10 Most Overrated Movies Of 2013

Without a doubt, the most frustrating creature is the bad film masquerading as a good film. How many of these did you fall for into liking?

By Audrey Fox /

As awards season rolls around, we take stock of the films we were given over the past year. There are some good films, which we celebrate, and bad films, which we mock and/or grieve. But without a doubt, the most frustrating creature is the bad film masquerading as a good film. And somehow, everyone buys into it except for us. It gets award nominations, makes a killing at the box office, and critics are calling it the best film they've seen in the past ten years. But in our heart of hearts, we know the truth: it's just no damn good. I like to think that I'm a good judge of quality when it comes to film. And to be fair, a pretty substantial portion of the time my views tend to fall in line with the great huddled masses. But every once in a while, a film comes out that everyone else LOVES, and I think it's a steaming pile of crap. Is there something in this film I'm just not seeing? As my mother is wont to remind me, different strokes for different folks, and other sentimental stuff like that. But I know the truth. Sometimes people just like terrible movies, and we're the only ones who can see them for what they are. The Emperor's New Clothes, if you will. But anyway, here are the ten movies that came out in 2013 that I believe to be vastly overrated.

10. This Is the End

While it's a novel experience, seeing the heightened versions of all these famous actors, and it does feature some clever moments, the main issue in This Is the End is consistency. You get one moment that is laugh out loud funny, and then you wait about a half hour to 45 minutes for another one to come around again. As with most films like this, the loose construct of the script combined with the tendency of the actors improvise creates a movie that was probably unbelievably fun to make, but is spotty and slightly incoherent for viewers. While the film begins with a hilarious game of Spot the Celeb at James Franco's house and is really going strong for the first 45 minutes or so, it quickly fizzles out once the main cast is alone in the house together. Despite injections from solid supporting characters (Emma Watson is a particular highlight), it becomes clear they have no intentions but to do drugs and improvise the rest of the film, with only a fraction of the jokes being thrown out actually landing.

9. The Hobbit: Desolation Of Smaug

Any of Peter Jackson's Tolkien films are always going to pack a powerful visual punch, and The Hobbit: The Desolation of Smaug is no exception. The second Hobbit film is a work of art in terms of special effects and battle sequences, but it struggles when it comes to pacing. I think that these films are still suffering from the creative decision to make The Hobbit, a book of a mere 310 pages, into three movies that clock in at nearly three hours each. As a result, the plot is stretched until it resembles Mike Teevee from Willy Wonka and the Chocolate Factory. Middle films in a trilogy often suffer from inevitable sagging even at the best of times, and in this instance it's particularly egregious. To put it into perspective, The Desolation of Smaug features only five chapters from The Hobbit. Despite the natural abilities of Martin Freeman, who was born to play Bilbo, and the rest of the cast, the film's narrative padding is hard to ignore. And although Benedict Cumberbatch has been doing a full on publicity tour for this film, it's hard to get too excited considering that you can barely tell it's him.

8. Labor Day

I was under the impression that everyone was sort of on the same page about this one. It's a soapy drama starring Kate Winslet as a single mom who nurses a dashing escaped convict (played by Josh Brolin) back to help after she finds him bleeding on the side of the road. Despite the A-list cast, the material comes off like a made-for-TV movie that would air on Lifetime, and overall it's just a waste of the actors' talent and the audience's time. Then I saw the nominations for the Golden Globes, and discovered that Kate Winslet is up for Best Actress in a Motion Picture, Drama, and I was shocked. Admittedly, it hasn't been a particularly strong year for female roles that would be in awards contention, but still. This is not the type of film that should be winning anything. It should be quietly released, all the middle-aged ladies going through menopause will shed a few tears, and then it should go on its merry way into irrelevance. For whatever reason, this film is getting attention, despite its cloying sentimentality. I know that the average moviegoer appreciates comfortable, mediocre films, so I wouldn't be surprised if this film does well from a viewer standpoint (it's a tad early to tell -- the film was only released on December 27th), but I wasn't expecting the awards buzz.

7. World War Z

To be totally honest, I had my doubts that anyone would be able to adapt the groundbreaking novel World War Z into an acceptable film. The book was an anthology of anecdotes that detailed the zombie apocalypse from a variety of different perspectives, so it's understandable that it would be difficult to create a single linear storyline. But if it was that difficult, then they should have just let it remain an awesome novel, because the film called World War Z bears little to no resemblance to the book. It's basically just a generic zombie film using the title of a bestselling work of fiction to put butts in seats. The movie isn't terrible, I guess, but it's not great either. I guess the major problem is that there's so much zombie stuff out there right now, and this one doesn't distinguish itself in a positive manner. Mostly I just regret the fact that they couldn't manage to turn one of my favorite books into a serviceable film. It was more than just a zombie story, it was social commentary. It could have been amazing, if they had put any thought into it, but they just decided to cast Brad Pitt and hope that would be good enough.

6. Anchorman 2

I was actually a little bit shocked when I saw that Anchorman 2 has a 75% Fresh Rating on Rotten Tomatoes and that it seems to have been generally pretty well received, because I thought that the overdue sequel missed the mark by quite a bit. First of all, from a marketing standpoint, this movie really should have been made about five years ago, back when Anchorman was still huge. To wait this long and then have the film not be a stellar piece of comedy is a major disappointment. I felt that the story struggled tonally, trying to incorporate serious elements into the script (Ron and Veronica's divorce, Ron getting fired again, Ron going blind) and there wasn't enough they could do to make those parts funny for it to really work. James Marsden felt incredibly out of place...I don't know if his comedic style just didn't mesh with their improvisation, but it was a wasted opportunity. Steve Carrell was massively overused. Brick is hilarious when used in small doses, but it just doesn't work when half the film's screen time is devoted to him. Finally, the long-anticipated news team battle started strong, but lost me when it tried to incorporate the ghost of Stonewall Jackson stealing people's souls. If you haven't seen it yet, that sentence makes it sound a lot funnier than it actually was. I love all of these guys to bits, but I guess I was just expecting a lot more.

5. Gravity

I want to preface this by saying that overrated does not necessarily mean the same thing as bad. Don't get me wrong. Gravity was a good film. A really good film. But was it the wonderfully stark and gorgeously filmed masterpiece of Alfonso Cuaron's career that a lot of people are making it out to be? No. It's not. The visuals are spectacular, but the script is perhaps the weak link of the film. The backstory of Sandra Bullock's character sometimes feels like a bit of an afterthought. I know that a lot of directors are worried about audiences connecting with their characters, especially when the story they're telling is so insular that your exposure to them is in this very specific moment of time, so Cuaron can probably be forgiven for panicking and trying to give her more of an emotional background for us to relate to. But the problem is, the more they develop her emotional baggage and particular neuroses, the more I start to think that there's absolutely no way NASA would have chosen this woman to endure the rigors of space. As I said before, this is a very strong film, and I enjoyed watching it. I just thinks that there's the merest possibility that it may have been overhyped. Please don't hurt me.

4. Elysium

Elysium was Neill Blomkamp's sophomore outing, and his first big Hollywood film after the success of his brilliant District 9. This time he had the budget, he had the buzz, and he had access to some of the world's finest actors. With all that on his side, it's more than a little disappointing that Elysium was merely average. The concept of the Earth becoming a giant slum for the poor while Elysium sits loftily in space as a refuge for the wealthy is strong. But there are a lot of little niggling issues that bring down the entire production. Not least of which, what was going on with Jodie Foster's accent? That was the most appalling artistic decision I've ever seen, and I'm shocked that the actor and director let this film go to theaters with that performance featured in it. I also think it was a mistake for them to have settled on that particular accent for Sharlto Copley -- it was distracting and took away from the otherwise interesting character. Overall, it's a valiant effort, but I can't help but feel that the flaws in the production were the sign of an inexperienced director in a little bit over his head.

3. The Heat

I'm the first to admit that Melissa McCarthy was hilarious in Bridesmaids, but by this point the crude, loud shtick is wearing just the tiniest bit thin. It seemed like the only purpose of the film was for her to act violently aggressive in a way that would absolutely get her fired. Other than that, there's not a whole hell of a lot of plot going around. But the worst part is that The Heat completely underutilizes Sandra Bullock. She's a hilarious woman, and she's stuck being the uptight neurotic Fed. If McCarthy had expressed some restraint, they both would have been funny and neither would have come off as over the top. In addition, I'm really uncomfortable with some of the misogynistic undertones that plague this movie. It sometimes seems like the whole punchline of the film is, "Haha, it's a buddy cop movie...WITH WOMEN!" I hate that Sandra Bullock's character is a pariah within her department, seemingly just for the heinous crime of being passionate, dedicated, and a little overbearing. In male cop films, these types of characters are presented, but it usually isn't implied that they're bad people or worthy of being censured by their colleagues.

2. Pacific Rim

I'm sorry, I love Burn Gorman and Charlie Day as much as the next person, but I have no time for this movie. I have no time for a movie that's all about robots punching monsters, only to realize in the last fifteen minutes that the robots have swords that work like a thousand times better than their little robot fists. Because that would only have saved tons of lives, right? I'm uncomfortable with the idea of drift compatibility, just as I was uncomfortable with the flying horses in Avatar, because I really don't like the concept of literally being in someone else's mind and having someone else in yours. Charlie Hunnam's accent slipped once every three and a half minutes, despite the fact that he's really good at an American accent on Sons of Anarchy. Overall, I guess I just didn't get it. I thought it was a subpar, goofy sci-fi action film, but it turns out that it actually has a pretty substantial following (all of whom, I'm sure, will love this article). Sure, I liked Ron Perlman and Charlie Day, and the little girl who played the young version of Mako was probably one of the best child actresses I've ever seen, but at the end of the day, is that enough? I don't know, I just left the film feeling like I had just consumed a lot of empty calories...none of it really stuck with me.

1. American Hustle

I'm not going to lie, I was super pumped about this movie. Christian Bale, Jennifer Lawrence, Bradley Cooper, an awesome con set in the 70s to the tune of Led Zeppelin? How could this possibly go wrong? I wanted to love this movie so much, and for the first ten or fifteen minutes, it was what I wanted it to be. Then I don't know what happened. I think the issue with this film is that David O. Russell wanted to sacrificed plot in favor of character, but went the wrong way about it. First of all, any film about a confidence scheme needs to have a really tightly woven plot, otherwise it will make no sense. In this film, Russell allowed his actors to improvise, thus drastically changing the course of the plot. It also led to self-indulgent performances better suited for an acting exercise for a college drama workshop than a major motion picture. Even professional, usually reliable actors need directors to rein in their instincts, and that's what was missing here. I'm shocked that this film has been getting so much good press, because for me American Hustle was one of the biggest disappointments of 2013. The only person I really liked in the film was Jeremy Renner, who took a small role and imbued with such heart that you couldn't help but feel bad for the poor guy who was only trying to do his best.