10 Movie Characters They Couldn't Stop Recasting

These characters just kept looking different.

By Jack Pooley /

In any sufficiently long-running movie franchise, recasting is inevitable - everybody hates it, but on a long enough timeline, it's basically unavoidable.

Advertisement

There comes a time when actors either lose interest in a part, are unavailable due to scheduling conflicts, or sadly pass away, and so producers are left with no choice but to hire a new actor to play the role.

And in some rarer cases it's actually an active, motivated decision on the filmmakers' part, to change the direction or look of a character, or hire a more high-profile performer if the character gets a bigger role in sequels.

It's relatively common to see characters recast once, which is difficult enough, but sometimes characters end up suffering a bout of chronic recasting, where across a single iteration of a franchise they're played by three, four, or even more actors.

How successful this is really depends on the nature of the franchise - comedy generally gets away with it far easier than drama, but if they're a high-profile character, there's sure to be growing pains regardless with each recast.

Indeed, Hollywood just couldn't settle on a single actor - or even just two - to play these roles...

10. Kitty Pryde - X-Men

X-Men's Kitty Pryde is an interesting example to kick things off, because despite there being no discernible time jumps between the first three X-Men movies, the decision was nevertheless made to recast the character in each successive film.

Advertisement

In the first X-Men, Kitty appeared in cameo form as played by Sumela Kay, where we saw her phase through a wall before Professor X (Patrick Stewart) verbally confirmed her to indeed be Kitty Pryde.

In X2, Kay was replaced with Katie Stuart, who appeared briefly during William Stryker's (Brian Cox) assault on the X-Mansion.

But for threequel X-Men: The Last Stand, Kitty Pryde was given a far more substantial role, and so director Brett Ratner quite unsurprisingly decided to cast a more established name actor in the part.

And so, Elliot Page became the third and final performer to portray Kitty Pryde in the X-Men movie franchise, ultimately playing the role in both The Last Stand and X-Men: Days of Future Past to solid acclaim.

Though a Kitty Pryde solo film was also in the works at one point, this was eventually nixed following Disney's acquisition of Fox.

And with the X-Men surely making their debut in the Marvel Cinematic Universe sooner rather than later, there's a fair chance we'll see another new take on Kitty in the coming years - albeit within an entirely different continuity, of course.

9. John Connor - Terminator

It's basically comical at this point how many actors have played The Terminator series' future resistance leader John Connor.

Advertisement

In Terminator 2: Judgment Day, a young John is played in his most iconic form by Edward Furlong, but when Terminator 3: Rise of the Machines went into production over a decade later, Furlong was dropped from the role due to his substance abuse issues.

And so, Nick Stahl was brought aboard as his replacement, but when sequel Terminator Salvation was announced, the producers decided to recast again, apparently because they envisioned a slightly older, gruffer version of John Connor in the film.

And so, Christian Bale was hired for Salvation to much initial fanfare, despite many fans ultimately expressing disappointment with both the film and Bale's so-so performance as Connor.

Between Bale's own misgivings with the film and the next movie, Terminator Genisys, largely opting to ignore it, Connor was again recast, with Jason Clarke now taking the part.

That's four major actors who've played John Connor across six Terminator films, not to mention Michael Edwards briefly playing him in one of T2's future scenes, and Thomas Dekker taking the role for the TV series Terminator: The Sarah Connor Chronicles.

With Terminator: Dark Fate shockingly killing John off, it seemed like the franchise was finally set to move on from him, yet given the film's atrocious box office performance, it remains uncertain what will become of both Connor and the series as a whole.

8. Tommy Jarvis - Friday The 13th

Tommy Jarvis is one of Friday the 13th series' stalwart heroes - one of the few to actually defeat Jason Voorhees and survive to tell the tale to this very day.

Advertisement

Tommy first appeared in the fourth film, Friday the 13th: The Final Chapter, as a child, where he was played by Corey Feldman. Tommy instantly became a fan favourite character, and is singled out for even managing to "kill" Jason at movie's end.

Jason of course returned soon enough, though, and in Friday the 13th: A New Beginning, the part of a traumatised teenage Tommy was primarily played by John Shepherd, with Feldman making only a brief cameo as a younger Tommy.

But Shepherd turned down an invitation to reprise the role for Friday the 13th Part VI: Jason Lives, and so he was recast for a second and to-date final time, with Thom Mathews portraying a more mentally stable, now-adult Tommy.

Since then, Tommy Jarvis has been missing from the franchise despite his esteem among fans. Attempts were made to include him in both Jason Goes to Hell: The Final Friday and 2009's remake, yet neither ultimately came to fruition.

If the legal issues surrounding the rights to the franchise are ever cleared up, though, don't be surprised if Tommy turns up in a reboot, as almost certainly played by yet another actor.

7. Frankenstein's Monster - Frankenstein

Universal's original Frankenstein franchise ran from 1931 to 1948 and saw eight movies released, with a grand total of four actors donning the prosthetics to play Frankenstein's Monster.

Advertisement

First and most famously, of course, the great Boris Karloff played the Monster in the original trilogy - Frankenstein, Bride of Frankenstein, and Son of Frankenstein, as remain the most revered entries into the series.

After that, Lon Chaney Jr. took up the mantle for The Ghost of Frankenstein, and then the legendary Bela Lugosi - who was originally offered the role before Boris Karloff - took over for Frankenstein Meets the Wolf Man.

And finally, Glenn Strange played the Monster for the bookending trilogy, House of Frankenstein, House of Dracula, and Abbott and Costello Meet Frankenstein.

Frankenstein's Monster is admittedly a bit of a Hamlet character - even in movies that exist within the same continuity, he's so much more than any one actor, and so recasting isn't nearly as troubling as it might be for other characters more firmly intertwined with the actor playing them.

That said, Karloff's take on the Monster is certainly the one that most best remember and is therefore generally considered the "definitive" portrayal.

6. Mike & Sean Brody - Jaws

The Jaws franchise admittedly entered an irreversible death spiral almost immediately following Steven Spielberg's beloved original, enough that the regular recasting of Martin Brody's (Roy Scheider) two sons, Mike and Sean, in the sequels was really the least of the series' problems.

Advertisement

It's odd, though, that Mike and Sean are the only characters to appear in all four movies and yet they're also the only ones who were recast in every single sequel.

Now to be completely fair to the franchise, the constantly recasting had a rhyme and reason to it: it was due to the series' ever-advancing timeline and the inevitable necessity to cast older actors in these roles to reflect that. So again, it's more a curiosity than a glaring creative flaw.

Across the franchise, Mike Brody was played by Chris Rebello, Mark Gruner, Dennis Quaid, and then Lance Guest, while Sean was portrayed by Jay Mello, Marc Gilpin, John Putch, and finally Mitchell Anderson.

5. Inspector Clouseau - The Pink Panther

The original Pink Panther movie series ran from 1963 to 1993, during which time nine Pink Panther films were produced and three actors shared the lead role of Inspector Clouseau.

Advertisement

First and most famously, Clouseau was played to great acclaim by Peter Sellers, who appeared in the first two Pink Panther films before a falling out with director Blake Edwards caused him to (temporarily) exit the franchise.

At this point, the mantle was passed to Alan Arkin for the third film, Inspector Clouseau, yet following its disastrous critical and box office performance, Sellers was convinced to return - and work again with director Edwards - for the fourth movie, 1975's The Return of the Pink Panther.

The film was well-received and a major box office success, prompting Sellers to play Clouseau twice more in The Pink Panther Strikes Again and Revenge of the Pink Panther, before passing away in 1980.

Given that Sellers was Clouseau in the eyes of the public, the filmmakers faced quite the challenge with what to do next. 1982's Trail of the Pink Panther ultimately repurposed deleted scenes from The Pink Panther Strikes Again to construct a new narrative, as predictably resulted in critical and commercial failure.

1983's Curse of the Pink Panther, then, was focused largely around a missing Clouseau, before it was revealed at the end of the film that Clouseau had undergone plastic surgery and was now assuming the guise of film star Roger Moore (who appears in a cameo).

Curse was also a flop, but the series limped along for one final entry, 1993's Son of the Pink Panther, where Roberto Benigni played Clouseau's son and - shocker - it also failed to make a dent.

The lesson here? Sometimes actors own roles, and if they pass away, it's probably best to just retire them, at least for a while.

The Pink Panther was finally brought back to prominence in 2006, however, when Steve Martin played Clouseau in a modestly successful yet critically drubbed franchise reboot.

4. The ENTIRE Main Cast - Atlas Shrugged

Franchise recastings don't get much more deranged or bizarre than that of Atlas Shrugged - the 2010s movie trilogy adapted from Ayn Rand's iconic-if-controversial novel of the same name.

Advertisement

For the second and third film, the entire ensemble cast was replaced, due to the production lacking the budget to pay the first film's cast members more money for each successive sequel, as is effectively expected in Hollywood.

For example, though Taylor Schilling played protagonist Dagny Taggart in Atlas Shrugged Part I, because of Schilling's success working on Orange Is the New Black thereafter, the producers couldn't afford her for Part II.

As a result, she was replaced with Samantha Mathis, and for Part III, Dagny was then played by Laura Regan. The same is true of seven other characters who appear in all three films in the trilogy - every single one of them was recast twice by series' end.

On one hand, replacing the entire cast each time at least gives each movie a blank slate of its own, but it's still extremely bizarre to have no consistent faces across the franchise at all.

3. Pinhead - Hellraiser

Recasts don't get much more controversial than Hellraiser's inimitable Cenobite leader Pinhead.

Advertisement

For the first eight films in the series, for the better part of two decades, the role was played by the great Doug Bradley, who brought a piercing physicality and unmistakable vocal power to the role that ultimately ensured the series' success.

As the series' budgets dwindled to painfully low levels, though, Bradley opted not to return for more recent sequels. But unlike recasting a Jason Voorhees or Michael Myers, replacing Pinhead - who has a distinct personality - proved mightily difficult.

2011's Hellraiser: Revelations - which was shot for just $300,000 - saw Stephan Smith Collins physically portray Pinhead, while the voice was provided by Fred Tatasciore.

Unsurprisingly, fans were miffed, and they were further irked when Pinhead was again recast for 2018's Hellraiser: Judgment, as played by Paul T. Taylor.

Neither of these new versions of Pinhead made a dent with fans who sorely missed Bradley, and when the upcoming, big-budget reboot was first announced, many hoped that Bradley might return to the part.

Yet the decision was ultimately made to start anew, casting talented Sense8 actress Jamie Clayton as a gender-swapped version of Pinhead.

Between the fascinating first glimpse of Clayton's take on the character and Bradley himself recently lending support for her casting, though, it seems like this third recast might actually be the charm.

2. Rusty & Audrey Griswold - Vacation

Recasting generally goes down better in comedies than it does in serious dramatic fare, and in the case of the National Lampoon's Vacation series, it basically became an in-joke in its own right.

Advertisement

The Griswold children, Rusty and Audrey, have both appeared in each of the five Vacation movies produced between 1983 and 2015, and hilariously they've both been recast every single time.

Rusty has been played by Anthony Michael Hall, Jason Lively, Johnny Galecki, Ethan Embry, and finally Ed Helms as an adult, while Audrey has been portrayed by Dana Barron, Dana Hill, Juliette Lewis, Marisol Nichols, and then Leslie Mann.

The recasting is so prolific and nonsensical, with the characters changing in both age and physical appearance on a whim, that the series has even made fun of it, with their father Clark (Chevy Chase) knowingly telling them in 1997's Vegas Vacation, "I hardly recognise you anymore."

Recasting can totally ruin a movie, but the Vacation filmmakers were smart enough to run with it and turn it into a defining aspect of the series in its own way.

1. Asterix - Asterix & Obelix

There have been four live-action Asterix movies released to date, and though Gérard Depardieu has portrayed Asterix's trusty sidekick Obelix in all four movies, Asterix himself has been replaced by a new actor twice to date - with a third on the way.

Advertisement

Christian Clavier took the role for the first two Asterix movies, Asterix and Obelix vs. Caesar and Asterix & Obelix: Mission Cleopatra, but for 2008's belated threequel Asterix at the Olympic Games, Clovis Cornillac took over the role.

For 2012's Asterix and Obelix: God Save Britannia, Asterix was again switched out, with Edouard Baer taking the part this time.

It doesn't stop there, either: the upcoming fifth movie, Asterix & Obelix: The Middle Kingdom, will replace the title character once more, with famed filmmaker-actor Guillaume Canet - who is also directing the film - donning the mustache.

Advertisement