10 Great Blockbusters Held Back By A Terrible Lead Performance
Even huge budgets and special effects aren't enough to cover up some terrible acting.
Just like nobody sets out to make a bad movie on purpose, no actor in their right mind would sign on to a project with the express intention of being terrible at their job, but it still happens nonetheless.
Not everybody gets to be as remarkably consistent as a Daniel Day-Lewis or a Christian Bale, and there can be a number of factors that contribute to a dismal performance. Sometimes the actor in question just never feels like the right fit for the role, there could be disagreements behind the scenes or even the necessity to fill a contractual obligation despite having little to no interest in the material.
Bad acting has sank far too many movies to mention, but it doesn't always have to be the deciding factor between success or failure. Plenty of great movies have featured either woefully miscast stars, talents exposed for being out of their depth or people that can never seem to get to grips with the script, but have still somehow managed to get results in spite of the shortcomings from the person with their name above the title.
10. Ryan Reynolds - Safe House
Denzel Washington and Ryan Reynolds are two of the most consistently watchable and charismatic actors in the business, so the prospect of seeing the two sharing the screen in the sort of star-powered two-hander with a decent budget that Hollywood rarely tends to make anymore initially made Safe House a hugely exciting prospect.
While Denzel is on typically great form as criminal mastermind Tobin Frost, Reynolds lets the side down with a disappointingly flat turn as rookie agent Matt Weston, with his performance as bland and formulaic as his character's backstory as he finds himself being easily overpowered by the sheer wattage of his adversary's star power.
It seemed as though Reynolds was under instructions to deliver the most derivative version of his established screen persona as possible as the cookie-cutter 'untested agent out of his depth and forced to improvise' archetype. Ultimately, this hurt the quality of the final product as his fellow A-lister easily stole the show without coming close to capitalizing on the potential chemistry between them.
9. Kevin Costner - Robin Hood: Prince of Thieves
Populating a blockbuster adaptation of one of England's most legendary folk heroes with a largely American cast was already a strange creative direction for Robin Hood: Prince of Thieves to take, but it just smacked of laziness that star Kevin Costner didn't even bother to even attempt any other accent than his signature drawl.
The movie was a huge hit that would go on to earn over $390m at the box office, although it unfortunately gifted the world with Bryan Adams' toe-curlingly awful ballad, but it largely succeeds in spite of the leading man's awful performance as the title character.
Without a doubt Prince of Thieves belongs to Alan Rickman's Sheriff of Nottingham, who almost single-handedly saves the entire movie from disaster as the scenery-devouring villain who blows everybody else away with one of the most gloriously over-the-top turns ever committed to the big screen.
Anytime the movie cuts from Rickman to Costner, it only reinforces how ill-equipped and out of his depth the latter was in trying to prove himself as a tights-wearing man of action.
8. Garrett Hedlund - Tron: Legacy
Tron: Legacy is full of stunning visuals, detailed and ambitious world-building, a thumping Daft Punk soundtrack and some jaw-dropping production design, but arguably the only thing more artificial than the world itself is Garrett Hedlund's attempts to convince us that he's well-suited to play the leading man in a $170m blockbuster.
The role of an audience surrogate is to guide us through an unfamiliar world, and it becomes a whole lot easier when we see things unfold through the eyes of a character that we're invested in. Unfortunately, Hedlund is not that man, and he ends up being comfortably outshined by an ensemble of co-stars that are deliberately avoiding all attempts to portray themselves as human beings.
Somehow, Hedlund's Sam Flynn turns out to be less emotive than the terrifying de-aging CGI that was uncomfortably plastered onto Jeff Bridges' face, although he ironically ends up delivering a performance as sterilized and cold as the world of Tron itself.
7. Jennifer Lawrence - X-Men: Days Of Future Past
Jennifer Lawrence only received fifth billing for her first outing as Mystique in X-Men: First Class, but the following year she scooped Best Actress at the Academy Awards for Silver Linings Playbook while also headlining the massively successful first installment in The Hunger Games series, and now that she was firmly established as one of the world's biggest movie stars she appeared to lose any interest in being a part of Fox's mutant franchise.
Her newfound status at the top of the A-list saw her given a much more prominent role in sequel Days of Future Past, but the increased amount of screentime only made it abundantly clear that she couldn't be bothered anymore. The prequel/sequel hybrid remains one of the finest X-Men movies, but anytime Lawrence appears you can almost feel the resignation and sense of contractual obligation in every line of dialogue.
Her performances got worse in the subsequent Apocalypse and Dark Phoenix, but Days of Future Past was the first time that the studio made it clear they were pushing their biggest name to the forefront of the series, even though she clearly didn't want to be there in the first place.
6. Aaron Taylor-Johnson - Godzilla
Gareth Edwards' Godzilla was a generally well-received reboot for the iconic kaiju, although a lot of people both praised and criticized the movie for the very same reason. The slow-burning approach to revealing the title character in all his fire-breathing glory built up a sense of anticipation that gradually rose as the story built to a crescendo, but holding off on the big guy didn't go down well with some audiences that have been conditioned to expect big-budget pyrotechnics from almost the very first frame.
These sorts of blockbuster monster movies are often let down by their thinly-drawn human characters, and despite boasting an ensemble cast of talented actors, leading man Aaron Taylor-Johnson turned out to be the wrong choice to hinge the entire narrative on.
Taylor-Johnson has proven to be a phenomenal actor with a huge amount of range, but for some reason he decided to channel the color beige when it came to portraying Ford Brody, a leading man as laughably generic as his randomly-generated action hero name. From almost the second Bryan Cranston gets bumped off and his onscreen son is forced to do the dramatic heavy lifting, the human aspect of Godzilla failed to generate even a shred of interest.
5. Orlando Bloom - Pirates Of The Caribbean: Curse Of The Black Pearl
Johnny Depp may have taken top billing, stolen all the headlines, created one of the most iconic movie characters of the 21st Century and scored his first ever Academy Award nomination for his troubles, but Captain Jack Sparrow is not Pirates of the Caribbean: Curse of the Black Pearl's leading man.
That honor falls to Orlando Bloom's Will Turner, who fills the audience surrogate role as both he and us find ourselves slowly introduced to the world of piracy and the wacky band of misfits that inhabit it. Unfortunately, the actor's one-note and stoic heroism renders him as a less than engaging presence, one that gets reduced to rubble anytime he shares the screen with Depp's tour-de-force of bizarre tics.
Captain Jack inevitably found himself the focus of the franchise, but it eventually turned out that he worked much better in significantly smaller doses, although the studio didn't really have much of a choice after the constantly-frowning Will Turner appeared to undergo a total charisma bypass and ended up as the first installment's least interesting character.
4. Charlie Hunnam - Pacific Rim
Anybody that's seen Sons of Anarchy, The Lost City of Z or Guy Ritchie's The Gentlemen knows that Charlie Hunnam is far from the terrible actor that his misadventures in the realm of Hollywood blockbusters seem to have painted him as, and it would probably be for the best if he stayed away from chancing his arm at headlining another big-budget blockbuster for a while yet.
Nobody paid to see Pacific Rim in order to witness a disgraced hero's bid for redemption, but it would at least help if the movie managed to give us a protagonist that was at least halfway interesting to tide us over until we got to the main course of giant robots and giant monsters beating seven shades of sh*t out of each other.
After trying to establish a tragic backstory that only leads to a yawn-inducing battle of the blands between Hunnam's Raleigh Beckett and his brother Yancy, the Geordie actor fails to give us any reason to care about a character that's less expressive than the giant robots he co-pilots, and they don't even have faces.
Obviously human drama was not Pacific Rim's major selling point, but Hunnam's lead performance was so weak that most people just found themselves twiddling their thumbs until the smashy smashy started all over again.
3. Taylor Kitsch - John Carter
John Carter is nowhere near as bad of a movie as the dismal box office performance and subsequent reputation as one of the biggest financial disasters of all-time would suggest, but Andrew Stanton's sci-fi epic failed miserably on two very important counts.
One was the marketing, with the promo footage making it come across as yet another in a long line of familiar space operas, despite the fact that Edgar Rice Burroughs' source material was one of the most influential works in the genre that had inspired everything from Star Wars to Avatar.
The other was the leading man, with 2012 going down in the history books as the year Hollywood tried and failed to turn Taylor Kitsch into a movie star. With all of the world-building, extensive mythology, intergalactic warfare and green-screen shenanigans filling virtually every frame of the movie, John Carter required a leading man able to hold his own against all of the technological wizardry on show, not one that would fade into the background.
He tried his best, but a niche story like A Princess of Mars needs a hero that both fans and more casual viewers can identify with and relate to, and Kitsch's monotone and relentlessly stoic performance ended up going down like a lead balloon.
2. Keanu Reeves - Bram Stoker's Dracula
Keanu Reeves has spent virtually his entire career battling against accusations that he isn't a very good actor, but you don't spend nearly 30 years as one of the industry's most recognizable and popular stars without doing more than a few things right.
Having starred in four of the greatest action movies ever made thanks to Point Break, Speed, The Matrix and John Wick, Reeves has more than proven his action hero credentials. However, his work in more dramatic fare has often left a lot to be desired, and that's never been made clearer than his painful turn in Francis Ford Coppola's Dracula.
Coppola's movie is the kind of thing that the studios just won't take a risk on anymore unless its being made by Tim Burton, a blockbuster-sized gothic horror fantasy that doesn't shy away from being very strange and often disturbing with a star-studded ensemble each taking their turn to chew the scenery.
However, Reeves is awful as Jonathan Harker. Just awful. His misguided attempts at nailing an English accent only draw more attention to how bad his acting is, and he's hopelessly outgunned and outmatched by every other member of the cast, with the obvious exception of the just-as-terrible Winona Ryder.
1. Hayden Christensen - Star Wars: Episode III - Revenge Of The Sith
Following on from his laughable efforts in Attack of the Clones, many Star Wars fans were right to be concerned about how Hayden Christensen would fare when tasked with concluding one of the franchise's most important story arcs when Anakin Skywalker's turn to the dark side was completed in Revenge of the Sith.
While his performance was undoubtedly hugely improved from his stilted work in the previous movie, it still wasn't up to scratch given the narrative stakes. As a whole, Revenge of the Sith offered up plenty of thrilling action-driven spectacle and is the best of the prequel trilogy by some distance, but audiences never once felt convinced that Christensen's portrayal of Anakin was believable enough to convince you that he would eventually become the most feared man in the entire galaxy.
That being said, the movie still managed to succeed almost in spite of the leading man's limitations as an actor, but certain Star Wars aficionados will always feel let down by George Lucas' poor judgement when it came to casting the man who would become go on to become Darth Vader.