Old Me: Incredible, that's the best way to describe this. I've talked before about how fantastic the makeup in this movie is, but there's still so much more to it than that. First, the whole look of the movie is amazing with a very gritty Victorian look. Also amazing, of course, is the story it tells... It follows John Merrick - a real historical figure who was born with one of the worst physical deformities ever witnessed in a human being - and the mercy shown him by a surgeon named Frederick Treves. Considering who was involved with getting this film off the ground (Mel Brooks and David Lynch), it's a surprisingly beautiful and emotional slice of filmmaking. But special praise must surely be reserved for John Hurt for his great acting job. Take a look at the picture above. How many people could pull off acting with that much makeup on their face? Let alone get nominated for a Best Actor award at the Oscars the following year?

8. Life Is Beautiful

8 Year Old Me: First off, this movie was filmed in a different language, so the mouths move all funny when people are talking. That alone makes this a bad movie, but it gets worse. While it starts off funny, it gets depressing really quick, and has the main guy and his whole family get thrown into a Nazi concentration camp. I thought this movie was called Life Is Beautiful! Beautiful? Holocaust? Doesn't work. Then to make things worse, the main guy dies. And right after that, the movie ends! What's up with that? 22 Year Old Me: This movie has gone down in my personal records as being the only film to successfully make me cry. Because while 8 year old me may have had a valid point about it being odd to call a Holocaust movie Life Is Beautiful, the film certainly has lots of beauty. You just have to watch. As the introduction itself tells us...
"This is a simple story, but not an easy one to tell. Like a fable, there is sorrow. And like a fable, it is full of wonder and happiness."
See, the beauty of the film is not what happens to the main character, Guido. The beauty is how he puts everything aside - including his own safety, and eventually his very life - just to ensure the survival of his wife and his son. Throughout their entire ordeal, he constructs stories to tell his son to keep him from realizing the horror of what's happening, and in the end sacrifices himself so his family can escape. After this has all happened, the film ends with a voiceover by his son...
"This was my father's sacrifice. This was his gift to me."
And that, ladies and gentlemen, is beauty.

7. 12 Angry Men

8 Year Old Me: Ugh, not this movie. This movie is so pretentious. From the title I thought it would be exciting, and at least have some punching or something. But no, it's just two hours of a bunch of guys sitting around in a room talking to each other! They don't even leave the room! They talk about some court case (boring) and argue about it. Literally nothing happens in this movie. Also, it's in black and white! What's up with that? They'd had movies in color for like, a hundred years by then. 22 Year Old Me: This movie is incredible. Who would have thought you could make a suspenseful, captivating film about murder without ever showing the murder happen? The way the director Sidney Lumet is able to project the audience into the atmosphere of the film is simply unparalleled. The way the camera starts high in the room, but slowly lowers into eye level of all the characters gives a sense of forced claustrophobia, so you begin to feel the anxiety the jurors are experiencing. The noise of the city slowly creeps in, especially while important discussions are taking place, so you totally understand when one of the jurors explodes with anger. And you don't even realize you sympathize with him! Of course, the script and pacing are vital to this film as well. The characters review the entire case, piece by piece, and in doing so uncover truths that had been right before their eyes which they had missed previously. Finally, the acting is powerful, particularly in the parts when it's revealed some of them are allowing their prejudices and opinions to cloud the facts. Truly, this film is a classic, and is one of my favorite films of all time.

6. My Fair Lady

8 Year Old Me: Why does Mom watch this movie so much? It's just.... ugh. Here's everything wrong with the movie. First, it's three hours long! We spend three whole hours watching some snooty guy teach a girl to speak with a different accent. Seriously, that is the whole plot. Second, they sing through the whole thing! It hardly ever stops! Third... what is that stupid outfit the girl is wearing? 22 Year Old Me: This film stands out to me as being one of the better Best Picture winners, despite some heavy competition that year (Dr. Strangelove, Becket, and Mary Poppins, each of which would be worthy of the win)! The film conveys one of the most elegantly simple love stories ever told. As eight year old me described, it follows a pretentious phonetics professor who makes a bet with another man that he can take a woman off the street and teach her to speak so well that she could pass as being a duchess at an upcoming embassy ball. As time goes on however, they slowly begin falling for each other, despite frequent clashes and outbursts at one another. While that may sound terribly cliched amidst today's glut of unimaginative romantic comedies, part of the charm of My Fair Lady is how easily and even subtly it expresses the idea. At no point in the film do the characters tell each other "I love you". At no point do they kiss one another, or even embrace in a romantic way. And yet, Rex Harrison and Audrey Hepburn carry their roles so well you can feel it developing right along with them. Plus, the songs are amazing. I dare you to hear "Wouldn't It Be Loverly" or "I Could Have Danced All Night" and not immediately become happier.

5. Sleuth

8 Year Old Me: What is wrong with this movie? It's called Sleuth, but there is no cool detective story, there's no mystery, no villains... all it has is two guys talking about how to stage a break-in, but they don't even do it! They start arguing, and that's like all there is to it! Of course, it takes them something like three hours to do this. Plus, there's lots of shots of like creepy animatronics that don't do anything. Seriously, what is up with this movie? 22 Year Old Me: I really have no idea how I could have ever not liked this film. There is just so much brilliance that went into this movie! Let's start with the credits at the beginning. It lists several actors and characters in the film, as is normal. But it isn't until later you realize there were really only two people in the film - Michael Caine and Laurence Olivier. That's right, they straight up invented a batch of actors and characters just to pad out the credits. Additionally, there's so many twists and turns that it's nearly impossible to keep up with it. The twists keep coming, one after another, long past the point you expect any film would have the bravery to do. I don't want to reveal too much (the fact there's only two actors in the film gives away too much as it is!), but this film is a must see for any fan of the mystery genre. Brilliant writing, incredible acting (this is one of only two films to have the entire cast nominated for acting Oscars), even the set decoration is memorable and may possibly give you nightmares.

4. 2001: A Space Odyssey

8 Year Old Me: What is this movie supposed to be about? Does anyone know? Anyone? It gives me a headache trying to comprehend. The first third of the movie is a bunch of stupid monkeys throwing a bunch of stupid bones at a big black slab. The next third is a decent space movie, but nowhere near as awesome as, say, Star Wars Episode I: The Phantom Menace. The last third is... I dunno, a Pink Floyd music video? It just makes no sense. At all. Skip it and watch a good space movie instead. 22 Year Old Me: This is a perfect example of a movie that is better without an explanation. I find it much more enjoyable to argue over the meaning than to have it explained. See, there's totally a meaning to it. Arthur C. Clarke wrote a novelization of the film which pretty clearly lays out the meaning. But does an understanding of a film necessarily improve the viewing experience? Absolutely not, as this movie proves to us. In addition to the opportunities for amateur philosophising about the movie and its meaning, the film is also a treat for the eyes (as I've written about before) and for the ears. The sparse dialogue, replaced with a classical music soundtrack, provides us with some of the most enduring moments in film history - not to be missed.

3. City Lights

8 Year Old Me: This movie is silent. Therefore, it is a bad movie. 22 Year Old Me: How can someone write off a film based solely off the fact that there's no audible dialogue? How can they overlook the brilliance with which many silent movies were told, and the revolutionary ideas committed to film? Ever since I overcame my bigotry towards silent films, I've discovered a whole new realm of beauty I never knew existed. Few movies better exemplify this beauty than Charlie Chaplin's crowning achievement, City Lights. Released a full four years after talkies became the norm, City Lights tells a simple, moving story: a homeless man, The Tramp, meets a blind flower girl who mistakes him for being a rich aristocrat. Moved with pity for her, this former drifter sets about earning money to pay for an eye operation so she can see again. He goes from job to job, scheme to scheme, sacrificing everything for a girl who doesn't even know the truth about him. Along with way, the film strikes a stunning balance between hilarity and pathos, sometimes making you laugh and be depressed in the same scene. Again, I would feel remiss to give away everything that happens, but it is worth noting that even today many regard the closing scene of City Lights to be among the finest acting ever put to celluloid.

2. Rear Window

8 Year Old Me: I thought Alfred Hitchcock was supposed to be cool. He gave us that awesome movie where Cary Grant gets chased by an airplane and then climbs down Mount Rushmore. He gave us that scary movie with the people getting stabbed in the shower (at least, I think it looks cool. Dad won't let me watch it).

Advertisement

But man, where did he go wrong with this movie? The idea is cool. Jimmy Stewart is a guy who's spying on his neighbors and figures out that one of the guys murdered his own wife. Only problem is that Jimmy Stewart is stuck in a wheelchair through the whole movie and never leaves his apartment! This movie is like watching a movie about a guy watching a movie, and nothing else. He can't do anything about it! He calls the police, but you know how that turns out in movies. This movie is just really dull, and throws away a brilliant concept.

I don't think it's coincidence that this guy was in Hitchcock's other stupid movie, Vertigo. Does anyone like that movie?

Advertisement

22 Year Old Me: It actually hurts to read the review by eight year old me. Everything I once hated about this film is now what makes me recognize it as being brilliant. One of my fondest memories in recent months is watching a run of this film at a small local theater. Seeing this movie on a big screen was simply incredible. I have never ever been so utterly immersed in a film experience before or since.

The way Hitchcock constructs the little world of this film is amazing. All you see is what Stewart's character L.B. Jeffries can see. But even in that tiny world, all his neighbors are fully developed characters despite having no lines. Most of the musical score comes from a piano playing neighbor who leaves his windows open. And how does someone construct a totally believable murder mystery while never visiting the crime scene, simply looking at it through open curtains?

Advertisement

Hitchcock does it.

1. Lawrence Of Arabia

8 Year Old Me: Oh please no - don't make me think about this movie again. Watching it was like watching paint dry while having needles stuck under my fingernails. For three and a half hours, we are promised a war movie. Doesn't that sound great? A war movie in the desert with guys wielding swords on horseback? How could that possibly go wrong? I'll tell you how. By not actually having any of that! Instead it keeps being about this Lawrence guy being sad, then yelling things, back and forth and back and forth. Did I mention this happens for three and a half hours? 22 Year Old Me: If I were to talk about what makes Lawrence of Arabia one of the greatest films of all time, we'd be here all day. Thus, I'll try to hit the highlights. First, of course, is the visuals. I never would have thought (I certainly didn't when I was eight) that vast expanses of sand dunes could be awe-inspiring, but this film shows it. The amazing landscapes are punctuated by insignificant figures of men and horses and camels crossing the desert, giving you a sense of the trials one would face attempting such a journey. Secondly, the characterization of Lawrence is stunning. He begins as a rather ordinary soldier, who discovers his abilities when thrust into the right circumstances. At this point, we witness his slow transformation into an egomaniac who is so sure of himself and his strength that he walks into an enemy base alone. But the greatest thing about this film must be Peter O'Toole's incredible performance. I've included one scene taken from the film to give you a brief impression of his stellar acting. To put it in context, Lawrence's tiny army is on their way to Damascus for a very important mission when they come to a village that was home to some of his men. Upon arrival, they see the village has been ransacked and the inhabitants slaughtered. Still in view is the army that did it. At this point, Lawrence must choose: do his duty and progress to Damascus, or avenge the deaths of the villagers? This scene still gives me goosebumps no matter how many times I see it. And to think that when I first saw this film, I fell asleep during this part. Eight year old me, you were fun... but you sure had terrible taste in movies. So how about all of you? Any films you hated as a kid but love now? Sound off in the comments below!