10 Movie Sequels That Avoided Obvious Mistakes

James Gunn knew exactly what he was doing on Guardians of the Galaxy Vol. 3.

By Jack Pooley /

Making a sequel to a hit movie is damn hard at the best of times - you've got to justify its existence creatively while also trying to match or exceed the original's quality. No easy feat.

Advertisement

As such it's little surprise that so many hugely anticipated sequels get caught up in the weeds and deliver a sub-par, disappointing end result.

While many dud sequels ultimately just fail to recapture the original charm, often a film makes a mistake that's considerably more specific on a storytelling level.

And so, it's always a relief when a heavily hyped movie arrives with the clear potential to make a fatal, fandom-infuriating mistake, only to tap-dance past it instead.

These 10 sequels all had audiences bracing for a major creative gaffe, only for the filmmakers to shame your lack of faith by avoiding them entirely.

From eschewing the most obvious sequel tropes to ignoring the narrative path everyone expected the story to take, these movies all surpassed expectations by taking the bolder, braver road that didn't feel like a studio mandated it.

The lesson here? It often pays to trust skilled filmmakers...

10. CGI Paul Walker - Every Fast Film After Furious 7

The fact that Furious 7 turned out as well as it did is nothing short of a miracle, considering the unfortunate passing of Paul Walker mid-production, forcing his role in the film to be completed with digital doubles and his brothers, Cody and Caleb, acting as stand-ins.

Advertisement

The end result is impressively seamless for the most part, and more importantly gave Walker's character, Brian O'Conner, a fitting and affecting retirement.

Ever since Furious 7 did such an outstanding job keeping Brian in the movie, though, fans have suggested it's just a matter of time before CGI Brian reappears in a future film.

Yet the three mainline Fast movies since, for all of their faults, have shown surprising restraint in keeping Brian completely off-screen.

There are some undeniably awkward moments where the films have had to clunkily write around Brian's absence - especially with his partner Mia (Jordana Brewster) still being in the mix - but it's certainly preferable to ghoulishly inserting Brian into the films.

While it's certainly possible, even likely, that Vin Diesel and co. won't be able to resist bringing CGI Brian back for the series' final dinner scene, it's at least a relief that the last three movies have respectfully avoided exploiting Walker's image in a way which many fans would surely find tacky.

9. Just Repeating The Same Movie - Aliens

Ridley Scott's Alien is such a perfect cinematic organism that it would've surprised nobody if it led to a glut of more-of-the-same sequels that basically just regurgitated the same space-slasher formula ad nauseum.

Advertisement

But in 1986, a little-known filmmaker called James Cameron rose to the challenge to deliver a sequel, Aliens, which basically sidestepped every last mistake an Alien sequel could possibly make.

First and foremost, Cameron clearly had no interest in just doing the same thing again, because while Ripley (Sigourney Weaver) returns to LV-426 and comes back into contact with the Xenomorphs, the context is very different.

If Alien was a slow and suspenseful horror film, Cameron's film is far more action-centric, with Ripley being joined by the gung-ho, ill-fated Colonial Marines who lend the movie a considerably different energy to the original's Nostromo crew.

Beyond that, Aliens also invests us far deeper in Ripley as a character per her surrogate mother interactions with young Newt (Carrie Henn), ensuring it's anything but a sequel that merely paints within the established lines.

Yet Cameron's film also set such an impossibly high bar for the series - and sequels in general, honestly - that nothing else in the Alien series has been able to touch it.

8. Making Rey Related To A Legacy Character - Star Wars: The Last Jedi

Star Wars: The Last Jedi is a divisive sequel for many reasons, but writer-director Rian Johnson made one incredibly shrewd call when penning the script - even if said call was ultimately undone by the next movie.

Advertisement

After The Force Awakens riffed vaguely on the mysterious backstory of protagonist Rey (Daisy Ridley), many fans rabidly speculated that she would be revealed to be related to a major legacy character - most likely being the daughter of Luke Skywalker (Mark Hamill).

But Johnson evidently had little interest in tagging a contrived familial relation onto the Sequel Trilogy's lead character, and so had Kylo Ren (Adam Driver) reveal to her that her parents were in fact junker nobodies entirely unrelated to any established Star Wars character.

Given Star Wars' tendency to draw convoluted links between its characters and in turn make its apparently vast galaxy feel incredibly small and incestuous, it was a major breath of fresh air for Rey to be a hero entirely unreliant on nepotistic ties to the past.

It's just a shame that, amid the inane fan backlash over this revelation, J.J. Abrams decided to walk it back in sequel The Rise of Skywalker, where Rey was revealed to be the granddaughter of Emperor Palpatine (Ian McDiarmid).

7. Trying To Top The Original Twist - Saw II

The moment that Saw became a surprise box office smash, it was inevitable that Lionsgate would hastily greenlight a sequel. And though Saw II was ultimately released less than a year after the first, it impressively avoided one potentially fatal pitfall - trying to top the original's legendary twist.

Advertisement

The first Saw movie ended with the jaw-dropping reveal that antagonist Jigsaw aka John Kramer (Tobin Bell) had actually been posing as the "corpse" in the middle of the grotty bathroom all along - a twist so brilliantly unexpected it was basically impossible to out-do.

And so for Saw II, writers Leigh Whannell and Darren Lynn Bousman smartly decided to not try and top the nobody-can-guess-this insanity of that ending, opting instead for two more modest twists which were themselves incredibly satisfying.

The first twist is that Detective Matthews' (Donnie Wahlberg) son Daniel (Erik Knudsen) was actually safe the entire time - due to his game taking place days prior - while the second revealed that Amanda (Shawnee Smith) was Jigsaw's secret apprentice.

Both twists are well-executed and genuinely surprising, yet the writers clearly knew there was no way to beat the original twist while still maintaining internal credibility, and so they didn't even bother trying.

It's just as well, because later films in the series eventually strained for more outlandish twists in an attempt to keep fans interested, yet these reveals mostly fell flat.

6. Ditching Ilsa After One Movie - Mission: Impossible - Fallout

As entertaining as the Mission: Impossible franchise is, until recently it's had a bit of a strange relationship with its central female characters, most often operating a revolving door policy whereby each female lead is replaced in the next movie.

Advertisement

The first four films in the series introduced audiences to characters played by Emmanuelle Béart, Thandiwe Newton, Michelle Monaghan, and Paula Patton, each of whom were gone by the next installment - beyond two brief appearances by Monaghan in two subsequent movies.

And so, when Rebecca Ferguson was cast as MI6 agent Ilsa Faust in the fifth movie, Rogue Nation, there wasn't much hope that she'd appear in the sequel, Fallout.

But thankfully Fallout finally broke the unsavoury streak, bringing Ilsa back not for a mere perfunctory cameo but another beefy role of equal size to her prior appearance.

Better yet, Ferguson will return in the upcoming two-part finale to the franchise, Dead Reckoning, bringing her total appearances to four - that's half the entire series.

5. Having Rocky Win - Rocky Balboa

Back when a sixth Rocky film was first announced, even many die-hard fans questioned the believability of a 60-year-old Rocky (Sylvester Stallone) stepping back into the ring to battle a man roughly half his age, especially after Rocky V saw him get diagnosed with brain damage.

Advertisement

More to the point, many simply doubted Stallone's ability to put his ego aside and have Rocky lose against the heavyweight champ, Mason "The Line" Dixon (Antonio Tarver).

After all, with Sly promising that Rocky Balboa would give the series a far more fitting ending compared to Rocky V's miserable climax, would it have surprised anyone if he over-corrected and gave Rocky an unrealistically happy ending where he triumphed over Dixon?

But thankfully Stallone's better creative instincts won out and Rocky ends up losing the fight to Dixon via split decision, yet in defeat he goes the distance and proves himself regardless, circling back quite brilliantly to the original Rocky which ended the very same way.

Expectations were understandably low for Rocky Balboa given the familiar whiff of a desperate belated sequel, but Stallone thankfully nailed it.

4. Solving The First Film's Mystery - Blade Runner 2049

When Blade Runner 2049 was first announced, the question on everybody's lips was - will it reveal the truth about the original film's protagonist, Deckard (Harrison Ford)?

Advertisement

After all, the agonising mystery over Deckard's true identity - whether he's a replicant or a human - has plagued fans for literally decades, and it seemed basically inevitable that the sequel would finally explain it one way or another.

But instead, director Denis Villeneuve opted not to confirm Deckard's status one way or another, refusing to even consider the question within the movie itself and instead allowing the enigma to endure.

Given that Blade Runner director Ridley Scott and Harrison Ford have famously argued over whether Deckard is a replicant or not - Scott says yes, Ford says no - effectively ignoring the question, and perhaps tacitly suggesting it doesn't even matter, was absolutely the right way to go.

Generally speaking, it's better to let a mythologised mystery live on forever more rather than de-mystify it, especially considering the backlash confirming it either way would cause.

3. Bringing Back Every Original Cast Member - Top Gun: Maverick

Though Top Gun: Maverick's marketing certainly suggested it'd be one hell of a visual feast, it was harder to get a bead on the story, and how aggressively it'd function as a "legacy sequel."

Advertisement

Generally speaking, legacy sequels feel obliged to bring back as many prior characters as possible, as can often cause them to feel overcrowded or desperately trying to activate the audience's nostalgia receptors.

But Maverick actually split the difference quite brilliantly, because while it absolutely adhered to many legacy sequel tropes - namely, having the aging Maverick (Tom Cruise) teach a new class of young recruits - it clearly didn't feel compelled to bring every character back just because.

While we do get a bittersweet reunion between Maverick and Iceman (Val Kilmer), numerous key characters from the original movie are absent - Mav's original love interest Charlie (Kelly McGillis), Top Gun instructors Viper (Tom Skerritt) and Jester (Michael Ironside), all of the original surviving pilots aside from Iceman, and Goose's (Anthony Edwards) wife Carole (Meg Ryan).

Rather than bloating the runtime out with perfunctory everyone-is-here cameos, Maverick achieves a considerably more streamlined synthesis of fan service and contemporary blockbuster thrills. As a result, it's one of the greatest legacy sequels of all time.

2. Getting Peter & Gamora Back Together - Guardians Of The Galaxy Vol. 3

James Gunn may be one of the most canny filmmakers making superhero movies today, but fans were nevertheless worried that sentimentality might get the better of him in Guardians of the Galaxy Vol. 3.

Advertisement

After all, Gamora's (Zoe Saldana) death in Avengers: Infinity War created a major creative roadblock for Gunn, who hadn't expected that to happen. And so, he was forced to pivot by effectively replacing the original Gamora with her 2014 variant who debuted in Avengers: Endgame.

As such, many fans suspected that Gunn would basically try to revert Gamora to her original state by film's end, having her fall in love with Peter Quill (Chris Pratt) and more-or-less paper over the fact that the "real" Gamora died.

But instead, Gunn sidestepped this very obvious storytelling gaffe, directly addressing the fact that this Gamora isn't the Gamora Peter fell in love with, and ending the film without the new Gamora also falling for Peter.

Ultimately this version of Gamora looks favourably upon Peter by film's end and gets a nice moment with him before he heads back to Earth. And so, rather than disastrously attempt to force a romance between them, Gunn deepened their character development by keeping things emotionally honest.

1. Going PG-13 - Logan

Even though James Mangold's Logan - a quasi-sequel to both The Wolverine and X-Men: Days of Future Past - was shot with an R-rating in mind, fans were understandably skeptical that this rating would stick, considering how much of a ceiling it would place on the movie's box office prospects.

Advertisement

But to their credit, Fox indeed allowed Mangold to deliver an R-rated finale to Hugh Jackman's linear tenure as Logan - excluding his upcoming role in Deadpool 3, which is set before the events of Logan.

Rather than be yet another neutered PG-13 movie about a man with metal claws stabbing people to death - one of the chief complaints about 2013's The Wolverine in particular - Logan put its R-rating to damn good use with ultra-violent action and liberal use of appropriately colourful language.

The result was both the best Wolverine movie and Jackman's greatest performance in the role to date, while it also went on to become one of the X-Men series' most commercially successful films.

Basically, everything worked out for the best because Fox didn't cynically try to make a post-apocalyptic Wolverine movie appealing to children.

Advertisement