10 MAJOR Plot Holes In The Star Wars Sequel Trilogy
Reflecting back on the biggest head-scratchers of the final trilogy in the famed Skywalker Saga.
With the final installment of the Skywalker Saga now well in our rear-view mirror, fans have had time to digest the Star Wars sequel trilogy and explore the positives and negatives.
To some, just having three more Star Wars movies is enough to put a smile on their face, while to others there's a sense of bashing any new and fresh move these films make. Regardless of your overarching thoughts on The Force Awakens, The Last Jedi, and The Rise of Skywalker as a collective, there are clearly some major plus points across these pictures - and likewise, there are some moments and plot strands that simply didn't hit home.
One thing that all three of these latest jaunts to a galaxy far, far away - at least in a Skywalker Saga sense - have in common, is that there are several undeniable plot holes strewn throughout them. And while some of these plot holes may have been elaborated on and explained in recent comic books and novels, not everybody who watches the sequel trilogy will be privy to said comics and books.
With that in mind, then, here are ten head-scratching plot holes from the closing trilogy of the Skywalker Saga.
10. The Reconstruction Of Luke's Lightsaber
Before The Rise of Skywalker, the last time we saw Luke Skywalker’s trusty lightsaber it was being pulled to pieces by Rey and Kylo Ren in The Last Jedi. But magically, by Episode IX of the Skywalker Saga, Luke’s weapon was in perfect working under.
If you remember, The Last Jedi saw a Force tug-of-war of sorts that saw Luke’s lightsaber pulled into a million tiny pieces. Without even the mildest of explanations, this was all forgotten about by the time we see Rey with this exact weapon in The Rise of Skywalker.
One could maybe attempt to make the argument that Rey repaired the lightsaber herself at some point between the events of The Last Jedi and The Rise of Skywalker, but that argument can be immediately countered by how the closing moments of The Rise of Skywalker imply that Rey has yet to ever build – or in this case reconstruct – a lightsaber.
So, just how did Luke’s lightsaber get repaired? Who repaired it? How were they able to repair it? And how is it flawlessly back in one, perfectly working piece?
9. The Millennium Falcon's Fuel
Seeing the Millennium Falcon fire up and escape from Jakku in The Force Awakens is one of the most breathtaking set pieces of the most recent Star Wars trilogy. Still, there's one huge plot hole in amongst all of this.
The audience is led to believe that the Falcon has been left to rot in the desert land of Jakku, with the old girl now merely a big ol' hunk of junk that's long since passed its best days - which makes it all the more head-scratching that Rey, Finn, and BB-8 power up this most legendary of vessels and use it to outrun the nefarious First Order.
If, as we've been told, the Falcon has indeed spent years or even decades in the dusty and coarse landscape of Jakku, surely it would take just a little while longer to get her back up and running - if it was even possible to get her working whatsoever.
Added to that, just how is there fuel still in the Millennium Falcon when we're reintroduced to the ship in The Force Awakens? Even if the Falcon happened to be dumped with a full tank of fuel, that fuel would've dried up and evaporated way before Rey, Finn, and BB-8 stumble across this bird that once did the Kessel run in less than 12 parsecs.
8. Those Force Voices
One of the most impressive, fan-pleasing moments of The Rise of Skywalker saw Rey visited by the voices of a whole host of fallen Jedi as she’s being pummelled by Emperor Palpatine.
From what we know, said fallen Jedi include Yoda, Luke Skywalker, Mace Windu, Qui-Gon Jinn, Obi-Wan Kenobi, Anakin Skywalker, Ahsoka Tano, Kanan Jarrus, Adi Gallia, Luminara Undull, and Aayla Secura. The element of all of this that doesn’t make sense, however, is tied to Qui-Gon.
Back in The Phantom Menace, Liam Neeson’s Qui-Gon explained how he was the first Jedi in centuries who would be able to communicate through the Force following his death. That means that Qui-Gon gets a pass on being able to speak to Rey. But the rest of those Jedi? Not so much so.
Jinn was killed off before he was able to pass this knowledge on to any of his fellow Jedi Knights, which would seem to suggest that it would be impossible for any Jedi other than Qui-Gon to be able to speak from the beyond the grave.
You could possibly say that somebody as wise as Yoda could likely teach themselves this particular trick, but it still feels questionable to have had so many Jedi have this ability considering that such a big deal was made about Qui-Gon Jinn being the first Jedi for generations to be able to pull this trick off.
7. The Idiocy Of Palpatine
Considering that he’s lived for hundreds of years and is a supreme being with a vast intellect, the Emperor ended the sequel trilogy looking like a complete and utter idiot.
The famed saying about the definition of stupidity being repeating your actions but expecting different results is something that Palpatine is culpable of in The Rise of Skywalker. Despite his apparent genius, this Sith Lord is made up look like a total boob as he again falls back on using his lightning abilities on Rey.
Back in Revenge of the Sith, Palpatine was left disfigured after just such an attack on Mace Windu saw this lightning fired back at him. And that is again the source of his ultimate demise in The Rise of Skywalker – this time with Rey pulling inspiration from Windu’s playbook.
Of course, this is without even taking into account how well his lightning attack on Luke Skywalker went in Return of the Jedi. Back then, it was the reprieved Anakin Skywalker who struck Palpatine while he was mid-flow on yet another blast of lightning.
Speaking in a narrative sense, Palpatine's actions at the end of Episode IX make him look like a total bonehead and makes you question why he'd repeat something that has so clearly failed in previous movies.
6. But Can't Palpatine Just Return Again?
Upon the first teaser trailer for The Rise of Skywalker culminating with the ever-familiar, eerie, chilling cackles of Palpatine, the collective Star Wars fandom lost its mind.
This, of course, being the one and the same Palpatine who was last seen, at least in a chronological sense, thrown to his death by a reformed Anakin Skywalker at the climax of Return of the Jedi. But just how did the most notorious Sith survive his Episode VI demise, and just where has he been in the decades since then?
Truth be told, it's never actually fully explained in The Rise of Skywalker just how The Emperor is alive and well. Dominic Monaghan's Beaumont Kin even hazily questions this resurrection at one point, suggesting it could be dark science, cloning, or some sort of Sith shenanigans. The point being, no finite answer is given to just why Palpatine isn't as dead as we were so long led to believe he was.
At one point, Kylo Ren's bravado of saying he'll kill Palpatine is outright mocked by the Sith Lord, as he kindly informs Kylo that he's died before.
So, if the reason for Palpatine's return here is never properly explained, then what's to say that his apparent death at the hands of Rey and the thousands of Jedi who she channelled would stop any future Palpatine return?
5. Rey's Erratic Force Detection Skills
Granted, The Force Awakens featured a Rey slowly coming to the realisation of just what potential powers lie at her literal fingertips. But by the time of The Rise of Skywalker, viewers see a Rey who has pretty much mastered the Force and is at one with her abilities - well, bar that lack of explanation over the reconstruction of Luke's lightsaber.
With that in mind then, there are a couple of glaring head-scratching moments in Episode IX. Firstly, how did Rey not 'feel' that Chewbacca wasn't actually dead? In amongst all of the presences that we have seen her be able to feel through the Force, surely Rey would have known all along that Chewie wasn't actually as dead as we were meant to believe - particularly as later in the movie we see Rey easily detect the Wookiee is in her vicinity.
Elsewhere, this same flaw can be pinpointed when Kylo Ren appears on the fallen Death Star. This catches Rey off-guard, when it should be even easier for her to detect Kylo due to him likewise being tethered to the Force.
Considering how many other times we see Rey use the Force to sense the presence of others, these two examples make a mockery of all of that.
4. What Was The Point Of The Knights Of Ren?
Not necessarily a plot hole, per se, but it's more of a 'what even was the point?!' situation here.
In the lead to The Force Awakens' release, the Knights of Ren were all over the marketing material for the movie. Looking like nothing but pure, unadulterated, unstoppable badasses, the mere visual of these six warriors at Kylo Ren's side had intrigue and anticipation levels amped up to ridiculous levels amongst long-time franchise fans.
Despite all of the hype surrounding the Knights of Ren, they were barely in The Force Awakens, were completely absent from The Last Jedi, and were simply around in The Rise of Skywalker to serve as fodder for Ben Solo to take down towards the film's climax.
So, after all of the badass imagery, after all of the mystique, after all of the hope of seeing just what these group of warriors were capable of, the Knights of Ren were a pointless addition to the sequel trilogy. It's almost as if they were created purposely to sell a bunch of toys and merchandise, or that the sequel films had so many cooks in the proverbial kitchen that the creative waters of the trilogy were left muddied and confused.
3. Poe's Survival
After a big-screen break of just over ten years, Star Wars raced back to cinemas across the globe in spectacular fashion with the opening act of The Force Awakens.
Used to set up the four core characters - Rey, Kylo Ren, Poe Damiron, and Finn - of this new trilogy, the film hit the ground running in glorious fashion. And key to that, was Poe and Finn hijacking a TIE Fighter as they looked to escape the wrath of the First Order.
That escape wouldn't quite go to plan, and said TIE Fighter was shot down and left in a burning heap. While Finn managed to escape the crash-landing vessel, taking Poe's jacket and the name he gave to this former Stormtrooper in the process, it looked far less promising for Oscar Isaac's character.
As The Force Awakens unfolds, we would eventually see that Poe Dameron actually survived the TIE Fighter crash - although that doesn't really make any sense.
It's never explained how Poe survived, and it's not even realistically feasible for him to have survived.
Going even further down the rabbit hole, the original plan of The Force Awakens' explosive opening was actually to introduce Poe in a major way before killing him off as we arrive in Jakku. Both Isaac and director J.J. Abrams have confirmed this, and rumours suggest that Poe's role may have been expanded once an on-set injury to Harrison Ford hit plans hard for Han Solo having a larger part to play.
Reading between the lines here, and it appears as if nobody could really be bothered to come up with a reasonable explanation as to how Poe would've survived in this rejigged script.
2. The Further Muddling Of The Chosen One
For the longest time, it was open to interpretation that the famed Chosen One of Star Wars lore was either Anakin Skywalker or Luke Skywalker. Some would even offer up Leia Organa as possibly being the true Chosen One. But now, with the sequel Star Wars trilogy behind us, further questions have been thrown up where this topic is concerned.
By all accounts and purposes, the most likely person to be the Chosen One was Anakin. This almost biblical figure was said to bring balance to The Force - which we saw Anakin, as Darth Vader, do by killing off The Emperor at the close of Return of the Jedi.
Some of the wisest beings in the history of the galaxy worked solely on the belief that Anakin was indeed the Chosen One, yet that idea was muddied once again by the events of the sequel trilogy.
Outright plot hole? Maybe, maybe not. But the main head-scratcher here is that the story of the sequel trilogy only served to drum up more confusion about the narrative established in the six Skywalker Saga movies prior to this latest triumvirate.
1. Kylo's Kef Bir Escape
While The Rise of Skywalker may not have split opinion quite as much as The Last Jedi, the final part of the Skywalker Saga still had its fair share of detractors. No matter what your thoughts on the film though, it cannot be denied that the Kef Bir battle between Kylo Ren and Rey on the fallen second Death Star is a phenomenal piece of cinema.
That said, this ocean-set fight did have one ginormous flaw.
After Rey had nabbed Kylo's ride, and with all other vehicles suggested to merely be useless, decayed relics, there is seemingly no way whatsoever that Kylo could have possibly got off that part-submerged Death Star - let alone make it off the planet of Kef Bir.
Still, make it off Kef Bir, Kylo did. After a heart-to-heart meeting with the spirit of his father, the rechristened Ben Solo managed to make it to Exegol just in the nick of time to join Rey in her showdown with Palpatine. How Ben got there, we're never told - and that is something that's since stuck in the craw of many a Star Wars fan.