Darren Aronofsky's blockbuster retelling of the epic Biblical story of Noah and the Ark, Noah, is set to touch down in cinemas soon. Unless, that is, you live in Indonesia, Egypt, Bahrain, Qatar, Jordan, Kuwait or the United Arab Emirates, all countries which have banned the movie on the grounds that Islam prohibits the depiction of Biblical figures, also backed by some Christian groups, who claim that Aronofsky's vision is not in line with the Scriptures. Losing the Christian audience in America has also been a huge concern for the studio, not least on account of the potentially devastating effect this could have on box office takings. Erring on the side of caution, in March Paramount attached a disclaimer to all forms of advertising:
The film is inspired by the story of Noah. While artistic license has been taken, we believe that this film is true to the essence, values and integrity of a story that is a cornerstone of faith for millions of people worldwide. The biblical story of Noah can be found in the book of Genesis.
Aronofsky and leading man Russell Crowe sought the blessing of the Vatican earlier this year - the box office success of Mel Gibson's The Passion of the Christ was largely secured thanks to a Vatican statement issued before the release which described the film as "the cinematographic recounting of the historical fact of the passion of Jesus Christ according to the Gospel accounts" - and recently Pope Francis gave his blessing to Noah after granting Russell Crowe an audience. Noah isn't the first film to stir up a huge amount of controversy among religious groups - throughout movie history, a number of films have been condemned - or outright banned - for theological reasons. Some of the reasons for controversy are to be expected, as is the case with Noah. Others, however, may come as a complete surprise...
10. Ben-Hur
The film Ben-Hur is synonymous with the golden age of Hollywood epics. William Wyler's sprawling tale - the largest and most expensive production ever at the time of filming - has become something of a staple of Christmas television scheduling. It recounts the story of Judah Ben-Hur (Charlton Heston), a rich prince and merchant who ends up in the galleys following an accident and vows to take revenge on the governor who imprisoned his mother and sister. After years as a slave he befriends a powerful Roman and becomes a champion charioteer, where he faces off against the childhood friend who years before betrayed him. A pivotal encounter with Jesus teaches Ben-Hur about peace and forgiveness, after he is reunited with the woman he loves. Most audiences remember Ben-Hur for the legendary chariot race sequence, arguably the first blockbuster action scene in Hollywood history. The Chinese, however, saw the film differently. Authorities banned Ben-Hur on the grounds that the movie was "propaganda of superstitious beliefs, namely Christianity." The Canton Censor Board allowed a version of the film, albeit with heavy cuts of scenes relating to Christ, describing them as "absurd and fictitious" which tended to undermine the government's "social program". Given the mass killings of the Cultural Revolution which was to come in the following years, perhaps Christ's fundamental message of "peace and forgiveness" was at odds with Mao's idea of the Chinese Great Leap Forward...
9. Harry Potter (All Of Them)
Few long-running movie franchises have proven to be as enduring and popular as the Harry Potter series, adapted from the novels by J. K. Rowling. A generation of children grew up with Potter and his friends, enduring the trials and tribulations of the young wizard as he honed his skills and confronted the forces of evil, culminating in the final showdown with the Dark Lord Voldemort. Given that the Potter universe is based around witches and wizards and is replete with concepts lifted from mythology and witchcraft, it was perhaps inevitable that it would find condemnation from religious groups who viewed it as countering the message of religion. Sure enough, a number of religious organisations have condemned the books on such grounds: the Greek Orthodox Church among others have described Harry Potter as Satanic, declaring that it "acquaints people with evil, wizardry, the occult and demonology", while Roberta Combs, president of the Christian Coalition of America, heavily criticized the series on the grounds that it "encouraged homosexuality." To be fair, the movies have have had considerably less stick than J. K. Rowling's original novels. Rowling herself has gone to considerable lengths to demonstrate how the story actively promotes Christian values, and there are a number of large Christian organisations who echo this opinion, with one prominent Cardinal describing them as "a good dose of moral truth". Islamic scholars and rabbis have also spoken positively of the books and films. Perhaps the nature of religious condemnation of the Potter series can be summed up in Rowling's own words: "I don't take any responsibility for the lunatic fringes of my own religion."
8. Frozen
Disney's latest box office smash, Frozen, is perhaps the last film you'd expect to be condemned on religious grounds. It tells the tale of Anna (voiced by Kristen Bell) princess of Arendelle, who sets out to find her estranged sister Elsa after her magical ability to conjure up ice and snow inadvertently encase the kingdom in an eternal winter. A handsome mountain man and his faithful reindeer join her on her quest, along with a talking snowman who yearns to bask in the sun. It isn't Disney's greatest animated yarn, but the lush visuals and strong musical numbers certainly pleased audiences across the globe. At least, most audiences - one Christian pastor by the name of Kevin Swanson of the Reformation Church thought otherwise. Hosting a Christian radio show in Colorado, he described Frozen as "very evil", going on to state that it encourages homosexuality and bestiality. Swanson - a man who believes that Christians will one day be burned at the stake by homosexuals - insists that he is not a "tinfoil hat conspiratorialist" while at the same time insisting that Disney studios are "one of the most pro-homosexual organisations in the country." It isn't the first time Disney has come under fire from religious figures with somewhat extreme interpretations of their movies, although perhaps the most outlandish claim is that the number 666 appears in the swirls of their logo, proving that you can find just about anything to support wild theories, if only you look close enough.
7. The Da Vinci Code
Another hugely successful book to make it to the big screen, The Da Vinci Code - with its pseudo-revisionist approach to religious iconography and symbolism - was always going to raise the heckles of the religious community if only on account of the controversial legacy of Dan Brown's source material. Tom Hanks plays professor Robert Langdon, who becomes the prime suspect in the murder of a museum curator and sets out to clear his name, mustering all his academic skills in the process and uncovering a quest for the Holy Grail - the true identity of which the story suggests has been part of a two thousand year cover-up by the Catholic Church. The film, despite its box office success, is a woefully muddled affair (in keeping with the trashy source material, some might argue), which, in the words of Tom Hanks himself is "loaded with all sorts of hooey and fun kind of scavenger hunt-type nonsense." Notwithstanding the fact that practically all involved in the production seem to agree that the plot is absurd, religious groups around the globe rallied round to roundly condemn the film as blasphemous, offensive and full of theological errors. Indeed, the Interfaith Coalition Against The Da Vinci Code was promptly established in which leaders of a number of American Christian groups lambasted the film, saying that it "glorifies hieros gamos a satanic ritual that reduces women to nothing more than objects in a male dominated sex ritual." A prominent Catholic priest added that Sony - who produced The Da Vinci Code - "seeks to profit off bigotry, proselytises paganism, and undermines the dignity of women." Meanwhile, some atheist movie fans criticised the film simply because it was a badly written, contrived waste of time in which the talent in front of and behind the camera was woefully underused - although it's highly doubtful that any of them called for it to be banned.
6. The Matrix Reloaded
When The Matrix Reloaded was first released in the West the biggest criticism it faced was how inferior it was to the original. The Matrix remains today one of the greatest sci-fi action movies to emerge from Hollywood in decades - a perfectly paced high concept movie with a distinct visual style and some of the most memorable action sequences ever. Reloaded, on the other hand, seemed to little more than a cash in - a typical sequel which was made with the all-too-familiar ethos of "bigger, louder, dumber", in which cool fights were replaced by cartoonishly over the top CGI-laden brawls and chase sequences that appeared to be lifted straight out of a video game. At the time of its release the Egyptian government had far more important concerns than the artistic and commercial merits of the Wachowski's sequel, banning the movie not only because of the violence but because it tackled "religious themes". The Egyptian censors believed that a film about the search for the creator and controller of the human race may causes "crises", which assumes a poor ability on the part of the Egyptian population to distinguish between science fiction fantasy and their religious convictions. The film was also criticised for "promoting Zionism", although this political aspect to the condemnation was led more by the Egyptian press than the censors, proving that the media can be just as reactionary as religious organisations when it comes to posing as moral arbiters of decency and good taste.
5. The Hobbit
What do you get when a self-professed atheist filmmaker, Peter Jackson, films a children's book infused with mythological creatures? By now the answer should be entirely predictable: uproar from Christians for a Moral America, who immediately labeled Jackson as "Santa's Little Helper". The Hobbit - like Harry Potter - is a story in which witchcraft, wizardry and folklore play a large role in shaping the universe in which it is set, with wizards, trolls, orcs and an array of other fantastical creatures featuring throughout. While Christians for a Moral America concede that the original novel has strong Christian undertones (good versus evil being the most obvious one), Jackson's atheism seemed to preclude him from being capable of understanding these themes, and they issued a statement which read: "Jackson being the self-proclaimed Atheist he is obviously doesn't want to present this movie in the way it was meant by Tolkien. Let's vote with our wallets and send a big message to Hollywood and Jackson; Christians will NOT tolerate this blatant Anti-Christian bigotry and Atheist propaganda." Given the box office takings it seems apparent that few heeded their advice, while other Christian groups described the film as "faith friendly" and some even declaring that the character of Gandalf was a Christ-like figure (presumably these groups thought it best not to bring up his homosexuality).
4. South Park: Bigger, Longer & Uncut
South Park the television series made its name by being a harsh satirical take on American life and culture - nothing was considered too taboo to mock and lambast, whether it was vacuous celebrities, politicians or religious groups. Not surprisingly, when creators Matt Stone and Trey Parker were given the green light to make a feature-length South Park, freed from the constraints of television censorship, the gloves well and truly came off. South Park: Bigger, Longer & Uncut doesn't pull its punches in its wonderfully vulgar defense of free speech, attacking everything from Disney to Saddam Hussein while taking a hefty swipe at the Motion Picture Association of America, with whom Stone and Parker battled throughout the film's production. Not surprisingly, a feature cartoon which roundly mocks the near-Puritanical zeal with which America's self-professed religious "guardians" cast judgement on anything they perceive as offensive, South Park: Bigger, Longer & Uncut itself came under fire from the very people it satirised. The Christian Analysis of American Culture described it as "INCREDIBLY dangerous" (all caps denotes shouting, don't you know?) and provided a breakdown of the usages of expletives and calling it a "vulgar and vile movie" which mocked Jesus and accepted Satan. No doubt Stone and Parker were delighted with eliciting such a reaction, since it proved to a tee precisely the point about censorship and the knee-jerk reaction of pious religious groups they'd set out to make in the first place.
3. The Golden Compass
The Golden Compass was another Hollywood attempt to cash in on the successes of the Harry Potter and Lord of the Rings series, yet despite solid source material with Philip Pullman's His Dark Materials trilogy, the film was critically panned and bombed at the box office. With an all-star cast including Daniel Craig, Eva Green and Nicole Kidman, The Golden Compass tells the story of a young girl drawn into a parallel universe in which the evil power known as the Magisterium seeks to bring an end to free enquiry and tolerance - themes which Pullman intended as a critique of the dogmatic nature of the church. Ironically, since the film diluted these themes considerably - presumably so as not to offend religious groups who otherwise might not have gone to see it - it came under fire not only from religious groups but also from secular organisations. It was a classic case of "damned if you do, damned if you don't", and the compromise left in its wake a movie weakened by a lack of commitment to stick to its proverbial guns. Religious condemnation was the strongest, with a number of groups calling for Christians to boycott the movie altogether. The Catholic League accused it of promoting atheism (which it did in significantly more subtle terms than the original book), while one review accused it of encouraging rebelliousness and the occult. Pullman's response to calls for boycotts was to point out that the point was to encourage children to question authority - not something dogmatic religious institutions were likely to agree with.
2. Monty Python's Life Of Brian
If there is one film in cinema history that everyone knew from day one there would be a storm of controversy on its release, it is without a shadow of a doubt Monty Python's Life of Brian. Arguably one of the best comedies ever made (certainly if movie rankings and fan polls are anything to go by), the central theme of the film is a parody of religious zeal and persecution - guaranteed to be met with cries of "blasphemy!" from religious groups around the world. Brian Cohen is a young Jewish man who just happened to be born next door to Jesus Christ on the same day who, later in life, becomes mistaken for the Messiah, unwittingly amasses an ever-swelling number of unwanted followers and ends up crucified by the Romans. A hilarious satire on the fickle nature of religious belief, the gullibility of the common man and the hypocritical actions of those who claim to be acting under the impulse of a higher power, Monty Python's Life of Brian is as clever and well observed as it is frequently downright hilarious. Predictably it managed to offend almost anyone and everyone who called themselves a Christian, with rabbis and nuns uniting, taking to the streets to protest the film ("Nuns with banners!" declared Python member Michael Palin). One English council banned the film without having even seen it, basing their ruling on condemnation by an evangelical Christian group. In total 39 local authorities either banned it or imposed an X rating on the movie, and it wasn't until 2008 that Torbay council lifted the ban and allowed it to be screened. Using the accusations of heresy to their advantage, the Python team plied this notoriety into the marketing campaign, releasing posters which stated, "So funny it was banned in Norway!" proving that there is some truth to the expression, "There's no such thing as bad publicity."
1. Schindler's List
Of all the movies on this list, Steven Spielberg's harrowing and moving portrait of the Holocaust Schindler's List is without a doubt the most unexpected entry. What possible objection could anyone have - on religious grounds or otherwise - to a film about one of the most tragic eras in human history? How could you object to a film which sensitively deals with the genocidal crime against humanity carried out by one of the most brutal dictators of the 20th century, Adolf Hitler? The move to bar Schindler's List came from a number of Arab and Islamic nations, declaring that it functioned as "propaganda with the purpose of asking for sympathy" for the "Jewish cause" - this was effectively conflating the suffering of the Jewish people during the second world war with justifying the actions of the state of Israel in the occupied territories, and the Hebron massacre of Muslims by a Jewish fanatic was also cited, with Jordanian Information Minister Jawad Al Anani stating that "this was not an opportune time" to screen Spielberg's film. The director reacted strongly to the banning, stating, "It shocks me because I thought the Islamic countries would feel this film could be an instrument of their own issues in what was happening in Bosnia." In light of the political situation in Israel and the Occupied Territories (which international law acknowledges are held illegally by the state of Israel) the sensitivity on the part of Islamic countries is perhaps understandable, if not necessarily condonable. Spielberg himself believed the film should be read more broadly, saying, "This movie speaks not only on the Jewish Holocaust but of every Holocaust, by anyone's definition." The reaction in the Middle East clearly points to the subjectivity of this viewpoint. Like this article? Agree or disagree with the condemnation? Let us know in the comments section below.