10 Major Blockbusters You Knew Were Doomed Before Release

The films that made you wonder - why didn't they cut out the middle man and set a pile of money ablaze?

By Scott Campbell /

For an industry that seems to be taking increasingly less risks, Hollywood sure does like to spend hundreds of millions of dollars on properties that are by no means guaranteed to be successful. In this era of franchise filmmaking, movie studios are increasingly hedging their bets on mega-budget blockbusters in the hope it can lead to a lucrative string of feature films and merchandising spin-offs. When it works, it works well. The Marvel Cinematic Universe, the X-Men series, Pirates of the Caribbean, Transformers and both cinematic incarnations of Spider-Man are just a few of the franchises that have consistently generated solid returns over a series of summer tent-poles, regardless of quality. Based on a recognisable property with a built-in fanbase, these movies will always earn big bucks at the box office. However, Hollywood will never stop looking for the next great franchise and will run the risk of huge financial losses in an attempt to create it. With that in mind, this article will take a look at 10 major blockbusters that were always destined to fail. Some of these movies are ambitious projects that were plagued by bad publicity, while others just never seemed like great ideas to start with. The common thread that unites them is that their box office failure could have been predicted from a mile away. Do you agree with the article? Did any of these blockbusters ever have a real chance of success? Are there any other movies that you would have included? As always, sound off in the comments below.

10. The Lone Ranger (2013)

On paper, The Lone Ranger looked like a guaranteed smash hit. The studio, producer, writers, director and star that had combined to steer the first three Pirates of the Caribbean movies to over $2.5bn at the box office reunited in the hope that transporting the formula to the Western genre would yield similar results. It didn't. It was announced way back in September 2008 that Johnny Depp would be playing Tonto, with Gore Verbinski named as director in September 2010. The problems began when the production was temporarily delayed before a single frame had been shot due to concerns with a budget that had spiralled to over $250m, a frankly ridiculous amount of money to be spending on a Western. The production was beset with problems including wildfires, adverse weather conditions and the unfortunate death of a crew member, with rumours from the set full of tales of excess such as Verbinski's demands that the trains featured in the movie be built entirely from scratch at great financial cost. It seemed as though the knives were already out for Disney's latest mega-budget gamble, which carried extra significance given the huge loss made on John Carter just a year previously. Many analysts were predicting the movie would bomb, which would surely explain why the Pirates of the Caribbean connection was so heavily played up in the marketing. After several release date changes, The Lone Ranger hit theatres on July 3 and earned a catastrophic $29.2m during its opening weekend, and ultimately failed to even crack $100m domestic. The movie just about clawed back its budget with a worldwide gross of $260.5m but resulted in yet another huge financial write-down for Walt Disney Pictures.

9. Speed 2: Cruise Control (1997)

Speed is one of the greatest action movies ever made, a pulsating high-concept adrenaline ride that earned over ten times its $30m production budget. Director Jan de Bont's next movie was Twister, which would gross almost $500m to become the second highest-grossing movie of 1996. Unfortunately, the contractually-obligated sequel would turn out to be one of the biggest misfires in the history of blockbuster filmmaking. The first warning sign came when star Keanu Reeves opted not to return to the franchise, and was instead replaced by the bland Jason Patric. Next came the news that a movie with 'Speed' in the title would take place on a cruise ship, not renowned as the fastest mode of transport. Thirdly, the cringeworthy pun was added as a subtitle. Get it? Because they're on a cruise ship! The sequel was given a hefty $110m budget, of which a whopping $25m was spent solely on the final scene where the ship crashes into the island of Saint Martin. It was obvious that Speed 2 wasn't going to be very good based solely on the trailer, which comes equipped with poor dialogue, steel drum music, a portentous voiceover and constant references to the first movie. Widely regarded as one of the worst sequels ever made, the movie made less than $50m domestically and earned just $164.5m worldwide. Speed 2 would also go on to claim eight Razzie nominations and become acknowledged as terrible on numerous occasions by star Sandra Bullock.

8. Stealth (2005)

A high-concept blockbuster about a fighter jet powered by artificial intelligence that gains increased self-awareness when it gets struck by lightning sounds inherently stupid. Which is because it is. A lazy mash-up of Top Gun and 2001 directed by journeyman hack Rob Cohen, Stealth unsurprisingly tanked at the box office. Jessica Biel, Josh Lucas and Jamie Foxx play the cardboard cut-out lead characters that can be boiled down to 'cocky hotshot', 'tomboy' and 'laid-back cool guy' archetypes, with Foxx taking the tried-and-tested route of winning an Academy Award and then immediately starring in an awful studio movie. It was almost a guarantee that this movie would bomb upon viewing the first trailer, which treated the laughable concept with po-faced seriousness and awful dialogue. To the surprise of almost nobody, Stealth flopped hard and could only open in fourth place at the domestic box office with a paltry $13.2m. Backed by overwhelmingly negative reviews, audiences stayed away from the movie and it earned just $76.9m against the $135m production budget, resulting in one of the biggest box office disasters in history that ended up costing Columbia Pictures almost $100m.

7. R.I.P.D. (2013)

You'd think Ryan Reynolds would have learned his lesson about starring in comic book movies after Blade: Trinity, X-Men Origins and Green Lantern yet here he is, taking one of the lead roles in this tediously banal studio picture that lazily ripped off Men in Black and ended up becoming one of the biggest box office disasters in history. The only remotely watchable part of R.I.P.D is Jeff Bridges, who at least seems to be having fun in his role as a demented cowboy. The marketing was as bland and formulaic as the movie itself and didn't even attempt to look like anything other than an MiB knock-off, with Reynolds portraying one of the least interesting main characters in recent blockbuster history. Tellingly, the movie was not screened in advance for critics, which was a bad sign for a project that was rumoured to cost $130m. Clocking in at just 96 minutes, R.I.P.D still manages to be painfully unfunny, predictable and cliched while boasting some of the worst CGI seen in a studio tent-pole release. Many predicted the movie would tank months before it hit theaters, and boy were they right. Opening at an embarrassing seventh place at the domestic box office with $12.7m, R.I.P.D earned just over $78m worldwide and resulted in a huge financial loss for Universal Pictures.

6. Jack the Giant Slayer (2013)

Hollywood's obsession with live-action fairy tales continues at pace, with the impending release of Maleficent and Kenneth Branagh's Cinderella set for next year. Those movies would do well to avoid comparisons with Jack the Giant Slayer, a CGI-overloaded blockbuster that couldn't decide if it was a darker take on the material or a child-friendly family picture. With Bryan Singer behind the camera, Christopher McQuarrie's involvement with the script and a talented ensemble led by Nicholas Hoult that also featured Ewan MacGregor, Stanley Tucci, Eddie Marsan, Ian McShane and Bill Nighy, the project definitely had potential. A worrying sign was when the original June 2012 release date was pushed back by nine months to the following March, a month not renowned for successful blockbusters. Then came the first trailer, which featured hugely unconvincing CGI giants, which came as a surprise considering the movie was worked on by no less than seven effects houses. The studio virtually admitted they had a flop on their hands when they projected an opening weekend of just $30m, a disastrously low number for a project that had cost $185m even before factoring in the marketing budget. Although the movie took first place at the domestic box office, it still underperformed and earned just $27.2m. With worldwide grosses of just under $200m, Jack the Giant Slayer ended up posting a loss of well over $120m which came as little surprise as very few had believed the movie would be a success.

5. Cutthroat Island (1995)

The movie that effectively killed the pirate genre for a decade and accelerated the bankruptcy of Carolco Pictures remains one of the most infamous financial disasters in Hollywood history. The mind-boggling thing about Cutthroat Island is that everybody knew it was going to be a disaster a long time before it sank without a trace in theatres. With husband and wife team Renny Harlin and Geena Davis directing and starring, Michael Douglas was signed to bring an A-list presence to the cast. He soon dropped out, with Tom Cruise, Keanu Reeves, Jeff Bridges, Charlie Sheen, Liam Neeson, Ralph Fiennes and Michael Keaton all turning down the role before Matthew Modine was cast. No disrespect to the actor, but he surely wasn't who the studio had in mind to headline a $100m movie. When the director arrived on set, he was unhappy with the set design and ordered extensive rebuilding at great cost, as well as spending a million dollars of his own money on rewriting the script. Problems continued when cameras finally began rolling, as a dispute that saw Harlin fire the chief camera operator saw dozens of crew members quit in protest, as well as the logistical nightmares brought by shooting on water. Fittingly for such a troubled production, Cutthroat Island opened in thirteenth place at the domestic box office with a dismal gross of $2.4m, and quietly disappeared from theaters with a total domestic haul of just over $10m. The movie added just $8.5m from overseas markets to result in a financial write-down of nearly $100m, which came as no surprise to those who had been following the extravagant production.

4. Mars Needs Moms (2011)

Mars Needs Moms became the biggest box office bomb in history when it was released in March 2011 and tanked spectacularly, resulting in one of the biggest embarrassments in the history of Walt Disney Pictures. A movie about aliens kidnapping a child's mother was always going to be a tough sell to family audiences, and negative word-of-mouth seemed to have Mars Needs Moms doomed long before it hit theaters. Robert Zemeckis' decade-long obsession with performance capture was admirable, if a little misguided. As one of the most talented filmmakers of his generation it would have been much better to see the director tackle more live-action projects than direct and produce a number of features that could never truly escape the uncanny valley. The marketing for Mars Needs Moms often made it out to be visually spectacular, but also made it look a little creepy when it came to the human characters, while trailers made the movie to look like a generic family comedy full of light-hearted pop music and poor attempts at humor. Audiences stayed away from the movie in droves, and it could only muster a $6.9m domestic debut despite playing in over 3100 theaters, which was nothing short of a disaster but not exactly a shock. With a budget of $150m, Mars Needs Moms earned a catastrophic $39m worldwide that resulted in a huge financial loss and marked the death-knell for ImageMovers Digital.

3. Battlefield Earth (2000)

Prominent Scientologist John Travolta making a movie based on the novel from Scientology founder L. Ron Hubbard, plowing millions of dollars of his own money into the project after years of failing to secure funding from major Hollywood studios, that was finally set up at Franchise Pictures, which was a company founded by a Lebanese dry-cleaning mogul turned nightclub owner with a track record of making awful movies. What could possibly go wrong? As passion projects go, Travolta wanting to play an 8ft tall Rastafarian alien in a dystopian sci-fi is up there with the strangest. Even stranger is that the actor initially approached none other than Quentin Tarantino to direct (did he honestly think that would happen?) and that he described the project as 'like Star Wars, but better'. Battlefield Earth was always destined to fail; the media were constantly scrutinising the possible Scientology influence, while a leaked copy of the script that was circulated under a false name was given dismal reviews. The $73m vanity project opened to vitriolic reviews that labeled it as one of the worst movies ever made, and it tanked at the box office with a total worldwide gross of just $29.7m. However, Battlefield Earth did score success at the Razzies where it scooped seven awards including Worst Picture, Worst Director, Worst Actor and Worst Screenplay. If there was ever a movie that was destined to fail, it was Battlefield Earth.

2. John Carter (2012)

An adaptation of Edgar Rice Burrough's seminal sci-fi had been in the works for years, with names including Robert Rodriguez and Jon Favreau attached at various points before the rights returned to Disney with Finding Nemo and Wall-E director Andrew Stanton set to make his live-action debut. Unfortunately, despite being an entertainingly old-fashioned adventure armed with cutting-edge CGI, John Carter became one of the biggest bombs in box office history. As soon as the movie entered production, many were predicting that the project would be a financial disaster. An unproven live-action director handed a $250m budget to make an epic sci-fi based on a story first written in 1917 that required incredibly complex effects work was a huge gamble. During production, and possibly in response to the financial catastrophe Mars Needs Moms, allusions to the red planet were dropped from the title in favor of the painfully generic 'John Carter', with rumours that the movie needed to earn at least $600m simply to break even placing crushing expectations on the project. John Carter could only open in second place at the domestic box office with just over $30m, and closed with just $73m in the States. Overseas, the movie did much better and earned $211m (almost 75% of the total gross) but the worldwide takings of $284.1m saw a financial write-down of over $100m and Disney publicly acknowledge the hit they had taken with the project. A visually stunning, massively ambitious project that will no doubt increase its cult following over the years, the sad fact remains that John Carter was always likely to be a box office bomb.

1. 47 Ronin (2013)

Did anybody really think that 47 Ronin was going to be a success? Anybody? Taking a Japanese national legend and turning it into an epic fantasy action film featuring witches, dragons and monsters starring Keanu Reeves always sounded like a strange concept for a movie, not to mention a difficult sell. Originally set for release in November 2012, a number of delays saw the movie finally hit theatres 13 months later, where it swiftly became one of the biggest box office disasters in history. The project seemed to be troubled for the start. Handing Carl Rinsch a budget of $175m for his very first feature was a huge gamble, with constant rumblings from the set that the director was struggling to manage a project of such magnitude. Rumours abounded that things had gotten so bad that Rinsch was locked out of the post-production process, although these were swiftly denied. Before release, the movie was not screened to critics and Universal went so far as to acknowledge they had taken a financial hit on the movie before it had even hit theatres, something which is virtually unheard of. When it was finally released, 47 Ronin could only make it to ninth place at the domestic box office with a debut weekend of just $9.9m, and the movie would fail to even get to $40m Stateside. Even more embarrassingly, the movie tanked in Japan where it opened in third place with $1.3m, showing the disdain audiences there had for the Hollywoodized version of the tale. Worldwide, 47 Ronin earned a little over $150m, which is roughly the same cost as the financial write-down. The sad thing is, none of this came as any surprise.