Christopher Nolans Interstellar, released last month to a largely positive reception, has had its critics; many have described it as Nolan's weakest, complete with the trademark ambition but not the entertainment value or satisfying storytelling weve come to expect from the director. But while Interstellar is a deeply flawed film, and one that did divide viewers, most critics at least agreed upon certain things. For instance, theres the powerful performance by Matthew McConaughey in the lead role, the sheer emotive power of what must be Nolan's most personal film, and the majesty of the visual effects, with the sequence depicting the Endurance's journey through the wormhole in particular drawing praise. Interstellar has rightly been celebrated for these things, but while those are certainly some of the most obvious plus points, they're not the be-all and end-all. Nolans movie is a dense, 169-minute behemoth, full of hard science and myriad characters big and small. It's an epic science fiction extravaganza. Attempting to tackle the entirety of the movie, therefore - positives, negatives and all - is inevitably going to prove difficult. Its why so many great aspects of the film have yet to receive their due. Here are 10 positives of Interstellar that many have so far over-looked. Spoilers follow.
10. The Mere Presence Of Michael Caine
After six straight projects together, it's easy to lose sight of how effective the working relationship between Michael Caine and Christopher Nolan has been. With the actor cast in every film of Nolan's since 2005, an appearance by Caine in a his movies has become as predictable as the Hitchcock cameo. That shouldn't detract, however, from the fact that Caine is no mere good luck charm: he's an icon of cinema that's arguably never been encouraged to be more human than he is in Nolan's films (back in his cool 60s/70s heyday, the idea of a warm, avuncular Michael Caine would've been unthinkable). On collaboration number six, Caine is just as effective for Nolan as ever. Professor Brand may be no great feat of character writing on the part of co-screenwriters Christopher and his brother Jonathan Nolan, but in Caine's hands Brand is lent immediate weight and gravitas in his early scenes, and a crushing emotionality in later ones. Plus, what with Caine retiring from acting and all (apparently unless the "right script" comes along - no doubt Nolan will still have him on speed dial), a standout supporting performance of Caine's so late in his career done with such ease is to be savoured, not taken for granted.
9. The Robot Design
It's difficult this late in the game to design A.I. for a movie that doesn't appear either derivative or just plain boring. Kudos, then, to the design staff of Interstellar for cooking up something that not only looks striking (TARS turning into a spinning wheel to better navigate through the water of Miller's planet is a must-rewind moment for when the film arrives on home video), but that also registers as practical. This, of course, chimes with Nolan's insistence on always keeping his films' designs firmly in the world of the realistic, but perhaps the single greatest achievement concerning the robots of Interstellar is how much we're able to connect with them. If there's one chief problem with Interstellar, it's that some of the characters are sorely under-developed. Robots TARS and CASE, meanwhile, have more personality than most of the humans in the film. While TARS is a sarcastic, garrulous and ever-so-slightly sadistic droid, counterpart CASE is a more reticent and downbeat machine, and both are lent expert vocal work by Bill Irwin and Josh Stewart. When we lose the robots late in the game to the black hole, it's a Wilson-in-Castaway moment: suddenly, there's an unexpected feeling of loss for someTHING as opposed to someONE.
8. The Feminist Slant
Is it a coincidence that the first and last words we hear in Interstellar come from a woman? Perhaps, but first take into account how crucial the actions of women are in the film. Very few big, effects-driven films are powered by strong women; fewer even acknowledge the necessity of women beyond looking pretty and existing as objects for the men. Interstellar may have one of Hollywood's most bankable male stars in the lead role, but make no mistake that Interstellar's women play a huge role. Consider the fact that Amelia Brand (Anne Hathaway), most likely named after legendary explorer Amelia Earhart, simultaneously gets further across the universe than anyone in human history and establishes a vital new colony for mankind. Consider that it's Murphy (Jessica Chastain), and not Prof. Brand, that cracks the gravity problem, thus saving humanity from extinction on Earth. Murph's are the first and final words of the film, and it's her - much to Cooper's surprise - that has gone down in history as a hero by the time Cooper re-emerges from the black hole. Far too many Hollywood films ignore the importance of women in society; Interstellar tries to restore the balance.
7. The Realisation Of The Space Scenes
Following Alfonso Cuaron's Gravity, it was always going to be tough for a while to make an impact when it came to movie scenes set in outer space. Cuaron's effortless-looking depiction of a zero-G, zero-oxygen, zero-sound environment represents the high watermark to which all other space-set films must aspire and, post-Gravity, it's as though we've all forgotten how difficult it is to achieve this level of realism. And yet, in its own quiet way, Interstellar deals with the intricacies of space on film with a similar proficiency. Note the physics involved in Dr Mann's unsuccessful attempt to manually board the Endurance: from Mann's docking to eventual ejection and the shattering of the Endurance, Nolan and his team have crafted something balletic but messy and suffocating. Or witness the Endurance's trip across our solar system to the wormhole, in itself a short, mesmerising star trek reminiscent of the Discovery One's journey in 2001: A Space Odyssey. Had Interstellar been released prior to Gravity, more people would be talking about how well-handled the space-set scenes of Nolan's film are.
6. The Message
While 2014 was a good year for pertinent messages sneaking into Hollywood blockbusters - think the subversive counter-culturalism of the vaguely socialist The Lego Movie, or the mutually-assured-destruction allegory of the covertly anti-war Dawn of the Planet of the Apes - Interstellar took perhaps the bravest stance in asking us to consider the fate of our children and grandchildren on this planet. Interstellar has a responsibility, as a blockbuster, to first and foremost entertain the audience, but there's a lingering sense of dread over those initial scenes set on Earth that suggests Nolan is asking a generation to really think about where things are heading. The dread doesn't relent much when the action moves into space, and the feeling that time is running out on this last-ditch attempt to find alternative shelter for mankind worsens as the film rolls on. This makes Interstellar an important film, even if it's not always a narratively successful one. No other recent blockbuster has been so conscious of our need to explore and move forward; no other recent blockbuster has tackled environmental awareness with such effect. And it's done so effectively because of...
5. The Dystopian Future
Has there ever been a more terrifying issue approached with such mundane familiarity than Interstellar's slow eco-apocalypse? When you think dystopian cinema, you think the garish neon of a choking LA in Blade Runner, or the ostentatiously Orwellian architecture of the city at the heart of Brazil. Interstellar, however, offers a much sadder, more recognisable look at humanity's struggle in the near-future. In Interstellar, the Earth has become a dustbowl, with resources scarce, and people, now many of them farmers, living on the only few crops that still grow. Interstellar's Earth is a world coated in dirt. Here, there are no more armies, there's no more space programme, and there are definitely no more hotdogs at baseball games. What's left is a planet full of people trying to live out a facade of normal life while putting all their effort into making sure there's just enough food to go around. New generations are now simply 'caretakers' of the almost all dried-up globe, inhabitants of a dystopian future facing the ultimate oppression: there is no place to escape to.
4. Romilly
While the tear-jerking hook for many Interstellar fans is Cooper missing 23 years of his childrens' lives while trapped on Miller's planet then playing back decades of family messages, less notice has been given to the character of Romilly (David Gyasi), whose arc is the film's secret emotional weapon. Left on the Endurance while Cooper and Amelia carry out their ill-fated scout of Miller's planet, Romilly is forced to live in isolation for almost a quarter of a century until he sees his crewmates again. When they return, young as when they left, Romilly's grown into middle-age. It's a shocking, bizarrely emotional scene played out with commendable understatement. David Gyasi is excellent in a part that never really asks much of him. He gives life to Romilly in minor ways: nervously cracking wise about travel sickness with Amelia; showing tangible excitement when asked by Cooper to explain wormholes in layman's terms; the way he is, 23 years older, slouched and marred by unspoken loneliness. A constant, though, is that Gyasi keeps Romilly as a consummate, dignified professional throughout, never one to give in to emotion even when the most trying circumstances have clearly worn him out. If there's any justice, there'll be much bigger things for the actor to come.
3. The Practical Effects
Maybe it's because everyone's just so used to Nolan's canny implementation of practical effects; maybe the practical effects are just particularly seamless in Interstellar. Whatever the reason, there wasn't enough appreciation for the blend of model work, scale mock-ups and real environments used in Nolan's latest, even if the CGI'd combo of the wormhole and Gargantua deservedly got much of the praise. Taking a page out of 2001: A Space Odyssey's book, Interstellar uses old-school techniques where possible to give effects work a more realistic look. Old school like 3D printed and hand-sculpted "maxatures", which is what the crew named the 25-feet and up models of the The Ranger, Endurance and Lander spacecraft. Included in filming were 46-feet and 50-feet 'miniatures' of The Ranger and Lander craft, big enough for cinematographer Hoyte van Hoytema to mount IMAX cameras on. Nolan also avoided green screens, by having his actors perform in front of digital projectors, with the completed effects played behind them. It's easily some of the best practical effects work done of late.
2. Anne Hathaway's Performance
Much of the acting praise for Interstellar has gone to Matthew McConaughey and Jessica Chastain, understandable considering they get the meatiest roles in the film and give two highly charged performances. Anne Hathaway's Amelia Brand, on the other hand, feels like something of a side act in Cooper's story, at least until her final coup de grace of kickstarting a new human colony on Edmunds's planet. But Hathaway is, regardless, one of the best performers on show, convincingly making Amelia a strong, intelligent and flawed human being. The scene in which Amelia reveals that her feelings for Wolf Edmunds may have swayed her decision-making could have come across as hokey and unbelievable - we're talking about a scientist declaring that "love is the only thing that transcends time and space," after all. But Hathaway sells it: the anguish and frustration Amelia feels at the prospect of probably never seeing Wolf again is clear in those big expressive eyes of Hathaway's. The actress is good enough to warrant her character her own film - a sequel, perhaps?
1. Hans Zimmer's Score
Yes, it contributes to the cacophony that drowns out some of Interstellar's dialogue, but that doesn't mean what composer Hans Zimmer wanted us to hear isn't worth listening to. His Interstellar score, in fact, is one of his best, not least because it's so surprisingly uncomplicated, melodious and tranquil. Zimmer gave the world the over-egged wailing of Gladiator and the booming orchestral arrangements of Inception, so it's a pleasant surprise to hear him reduced to the organ and some minor percussion, strings and synth for Interstellar. The result is music that's almost religious. While most critics have focused on the way Zimmer's score is occasionally used overbearingly in Interstellar, it must also be said how effective the soundtrack is the majority of the time. It gives key moments boosts of inspiration, heartache or sorrow, and unquestionably does some major emotional lifting in the film. Zimmer spent two years working on this score, inspired by Nolan's notes insisting on the composer drawing on his personal reflections on parenthood and loneliness. If Interstellar deserves an Oscar for anything this awards season, it's for having one of the best scores of 2014. Now the dust has settled, what are your thoughts on Interstellar? What other over-looked positives are there for Nolan's latest?