10 Must-See Fan Documentaries About The People Who Matter Most

We see thousands of documentaries about the stars, but when the cameras are reversed it's something just as equally enthralling.

By Andrew Dilks /

When it comes to documentaries about movies there are literally hundreds to choose from - in-depth 'Making Of' features which take us behind the scenes, retrospective pieces which focus on cinema's icons with talking heads gushing praise, and interviews with and about the great actors and directors of our time. From silent classics to modern masterpieces, the movies and their creators have featured in countless documentaries, with virtually no stone left unturned. Some franchises earn billions at the box office and much more besides in terms of home media sales and merchandising. They become cultural phenomenons, etched in the minds of public; modern mythologies which speak to something perhaps as timeless as the epic tales of ancient Greece. And yet, the people who make this happen are under-represented in the world of the documentary - without the fans who flock to the cinema and collect the toys, books and other paraphernalia this multi-billion dollar industry would never exist. The following documentaries more than make up for this apparent oversight - they take us into the world of fandom, from the hardcore video gamers who dedicate their lives to mastering classic arcade games to achieve the world's best ranking to the passionate followers of some of the most popular franchises around today. These are documentaries about the people who truly matter the most - the fans.

10. The Dungeon Masters

The classic role-playing game Dungeons and Dragons has been around since the 1970s and is still going strong to this day, with an estimated 20 million people playing it over the years,and sales of over $1 billion in books, equipment and other merchandise. While perhaps not as popular with the younger demographics, it nevertheless maintains a hardcore following who gather to play adventures and campaigns, collect miniatures and attend D&D conventions. The Dungeon Masters was originally intended as an overview of the game, charting the history of Dungeons and Dragons up to the present day. But when director Kevin McAlester began filming the documentary he soon realised that focusing on a narrow selection of players would offer a more interesting insight into both the game and those who played it. What emerges is a far more touching, personal story of avid gamers using the game as an escapism from ever-encroaching real-world problems; an America seemingly crumbling under the weight of an economic recession and the hopes, dreams, failures and successes - however small - of the three gamesmasters McAlester focuses on. In a sense, the gaming world is as much about learning life lessons as it is about offering a distraction from life. McAlester may not be a Dungeons and Dragons player himself, but this lack of familiarity affords him the level of detachment required to document the lives of his subjects with a degree of objectivity, making the final product all the more revealing.

9. Chasing Ghosts: Beyond The Arcade

Readers have to be above a certain age for sights like the one depicted in the image above to evoke a familiar childhood memory. The arcade as it used to exist has all but disappeared, relegated to motorway service stations and the faded seaside resort town. But there was a time when they were hives of activity - social hubs where young people (mainly boys, of course) flocked by the dozens to play the latest games and try and beat one another's high scores. Chasing Ghosts: Beyond the Arcade takes us back in time to the heyday of arcade gaming - the golden age of video game champions who mastered some of the toughest titles ever released and landed on the cover of Life magazine. While games such as Pac-Man, Donkey Kong, Stargate, Defender and other renowned classics might look primitive by today's high definition standards, their visual simplicity betrayed a difficulty level which would challenge even the most hardcore gamer. Lincoln Ruchti's 2007 documentary revisits some of the legends of the time, beginning with the entrepreneur Walter Day who set up the Twin Galaxies International Scoreboard and the superstar teenage gamers who vied for the top spots. It's a wonderfully touching and affectionate portrayal, and seeing many of the champions reflecting back on their short-lived fame as adults stands as a testament to the resilient draw of video game culture. Chasing Ghosts was a huge hit at the Sundance Film Festival, and found a fan in none other than Pixar's Andrew Stanton, director of Wall-E, who enjoyed it so much he arranged a private screening for his colleagues. The influence of these old school games is clearly present in Wreck-It Ralph, which owes more to the retro games of yesteryear than all the next-generation console games combined.

8. MacHeads

Some fans out there are far more interested in the medium rather than the message. The technology - its ergonomics, functionality and reliability appeals to them more than the applications and software the devices are intended for. Perhaps no other group considers themselves more tech-savvy and elitist than Mac owners. MacHeads - which takes its name for the faithful hordes who can't get enough of the brand - is a documentary all about the users and their fervent (some might say obsessive) appreciation for anything produced by Apple Inc. Kobi and Ron Shely's documentary takes a look inside their world, from the early days of hardcore Mac users and their endless battle with PC owners to the iPod/Pad generation, who see their gadgets and tablets as extensions of their personalities. Their unity is most apparent in their idol worship of Steve Jobs (who died after this documentary was made); a man they hold in the highest esteem as something of a demi-god. It's brand evangelism at its most prominent, filling the coffers of a billion dollar corporation with the sales of products marketed not for their utility but as a lifestyle choice. While MacHeads does touch on the corporate changes Apple have undergone over the years - in which they've moved further and further away from the user-friendly model with which they made their name in the early days of computing - the documentary prefers to keep focus on the community. Stare too hard though and it starts to look more like a cult.

7. Ringers - Lord Of The Fans

Of all the franchises on this list, The Lord of the Rings finds its roots the furthest back in history. J. R. R. Tolkien died long before it reached the level of popular appeal familiar today, and we can only guess what he would have made of Peter Jackson's movie trilogy and the global phenomenon they spawned (the less said about The Hobbit the better). Ringers: Lord of the Fans is a surprisingly comprehensive documentary which covers everything Tolkien-related from the days when his fantasy worlds influenced aspects of the counter-culture movement in the 1970s - most notably progressive rock - and interviewing the legendary Lemmy of Motorhead, up to the 2005 when the documentary was produced, by which point the impact of Jackson's film adaptations was being felt around the world. It's a portrait both of the stars and their fans, who like the best devotees love to spend their time dressing up as their favourite characters. Perhaps the stand-out moment though - certainly one for real fans - is Leonard Nimoy performing the cringe-inducing song, The Ballad of Bilbo Baggins, the original video for which really has to be seen to be believed. You have been warned... https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AGF5ROpjRAU

6. The King Of Kong: A Fistful Of Quarters

If Chasing Ghosts: Beyond the Arcade offered a wonderful overview of an era of video games seemingly stuck forever in the 1980s, King of Kong: A Fistful of Quarters dispels the notion that it is nothing more than a faded memory and shows that the competitive spirit of the age is very much alive and kicking. The kings of the scoreboard might have grown up, got "proper" jobs and raised families, but that hasn't gotten in the way of competing for the number one position. King of Kong - as the title implies - focuses on recent efforts to attain the highest score on Nintendo's smash hit masterpiece Donkey Kong, following Steve Wiebe as he attempts to claim the high score crown from reigning champion Billy Mitchell. It's a classic tale of rivalry - a Rocky for geeks, trading muscles for mullets - and it's clear that the passion these guys felt for gaming and the pride they took in their high scores has waned very little over the years. Perhaps inevitably, King of Kong came under criticism after its release, not least on account of disputes over who held which high score and when, but these quibbles don't detract from the documentary's entertainment value, whether you're a gamer who likes to argue the merits of PS4 versus Xbox One or one who longs for the return of Pole Position in your local chip shop.

5. Room 237

Few directors have been more discussed by movie fans as the legendary Stanley Kubrick. His films are loaded with multiple meanings, transcending the standard "literal" readings most cinema offers and entering the realm of the symbolic, endlessly open to new interpretations. And few Kubrick films have been as widely discussed as his 1980 loose adaptation of Stephen King's The Shining. Rodney Ascher's 2012 documentary Room 237 takes a look at nine Kubrick fans and their deeper readings of The Shining, picking apart every element of the film's production in order to tease out an esoteric meaning - a hidden subtext which they believe was Kubrick's true intention for making the movie. These theories range from the film as an allegory for the genocide of the Native Americans or the genocidal action of the Holocaust, to being a retelling of the mythical story of the minotaur or a confessional movie in which Kubrick is trying to inform the audience about his involvement in the faked footage for the moon landing. The theories offered should, of course, be taken with a pinch of salt - certainly, people who worked with Kubrick on The Shining who have seen Room 237 describe the ideas posited as ludicrous at best - but plausibility issues aren't really the point. Rather, it's a fascinating insight into the obsessive dedication with which some Kubrick fans dedicate themselves to carefully analysing his movies, and in this sense it barely touches the tip of the iceberg - the internet is awash with hundreds of competing theories as to the true meaning of The Shining, with many more taking apart Kubrick's other fantastic movies.

4. Trekkies

From Dungeons and Dragons to The Lord of the Rings, a lot of fans just love to get dressed up as their favourite characters and show off their costumes at fan conventions. But perhaps the best fans for really getting into character are Trekkies, some of whom have been doing so for decades. Roger Nygard directs this great documentary about the eponymous fans, with former crew member Denise Crosby (who played Tasha Yar in Star Trek: The Next Generation) covering the lives of a group of hardcore followers. Some of them escape from their lives dressing as Klingons and spending small fortunes at memorabilia auctions, while others dedicate their spare time to maintaining the Brent Spiner fan club or producing a Star Trek movie of their own. They all take it very seriously, and for many of them Star Trek is far more than a slice of entertainment to pass the time after work; it is a way of life and a philosophy, with creator Gene Roddenberry's emphasis on plausible science leading to more than a few careers in academia, astrology and even one at NASA. It remains to be seen whether or not the legacy of Star Trek will continue on down future generations - if J. J. Abrams has anything to do with it, any intellectual qualities the concept had will inevitably be phasered out in favour of mindless explosive action and 'might-makes-right', repeatedly-punching-people-in-the-face diplomacy. Let's hope the true fans keep the spirit of Roddenberry alive and well.

3. The People Vs. George Lucas

Few movies have been as hotly anticipated and subsequently roundly despised as the Star Wars prequels - few filmmakers have been so loved and hated in equal measure, credited both for shaping childhood memories and taking a huge dump on them from a great height. In this regard, George Lucas resides in a league entirely of his own; a near-mythical creator and a simultaneous destroyer of dreams. That's hyperbole but it captures the essence of the superb documentary The People vs. George Lucas, in which fans the world over discuss the legacy of the Star Wars series and the dichotomy between artistic freedom (using the term very loosely in the context of George Lucas, naturally) and audience expectations. Beyond this, it goes into the rich history of fan-created media, ranging from the hilariously cheap to the professionally made, and demonstrates how popular franchises which transform into such huge social phenomenons are perhaps more open source than we realise. Director Alexander Phillipe strives for a balance that doesn't quite come across, yet few would argue with the central position held by many throughout the documentary, that Lucas went from an accomplished "ideas man" to little more than a corporate businessman concerned only with cold, hard cash. The People vs George Lucas is a spirited, impassioned and often funny look at the films and the creator everyone loves to hate.

2. Comic-Con IV: A Fan's Hope

If any documentary on this list represents an all-out fan-fest orgy, then it's undoubtedly Comic-Con Episode IV: A Fan's Hope. Morgan Spurlock's film exploring the phenomenon of the San Diego Comic-Con International not only manages to capture the incredible diversity of franchises and mediums at the convention, but also crams in dozens of talking heads, from Joss Whedon and Kevin Smith to Stan Lee and Guillermo del Toro. The film follows five people as they attend "The ultimate geek Mecca": two aspiring illustrators intent on getting a deal with their favourite imprint; a costume designer and cosplayer determined to win the costume competition; a comic book store owner trying to clear his debts; and a young fan who uses his Q and A moment with Kevin Smith to propose to his girlfriend. Dividing its time between the fans and the creators reveals a great deal about the similarity between the two - many of the writers, directors and creators of the franchises millions of fans have come to love come across as every bit as fanatical about these fantasy worlds as the rest of us. It's sad that comics have been relegated almost to the sidelines at the San Diego events - after all, as the name of the event implies, this great visual art form was the primary reason they started in the first place. Inevitably, profit-driven corporations and Hollywood executives have come to treat the conventions almost as giant sandbox events, both testing and teasing the market with new products. But for the most part the fans are discerning and in their own ways fickle - it'll be a long time before the soul is sucked out of this scene.

1. Cinemania

There are some fans out there who are so committed to the movies they love and so knowledgeable about every aspect of cinema that they put even the most vocal fanboys to shame. These are the people who have moved beyond mere fandom, obsessing over one particular franchise or genre, and should rather be considered as experts in their field capable of holding their own in the company of film critics and academics. These are the true film buffs. Cinemania follows five such film buffs around Manhattan as they struggle to cram in as many films in each day as the listings and subway timetables will allow for while maintaining their meticulous notes (one man obsesses over running times, and often corrects a theatre for getting the times wrong), occasionally finding some time to socialise with their fellow film-spotters. Most of them refuse to watch movies on home media, and instead their apartments are full to the rafters with endless books on films and their makers. Their standards are incredibly high too, largely dismissing Hollywood fodder in favour of the true greats of film history, from Rainer Werner Fassbender (no relation to Michael) and Ingmar Bergman to Federico Fellini and Jean-Luc Godard. Cinemania is a real gem, both a fantastic documentary about obsession which cautiously touches on the mental illness of fandom (after all, the word "fan" derives from "fanatic") and an ode to the cinema itself; that vast, ever-changing silver canvas upon which our dreams and realities are projected. German directors Angela Christlieb and Steven Kijak's affectionate documentary does full justice to the subject matter - a must-see for film buffs everywhere.