10 Movie Sequels That Basically Wrote Themselves (But Never Happened)

These sequels are so obvious that no one can understand how they haven't been made yet.

By Jake Cook /

Everyone loves a good sequel, particularly when it's for a well deserving movie. Perhaps this is why it can be so disappointing when a movie that you love, which is filled with endless potential for future storylines, never manages to inspire a follow-up.

Advertisement

These projects can often be abandoned when they fail to take shape, or when studios simply can't see the box office potential. Sometimes, however, the filmmakers involved just can't come up with a story they think is worth telling, no matter how potentially lucrative one could be.

Whatever the reason may be, there are some movies frustratingly overloaded with obvious sequel potential that is just waiting to be explored. It's almost impossible to imagine that any competent Hollywood screenwriter would ever struggle to come up with a decent script for these films, but somehow, they did.

These are ten movies with sequels that definitely should've happened, but ultimately, never did.

10. The Hangover 2 (A Good One)

This first entry might be considered cheating by most, given that there are already two (terrible) sequels to the first Hangover. However, there is actually a really great premise for a sequel to the original film that would have been all too easy to bring to life.

Advertisement

The story could have followed the "Wolf Pack" as they arrive at a destination wedding for Stu (or possibly Alan). They then embark on yet another bachelor party, despite trepidation, after becoming jealous of their partners' plans for a bachelorette party.

When they awake the next morning to find nothing out of place, they assume that everything is fine. Until, they head downstairs and discover their spouses passed out in various parts of the hotel, unable to remember last night, and the bride missing.

Taking this approach to the sequel would have allowed the filmmakers to make the necessary callbacks to the original, whilst still offering something new. It's always refreshing when an R-rated comedy is willing to show women being just as debauched as the men. It's a premise so obvious it makes you wonder just how the people behind the series managed to miss it.

9. Drag Me FROM Hell

This 2009 Sam Raimi horror flick gave audiences one last surprise in its closing moments when protagonist, Christine, was, well, dragged to hell. The critical and box office success of the film left fans wondering when the inevitable sequel would be announced. Sadly, no such plans seem to be on the horizon, as Raimi has stated he hasn't been able to come up with a story.

Advertisement

This is a little hard to believe, given the events of the final scene. As Christine is pulled into the fiery depths of hell by a bunch of demonic hands, her boyfriend Clay looks on in horror, unable to help. This is the perfect jumping off point for a sequel, which could follow Clay as he studies the occult in an attempt to rescue Christine from eternal torment.

Watching Justin Long constantly fighting off demons certainly sounds like one hell of a compelling ride. It would even be open to some great twist and turns along the way.

Perhaps the lack of a sequel for this one isn't so much that Raimi can't think of a story, but rather that he hasn't thought of one he wants to tell.

8. Master And Commander 2

The Master And Commander sequel doesn't just write itself, it's already been written... kind of.

Advertisement

The original 2003 sea-faring epic took its inspiration from the Aubrey-Maturin book series by Patrick O'Brian. The adaptation was met with widespread acclaim and adoration from fans, even managing to land itself eight Academy Award nominations and two wins for its trouble.

With this success, and so much unused material still left to explore from the books, fans were enamoured with the idea of a sequel. Despite this untapped gold mine of literary brilliance, plans to continue the story are apparently not on the table.

The major reason for this seems to be entirely box office related. The film's director, Peter Weir, confirmed as much when he said that while the movie did “well-ish” financially, it wasn't enough to merit spending another $150 million on a sequel.

It's such a shame, since Russell Crowe and Paul Bettany had such great chemistry together. Seeing the two continue to appear alongside each other, performing such wonderful material, could have made this a truly prestigious film franchise.

7. Spaceballs 2: The Search For More Money

The title for this one already exists, and given how oversaturated the Star Wars brand has become, it couldn't be a more apt one. For whatever reason though, it seems that there were never any actual plans to make 'Spaceballs 2' a reality.

Advertisement

The potential material for another Spaceballs has been piling up ever since George Lucas released the prequels. Mel Brooks’ affinity for integrating meta humour into his comedies provides endless opportunity to ridicule the state of filmmaking today, which heavily relies on nostalgia. There's even a chance for him to include a series of bits about how long awaited sequels, such as this one, are never able to meet fan expectations.

Despite how perfect the current era of cinema is for another Spaceballs, the odds of it happening have been steadily decreasing for years. Mel Brooks has maintained that it could still happen, but since so many of the original cast members have passed away, it wouldn't feel like much of a genuine sequel.

At this point, all this talk feels more like wishful thinking about what could be, rather than any actual interest in getting the film made.

6. Jumper 2

There are no rules that say the movies on this list have to be good, and make no mistake, Jumper is not a good movie.

Advertisement

With that being said, much like Master and Commander and unknown to most, the film is actually based on a series of books. This means there's a wealth of material left unexplored that could have been included in the sequel had the film been well received.

If the sequel had taken its cues from the books, it would have skipped ahead a few years, and introduced the main couple's daughter. This would give the story a new element of tension, particularly since in the film it would be the girl's grandmother who's pursuing them.

Seeing a family of Jumpers come together to take on the evil Paladins, and potentially lead a rebellion of people like them, could have made for a compelling story that built on the events of the original movie.

With the author having moved on after the failure of the film to adapt other projects, it's unlikely that the property will ever spawn a franchise.

5. Commando 2: Like Father, Like Daughter

With tons of explosions, Arnie side-wielding huge machine guns, and cheesy one liners, this film has everything your heart could desire from an Arnold Schwarzenegger action flick.

Advertisement

It follows John Matrix as he attempts to rescue his kidnapped daughter from mercenaries, and ends with him declaring his retirement. With such a concrete ending, you might be left wondering: what could they possibly do for a sequel? That is until you realise that his daughter is played by a young Alyssa Milano, who you may remember from the hit TV series Charmed.

A sequel that would see the roles of hostage and rescuer reversed could have been the perfect modern day follow-up to this macho action movie. The plot would basically be the same as the original, but with the initial reveal being that John's daughter, Jenny, grew up to be a Special Forces operative. Taking this approach, and getting Milano the action vehicle she deserves, is such an obvious way to keep things fresh, it's almost criminal that it’s never been tried before.

Here’s hoping someone in Hollywood wakes up to the solid gold nugget they're sitting on before both actors age out of their respective roles.

4. Mathilda: The Ex-Professional

Leon was the film that introduced Natalie Portman to the world as the young, wanna-be hit-woman, Mathilda. While the film ended fairly conclusively, with Mathilda escaping the carnage that kills Leon to go attend boarding school, it still left a lot of room to speculate what happened to her character.

Advertisement

Coming up with a plot to such a sequel is all too easy. Over the course of the original film, the young girl is taught many skills by Leon. It would be great to return to this character and see her fully free of her previous life - perhaps even working as a teacher at her boarding school.

When she soon discovers an outbreak of drugs amongst students in her neighbourhood, she just can't resist reverting back to her old habits. This catalyst could also be used to team her up with a young sidekick, mimicking her relationship with Leon.

The fact a sequel to this film seems so incredibly easy to write just makes it all the more frustrating that one never happened.

3. Mrs Doubtfire 2

The rumour that a sequel to this hit Robin Williams comedy was in development circulated for years but never eventuated. Hiding in plain sight though, was a storyline so obvious, it makes you question why so much time was spent labouring over something so simple.

Advertisement

The original film sees the main character, Daniel Hillard, turn the persona of Scottish housekeeper Mrs Doubtfire into a children's TV character. A good sequel could have seen Daniel dealing with the studio behind the show not wanting an audience of kids to know the character is just a man in drag.

Of course, because we have to have conflict in our movies, the secret would inevitably be revealed. Daniel Hillard would become the talk of the town, as he confronts angry parents, and a network that wants to take him off the air to avoid controversy. Taking this approach to a sequel would have been a fantastic way of exploring new themes of prejudice and fame, whilst keeping true to the original themes of parenting.

A sequel was eventually announced, but due to Robin Williams’ tragic passing, we may never know just what the writers had planned.

2. Batman Beyond

Ever since the excellent Cartoon Network show Batman Beyond came into the world, the call for a live action film adaptation has been a prevalent demand amongst fans.

Advertisement

An excellent way of bringing it to the big screen, that would make it digestible and appealing to casual viewers, would be to sell it as sequel to the Tim Burton Batman movies starring Michael Keaton.

Bringing Keaton back as an old and grizzled Dark Knight, who has long been retired due to a heart condition, would be the perfect ending to his version of the character - something his current tenure as Batman is sorely missing.

It would be great to see Burton's Batman movies finally rounded off as a complete trilogy, rather than being directly tied to the Schumacher films. Crafting a story that combines elements from both interpretations, should be a relatively easy feat, and a potential gold mine for Warner Bros.

There's no official word on whether or not Keaton or Burton would be interested in such a project, but neither seem to be in much of a hurry to return any time soon.

1. The Breakfast Club 2: 10 Year Reunion

The Breakfast Club has long been held up as the pinnacle of John Hughes' movies. Returning to these characters to see if they did in fact remain friends, or if their relationships deteriorated, has endless possibilities to explore. The most obvious way to do this, would have been by ageing the characters up 10 years, and setting the events during a high-school reunion.

Advertisement

Now adults with their own lives and responsibilities, the group would slowly begin to wander off from the reunion, eventually meeting up in the library where they shared that detention all those years ago. This would allow them to reopen those old discussions, as well as fill the audience in on what happened to the group after that day.

The sad part about this obvious premise for a sequel is that it was obvious to John Hughes too. He had long planned to do a "10 years later" sequel to The Breakfast Club, but wanted to wait for the actors to reach the appropriate ages.

Unfortunately, Hughes had falling outs with a number of the original cast members. He shelved the project as a result, which is a terrible waste of a film that would have given audiences the closure they wanted.

Advertisement