10 Great Movie Performances (No One Ever Talks About)

Shame on audiences for sleeping on these fantastic performances.

By Jack Pooley /

As much as many of the year's finest performances get praised lavished upon them at year-end awards ceremonies and the endless reams of "best-of" lists, there are so many more great feats of acting that sadly end up slipping through the cracks.

Advertisement

We as audiences can naturally only ever see so much, but it's always a crying shame when fantastic performances end up fading into the ether.

These 10 performances are all remarkable acting achievements, each bringing an uncharacteristic honesty to their characters no matter the genre or tone.

And while in most cases these movies contain their respective actors' finest acting work to date, they largely fell upon deaf ears on release or shortly therefore, winning a quick swath of critical praise before everyone moved onto the next big thing.

But these performances absolutely shouldn't be slept on - they're often superior to the turns that actually did win Oscars in their respective years, and deserve to be seen by as many film lovers as possible.

In particular, if you're a fan of any of these actors, these performances should be considered required viewing...

10. Ted Levine - The Silence Of The Lambs

0

Considering it's one of just three movies in history to win the Big Five Academy Awards - that's Best Picture, Director, Actor, Actress, and Screenplay - it might seem odd to talk about any aspect of The Silence of the Lambs as underappreciated.

Advertisement

But people trip over themselves to praise the performances of Anthony Hopkins and Jodie Foster so much - quite understandably, at least - that they seem to forget the film's third great piece of acting.

Ted Levine plays the supporting role of deranged serial killer Buffalo Bill, delivering an utterly bone-chilling performance which bafflingly received little praise from awards bodies and isn't much talked about today.

As much as Hopkins' performance as Hannibal Lecter became impossibly iconic, Levine's work is equally great, without which Jonathan Demme's thriller wouldn't be nearly as viscerally unsettling.

His performance is so much more than the widely-parodied scene where Bill tucks in his junk in the mirror while listening to "Goodbye Horses," but that's the single image most people associate Levine with.

That Levine wasn't nominated for a Best Supporting Actor Oscar in a relatively soft year, where Jack Palance won the award for City Slickers no less, is nothing short of criminal.

9. Oscar Isaac - A Most Violent Year

There's little doubt that Oscar Isaac will end up with an Academy Award sooner or later, and he absolutely should've been nominated for one in J.C. Chandor's expertly crafted crime drama A Most Violent Year.

Advertisement

Despite scoring strong critical praise and considerable awards hype, the film sank like a stone at the box office and failed to make a dent on the awards circuit, ensuring Isaac's sublime work largely went unsung.

Isaac plays Abel Morales, a heating oil entrepreneur who struggles to expand his business in the face of extreme, often violent competition.

This isn't a remotely showy performance from Isaac but instead a phenomenally restrained piece of acting, simmering with furious intensity in a way reminiscent of '70s Al Pacino.

Though Isaac's career skyrocketed the very next year after he appeared in Star Wars: The Force Awakens, this is still the strongest work he's ever produced, and yet curious few have actually seen it. Don't sleep on it any longer.

8. Charlize Theron - Young Adult

To be completely fair, Charlize Theron did receive a Best Actress Golden Globe nomination for her astonishing performance in Jason Reitman's dark dramedy Young Adult, yet given how the film and the performance quickly fell off the radar thereafter, you'd barely know it.

Advertisement

Theron plays Mavis Gary, a garden variety trainwreck of a human being - a 37-year-old alcoholic ghost writer who returns to her hometown in the hope of winning back her happily married high school boyfriend (Patrick Wilson).

Theron takes a potentially cartoonish character trapped in a state of arrested development and makes her unexpectedly relatable, tapdancing on a tonal razor's edge as she renders Mavis both pitiable and weirdly charming.

It's tough to make a blatant a**hole this likeable, but she pulls it off splendidly. Furiosa's great and all, but this is arguably the finest performance of Theron's storied career, and one that absolutely merits far more attention than it's ever received.

7. Michael Stuhlbarg - A Serious Man

Surely the best performance in a Coen brothers movie that nobody ever actually talks about, Michael Stuhlbarg is magnificent as put-upon physics professor Larry Gopnik, who struggles to reconcile his Jewish faith with the avalanche of bad luck coming his way.

Advertisement

A legendary sad sack performance for the ages, Stuhlbarg is perfectly in tune with the Coens' singularly off-kilter tone, delivering a deliciously deadpan performance as the deck becomes increasingly stacked against Larry.

Larry's search for meaning in a world seemingly devoid of it is intensely relatable no matter your own faith, and though it's not a performance filled with Oscar-baiting tirades, it was wholly worthy of a Best Actor nomination.

Stuhlbarg was at least nominated by the Golden Globes, and though the role absolutely made his career, it's rarely mentioned in the pantheon of great Coen brothers performances, for shame.

6. Tilda Swinton - We Need To Talk About Kevin

Tilda Swinton is one of cinema's all-time great chameleons, yet has arguably never been better than when playing one of her more down-to-Earth characters in Lynne Ramsay's challenging drama We Need to Talk About Kevin.

Advertisement

Swinton plays Eva Khatchadourian, the mother of the titular Kevin (Ezra Miller), who is in prison after going on a high school killing spree.

Much of the film is focused on Eva trying to come to terms with her son's act and any role she may have played in it by failing to bond with her son.

Though much of Eva's emotion is subtle and internalised, Swinton does a fantastic job depicting a self-tormented woman who is quite literally spat on by society.

The film's subject matter makes for uncomfortable viewing, yet thanks to Ramsay's uncompromising approach, Swinton is able to deliver a frank, full-bodied rendition of a parent in crisis.

Once again, though, the Golden Globes at least nominated her for Best Actress while the Academy flatly ignored her.

5. Aaron Eckhart - Thank You For Smoking

As much as you could probably put Aaron Eckhart's underrated performance as The Dark Knight's Harvey Dent on this list - considering how thoroughly he's overshadowed by Heath Ledger's Joker - the strongest work of his career actually came a few years earlier in Jason Reitman's satirical drama Thank You for Smoking.

Advertisement

The chisel-jawed, impossibly slick Eckhart is perfectly cast as Big Tobacco spokesman Nick Naylor, so infuriatingly charming as to be entirely believable in the role of a man intended to re-shape public opinion re: smoking.

And yet, the majority of audiences will associate Eckhart with The Dark Knight and not a whole lot else, despite this being the easy standout turn of his career.

And in what's starting to sound like a broken record, Eckhart was also nominated for a Golden Globe for his performance all while the Academy snubbed him.

4. Robert Pattinson - Cosmopolis

As much as many had an intense knee-jerk reaction to Robert Pattinson's casting as Batman, the actor has won himself a tremendous amount of goodwill in recent years with terrific performances in the likes of Good Time, High Life, The Lighthouse, and The Devil All the Time.

Advertisement

But even in the midst of his years as part of the Twilight franchise, Pattinson proved himself incredibly talented, yet many weren't ready to hear it.

In the case of David Cronenberg's 2012 dramatic thriller Cosmopolis, you can at least understand why so many people slept on it - the film is incredibly challenging with its dense dialogue, "random" asides, and generally inaccessible filmmaking style.

But no matter what you make of the film entire, Pattinson's performance as self-destructive billionaire Eric Packer is brilliantly calibrated to make lurid sense of author Don DeLillo's knowingly verbose, stream-of-consciousness dialogue.

It confirmed Pattinson was a "serious" actor years before most of the world actually caught onto this fact, many instead dismissing it out of hand as "the Twilight guy" playing dress-up.

Unsurprisingly Pattinson received little awards attention for his turn, but if you've become enamoured by his more recent work, you absolutely need to pay this 2012 cult gem a visit.

3. Marion Cotillard - Rust & Bone

Though Marion Cotillard missed out on an Oscar nomination for her performance in Jacques Audiard's stellar 2012 drama Rust and Bone, her performance was largely lauded on the awards circuit, even if it ultimately picked up few wins.

Advertisement

Cotillard plays killer whale trainer Stéphanie, who after an accident involving one of the animals has her legs amputated, and naturally struggles to adjust to her new mode of life.

Cotillard does so much more than simply make us basically sympathise with Stéphanie - it's a deeply visceral performance which demonstrates the toughness and strength-of-character required to adjust to such a drastic change in life circumstances.

Despite being lauded at the time, Cotillard's work here is rarely mentioned when discussing the actress these days, largely overshadowed by her more statuesque performances in films such as Inception and The Dark Knight Rises (namely that infamous death scene).

2. Val Kilmer - Tombstone

As much as Val Kilmer has a ton of iconic performances to his name, the one that absolutely doesn't get nearly enough credit is his movie-stealing turn as a tuberculosis-riddled Doc Holliday in the terrifically entertaining 1993 western Tombstone.

Advertisement

Though Kurt Russell's Wyatt Earp is by all rights the film's protagonist, Tombstone belongs to Kilmer's loquacious, weirdly suave, and totally badass Holliday.

Kilmer's charismatic turn grabs the viewer's attention in every second, which amid an ensemble cast this accomplished is no easy feat.

It's the finest work of his career bar none, and while Kilmer's performance was widely lauded by critics at the time, the film quickly disappeared from the public consciousness after its Christmas release.

As much as anyone who's seen Tombstone is bound to be knocked out by Kilmer, it's a shame his performance isn't more talked about in comparison to, say, his roles in the likes of Top Gun, The Doors, Heat, Kiss Kiss Bang Bang, and even Batman Forever.

Bafflingly, the only awards Kilmer even ended up nominated for was two MTV Movie Awards for... "Best Male Performance" and "Most Desirable Male." Oof.

1. Ryan Reynolds - Buried

Ryan Reynolds has certainly enjoyed a major career turnaround over the last five years with the phenomenal success of the Deadpool movies, and though it's absolutely fair to call Deadpool his signature performance, it still isn't quite his best.

Advertisement

The finest work of Reynolds' career came in 2010 in the gut-wrenching thriller Buried, playing American contractor Paul Conroy, who while working in Iraq is kidnapped and buried alive in a wooden coffin.

Expertly directed by Rodrigo Cortés for maximum claustrophobic suspense, Buried is an almost entirely one-man show for Reynolds, being the only actor we physically see on-screen for the movie's entirety, while speaking to a small cast of supporting characters on the phone.

Back in 2010, few would've ever guessed he had a performance this gutsy and persuasive in him, and even today, it stands far apart from the wise-cracking roles he's made his name on.

And yet, despite strong reviews and a solid box office performance, Buried is largely forgotten a decade later, Deadpool casting such an impossibly large shadow over his back catalogue as it does.

Advertisement