When Fox announced their aim to reboot the Fantastic Four franchise with a new feature film in 2015, the news was met with a familiar mixture of excitement and resignation amongst fans of the long-running comic book franchise. After all, this was the Fantastic Four one of Marvel Comics greatest super hero teams, practically household names in the geek circles we run in. But wed been burned before. Leaving aside B-movie producer Roger Cormans abortion of a movie from 1994 (allegedly only made as a placeholder because the rights would revert to Marvel unless a movie was produced), 2005s Fantastic Four and 2007s sequel Fantastic Four: Rise Of The Silver Surfer were widely panned by fans and critics alike, director Tim Storys efforts perceived as high camp with low comedy. Incoming director Josh Trank, however, has some excellent form here, having made his directorial debut in 2012 with low budget super hero smash hit Chronicle. Hes made some interesting casting choices (some of which have resulted in comic fan apoplexy) and, with studio 20th Century Fox so confident in his work so far that theyve greenlit a sequel and set a release date of July 14th 2017, this looks as though it could be the Fantastic Four movie that fans have been waiting for. But there are some pitfalls to bringing Marvels first family to the big screen. Heres our list of prior errors of judgement that Trank would do well to avoid this time around
10. Give Us A Cast That Works Together
Tim Storys original Fantastic Four (Ioan Gruffudd, Jessica Alba, Chris Evans and Michael Chiklis) were clearly selected precisely because they looked the part. Heavyset Chiklis was a Fantastic Four fan his entire life, and lived to play Ben Grimm, while Evans and Alba made picture perfect Storm siblings. Meanwhile Gruffudd tall, mannered and scholarly looked like an ideal Reed Richards. It was the stuff movie posters are made of but not movies, sadly. Never able to flesh out the two dimensional script, Gruffudd struggled to make his Mister Fantastic authoritative or highbrow enough, while Alba, as the Invisible Woman, may have been the first actress ever to deliver a invisible performance in a film, claiming later that she was told to look pretty and do nothing else, that they could CGI the tears in later. Chiklis and Evans fared better, the former properly inhabiting the pathos of his role despite the mountain of prosthetics that he was forced to endure as The Thing, while the laters perfect comic instincts made his Human Torch the instant standout, and the primary reason to rewatch the films. Interestingly, Josh Trank has elected to go for a younger cast that you wouldnt necessarily earmark as the characters theyre playing at first glance. Hes previously worked with Michael B. Jordan in Chronicle, and both Jordan and Miles Teller (cast as the Human Torch and Mister Fantastic, respectively) are highly respected young actors who worked together last year in That Awkward Moment. Meanwhile, Kate Mara is already a veteran of television and ensemble cast movies, last seen by most in Netflixs huge hit House Of Cards. Jamie Bell will bring experience in motion capture when portraying The Thing, learned from the great Andy Serkis and through his work on Spielbergs The Adventures Of Tintin. Fanboys have been vociferous about the casting of a black man as Johnny Storm while Kate Mara plays his sister Susan, but seem to have forgotten that Albas distinctively Latina heritage wasnt an issue when cast as Evans sister ten years ago. No-one would seriously hold up David Hasselhoffs Nick Fury as superior to Samuel L. Jacksons interpretation of the character, and most would agree that the late Michael Clarke Duncans portrayal of the Kingpin was one of the only decent things about the poorly received 2003 Daredevil movie. It seems that in selecting a cast famed for their acting chops and ability to work together, Trank may have already skirted the pitfalls involved in casting his heroes. Thats important, because
9. They Should Be A Proper Family
The Fantastic Four aren't just a group thrown together by their genetic heritage like the X-Men or by circumstance like the Avengers. Theyre a family. Ben Grimm is Reed's best friend since they were teenagers (either grade school or college, depending on which origin you want to go with). Johnny and Sue Storm are siblings, and Reed and Sue have pretty much been sweethearts since they first met. Meanwhile, the fractious relationship between The Thing and the Human Torch is as indelible a friendship as Bert and Ernie or Laurel and Hardy. Every relationship here is cinematic gold, given the best of writing and performance. We didnt get that with any of the previous three movies. No one could believe that Albas Sue Storm would be interested in Gruffudds fusty Richards for a second, and her flat performance contrasted so horribly with Evans sparky flippancy that you couldnt see them as brother and sister, either. The links between these characters go far deeper than a blue union suit and a shared super powered origin story. We need to see that in the rebooted Fantastic Four movie, or we wont believe a second of it.
8. We Want Production Values That Look Valuable
CGI has moved on light years in the last decade. The ropey backdrops and half-baked effects of the 2005 and 2007 movies are things of the past. Moreover, we now have the ability to seamlessly meld stunning computer wizardry with astonishing practical special effects and camera work, a trick that was still being worked out ten years ago. Theres no need for comic book movies to look like cartoons anymore. Part of the willing suspension of disbelief required for cinema like this is that it not look as if its been animated by tech nerds in a basement. Motion capture has become an art in 2014. Lets see that art play a major role in the Fantastic Four.
7. We Need Marvel Cameos
Fox owns the movie rights to both the X-Mens cast of thousands and the Fantastic Fours supporting characters and rogues gallery. Although current scriptwriter, X-Men: Days Of Future Pasts Simon Kinberg has recently ruled out crossovers between the two franchises, that doesnt mean that the studio cant take a leaf from Marvels book and bring in cameos from and references to other Marvel characters that they have in their back pockets. This doesnt just mean the principal characters, Doom, the Silver Surfer and Galactus. Through association, Fox conceivably has access to Namor and the whole of Atlantis, the Black Panther, the Inhumans, Annihilus and even the Skrulls. And just because the X-Men wont have an official crossover anytime soon, doesnt mean that members of their staggeringly vast supporting cast cant make an appearance. Its even possible that She-Hulk could join that list shes an ex-member of the team, after all. Thatd be a kick in the pants for Marvel. Basically, Fox and Trank need to look at which Marvel characters they can legally use as part of their deal, and then figure out a way to make casual reference to a select few in the final script. They can energise fan interest by having some of them appear in the reboot, riffing off the Marvel way of doing things. At the very least, its a whole lot of excellent free publicity, as comics sites across the length and breadth of the internet devote themselves to numbering the dropped names, the Easter Eggs and the blink-and-youll-miss-them cameos.
6. The Need To Create Anticipation For The Next Film
Impressively, Fox have already decided to make a sequel to the as-yet-untitled reboot movie, and even given it a release date. Now let's see some thought go into what might take place in that sequel. Marvel has practically perfected the art of the teasing post-credits sequence, and Sonys Spider-Man movies old and new were remarkably adept at introducing characters who audiences could see as becoming the antagonists for sequels and beyond. More than that, Marvels cinematic universes push plot points onwards from film to film. First Loki fights the god of thunder in the Thor movie, and falls to an uncertain fate. Then the tesseract appears in Captain America: The First Avenger, and is lost. Then Loki reappears to reclaim the tesseract in The Avengers, whose events lead us into Marvels Agents Of S.H.I.E.L.D. and Iron Man 3. We already have the go-ahead for a second film featuring these characters, and its guaranteed that Fox has tied the cast into a contract for more than one film. Give us an arc plot. Lets see where this goes.
5. We Need A Bigger And Better Thing
As good as Michael Chiklis was under all those prosthetics in Tim Storys anaemic offerings (and he worked his rocky orange socks off to bring the essential melancholy of the part to life), a man in a rubber suit just wont cut it in post-Avengers Hollywood. Weve seen the Hulk in three movies now. While admittedly Ang Lees take on the comic book phenomenon was a patronising snore of a film, the CGI Hulk was a terrifying force of nature, and a revelation to people whod grown up with the television version of two decades earlier (bodybuilder Lou Ferrigno in a fright wig and green body paint). Even the smaller version in The Incredible Hulk was a total badass. The Avengers cemented Mark Ruffalos Bruce Banner and accompanying enormous green rage-monster as the definitive big screen Hulk. The Thing is supposed to be able to go toe-to-toe with everyones favourite the emerald giant, although that perennial rights issue means its basically never going to happen moreover though, hes supposed to be able to look like he could. Fundamentally, we need a giant-sized Thing. Sorry, but that joke was pretty much inevitable. Its amazing weve been able to hold off for this long, to be honest.
4. We Need Less Of The Campness
Okay, okay, we know the propertys called The Fantastic Four. This isnt Shakespeare. But its also not a pantomime. We dont need godawful dance scenes, pratfalls or mugging to camera to sell this franchise. A better approach would be to play the sillier aspects completely straight. This calls for some serious chutzpah, but when it works its a beautiful thing. Look at Leslie Nielsons deadpan, dignified performance in the Naked Gun movies. Mark Wahlberg does something very similar in The Other Guys, a character that doesnt seem to realise how ridiculous everything around him is. Some self-aware, sly scripting and a deadpan wit will pay dividends here. Its much more of a recipe for success than playing everything with a wink and a giggle. Less cheese, more pickle!
3. We Want A Genuine Sense Of Threat
Not just to the newly formed Fantastic Four, but to the world (or at least the USA). Let's have them mobilising to fight something important, something worthwhile. Were not talking about the nonsensical, meaningless destruction that Man Of Steels third act delivered. That kind of wholesale carnage is just sound and fury, signifying nothing. No, we need something dangerous, that strips the last veneer of camp from the equation and forces us to suspend all disbelief in the face of real, serious tension. A cartoon slugfest wont do the job, and neither will a bloodless scrap against an army of Doombots. Lets have our heroes put themselves on the line for something meaningful, that resonates with the audience. Then well find ourselves cheering for them, even if they have silly names and daft blue suits. Thats how decent drama works.
2. We Need A Real Doctor Doom
Victor Von Doom is one of the Marvel Universe's most fascinating and charismatic characters. Hes fought everyone there is to fight the Fantastic Four, the Avengers, the X-Men, Spider-Man, you name it. He's an international politician and world leader, a Machiavellian super villain, a master sorcerer, a genius scientist. Hes stolen the power of gods and immortals, travelled in time, died and been reborn. With a will of pure adamantium, nothing seems capable of stopping him. Possessed of a tragic back-story and overweening arrogance, Doctor Doom could be the new Loki if hes finally portrayed correctly, both nemesis to the protagonists and reluctant ally. Julian McMahon was a camp, urbane cringe-fest as Doom in 2005s Fantastic Four and its uninspired sequel. We need a Doctor Doom that appears capable of taking on all of the Fantastic Four on his own, and one that you secretly almost want to win. Is Toby Kebbell the man for the job? Hes certainly got presence, but only time will tell as to whether he can inhabit the man in the iron mask sufficiently to give us the Victor Von Doom we deserve
1. We. Want. Galactus.
We dont want a weird alien cloud of plasma here, guys. Galactus is one of Marvels most iconic villains, a cosmic entity of staggering scale. Whether he appears in this film, or in the sequel, we need to see Galactus as hes meant to be seen. Hes a giant, terrifying alien creature from before the birth of the universe, not some abstraction or a bad CGI weather pattern. Give us size sheer, mindboggling size. Give us something jaw-dropping, a pull-back reveal that dwarfs Godzilla and makes the Star Destroyer at the beginning of A New Hope look like a Lego toy. Give us something that Reed cant get his egghead around, something that renders the Torch speechless, something that actually forces Doom to consider allying himself with his old foes. Give us Galactus.